Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Asked to contribute to Christmas Dinner… money instead?

308 replies

ThatsVertigo · 15/11/2026 15:23

We are spending the festive period at SIL and BIL. They will have a full house with us, my PIL, between us 5 kids, and 2 dogs - not to mention 4 more adults from SIL side who are local and joining us on Christmas Day. Safe to say it will be hectic fun!!!

I have been asked to contribute to dinner, in principle I have no problem with this, it must be daunting, expensive, and exhausting to host so many people for multiple days, and I am a good cook. However, I have been asked to make a tiramisu for those of us who don’t like Christmas pudding to have as dessert on 25th. This leaves me with 3 options, none of which I like -

  1. Make the tiramisu and bring it with me. Since we are travelling on 21st I would have to make this on 20th and with it being so rich with dairy I worry about it lasting, and not sure the texture would be as pleasant after so many days? I have no idea how a massive tiramisu will fit in the fridge with all the other food. Plus we have a 4 hour drive with all mine, DH, and kids stuff and I just don’t know if I will have space for a huge cool bag.
  2. Make it there. I would have to go out to the shops and cook in an unfamiliar kitchen, all the while getting under SIL feet - an absolutely lovely woman, but quite highly strung.
  3. Buy one from a supermarket there. A serious a downgrade on a proper homemade one.

What I’m wondering is whether it would be acceptable for me to reply and ask if she would consider talking a monetary contribution instead. I was thinking £150 for my family unit - substantially more than ingredient cost.

OP posts:
ThatsVertigo · 15/11/2026 16:34

I really feel this whole thing has gotten derailed.

Year after year I see post on MN from people who want finalincal contribution to their hosting. The response on here is that it's vulgar to do so and that it's much more 'proper' to ask for people to bring dishes.

Could it not be the case that SIL is more than happy to make/source a tiramisu herself and would actually prefer money, but feels unable to do so and has asked me to bring a pudding instead?

OP posts:
nidvideouioui · 15/11/2026 16:34

I’d contribute financially and buy a couple very nice tiramisus. That should cover it.

HallowenStorm · 15/11/2026 16:35

ThatsVertigo · 15/11/2026 16:30

I don't like Christmas pud, not sure who else doesn't, but SIL and BIL know all of the guests so I presume the choice was based on what people like.

Agree but it’s also a diddly one that doesn’t transport well.

Tbh I’d buy a dessert from a good patisserie, not a supermarket. We have one guy in town that is doing amazing cakes. That’s where our Christmas dessert comes from (only dh likes Christmas cake and preparing yet another dish is far down my list)

daysfilledwithdappledlight · 15/11/2026 16:36

ThatsVertigo · 15/11/2026 16:26

I've already said that we will be getting them wonderful Christmas presents (of course that includes the nieces and nephew, and their dog!). AND a host gift - that's not what I am enquiring about.

I was asked to contribute to the meal in the form of a tiramisu, I was wondering if SIL might not actually prefer a meal contribution in the form of £150 rather than a dessert. This has nothing to do with the host gift.

And because the suggestions on this thread that myself and DH are being tight are making me aggy, the host gift we have planned is a bottle of Louis Roederer Cristal, and a vocuhers for full day inclusive of two treatments each at a lovely local spa. I think that is more than suitable to show our gratitude for being hosted.

Edited

Wow, I wish we were hosting you! Incredibly generous!
Hope you work out your tiramisu conundrum!

HallowenStorm · 15/11/2026 16:37

ThatsVertigo · 15/11/2026 16:34

I really feel this whole thing has gotten derailed.

Year after year I see post on MN from people who want finalincal contribution to their hosting. The response on here is that it's vulgar to do so and that it's much more 'proper' to ask for people to bring dishes.

Could it not be the case that SIL is more than happy to make/source a tiramisu herself and would actually prefer money, but feels unable to do so and has asked me to bring a pudding instead?

Money means she still has to think about what and where to get the cake if she buys it. Or has to make the cake/tiramisu if it’s home made.

Basically it doesn’t the sweet spot of ‘something I won’t have to think about’.

It’s not about beimg vulgar/not daring. It’s the (mental) load that is still on her shoulders if you give her money.

HollyhockDays · 15/11/2026 16:37

So you think the need the money? Surely you have an idea of their finances??

How long does it take to make your version?

Ithinksheis · 15/11/2026 16:38

ThatsVertigo · 15/11/2026 16:34

I really feel this whole thing has gotten derailed.

Year after year I see post on MN from people who want finalincal contribution to their hosting. The response on here is that it's vulgar to do so and that it's much more 'proper' to ask for people to bring dishes.

Could it not be the case that SIL is more than happy to make/source a tiramisu herself and would actually prefer money, but feels unable to do so and has asked me to bring a pudding instead?

If your SIL started a thread with the detail of what’s she’s doing and how many hosting - asking whether appropriate for some financial contribution to all the food and booze over days - no one would think she was taking the piss. They would be surprised that guests hadn’t OFFERED to contribute financially @ThatsVertigo

Ithinksheis · 15/11/2026 16:39

For days this SIL is hosting lots of people. The cost will be eye watering.

TheRealWhacker · 15/11/2026 16:40

ThatsVertigo · 15/11/2026 16:34

I really feel this whole thing has gotten derailed.

Year after year I see post on MN from people who want finalincal contribution to their hosting. The response on here is that it's vulgar to do so and that it's much more 'proper' to ask for people to bring dishes.

Could it not be the case that SIL is more than happy to make/source a tiramisu herself and would actually prefer money, but feels unable to do so and has asked me to bring a pudding instead?

Well yes, but you got very offended by the suggestion of contributing the tiramisu AND the money and insisted you were getting her fancy champagne and a spa day instead.

I don’t understand why you can’t just say “Hi SIL, do you mind if I bring a shop bought tiramisu so I don’t take up space in your kitchen as mine won’t travel well. Also, can we bring something else as well, a case of wine or champagne? Or if you let me know what supermarket you shop at I’d love to send a voucher to contribute”.

AtIusvue · 15/11/2026 16:40

millymollymoomoo · 15/11/2026 15:27

Just make a tiramisu there. Hardly loads of cooking !

Exactly. It’s a basic assembly job.

Arcticbattle32 · 15/11/2026 16:42

Make it there, or suggest bringing something which is easier eg something you could make and freeze ahead. That’s an awful lot of work hosting all those people at Xmas - so I’d fall into line as much as possible.

Trallers · 15/11/2026 16:44

I'd ask her.

"I'm very happy to contribute a tiramisu and i have a receipe for a good one so that works out well. Can I ask about logistics though? Were you thinking I'd bring it made on the 21st (I'm worried it might not last), or make it at yours (need to plan for ingredient purchase and prep time in that case)?

Just in case you'd prefer this but didn't want to ask in case it sounded cheeky, we'd be very happy to contribute $150 towards the meal rather than bring a dish.

Anyway whatever you'd prefer, just let us know. We are so grateful for you doing this - I know how much work goes into hosting and you're doing a wonderful job".

changeme4this · 15/11/2026 16:44

If you are happy to make that for dessert, I would pack my own kitchen gear in the car and take along to assemble at a more appropriate time.

im concerned though for the amount of time your SIL/BIL are hosting and the numbers, they might have bitten off more than they should and someone is going to burn out.

how would you feel about hosting a meal out or takeaway on a night leading up to the main event ?

Breadcat24 · 15/11/2026 16:44

Why not suggest something like a chocolate tart or a fallen chocolate souffle instead?
Easier to transport and much the same if served with boozy or coffee flavoured cream. Also more stable.

Mapletree1985 · 15/11/2026 16:45

You obviously can't make it ahead, but I don't see why you can't make it there. Tell her you'll need the kitchen for two hours or however long it takes and ask for a time that is convenient to her.

Cakeandcardio · 15/11/2026 16:45

Make it there. Could you make it early morning on the 24th?

DailyEnergyCrisis · 15/11/2026 16:45

Make the tiramisu there I reckon and offer to bring another evening meal or pay for a takeaway for everyone, or all the Christmas Day canapés. Lighten the load a bit.
She’s asked for practical help so I think to just offer her the cash instead is a bit of a lame effort- she’s told you what she needs already, and it’s not exactly a big ask.

The Christmas/hosting gifts sound like an appropriate add on given how long you’re staying and the time/work/expense of hosting.

AirborneElephant · 15/11/2026 16:46

Don’t offer money, it’s not about the value it’s having something taken off their plate. Either make your own and freeze, make it there, suggest another pudding that lasts better, or buy a frozen one. But the point is to provide a fully finished pud that doesn’t require her to do anything.

Glittertwins · 15/11/2026 16:46

Cakeandcardio · 15/11/2026 16:45

Make it there. Could you make it early morning on the 24th?

I made one yesterday- took me less than 30 mins

CleverKitten · 15/11/2026 16:46

Could you ask to swap and supply the turkey or a £100/150 supermarket gift card instead and ask if a local person could provide a pudding?

Arcticbattle32 · 15/11/2026 16:47

When I’m hosting and people offer to contribute I will usually say “bring a dessert” or something… (home made or bought!), rather than dictate a certain dish. I don’t know many people who actually like tiramisu now I come to think of it!

DailyEnergyCrisis · 15/11/2026 16:47

When I’ve done similar I’ve got a supermarket shop to the hosts house and put loads of booze, chocs, desserts, canapés on too- £150 won’t touch the sides when catering for so many.

spanishcheese · 15/11/2026 16:49

Ask SiL what she prefers.

Is there another family kitchen nearby you can use for prep the day before?

Otherwise suggest a different alternative dessert that will travel.

Minasama · 15/11/2026 16:49

You have to ask her - but money doesn’t replace the time. If you don’t provide it it’s back on her to-do list.
I would ask her if she’d prefer you to make it there or to buy one given your travel schedule. Or contribute cash.