Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Asked to contribute to Christmas Dinner… money instead?

308 replies

ThatsVertigo · 15/11/2026 15:23

We are spending the festive period at SIL and BIL. They will have a full house with us, my PIL, between us 5 kids, and 2 dogs - not to mention 4 more adults from SIL side who are local and joining us on Christmas Day. Safe to say it will be hectic fun!!!

I have been asked to contribute to dinner, in principle I have no problem with this, it must be daunting, expensive, and exhausting to host so many people for multiple days, and I am a good cook. However, I have been asked to make a tiramisu for those of us who don’t like Christmas pudding to have as dessert on 25th. This leaves me with 3 options, none of which I like -

  1. Make the tiramisu and bring it with me. Since we are travelling on 21st I would have to make this on 20th and with it being so rich with dairy I worry about it lasting, and not sure the texture would be as pleasant after so many days? I have no idea how a massive tiramisu will fit in the fridge with all the other food. Plus we have a 4 hour drive with all mine, DH, and kids stuff and I just don’t know if I will have space for a huge cool bag.
  2. Make it there. I would have to go out to the shops and cook in an unfamiliar kitchen, all the while getting under SIL feet - an absolutely lovely woman, but quite highly strung.
  3. Buy one from a supermarket there. A serious a downgrade on a proper homemade one.

What I’m wondering is whether it would be acceptable for me to reply and ask if she would consider talking a monetary contribution instead. I was thinking £150 for my family unit - substantially more than ingredient cost.

OP posts:
mybiggreenfrog · 15/11/2026 17:32

Ask if you can buy the drinks instead ... you can go out 23rd and get them

watchingthishtread · 15/11/2026 17:32

ThatsVertigo · 15/11/2026 15:39

yeah, so the consensus here seems to be either just ask - I would be hoping that she might divert the task of pudding to her brother/his husband or her parents who are local and just coming for Christmas Day so avoids all of the logistical issues I have.

Or to make it there. While I appreciate the oven isn't switched on I don't find tiramisu low effort - the recipe I like is pretty involved and with loads of washing up, between whipping the whites, cream, and yolks + sugar over a Bain Marie it uses 3 bowls. I don;t have time between now and Christmas to recipe test, so would be sticking with my PITA but tried and tested delicious one.

So use a different recipe.

You have one job.

Marieb19 · 15/11/2026 17:33

Why ask us, ask her. It's a perfectly reasonable question.

Frugalgal · 15/11/2026 17:34

ThatsVertigo · 15/11/2026 15:23

We are spending the festive period at SIL and BIL. They will have a full house with us, my PIL, between us 5 kids, and 2 dogs - not to mention 4 more adults from SIL side who are local and joining us on Christmas Day. Safe to say it will be hectic fun!!!

I have been asked to contribute to dinner, in principle I have no problem with this, it must be daunting, expensive, and exhausting to host so many people for multiple days, and I am a good cook. However, I have been asked to make a tiramisu for those of us who don’t like Christmas pudding to have as dessert on 25th. This leaves me with 3 options, none of which I like -

  1. Make the tiramisu and bring it with me. Since we are travelling on 21st I would have to make this on 20th and with it being so rich with dairy I worry about it lasting, and not sure the texture would be as pleasant after so many days? I have no idea how a massive tiramisu will fit in the fridge with all the other food. Plus we have a 4 hour drive with all mine, DH, and kids stuff and I just don’t know if I will have space for a huge cool bag.
  2. Make it there. I would have to go out to the shops and cook in an unfamiliar kitchen, all the while getting under SIL feet - an absolutely lovely woman, but quite highly strung.
  3. Buy one from a supermarket there. A serious a downgrade on a proper homemade one.

What I’m wondering is whether it would be acceptable for me to reply and ask if she would consider talking a monetary contribution instead. I was thinking £150 for my family unit - substantially more than ingredient cost.

Asher which she'd prefer. It is too long to leave it from 21st to 25th.

CatSquirrelDuck · 15/11/2026 17:38

I would order a nice one and pick it up ... or offer to pick up alternative pudding options AND make a financial contribution anyway ... hosting is very expensive these days

InessaMou · 15/11/2026 17:39

ThatsVertigo · 15/11/2026 15:23

We are spending the festive period at SIL and BIL. They will have a full house with us, my PIL, between us 5 kids, and 2 dogs - not to mention 4 more adults from SIL side who are local and joining us on Christmas Day. Safe to say it will be hectic fun!!!

I have been asked to contribute to dinner, in principle I have no problem with this, it must be daunting, expensive, and exhausting to host so many people for multiple days, and I am a good cook. However, I have been asked to make a tiramisu for those of us who don’t like Christmas pudding to have as dessert on 25th. This leaves me with 3 options, none of which I like -

  1. Make the tiramisu and bring it with me. Since we are travelling on 21st I would have to make this on 20th and with it being so rich with dairy I worry about it lasting, and not sure the texture would be as pleasant after so many days? I have no idea how a massive tiramisu will fit in the fridge with all the other food. Plus we have a 4 hour drive with all mine, DH, and kids stuff and I just don’t know if I will have space for a huge cool bag.
  2. Make it there. I would have to go out to the shops and cook in an unfamiliar kitchen, all the while getting under SIL feet - an absolutely lovely woman, but quite highly strung.
  3. Buy one from a supermarket there. A serious a downgrade on a proper homemade one.

What I’m wondering is whether it would be acceptable for me to reply and ask if she would consider talking a monetary contribution instead. I was thinking £150 for my family unit - substantially more than ingredient cost.

There's no cooking involved in making tiramisu, it's literally making coffee and making the cream mixture - the rest is just assembling. And it's a really quick dessert to make, too, so you won't be in the way for long. You're making this more difficult than it needs to be.

I'd make it at theirs the night before, maybe later in when most have retired for the evening and won't disturb me.

lycheesalltheway · 15/11/2026 17:40

ThatsVertigo · 15/11/2026 17:14

I agree it's a long time. SIL and BIL suggested it.

The 5 DC are at an age where they play together so sweetly and love time with their cousins - when it's time to go home after a normal weekend visit there's often one hiding somewhere in the hopes of staying longer 😂 They're also at an age where they all believe fully, a year or two more and the older ones will grow out of it. We all agreed it was a particularly magical age, and SIL suggested it was an opportunity for a special Christmas - probably never to be repeated, unless the nagging of kids becomes unbearable next year!!!!

OP I think you sound like such a lovely and considerate SIL, offering to pick up bits and pieces and blocking out a time to make it. I really hope it all goes well!

Completely not the point of your thread but I am now intrigued by your tiramisu recipe. Would you mind sharing it? I could use the distraction and would like to try although I am not a good cook - so maybe you would not recommend?

Octaviathethird · 15/11/2026 17:42

24Dogcuddler · 15/11/2026 15:35

Check if you can have this delivered to her? You could add other items to the order.
Maybe make some other home made items to take or posh chocs or panettone from Sous Chef.

https://www.cookfood.net/products/tiramisu?srsltid=AYCX9vJH16LKuSiUD3Ao9XsGMs2Fcon9FwR4O8kKvLfJd5_hr4ue6eR5

I was going to suggest this, this is honestly the best tiramisu I've ever had!

SqB · 15/11/2026 17:42

Buy one from M&S and decant it claiming all credit. Well, that’s what I do 🤣🤣🤣

MiniPantherOwner · 15/11/2026 17:42

I was ready to say 48 hours is the maximum time you would want to keep a homemade tiramisu before eating it if you don't want to poison everyone, but you've already decided against that and sensibly asked you SIL. If the tiramisu is going to be tricky to make I thought the suggestion someone has already made of a pavlova would be good. They look fancy, are always popular and you can make the meringue at home to take with you as long as you're careful about packaging it. Just whip some cream and add fruit on the day and it's ready to go.

BeanNaGealai · 15/11/2026 17:47

ThatsVertigo · 15/11/2026 15:53

Ok, I get this. I was just going off many threads I've read on here before.

Posters will often ask about whether they can request monetary contributions and the response is that it would be crass to do so and they should ask for people to bring something instead. I wasn't sure if she would privately be grateful to have the money and that might have been her preference all along but just felt it would be a faux pas to actually ask us.

I wonder if I message her and give her the option of agreeing to me having a kitchen slot on 24th or having the money. (of course we will be getting her and BIL fab Christmas presents, and host gifts to show our gratitude regardless of if they say no to the money).

I would be pissed off at being offered money instead. The whole point is to take part of the load off the host’s shoulders.

We host my family every year. Everyone brings something. They either make it in advance if suitable or do as much prep in advance as possible and cook/assemble on the day. It makes hosting much more manageable. Giving me money would make it cheaper but much more stressful. My preference is less stress.

OutAndAbouting · 15/11/2026 17:48

Trallers · 15/11/2026 16:44

I'd ask her.

"I'm very happy to contribute a tiramisu and i have a receipe for a good one so that works out well. Can I ask about logistics though? Were you thinking I'd bring it made on the 21st (I'm worried it might not last), or make it at yours (need to plan for ingredient purchase and prep time in that case)?

Just in case you'd prefer this but didn't want to ask in case it sounded cheeky, we'd be very happy to contribute $150 towards the meal rather than bring a dish.

Anyway whatever you'd prefer, just let us know. We are so grateful for you doing this - I know how much work goes into hosting and you're doing a wonderful job".

This.

Also, I'd contribute the £150 and make the dessert. Not an either or. Sorted.

Edit - I've just seen your 17.04 post which I had missed earlier. Brilliant. Hope it works out well. Happy nearly Christmas!

GloryDias · 15/11/2026 17:51

ThatsVertigo · 15/11/2026 17:10

Jesus Christ, I forget that an OP can do no right on MN.

Do you think I copy and pasted my exact WhatsApp message? I guarantee the text she received will not be interpreted as passive aggressive.

You can never win with anything you post on here, someone will always find fault 🙄

Itsthewoluff · 15/11/2026 17:56

Let us know her answer. I think it’s taking work off her she wants. I expect a fancy ready made one would also be ok.

RVectensian · 15/11/2026 17:56

I'd just say I'm happy to make it, if I can book a slot in the kitchen on the 23rd. Tell her you'll need it for a couple of hours, plus you'll either need fridge space for the ingredients or you'll pop out and get them when there. If she sounds aghast at the kitchen use, you'll know so you can then say not to worry, you'll get a suitable alternative.

It isn't rocket science, and I'm assuming you'll be in the kitchen at various points cooking other meals etc over the period.

I wouldn't hand the decision back to her.

I would make a financial contribution as well, regardless of what present you have got, they're hosting your whole family for a fair while

Fluffymoocher · 15/11/2026 17:59

burnoutbabe · 15/11/2026 16:03

Don’t you mean her husband should be chipping in and providing meals for everyone? As it’s his family they are staying at.

if my mother in law told me I was in charge of meals over my partner (her son) I’d be having words.

No, I mean every adult and older child should be chipping in to the household they are staying at for almost a full week.
As far as I can see we aren’t speaking to her DH though?

PuzzledObserver · 15/11/2026 18:01

Do a click and collect order for all the ingredients at a supermarket near the destination so you can pick it up when you arrive. Make it there.

Coconutcreamz · 15/11/2026 18:01

In your place I would bring a large homemade Pavolova.
I would bring some tinned peaches if fresh fruit is difficult to source.
I would bring one 500ml of fresh cream, not taking up space and whip that into bought custard.
Top the custard mix with chopped peaches, and lots of crushed chocolate flakes.
I did the above in a similar situation and it was a huge hit.

5 days with children is a lot.
So lots of easy dinners that can be quickly put together with lots of tins, rice and pasta, with beef or chicken from the freezer would be my plan.

Also a case of lovely wine for the hosts slways goes down well as well as whatever you will consume yourself.

Arran2024 · 15/11/2026 18:04

I once went to a barbecue where everyone except my dh and I got extremely ill (one person was hospitalised) - we don't like coffee so didn't eat the tiramasu, which is how we easily identified the culprit.

ThatsVertigo · 15/11/2026 18:04

interesting turn of events. SIL has just replied saying that her brother got it into his head he wants to give making a Croquembouche a go and this was the perfect event, but she didn’t want to hurt my feelings by telling me my services we no longer needed. Her brother and his husband were tasked with providing canapés so this is something he is taking on in addition, it sounds divine so who am I to complain!!!

She said that she has everything else in hand and that the money would actually be a lot more practical than a dessert that will be surplus to requirements and annoying to store. But she will hold me to doing the last minute supermarket shop.

OP posts:
donthaveaname · 15/11/2026 18:07

ThatsVertigo · 15/11/2026 18:04

interesting turn of events. SIL has just replied saying that her brother got it into his head he wants to give making a Croquembouche a go and this was the perfect event, but she didn’t want to hurt my feelings by telling me my services we no longer needed. Her brother and his husband were tasked with providing canapés so this is something he is taking on in addition, it sounds divine so who am I to complain!!!

She said that she has everything else in hand and that the money would actually be a lot more practical than a dessert that will be surplus to requirements and annoying to store. But she will hold me to doing the last minute supermarket shop.

sounds like a perfect solution! You have a great sil! (And you are a great one too!)

Coconutcreamz · 15/11/2026 18:07

It sounds wonderful.
I would definitely be bringing SIL a really lovely hostess gift.
Something that she wouldn't buy herself for organising what sounds like a very magical generous holiday break.

ChocolateApples · 15/11/2026 18:08

OP, you are highly unreasonable. How date you not hate SIL. Instead you plan to enjoy a nice prosecco in the hot tub with her. I can't believe you've communicated effectively with her and deprived the board of additional drama. Children playing together and having a lovely Christmas; it's dreadful. Do better!

JMSA · 15/11/2026 18:09

Out of you both, you have significantly less to do. Please don’t make the tiramisu her problem on top of everything else.
A simple text in advance, to ask when it would suit her for you to use the kitchen to make dessert.

JMSA · 15/11/2026 18:10

Sorry, just saw the update.
She’s amazing!