Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Open phone policy at home

83 replies

Skyflier · Yesterday 10:47

Like most of us probably, my life is on my phone. My calendar, social media, messages and also I keep a journal on there. It’s nothing major - just a brain dump when life gets hard. DH has decided he wants an open phone policy at home. Now I have nothing to hide. I’m not messaging other men, having an affair or liking random men’s posts on instagram. Nothing. But I have messages from my friends on personal things they probably wouldn’t want my DH seeing. But AIBU to think my phone is my private space and not to be accessed? There is no history of cheating on either side My BIL is a pompous arse and has this policy with his wife and I think DH is copying him. I asked why all of a sudden is access to my phone important and he says he doesn’t want to see it, just wants to know if he did he could. I’m on the fence and genuinely would welcome thoughts

OP posts:
ApplePumpkin · Yesterday 10:48

My phone is private to me. And will stay that way.

BirdLandedonmyHead · Yesterday 10:57

Its like asking to read your diary. No way.
Especially since many have access to work stuff on their phones!

Brightbluesomething · Yesterday 11:03

That sounds really controlling for no good reason. I wouldn't agree to that. You're entitled to privacy. Whats his next step if you say no?

TheIntricaciesOfHarpUpkeepAndMaintenance · Yesterday 11:06

I would just say no, tbh. It’s weird and controlling. People are entitled to privacy.

WitchesBritches · Yesterday 11:10

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

NO

I have other people's private information on my phone, I respect their privacy, it's not for his eyes.

OneNewLeader · Yesterday 11:13

We have a file (paper) that has passwords to phone, bank accounts, everything really. Largely as part of our death admin. I’ve never looked at it. I’m not interested in my DH’s messages, he’s not interested in mine. Has worked for decades.

MrAlyakhin · Yesterday 11:14

I think it sounds weird. How long have you been together and been married? Why now? I would feel affronted as if I was no longer trusted. I would also lose a bit of respect for him if he's been so easily influenced by another person.

I have used DHs phone, he might use mine but we trust each other. We don't have a 'policy' about phone use.

If he insists I would be introducing all sorts of policies to piss him off - but that would signal the death knell of the relationship.

LauraNorda · Yesterday 11:18

On the other hand, how many threads have started on here with the words, "my husbands phone was just lying there so I thought I would take a look"?

SethAndReubenTooSendGaloshes · Yesterday 11:21

My DH could look at my phone if he really wanted to and I could look at his but the day either of us asks to would be the day our marriage died. Tell him to stop being so controlling and weird.

SethAndReubenTooSendGaloshes · Yesterday 11:21

LauraNorda · Yesterday 11:18

On the other hand, how many threads have started on here with the words, "my husbands phone was just lying there so I thought I would take a look"?

The one and only time in my life that I've looked at a partner's phone it was because I had reason to think he was cheating and he was. That's completely different to what OP is talking about.

Theyreeatingthedogs · Yesterday 11:22

I'd tell him to do one. I have loads of stuff on my phone I wouldn't want others to see. Nothing dodgy but it's my data.

mindutopia · Yesterday 11:23

Absolutely no way. You are not a child. There is no way I’d agree to this.

Dh and I have a very solid relationship and no cheating or concerns about cheating ever on either side in nearly 20 years.

But no way in hell would we want to have access to each other’s phones. My phone contains personal medical data, all my prescriptions, my banking, access to my emails including confidential client emails and other data for clients that I need to keep secure for data protection reasons. Same for Dh.

I want my data security solid on all devices in and out of the home. It’s for my own protection and for the integrity of my business and clients.

Sounds to me like someone is up to something on their secret burner phone and is trying to stay ahead of the game by heading off suspicions with this hare-brained controlling idea. 🙄

Pombearsinmyhair · Yesterday 11:24

Calling it a family policy doesn’t stop it being coercive control. Open phone policies are for children, not adults.

LittleBearPad · Yesterday 11:26

My DH knows my passcode and I know his. From time to time one of us will use the other’s phone to look stuff up, if it’s the nearest one to hand. We don’t however read each other’s messages or emails etc. That would be really odd.

What does an open phone policy mean specifically because if it’s being able to read texts etc, like many parents have with their children then I’d want to know why he wants it.

Jellycatspyjamas · Yesterday 11:27

Policies are for work, not family life. A big fat absolutely not from me.

persisted · Yesterday 11:28

Absolutely not. Being married doesn’t stop me from being an individual with a right to privacy. I will not put up with it.

MandemChickenShop · Yesterday 11:29

what a bell end.

tell him no, because you don't want him to see the collection of dick pics you've been building. tell him his mates have all been sending them to you over the years and you don't want him to see them as they would make him feel even more inadequate

ExtraOnions · Yesterday 11:29

We know passcodes in case something happens to one of us.

I’ve never checked my husbands phone, and he’s never checked mine. You are still allowed a private part of your life.

Bedroomdilemmas113 · Yesterday 11:30

We can look at each other’s phones and have each other’s passwords, but this is purely because we have ended up with the same password for everything. It’s entirely possible he’s changed his years ago and I wouldn’t know, but I assume it’s the same.

I have never looked through his phone and he’s never looked through mine.

I would take an open phone policy within a normal healthy relationship to mean (or should mean) you can leave your phone lying around, it’s not welded to your hand if you run for a quick wee or something. Not that your partner can access it any time he wants. Why would he actually want to? I have zero interest in what my husband emails or texts people.

Purplecatshopaholic · Yesterday 11:31

OneNewLeader · Yesterday 11:13

We have a file (paper) that has passwords to phone, bank accounts, everything really. Largely as part of our death admin. I’ve never looked at it. I’m not interested in my DH’s messages, he’s not interested in mine. Has worked for decades.

We do this too, so we could see each others phones if we wanted but we’ve never bothered. Doesn’t bother me at all.

Iknewit · Yesterday 11:33

My husband has no right to my messages, emails, search history etc and I have no right to his.
Unless there are exceptional circumstances, this is only ok for a child/teen who should have their phone regularly monitored.

MaggieBsBoat · Yesterday 11:37

I have no right to see my DHs private messages. He, like our children, has a right to a private life. The suggestion of a relationship that is otherwise smacks of coercion and control in my opinion. I’ve heard of daft things giving people the ick, but this would honestly give me the fear. The mere suggestion makes me go cold. I wouldn’t be able to look at my DH the same way after. Either that he would think this is a good idea or genuinely was that impressionable to other people’s ideas that he would suggest such nonsense.

EllisIsEllis · Yesterday 11:37

LittleBearPad · Yesterday 11:26

My DH knows my passcode and I know his. From time to time one of us will use the other’s phone to look stuff up, if it’s the nearest one to hand. We don’t however read each other’s messages or emails etc. That would be really odd.

What does an open phone policy mean specifically because if it’s being able to read texts etc, like many parents have with their children then I’d want to know why he wants it.

This is almost exactly what I was going to say.

Everyone in my family has access to to my phone, and they have all used it at some point to look something up/deal with Google Maps in the car, etc. But I 100% trust they wouldn’t pry into my personal information. I have the same access to DH’s phone (the DC don’t because it is also a work phone).

There is no ‘policy’, just trust and respect of personal space. The way your DH has phrased this sounds controlling, and like he wants the right to access everything on your phone.

materialgworl · Yesterday 11:39

He doesn’t trust you

Skyflier · Yesterday 11:40

Thank you all. I knew I wasn’t being unreasonable deep down. He’s not controlling and knows would get nowhere if he tried to be, so this is unusual. I would happily hand him my phone to use without a second thought but it’s private. It’s mine. Thank you for confirming I’m not unreasonable to say no

OP posts: