Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Open phone policy at home

91 replies

Skyflier · Yesterday 10:47

Like most of us probably, my life is on my phone. My calendar, social media, messages and also I keep a journal on there. It’s nothing major - just a brain dump when life gets hard. DH has decided he wants an open phone policy at home. Now I have nothing to hide. I’m not messaging other men, having an affair or liking random men’s posts on instagram. Nothing. But I have messages from my friends on personal things they probably wouldn’t want my DH seeing. But AIBU to think my phone is my private space and not to be accessed? There is no history of cheating on either side My BIL is a pompous arse and has this policy with his wife and I think DH is copying him. I asked why all of a sudden is access to my phone important and he says he doesn’t want to see it, just wants to know if he did he could. I’m on the fence and genuinely would welcome thoughts

OP posts:
MotherofPufflings · Yesterday 15:17

It would be a 'no' from me. And you don't even have to justify why, don't even engage or waste your emotional energy justifying it. He can rant and argue like a stroppy, unreasonable teenager if he wants to, no need for you to get embroiled.

Malasana · Yesterday 15:19

If he wants to start introducing family policies I’d be introducing a few of my own that would make his life a lot harder.

PithyBeaker · Yesterday 15:20

Skyflier · Yesterday 10:47

Like most of us probably, my life is on my phone. My calendar, social media, messages and also I keep a journal on there. It’s nothing major - just a brain dump when life gets hard. DH has decided he wants an open phone policy at home. Now I have nothing to hide. I’m not messaging other men, having an affair or liking random men’s posts on instagram. Nothing. But I have messages from my friends on personal things they probably wouldn’t want my DH seeing. But AIBU to think my phone is my private space and not to be accessed? There is no history of cheating on either side My BIL is a pompous arse and has this policy with his wife and I think DH is copying him. I asked why all of a sudden is access to my phone important and he says he doesn’t want to see it, just wants to know if he did he could. I’m on the fence and genuinely would welcome thoughts

Wow. BIL sounds a piece of work. Sounds like he and his wife have had issues and have come up with a performative way to prove their newfound trust…. It’s a “policy” easily evaded though if one or both of them have secret burner phones. Sorry but I just think this is totally bonkers and whatever spin your BIL has spun on your DH has obviously worked if he now thinks he needs it too. Wild.

GintyMcGinty · Yesterday 15:20

My phone is private.
My DH phone is private.
We trust each other.

herbalteabag · Yesterday 15:37

I would never let anyone go through my phone. It's private. I have nothing to hide, but my conversations are personal and also contain private info about other people.

Topseyt123 · Yesterday 15:52

DH and I never had a stated "open phone policy" at all. Nor did we have a joint email address either. Why is that needed?

We did actually know each other's passcodes and PIN numbers as we had just picked them up over 33 years of marriage.

We never used or looked at each other's phones either. Indeed, the only time I have ever accessed DH's phone was after he died earlier this year. Then I did need it to get information about bank accounts, utility accounts, income tax and contact information for his office colleagues, family and friends while I was organising the funeral and generally sorting through his estate, of which I am the executor and a beneficiary. Much of that information would have been difficult to get any other way.

Other than that though, I never went through his phone. I no longer need to now either, so again I don't.

Tell your DH to bugger off with his open phones policy. Ensure that you do both know how to access important accounts and information if anything should happen to one of you, but still a resounding NO! to open phones.

Skyflier · Yesterday 15:56

Thanks again everyone. It seems I’m not totally unreasonable about this boundary. I mean my phone lies around face up all the time and the most interesting texts I get are from Tesco but that’s not the point.
Hes not perfect by any means but this is out of character for him. BIL is an arsehole and they have been spending more time together so I can only conclude he’s got inside his head. I sense a conversation coming on tonight. Thank you again

OP posts:
puppyinapumpkinpatch · Yesterday 16:00

Our phones automatically lock, but we know one another's passwords / have one another's fingerprints saved to unlock (for potential emergencies and convenience), so in theory either of us could use the other's phone at any time we wish.

All that said, I would be extremely offended if my husband were implying that he needed to check up on me when there's no history of cheating between us.

Topseyt123 · Yesterday 16:06

Skyflier · Yesterday 15:56

Thanks again everyone. It seems I’m not totally unreasonable about this boundary. I mean my phone lies around face up all the time and the most interesting texts I get are from Tesco but that’s not the point.
Hes not perfect by any means but this is out of character for him. BIL is an arsehole and they have been spending more time together so I can only conclude he’s got inside his head. I sense a conversation coming on tonight. Thank you again

Tell him during the conversation that you sense arsehole BIL being at work behind this nonsense and you won't be complying.

Tell DH that he needs to take what arsehole BIL says with a sizeable pinch of salt and not be drawn in by it. He should know better than to let himself be influenced by such stuff.

TheSmallAssassin · Yesterday 16:18

I don't think it's odd to have a joint email address, we have one in addition to our personal addresses, and used it for school and still do for supermarket accounts, dealing with tradies and stuff like that, if someone wants to send us an invoice, that's the address I would use, then it's not automatically my job to sort it out.

My husband has told me his phone PIN in the past, but I need to be reminded every time I need to use it, and vice versa, but if he wanted an "open phone policy" he would get short shrift, either we trust each other or we don't.

Tortephant · Yesterday 16:53

MagnoliaParks · Yesterday 15:06

lol. DH and I use our phones interchangeably. I’ve never called it a policy or thought about it, but we would pick up the closest or most charged phone to Google something or to call someone we both know or to order something on Amazon (as examples).

I’ll often reply to texts for DH when he’s driving too.

I’ve never picked up his phone and gone through his messages or notes or calls or browsing history the same way I’ve never done that on my phone either. But there’s literally nothing on my phone he wouldn’t already know about (that he would care about, he doesn’t know the content of my WhatsApp with friends but there’s nothing in there he’d be interested in anyway!) and presumably he feels the same about his phone.

I’m an independent, stubborn, bossy person - it’s not a codependency or trust thing - it’s just a how do we live our lives in the easiest and most efficient way, so if I need to use a phone I use the most convenient one.

Totally agree.
This isn't about snooping, there is nothing to snoop about. It's using a device as part of our lives.

Tortephant · Yesterday 16:55

Bedroomdilemmas113 · Yesterday 14:12

You share a mailbox? As in an email address?

That is very strange if so.

Yes, we share a mailbox, and have a joint email address. We also have our own independent email address from before we met, which is useful occasionally.
I'm staggered you find that strange!

Raiderofthelostbattenburg · Yesterday 16:55

Definitely controlling. It would be a no from me. How could your friends trust you to have private conversations over messages if your partner was reading everything? What if you wanted to vent - as you’re entitled to - in private to friends about your other half?

Shinyandnew1 · Yesterday 16:59

That makes him sounds like a controlling arse! Basically, he wants an excuse to go through your phone without your agreement?!

Tortephant · Yesterday 17:04

Raiderofthelostbattenburg · Yesterday 16:55

Definitely controlling. It would be a no from me. How could your friends trust you to have private conversations over messages if your partner was reading everything? What if you wanted to vent - as you’re entitled to - in private to friends about your other half?

Sharing a phone does not mean snooping! If anything it takes away any feeling of need and mistrust!
I'm genuinely shocked by this thread. Do so many people have such poor relationships they have to keep things secret from their DPs?

Raiderofthelostbattenburg · Yesterday 17:07

Tortephant · Yesterday 17:04

Sharing a phone does not mean snooping! If anything it takes away any feeling of need and mistrust!
I'm genuinely shocked by this thread. Do so many people have such poor relationships they have to keep things secret from their DPs?

I think “an open phone policy” absolutely suggests snooping - or at least feeling entitled to read messages that were not intended for you. Respecting each other’s privacy is not the same as “keeping secrets”.

TheSmallAssassin · Yesterday 17:07

Tortephant · Yesterday 17:04

Sharing a phone does not mean snooping! If anything it takes away any feeling of need and mistrust!
I'm genuinely shocked by this thread. Do so many people have such poor relationships they have to keep things secret from their DPs?

There's secret and there's private! We don't need to share phones to dispel distrust, we inherently trust each other because we don't have a poor relationship. What's the point in staying together otherwise?

Tortephant · Yesterday 17:13

Raiderofthelostbattenburg · Yesterday 17:07

I think “an open phone policy” absolutely suggests snooping - or at least feeling entitled to read messages that were not intended for you. Respecting each other’s privacy is not the same as “keeping secrets”.

It's not a 'policy'!! They are our phones. full stop.

Raiderofthelostbattenburg · Yesterday 17:18

Tortephant · Yesterday 17:13

It's not a 'policy'!! They are our phones. full stop.

Sure, but I wasn't commenting on your personal set up - I was replying to the OP's question. In her post she said her husband framed it as an 'open phone policy' - that's the title of the thread. And an 'open phone policy' is something I personally would find controlling and, for me, would be indicitative of a lack of trust in the relationship and a lack of respect for each other's privacy.

SockFluffInTheBath · Yesterday 17:21

But I have messages from my friends on personal things they probably wouldn’t want my DH seeing.

I’d say this to him, and if he pushes it I would want to know why he thinks he has the right to be lord and master all of a sudden.

Leavemetonguetied · Yesterday 17:22

I wish my DH would read and respond to my work emails. I'm drowning.

Bedroomdilemmas113 · Yesterday 17:32

Tortephant · Yesterday 16:55

Yes, we share a mailbox, and have a joint email address. We also have our own independent email address from before we met, which is useful occasionally.
I'm staggered you find that strange!

And when you send an email from that mailbox who does it come from? Jane and Peter Smith? Or just one of your names?

This is one of the strangest things I’ve ever heard.

morgan56 · Yesterday 17:45

I also imagine that the more you resist this, the more he will push and wonder why if you don’t have anything to hide.

It is ridiculous and immature of him to expect this. I wouldn’t have it in my relationship, even if my partner said it would be the end.

Applestroodle · Yesterday 17:56

What does open phone mean? Mutual regular checks or just knowing the passcode?

DH and I both know each others passcodes. I occasionally answer or use his. I normally have nine with me so I don’t think he looks at mine.

OrangeBlouse · Yesterday 18:00

Tortephant · Yesterday 16:55

Yes, we share a mailbox, and have a joint email address. We also have our own independent email address from before we met, which is useful occasionally.
I'm staggered you find that strange!

Staggered? Really?

Swipe left for the next trending thread