Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Open phone policy at home

91 replies

Skyflier · Yesterday 10:47

Like most of us probably, my life is on my phone. My calendar, social media, messages and also I keep a journal on there. It’s nothing major - just a brain dump when life gets hard. DH has decided he wants an open phone policy at home. Now I have nothing to hide. I’m not messaging other men, having an affair or liking random men’s posts on instagram. Nothing. But I have messages from my friends on personal things they probably wouldn’t want my DH seeing. But AIBU to think my phone is my private space and not to be accessed? There is no history of cheating on either side My BIL is a pompous arse and has this policy with his wife and I think DH is copying him. I asked why all of a sudden is access to my phone important and he says he doesn’t want to see it, just wants to know if he did he could. I’m on the fence and genuinely would welcome thoughts

OP posts:
Pedant61 · Yesterday 11:40

You are 100% right, OP. We never look at each other's phones - why would we?

Itsasecretnow · Yesterday 11:42

My partner knows my passcode, as sometimes I’ve asked him to do something/keep hold of my phone if expecting a call that I can’t answer myself etc, and I’m not there for my face. But he’d never snoop, has never asked to look at my phone, and cares so little that he can never remember the code anyway. He’d have no problem passing me his phone if I wanted to show him something/help him with something. I actually have no idea if his current phone has a password on it as I’ve never needed to go on it apart from the rare thing like above, while he’s actually there. I do find it weird when someone says this.
Ive actually just had a conversation with my oh as I was writing this, asking what he thinks about it and we talked about the fact that we’ve no problem with the other having passcodes or anything, and he also said he thinks it’s weird, “why would anyone want to do that?!” (Referring to the open phone policy). We’d obviously share location if it was ever needed for any reason, but in the same vein as the open phone bs neither of us understands the need for any “tracking” apps, which it seems (from reading on here) sometimes can come after the demand for having an open phone. (Although I guess it’s different sometimes with families with kids, our (respective) kids have been grown up for years).
Op, have there been any other recent changes in your family, or with your husband?

Notmycircusnotmyotter · Yesterday 11:42

Absolutely not. You're allowed a private life.

LittleCatLife · Yesterday 11:43

We have this agreement but dh never wants to check mine !

PotteringAlonggotkickedoutandhadtoreregister · Yesterday 11:43

Like others, in theory we have this. DH and I have the same passcodes for our phones so that we can access them in case of an emergency - our whole lives are on there and, god forbid something happens, going to the apple shop to get them to break into his phone so I can access his online accounts etc is not top of the list of priorities.

In reality though our phones are private. No one looks, no one needs to.

SquigglePigs · Yesterday 11:46

I suppose technically DH and I have this because we both use the same pass code for our phones (and tablet and computers), we just wouldn't look. We've never formally agreed a "policy" though.

But you have every right to say no and he is being unreasonable to insist!

Itiswhysofew · Yesterday 11:46

I have nothing on mine that I'd be worried about, but it's my property and I'll be the one to decide if it gets looked at or used by anyone else.

Librarina · Yesterday 11:51

If my husband wants to see something on my phone (eg recently he needed to search for an email for some tickets), he would ask and if I was busy I would say yes and if I was free I would probably do it myself.

I've asked him if I can look for a picture I can remember him taking and he's said yes because it was easier for me to do it than for me to articulate the image I was trying to search for

I don't particularly understand this sense of a phone being strictly out of bounds. We know each other screen lock numbers but we don't actively 'check' each other. I suppose that's what trust looks like.

Livpool · Yesterday 11:51

No way would I be doing this. DH and I know each other’s passcodes and have occasionally used for looking something up urgently or to change a playlist. But not an ‘official’ open phone policy, you aren’t a child.

Pearlstillsinging · Yesterday 11:55

Just tell him it's against GDPR! Does he really want you to ask all your contacts for permission to give him access to their personal details?
I would expect that to make him think twice about the impression your contacts would get of him/his demands.

Skyflier · Yesterday 12:07

materialgworl · Yesterday 11:39

He doesn’t trust you

It does sound that way but I have given him no reason not to ever and I’m not doing anything. The only thing I have changed is that after years of bringing up my sons I am prioritizing some me time and not sure DH gets it. It’s only having a bit of Sunday self care now (I’m not at your gym every day or running marathons). He is a big old fashioned in that he likes Sunday to be us day but when I still work full time I don’t get much space for just me. I don’t see it as selfish, just self preservation

OP posts:
UnoriginalPoster · Yesterday 12:08

MrAlyakhin · Yesterday 11:14

I think it sounds weird. How long have you been together and been married? Why now? I would feel affronted as if I was no longer trusted. I would also lose a bit of respect for him if he's been so easily influenced by another person.

I have used DHs phone, he might use mine but we trust each other. We don't have a 'policy' about phone use.

If he insists I would be introducing all sorts of policies to piss him off - but that would signal the death knell of the relationship.

Edited

If he insists I would be introducing all sorts of policies to piss him off - but that would signal the death knell of the relationship.

I'd start with a 'no sex with anyone who does not see me as an autonomous adult' policy.

PumpkinsForLife · Yesterday 12:26

We share our phone codes so we can use each other’s if we need to. That isn't the same as an open phone policy and I'd feel very betrayed if I found out my husband had read my messages.

Tortephant · Yesterday 12:27

We just use which ever phone is closest if we want to check or look something up. We share a diary and mailbox. Total open phone policy if that’s what you want to call it. To me that’s normal and a part of a happy trusting relationship.

Bedroomdilemmas113 · Yesterday 14:12

Tortephant · Yesterday 12:27

We just use which ever phone is closest if we want to check or look something up. We share a diary and mailbox. Total open phone policy if that’s what you want to call it. To me that’s normal and a part of a happy trusting relationship.

You share a mailbox? As in an email address?

That is very strange if so.

TheEyesOfLucyJordon · Yesterday 14:27

ApplePumpkin · Yesterday 10:48

My phone is private to me. And will stay that way.

As is mine. I share as little as possible with as many as possible. CCTV and phone masts are already tracking my (occasionally exciting but usually pretty steady) life 🤬

Vaxtable · Yesterday 14:29

It’s a no from me. I would simply point out it’s like having a personal diary and it won’t be shared

ThereIsAPlaceForThis · Yesterday 14:53

I reckon BIL is shifty and has a second phone, with this “policy” as a smokescreen.

DH doesn’t know this, but is copying BIL either in admiration of his excellence, or under persuasion, so that BIL can tell SIL it’s totes normal and look, you guys do it too.

MagnoliaParks · Yesterday 15:01

Bedroomdilemmas113 · Yesterday 14:12

You share a mailbox? As in an email address?

That is very strange if so.

Surely it’s not? DH and I do, as do my parents and in in-laws.

Many of the emails we get are for both of us (utilities, mortgage, delivery notifications, purchases for the house, holidays, supermarket shop, Netflix etc) - it would be stranger for only one of us to get this and to have to forward the emails on to the other all of the time.

I have my own personal email address too, but I can’t even imagine why a cohabiting couple wouldn’t have a joint email address.

MagnoliaParks · Yesterday 15:06

ThereIsAPlaceForThis · Yesterday 14:53

I reckon BIL is shifty and has a second phone, with this “policy” as a smokescreen.

DH doesn’t know this, but is copying BIL either in admiration of his excellence, or under persuasion, so that BIL can tell SIL it’s totes normal and look, you guys do it too.

lol. DH and I use our phones interchangeably. I’ve never called it a policy or thought about it, but we would pick up the closest or most charged phone to Google something or to call someone we both know or to order something on Amazon (as examples).

I’ll often reply to texts for DH when he’s driving too.

I’ve never picked up his phone and gone through his messages or notes or calls or browsing history the same way I’ve never done that on my phone either. But there’s literally nothing on my phone he wouldn’t already know about (that he would care about, he doesn’t know the content of my WhatsApp with friends but there’s nothing in there he’d be interested in anyway!) and presumably he feels the same about his phone.

I’m an independent, stubborn, bossy person - it’s not a codependency or trust thing - it’s just a how do we live our lives in the easiest and most efficient way, so if I need to use a phone I use the most convenient one.

AuroraBloom · Yesterday 15:09

I can't imagine having a joint email address with my DP. It takes seconds to forward an email if it's needed.

AuroraBloom · Yesterday 15:11

We are also individual people and not just a couple.

OrangeBlouse · Yesterday 15:14

I have my own personal email address too, but I can’t even imagine why a cohabiting couple wouldn’t have a joint email address.

I can’t imagine why they would. Do two people become one amorphous blob when they become a couple?

I’d never heard of this before Mumsnet. Then a few years ago an old school friend posted this excited Facebook update about how “OMG, it’s actually happening - we’re combining profiles!!” Apparently she and her fiancé no longer needed individual ones 🙄

The switch to the new surname didn’t last long…

singthing · Yesterday 15:16

All this "oh we have no secrets" and "why would we we need separate email addresses?" is so creepy. First off, everyone is entitled to privacy for no reason other than they just are. People who feel the need to be inside each other's lives aren't better than those who are happy respect healthy boundaries. If there is no trust to let someone have that basic human expectation, then what's the point of your relationship?

And people who use "if you have nothing to hide" as an argument are just a walking red flag.

And second, it's not just about you, is it? All the people connected to the other person who may transmit information for the recipient's eyes aren't agreeing to you reading or seeing it as well.

ThePeppyOpalScroller · Yesterday 15:17

Your phone wont just have your information on it, it might also contain private information that other people have shared with you specifically. So no, an "open phone policy" would likely be an invasion of someone else's privacy.