Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

M&S calling security because a child was queuing to buy bread.

337 replies

Tinogirl · Yesterday 09:30

Reading another thread prompted me to post this.

Our M&S just a food one, is small with one entrance and a carpark obviously with pedestrian crossings between carpark and shop.

A few weeks ago around 4ish in the afternoon when it was still light I was queuing to pay behind a late primary school girl who was in school uniform. She had three batons of bread.

The cashier asked me if we were together without serving the child. The cashier asked her if she was alone and the child said her mother was in the car in the car park.

The cashier refused to serve her and called security who with a female member of staff took her back to the carpark .

WTF? I and everyone in the queues could not believe it.

When I pushed my trolley out the mother of the. Hold was arguing with the female member of staff. There were two other children in the car. The female staff member offered to stay with the car while the mother bought the bread but the mother just shouted she would never shop in there again.

I don’t think the mother did anything wrong.

I used to send my daughter into a small CoOp and a Tesco Metro while I waited outside to give her independence.

What do people think?

OP posts:
ColinISabirthdaycake · Yesterday 11:30

AffableApple · Yesterday 11:17

What do young carers do? Starve?

Well I guess they are older, but still.

maggisimpson · Yesterday 11:33

My 9 year old walks to Tesco on her own to buy things for me 😂

(sometimes I illegally give her my card to pay with too...)

MushMonster · Yesterday 11:33

SwanRivers · Yesterday 11:29

That is ridiculous. This girl was not shoplifting. She was queueing to pay!

Do you understand what a 'blanket ban' means?

The staff in my local Morrisons have been left absolutely terrified after gangs of school kids have steamed into the store en masse to shoplift.

They don't make these rules lightly.

I am really not worried about any type of ban, because I do not shop in places ran by idiots. Thanks.

DanceMumTaxi · Yesterday 11:33

God what is the world coming to. It’s not like she was sent in for something like knives or booze. It was just a few loaves of bread. This is the craziest thing I’ve heard in ages. How are children supposed to learn to be independent if they’re never allowed to try.

LauderSyme · Yesterday 11:34

If M&S has a shoplifting problem they should have security in place to deal with it. The girl was clearly doing exactly what the shop exists for, ie. purchasing food, and using security to handle her in this scenario seems wrong and ludicrous.

M&S is not entitled to act in loco parentis and I'd be writing to them to demand an explanation.

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · Yesterday 11:34

This is ridiculous, nothing wrong with someone that age doing this. How can kids learn and developed in a healthy way if we don’t allow any independence

SwanRivers · Yesterday 11:34

MushMonster · Yesterday 11:33

I am really not worried about any type of ban, because I do not shop in places ran by idiots. Thanks.

Idiots to protect their staff and customers from violent, shoplifting thugs?

Weird but your choice of course.

SwanRivers · Yesterday 11:38

LauderSyme · Yesterday 11:34

If M&S has a shoplifting problem they should have security in place to deal with it. The girl was clearly doing exactly what the shop exists for, ie. purchasing food, and using security to handle her in this scenario seems wrong and ludicrous.

M&S is not entitled to act in loco parentis and I'd be writing to them to demand an explanation.

They do.

But can you imagine the Mumsnet threads?

"I was shopping in M&S with my newborn baby when a gang of around 20+ schoolchildren ran into the store, shoving everyone out of the way and shoplifting everything they could get their hands on.

Kids were terrified and screaming, as were the elderly customers. The security staff did their best but they were outnumbered.

This is the 3rd time it's happened. AIBU to think they should ban kids in school uniforms before someone gets seriously hurt?"

This ^^ is very similar to the posts in my local FB community group.

LauderSyme · Yesterday 11:38

SwanRivers · Yesterday 11:34

Idiots to protect their staff and customers from violent, shoplifting thugs?

Weird but your choice of course.

Yes, fair point in general, but the schoolgirl in question here was obviously not a violent, shoplifting thug.

SwanRivers · Yesterday 11:39

LauderSyme · Yesterday 11:38

Yes, fair point in general, but the schoolgirl in question here was obviously not a violent, shoplifting thug.

But a blanket ban is a blanket ban.

Or do you expect the woman to risk losing her job?

PurpleThistle7 · Yesterday 11:42

Totally bizarre. We live a block or so from a corner store and my kids love being sent to pick up something. They’ve had their own debit cards since they were around 9, and I would send cash when they were younger.

XenaSharples · Yesterday 11:45

I used to buy my father's cigarettes at that age, but I needed a note from my parents to buy a tiny bottle of whiskey for my granny. Apparently the doctor recommended it.

IzzyLeng · Yesterday 11:45

When my Dd was 10yo she used to catch the bus into town with her friend and go round the shops and then come back on the bus. No adult in sight. I’d certainly have sent her into M&S to get bread on her own!

JLou08 · Yesterday 11:46

The staff were ridiculous. Late primary school age is the right age for them to become more independent in using a shop alone. I don't quite understand why they couldn't have let her complete the purchase and then escorted her to the car if they were genuinely concerned about her safety.

LauderSyme · Yesterday 11:46

I think you're getting a bit carried away with your irrational perception of risk here SwanRivers.

In reality you don't actually know whether this particular M&S store has instituted a blanket ban on schoolchildren in uniform.

milveycrohn · Yesterday 11:51

The problem here is that my understanding is, that school children in secondary school (year 7 and above), or age 11, would be expected to take themselves to and from school on their own (with the exception of a complicated journey maybe).
Therefore it is imperative that late primary age children are encouraged to gradually be more independent.
This means shopping (with parent outside as in this case), etc.
It is a far cry from when I was a child and used to travel out on my own from age around 7. I certainly understand that things have changed since then.

Candleabra · Yesterday 11:51

Staff were being ridiculous. But I’ve had arguments with the staff in M&S before and it’s often company policy that they privately disagree with but have to follow as they get mystery shopped all the time. One staff member (quietly) asked me to write to head office to challenge their policies as it was the only way to get anyone to listen.

BunkBedsArePeopleShelves · Yesterday 11:54

GooseCreekandtheRiver · Yesterday 10:31

What difference would it make whether she was paying by cash or card?

Kids bank accounts also have cards.

Indeed my 11 year old does her own shopping with her own visa card and has done for 2 years!

Strawberrydelight78 · Yesterday 11:55

Some supermarkets don’t allow unaccompanied children in because of anti social behaviour and shop lifting.

Strawberrydelight78 · Yesterday 11:56

Some supermarkets don’t allow unaccompanied children in because of anti social behaviour and shop lifting.

amber763 · Yesterday 11:56

Bloody hell I used to be sent to the shop as a kid with a note from my great aunt to buy her cigs. The staff were being utterly ridiculous

Flymyprettiesflies · Yesterday 11:57

That’s mad!

GardenAnarchist · Yesterday 11:57

So as the morning has progressed, we've moved from "the child is using a stolen bank card to buy iPhones" to "the child is part of violent gang of thugs terrorising shoppers with newborn babes" Grin

Thatcannotberight · Yesterday 11:59

That's insane. One of DS' friends in yr6 used to shop for his mum. He had walk to a ferry, cross the river, walk up to Sainsbury's and buy enough shopping to go in a shopping trolley, then go home. He did this every week. Nobody thought it was terrible. Including staff in the store.

ThisOldTrout · Yesterday 12:01

Clearly you were an onlookers and therefore it is not your business now the matter has passed. I would have avocated for the child at the time and stepped in amd said the child was before you and if the assistant declined to sell the bread purely on discrimination that the customer was a child, I would have intervened..but you knew what happened thereafter, the child was escorted back out to her mothers car and there was an altercation. It seems bizarre , M and S were only within their rights if the child was misbehaving in the store, attempting to shop lift, attempting to buy products that cannot be sold to children, unable because of immaturity to manage the errand . The mother should send a stiffly worded letter to the Head Office , to the CEO and copied to the store. Her reasons for sending in her daughter to the shop was that she was minding her other children in the car and did not see a need for them all to go in for the bread. I take it also that this child was not in her pyjamas because this is becoming a new unacceptable trend Im noticing, scantily clad females perusing the aisles of supermarkets in their nightwear!

Swipe left for the next trending thread