Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

It’s a DIL one this time!

929 replies

Muminturmoil0 · 14/11/2026 22:53

Long time lurker, first time poster.
I know MILs get a rough ride on MN but I don’t know where else to go.
I really don’t believe IABU so probably the wrong board to post on and I’m sure some of you will say IABU but also hoping for some advice and also to vent.

DS has been with his wife for I don’t know maybe 20 years and married about 15. They have twin 10 yo DDs
Last year DS came to stay with us, saying his wife had kicked him out for cheating. We were upset but didn’t question him on it as he didn’t seem to want to talk about it. He stayed with us around 6 weeks and eventually went home to his wife and children, 100 miles away from us. I didn’t ask any info and he didn’t tell us any. Personally I think she’s a mug for having him back but apparently they’re having therapy and working on things, so I’ve not said anything.
Was having monthly calls with DS and DGDs after he left here but the wife wouldn’t show her face on the calls. We’ve had no visits from any of them.

Anyway DS has now called us with a barrage of abuse telling us what awful people we are and I’m shocked! We had him staying here when his wife kicked him out and never interfered. He says we’ve not been supportive, his wife has never liked us (first I’ve heard!) and DGDs find us difficult too (again, first I’ve heard!)
I can’t help but think DIL has poisoned DS and DGDs against us and I don’t know why she would, maybe embarrassment, but we’ve done nothing wrong. I’m now told we can’t speak to our DGDs until we take responsibility for our actions. What actions? We’ve done nothing. AIBU for thinking they can all fuck off! DS has pissed me off as well tbh for falling for this shit from his wife. My DD agrees with us and thinks they (mainly DIL) are the problem, so I don’t think it is us and it’s good to hear that it’s not just me and DH who think it.

Would be good to know what MNers think should happen next. I think it’s on DS and his wife to get in touch with us, but I just don’t know what to expect next. He put the phone down on me because he didn’t like that I was standing up for myself and not just apologising for made up accusations.
I know MILs are often hated on here, but remember some of us are good and sometimes DILs are not. So help on what to expect from them next and what might happen next for anyone who has been in a similar situation would be gratefully received.

Can give more info or background if needed, happy to answer questions if helps with context. We’ve always been a nice happy family, but looking back I have felt the distance from DS since he moved away to where his wife and her family are from. But interactions up until now have been fine, so I don’t know where this has all come from. Hence why I’m thinking DIL may have had a heavy hand in this.

Expecting some criticism, but hopefully more help that hate. TIA.

OP posts:
99bottlesofkombucha · Today 09:56

SixtySomething · Today 09:06

So thank goodness for that.

I read post after post condemning OP in the worst terms the poster can think of.The range of insults used is impressive.
But it's all based on conjecture and how the poster chooses to look at the situation.
We don't know what actually happened. For all we know, DIL is a serial adulterer herself.
Personally I think the thread should be removed. It's unimaginable what it must be like to be on the receiving end of abuse like this. I just hope OP is no longer with us, for her sake and her wellbeing.

Ahhaaa not a chance, if the dil were a serial adulterer, ops opening post and every single follow up post would have mentioned ‘the skanky serial cheater’ in multiple ways. That’s pretty clear from her posts.

SixtySomething · Today 10:23

99bottlesofkombucha · Today 09:56

Ahhaaa not a chance, if the dil were a serial adulterer, ops opening post and every single follow up post would have mentioned ‘the skanky serial cheater’ in multiple ways. That’s pretty clear from her posts.

Of course DDIL probably isn’t a serial cheater. But my point is that there are so many things we don’t know which might make the situation look entirely different in one direction or another.
We have no business judging.
The outstanding thing for me is OP stating this is her first post; it was written with naivety/ innocence about what would come next,
The one thing that is certain is the glee with which MNetters pile in for the kill. I always have the image of a hunt chasing a poor lonely fox when I read these pile ons.
I think MN should have a fund for counselling for victims of pile ons. It must be awful.

Nettie1964 · Today 10:30

I am going to get a lot of heat for this but here goes. Most of the men I have known are so stupid and weak that if they want to stay with their wife they will listen to anything they say. "Your mum prefers her daughter's kids" " your mum supported you even though you cheated". I was once threatened with you will never see your Gc again, it just made me laugh. There is nothing you can do if someone makes this choice. Let them crack on with it. I wouldnt waste a single second worrying about it. Get on with your life enjoy it.i just wouldnt let anyone control me this way. Ps I still see my GDs the endless free babysitting and financial support proved to important. If the threat had been carried through I would have booked a nice holiday or ceramics course with the money I saved. Some DIL are absulute poison.

Lyraloo · Today 10:31

SixtySomething · Today 09:06

So thank goodness for that.

I read post after post condemning OP in the worst terms the poster can think of.The range of insults used is impressive.
But it's all based on conjecture and how the poster chooses to look at the situation.
We don't know what actually happened. For all we know, DIL is a serial adulterer herself.
Personally I think the thread should be removed. It's unimaginable what it must be like to be on the receiving end of abuse like this. I just hope OP is no longer with us, for her sake and her wellbeing.

WOw, her wellbeing! What about her poor dil and more to the point, her “blood” grandchildren. Don’t you care those poor kids lost a parent for six weeks and their grandmother didn’t even ring to ask if they were ok. Now you think she deserves sympathy! You’re clearly as delusional as she is!

Sotiredimightreallydie · Today 10:31

SixtySomething · Today 09:16

'But we all play interfering old bat bingo and raise it in the group chats when someone does it 😂'
Thank goodness I don't have to listen to you. Your attitude is awful. I'm sure anyone who offers their opinion means it kindly, Why can't you be thankful they're interested in your baby?
Why do you think you know it all? All this sneering at people who offer advice is pathetic. I remember the HV pointing out that the mittens on my DS's first babygro were too tight and he couldn't stretch out his hands. It sure was useful asit wouldnot have occurred to me. How can you have the arrogance to think you and only you know all there is to know about your baby?

I agree for the most part. With the exclusion of obvious flashpoints (boob Vs bottle, sleep training, car seats etc), I don't think there's anything wrong with sharing advice and I didn't have an issue with it myself.

But I'm an older mummy and quite confident in my parenting so I'd listen and then discard advice I didn't want/things that wouldn't work with my baby, without a second thought. I think more nervous mums can find it trickier though.

So I don't offer any advice, but it's a shame that people are more comfortable looking for anonymous tips online/through forums, rather than their friends and family.

It's clear how the MIL was with the advice here though, and given how little the she seems to spend with her grandchildren (these ones anyway...) I'm not surprised how DIL felt.

Velumental · Today 10:35

Nettie1964 · Today 10:30

I am going to get a lot of heat for this but here goes. Most of the men I have known are so stupid and weak that if they want to stay with their wife they will listen to anything they say. "Your mum prefers her daughter's kids" " your mum supported you even though you cheated". I was once threatened with you will never see your Gc again, it just made me laugh. There is nothing you can do if someone makes this choice. Let them crack on with it. I wouldnt waste a single second worrying about it. Get on with your life enjoy it.i just wouldnt let anyone control me this way. Ps I still see my GDs the endless free babysitting and financial support proved to important. If the threat had been carried through I would have booked a nice holiday or ceramics course with the money I saved. Some DIL are absulute poison.

This is a ridiculous way to absolve men of any autonomy

carchi · Today 10:46

They are having therapy and in my experience the therapist always asks about childhood and relationship with parents. This would bring the focus on you and away from him. Is it possible that he sees this as a way to blame you for his infidelity and persuade his wife that it's not his fault at the same time. Also the timing fits as up until then he was happily living with and talking to you.

SixtySomething · Today 10:46

Velumental · Today 10:35

This is a ridiculous way to absolve men of any autonomy

It’s pretty accurate though, depending on on the men you know. I’m sure there are honourable exceptions.

Velumental · Today 10:56

SixtySomething · Today 10:46

It’s pretty accurate though, depending on on the men you know. I’m sure there are honourable exceptions.

I can hand on heart say I don't know any men being held to ransom by their wives in this way.

How old are you? Do you have grown sons you think you see this in?

AppleCerulean · Today 11:02

SixtySomething · Today 10:46

It’s pretty accurate though, depending on on the men you know. I’m sure there are honourable exceptions.

I don't think most men are 'stupid and weak'. It doesn't fit any of the men in my life.

rainingsnoring · Today 11:02

thepariscrimefiles · Today 09:07

Many posters just read the first post and then vote. OP's subsequent posts show her views and behaviour in a much worse light, particularly about how she has treated her DIL who put in all the effort to try and build and maintain her MIL's relationship with her grandchildren. Having read all OP's posts, many people have found it difficult to defend her which are why most of the posts are supportive of OP's DIL and not OP herself.

I agree. The first post is the least bad and I think some people have simply taken the OP at her word and assumed that there must be some kind of back history with a difficult DIL.
If you read it properly though, even the first post is pretty terrible.
For starters, it's really odd to have your DS turn up having been kicked out for cheating and ask him absolutely nothing about it. That's not a normal response from what the OP describes as 'a naice, happy family'. She refers to her DIL as 'a mug' for having him back. She also said 'we've had no visits from any of them', as if they are royalty and completely unable to call or visit the family, (a family who are smarting after an infidelity). It then gets worse when you discover that the wife finds them unsupportive, and the DGDs find them difficult (why might that be?!) and then 'I can’t help but think DIL has poisoned DS and DGDs against us'. This conclusion is based on absolutely nothing that has been said in the first or any subsequent post. To top it off, she has brought her DD into this fall out, who has also decided that the evil DIL is to blame, despite no evidence for this.
As you said, it only goes downhill after this!

AppleCerulean · Today 11:05

carchi · Today 10:46

They are having therapy and in my experience the therapist always asks about childhood and relationship with parents. This would bring the focus on you and away from him. Is it possible that he sees this as a way to blame you for his infidelity and persuade his wife that it's not his fault at the same time. Also the timing fits as up until then he was happily living with and talking to you.

People keep popping up to say this, but the OP lists the accusations her son has made and they're all to do with her treatment of his wife early in their relationship, during pregnancy and postpartum up until now. She hasn't said that he's brought up any childhood issues - the problems she says her son has raised with her are that she stayed friends with his ex, criticised the DIL, refused to stop giving unwelcome advice and demanded that they do all the travelling so it would be easier for her. So this really doesn't seem to be a case of a therapist bringing up childhood memories - this is all behaviour the OP has exhibited through her son's marriage, not his early life.

SixtySomething · Today 11:05

Velumental · Today 10:56

I can hand on heart say I don't know any men being held to ransom by their wives in this way.

How old are you? Do you have grown sons you think you see this in?

My age is in my username . I don’t want to be specific but I have seen it in general across my extended family, yes. Also with friends.

The woman has no particular love for her DH’s family.
She decided how she’s going go play things for her own benefit and, yes, DH falls in presumably for an easier life.
I can quite see the situation OP describes where his previously dearly beloved DM is suddenly transformed into a villain without apparently having done anything. Unfortunately, she may well stay in that role until DiL or DS decide she’s useful eg for money or childcare, or something else.

rainingsnoring · Today 11:08

Sotiredimightreallydie · Today 10:31

I agree for the most part. With the exclusion of obvious flashpoints (boob Vs bottle, sleep training, car seats etc), I don't think there's anything wrong with sharing advice and I didn't have an issue with it myself.

But I'm an older mummy and quite confident in my parenting so I'd listen and then discard advice I didn't want/things that wouldn't work with my baby, without a second thought. I think more nervous mums can find it trickier though.

So I don't offer any advice, but it's a shame that people are more comfortable looking for anonymous tips online/through forums, rather than their friends and family.

It's clear how the MIL was with the advice here though, and given how little the she seems to spend with her grandchildren (these ones anyway...) I'm not surprised how DIL felt.

Exactly. I think many DILs would be perfectly willing to take advice from a kind and trusted MIL, who had a long history of being a supportive, older woman in her life, who had made an effort to foster a good relationship and spent time with her over the preceding years.
The OP, on the other hand, barely knows the DIL, clearly doesn't care for her at all, has never bothered to visit the young family and thinks of her as a vessel to carry her grandchildren. What woman would be prepared to take advice from such a person?!

rainingsnoring · Today 11:10

Nettie1964 · Today 10:30

I am going to get a lot of heat for this but here goes. Most of the men I have known are so stupid and weak that if they want to stay with their wife they will listen to anything they say. "Your mum prefers her daughter's kids" " your mum supported you even though you cheated". I was once threatened with you will never see your Gc again, it just made me laugh. There is nothing you can do if someone makes this choice. Let them crack on with it. I wouldnt waste a single second worrying about it. Get on with your life enjoy it.i just wouldnt let anyone control me this way. Ps I still see my GDs the endless free babysitting and financial support proved to important. If the threat had been carried through I would have booked a nice holiday or ceramics course with the money I saved. Some DIL are absulute poison.

If this thread and others are anything to go by, there are large numbers of poisonous MILs out there! It does a man credit if he stands by the woman he chose to marry, the mother of his children, rather than ganging up on her with a jealous MIL.

rainingsnoring · Today 11:14

SixtySomething · Today 09:06

So thank goodness for that.

I read post after post condemning OP in the worst terms the poster can think of.The range of insults used is impressive.
But it's all based on conjecture and how the poster chooses to look at the situation.
We don't know what actually happened. For all we know, DIL is a serial adulterer herself.
Personally I think the thread should be removed. It's unimaginable what it must be like to be on the receiving end of abuse like this. I just hope OP is no longer with us, for her sake and her wellbeing.

It's not all based on conjecture at all. The comments are based on what @Muminturmoil0 has actually written herself! The OP has written the very best version of events from her own perspective.
I would love to hear the DIL's perspective but perhaps you would not. It's funny that you accuse others of conjecture and then remark that the DIL may be a serial adulterer herself! You seem so desperate for the MIL to be in the right here that I think you must be projecting.

rainingsnoring · Today 11:15

SixtySomething · Today 10:46

It’s pretty accurate though, depending on on the men you know. I’m sure there are honourable exceptions.

What a depressing view you have of men and of women. I had no idea there were so many misogynists out there!

rainingsnoring · Today 11:30

SixtySomething · Today 11:05

My age is in my username . I don’t want to be specific but I have seen it in general across my extended family, yes. Also with friends.

The woman has no particular love for her DH’s family.
She decided how she’s going go play things for her own benefit and, yes, DH falls in presumably for an easier life.
I can quite see the situation OP describes where his previously dearly beloved DM is suddenly transformed into a villain without apparently having done anything. Unfortunately, she may well stay in that role until DiL or DS decide she’s useful eg for money or childcare, or something else.

Wow. This is a shockingly nasty post and all based on conjecture.
The 'DM' has literally spelled out many mistakes that she has made but you have chosen to ignore all of them and decide that it all must be the poor DIL's fault. Not only is it her fault but she is also just after their money. So horrible!

springintospring26 · Today 11:30

I know it sounds irrational OP but when my exdh cheated I found myself hating my in laws for a period of time. As I’ve said totally irrational but sort of thought ‘they’ve brought him up, he’s a product of them, none of my family of origin would cheat, he now comes from damaged stock’. This was even though they were wonderful to me, supportive and loving. I was just soooo hurt and angry. The feelings passed eventually, we got back together briefly but I couldn’t move on and ended the marriage. I stayed in touch with in-laws until
they both died. I wonder if your situation is anything similar. I also wonder whether your dil was angry you took your son in without question? Again unfair but …

carchi · Today 11:40

AppleCerulean · Today 11:05

People keep popping up to say this, but the OP lists the accusations her son has made and they're all to do with her treatment of his wife early in their relationship, during pregnancy and postpartum up until now. She hasn't said that he's brought up any childhood issues - the problems she says her son has raised with her are that she stayed friends with his ex, criticised the DIL, refused to stop giving unwelcome advice and demanded that they do all the travelling so it would be easier for her. So this really doesn't seem to be a case of a therapist bringing up childhood memories - this is all behaviour the OP has exhibited through her son's marriage, not his early life.

Yes I see what you mean and totally agree but I can't help wondering why this has all come out now rather than before. I'm still thinking that he trying to deflect some of the blame for his own behaviour.

TomatoSoupandCheese · Today 11:40

rainingsnoring · Today 11:08

Exactly. I think many DILs would be perfectly willing to take advice from a kind and trusted MIL, who had a long history of being a supportive, older woman in her life, who had made an effort to foster a good relationship and spent time with her over the preceding years.
The OP, on the other hand, barely knows the DIL, clearly doesn't care for her at all, has never bothered to visit the young family and thinks of her as a vessel to carry her grandchildren. What woman would be prepared to take advice from such a person?!

Exactly. My MIL didn’t give helpful advice, she just gave me her opinions about everything she thought I should be doing, about everything. It was exhausting. Down to what my DC wear, their haircuts, my house, what pushchair I should get. Everything. It’s only now I can really see it.

Chiefunderling · Today 11:47

Op, whether you believe it or not, there are many MIL’s out there who would never, ever treat their DIL’s & Grandchildren as you have done. Your lack of self-awareness is astounding & I expect that’s why you find yourself in this position. Your current behaviour & thinking also suggests that you perhaps didn’t raise your Son as well as you think you did.

The posters highlighting therapy are likely correct. Therapy will have shone a light on your parenting over the years. Your family dynamics do not sound healthy. They sound dysfunctional. There is nothing worse than a parent who refuses to self-reflect & refuses to take accountability for their poor actions & choices. Your DIL isn’t the problem here, you are. From your posts I see estrangement in your future. It’s a natural consequences of poor parenting & refusal to acknowledge past mistakes. Your DIL & Grandchildren will be better off without you in their lives.

SixtySomething · Today 11:58

rainingsnoring · Today 11:30

Wow. This is a shockingly nasty post and all based on conjecture.
The 'DM' has literally spelled out many mistakes that she has made but you have chosen to ignore all of them and decide that it all must be the poor DIL's fault. Not only is it her fault but she is also just after their money. So horrible!

‘Shockingly nasty’ !!
Yes, I can assure you, it’s a shockingly nasty situation to find yourself .
I’m unclear why you think it’s nasty to post about though? Perhaps you’ve led a sheltered life. Lots and lots of people are transactional in their relationships, meaning g they view them for what they can win/ lose from them. That includes some DDILs, and I ‘m sorry to bear such shocking news to you @rainingsnoring !
I’m actually answering a question about my own wider family and commented that it could also apply in OP’s situation.
I don’t have any opinions about OP’s DIL, certainly have no reason to imagine she’s after OP’s money.
We seem to be back in the world of MN fiction.

rainingsnoring · Today 12:03

SixtySomething · Today 11:58

‘Shockingly nasty’ !!
Yes, I can assure you, it’s a shockingly nasty situation to find yourself .
I’m unclear why you think it’s nasty to post about though? Perhaps you’ve led a sheltered life. Lots and lots of people are transactional in their relationships, meaning g they view them for what they can win/ lose from them. That includes some DDILs, and I ‘m sorry to bear such shocking news to you @rainingsnoring !
I’m actually answering a question about my own wider family and commented that it could also apply in OP’s situation.
I don’t have any opinions about OP’s DIL, certainly have no reason to imagine she’s after OP’s money.
We seem to be back in the world of MN fiction.

I could tell that you were projecting.
As you say, some people seem to be inventing fictions rather than just reading what the OP has actually written (her own, best version of events).

thegeeklady · Today 12:05

I'm thinking that some things came up in therapy and they are reacting to that. Just my guess, of course. I think therapy with them and you together would help. I am an advocate of being all together to talk with a trained psychologist to keep it civil and on track is a good step to take. I wish my family of origin would do that.

Swipe left for the next trending thread