Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

It’s a DIL one this time!

929 replies

Muminturmoil0 · 14/11/2026 22:53

Long time lurker, first time poster.
I know MILs get a rough ride on MN but I don’t know where else to go.
I really don’t believe IABU so probably the wrong board to post on and I’m sure some of you will say IABU but also hoping for some advice and also to vent.

DS has been with his wife for I don’t know maybe 20 years and married about 15. They have twin 10 yo DDs
Last year DS came to stay with us, saying his wife had kicked him out for cheating. We were upset but didn’t question him on it as he didn’t seem to want to talk about it. He stayed with us around 6 weeks and eventually went home to his wife and children, 100 miles away from us. I didn’t ask any info and he didn’t tell us any. Personally I think she’s a mug for having him back but apparently they’re having therapy and working on things, so I’ve not said anything.
Was having monthly calls with DS and DGDs after he left here but the wife wouldn’t show her face on the calls. We’ve had no visits from any of them.

Anyway DS has now called us with a barrage of abuse telling us what awful people we are and I’m shocked! We had him staying here when his wife kicked him out and never interfered. He says we’ve not been supportive, his wife has never liked us (first I’ve heard!) and DGDs find us difficult too (again, first I’ve heard!)
I can’t help but think DIL has poisoned DS and DGDs against us and I don’t know why she would, maybe embarrassment, but we’ve done nothing wrong. I’m now told we can’t speak to our DGDs until we take responsibility for our actions. What actions? We’ve done nothing. AIBU for thinking they can all fuck off! DS has pissed me off as well tbh for falling for this shit from his wife. My DD agrees with us and thinks they (mainly DIL) are the problem, so I don’t think it is us and it’s good to hear that it’s not just me and DH who think it.

Would be good to know what MNers think should happen next. I think it’s on DS and his wife to get in touch with us, but I just don’t know what to expect next. He put the phone down on me because he didn’t like that I was standing up for myself and not just apologising for made up accusations.
I know MILs are often hated on here, but remember some of us are good and sometimes DILs are not. So help on what to expect from them next and what might happen next for anyone who has been in a similar situation would be gratefully received.

Can give more info or background if needed, happy to answer questions if helps with context. We’ve always been a nice happy family, but looking back I have felt the distance from DS since he moved away to where his wife and her family are from. But interactions up until now have been fine, so I don’t know where this has all come from. Hence why I’m thinking DIL may have had a heavy hand in this.

Expecting some criticism, but hopefully more help that hate. TIA.

OP posts:
SixtySomething · Yesterday 23:13

Poppyfie1ds · Yesterday 22:24

Why is speaking out as just another mum okay but speaking out as a qualified and registered expert isn’t okay??

Although I accept that your own mum if you are very close is about the only exception. Not a MIL though.

Surely the difference is obvious?
When you’re an ordinary person it’s an opinion.
When you’re professionally qualified it’s ‘the truth.’
I don’t know about psychologists but for medics, giving your personal opinion about someone online alongside giving your professional status is viewed as bullying and ethically forbidden.
Is the same not true for psychologists?

GreenParrotLoud · Yesterday 23:18

SixtySomething · Yesterday 22:16

Yes , but a professional situation is different isn’t it?

If a DM/ MIL sees her DD/ DIL struggling with an upset baby and it’s clear what the problem is, I’m afraid I think a gentle suggestion is helpful IRL.

Of course, if one has been asked( told) that comments are not required, that’s different. But I know I appreciated my mother’s expedience and advice as a new mother, when I didn’t know what to do.

Or maybe just offer to take the baby for a while, take laundry home, bring some food round etc. Sometimes when you have a crying baby and you’re exhausted (DIL in this case had twins) it’s not always helpful to have advice. Sometimes what you need is empathy, practical help and a break.

What kinds of situations did you have in mind when it’s ok to give suggestions without being asked for them?

SixtySomething · Yesterday 23:30

GreenParrotLoud · Yesterday 23:18

Or maybe just offer to take the baby for a while, take laundry home, bring some food round etc. Sometimes when you have a crying baby and you’re exhausted (DIL in this case had twins) it’s not always helpful to have advice. Sometimes what you need is empathy, practical help and a break.

What kinds of situations did you have in mind when it’s ok to give suggestions without being asked for them?

I guess something like the baby is unhappy and her skin is cold to the touch. I know there's something about baby's heating system being different, but even so, I struggle to think it's wrong to suggest perhaps they're cold.
Babygro too small and feet squashed.
Baby in strong sun with no hat.
Clothes tied too tightly, causing marking to skin.

I believe that offers of help can also be seen as undesirable, because they may imply the mother isn't coping.

LaughingCat · Yesterday 23:41

SixtySomething · Yesterday 23:30

I guess something like the baby is unhappy and her skin is cold to the touch. I know there's something about baby's heating system being different, but even so, I struggle to think it's wrong to suggest perhaps they're cold.
Babygro too small and feet squashed.
Baby in strong sun with no hat.
Clothes tied too tightly, causing marking to skin.

I believe that offers of help can also be seen as undesirable, because they may imply the mother isn't coping.

There’s a saying I heard a few times from midwives (gave birth last October) ‘cold babies cry, hot babies die’. Basically, don’t overwrap the baby because their hands or feet feel cold, because they often do and it’s not a bad thing. It might make them a bit grizzly but is better for them in the long run.

That’s a far cry from the advice given to my mum when I was born, 40 years ago.

As a very tired new mum, if my MIL would have been overspilling with ‘helpful advice’ that was actually out of date or just not massively useful (clothing too tight? Babygrow too small? Not actually come across those issues with any of my mum friends 😂), I’d have probably been annoyed at her. She let me come to her though, with my questions in my own time. We have a good relationship and I love seeing her bond blossom with DD.

Onlyme7575 · Yesterday 23:48

To me it sounds like,she is resentful that you put him up,and that has caused issues between them,she has been niggling at him and then he has been having a go at you for it.she hasn’t taken part in calls or anything either,and sounds like she resents you.

SixtySomething · Yesterday 23:54

LaughingCat · Yesterday 23:41

There’s a saying I heard a few times from midwives (gave birth last October) ‘cold babies cry, hot babies die’. Basically, don’t overwrap the baby because their hands or feet feel cold, because they often do and it’s not a bad thing. It might make them a bit grizzly but is better for them in the long run.

That’s a far cry from the advice given to my mum when I was born, 40 years ago.

As a very tired new mum, if my MIL would have been overspilling with ‘helpful advice’ that was actually out of date or just not massively useful (clothing too tight? Babygrow too small? Not actually come across those issues with any of my mum friends 😂), I’d have probably been annoyed at her. She let me come to her though, with my questions in my own time. We have a good relationship and I love seeing her bond blossom with DD.

You haven’t come across a baby where the baby gro was too tight on the feet? I certainly have.I gave those examples because they’re things that I’ve come across. Don’t you think your laughter emoji is a wee bit patronising? Respect cuts both ways, surely?

squarecrow · Today 00:10

SixtySomething · Yesterday 23:13

Surely the difference is obvious?
When you’re an ordinary person it’s an opinion.
When you’re professionally qualified it’s ‘the truth.’
I don’t know about psychologists but for medics, giving your personal opinion about someone online alongside giving your professional status is viewed as bullying and ethically forbidden.
Is the same not true for psychologists?

Sorry but this just isn’t true or doctors wouldn’t be able to give “second opinions” would they? “Professionals” disagree all the time on everything you can think of. A professional opinion is only ever that: an opinion.

outerspacepotato · Today 00:25

LaughingCat · Yesterday 23:41

There’s a saying I heard a few times from midwives (gave birth last October) ‘cold babies cry, hot babies die’. Basically, don’t overwrap the baby because their hands or feet feel cold, because they often do and it’s not a bad thing. It might make them a bit grizzly but is better for them in the long run.

That’s a far cry from the advice given to my mum when I was born, 40 years ago.

As a very tired new mum, if my MIL would have been overspilling with ‘helpful advice’ that was actually out of date or just not massively useful (clothing too tight? Babygrow too small? Not actually come across those issues with any of my mum friends 😂), I’d have probably been annoyed at her. She let me come to her though, with my questions in my own time. We have a good relationship and I love seeing her bond blossom with DD.

Look up neonatal cold stress and hypothermia.

Lyraloo · Today 00:27

I cannot believe anyone on here would side with you! You are delusional if you think you’re not part of the problem. Your son cheated on his wife, came to stay with you for weeks, and you now blame you DIL, saying he can’t have been happy and basically blaming her for that. You never contacted her or even your grandchildren during those weeks! It’s no wonder they think you favour your other grandchildren! You are a terrible mil and just want to blame your dil for your sons and your own failings. Look at yourself and your selfish son, you’re both the problem!

SixtySomething · Today 00:27

squarecrow · Today 00:10

Sorry but this just isn’t true or doctors wouldn’t be able to give “second opinions” would they? “Professionals” disagree all the time on everything you can think of. A professional opinion is only ever that: an opinion.

That's completely different.Yes, professionals disagree. That's fine.

What is not fine is someone coming onto MN , giving an opinion, which involves someone else's post and then saying 'I say it's like this and I'm a doctor/psychiatrist.'
Someone did this a few weeks ago.I checked online and learned the BMA is very strict and considers it professional bullying to state you are a doctor , without identifying yourself, and giving your opinion online, because it makes it sound that their opinion is the right one.
Then, of course, as I realised, that's one reason why MN has that disclaimer that they don't guarantee the accuracy of any opinions on MN.
So, I was interested, when @Poppyfie1ds states she is a psychologist and it's NEVER right to offer advice if you're a MIL. It seems highly questionable advice to me and starts to get into muddy waters. Is this public education or a personal opinion, @Poppyfie1ds ?

HangrySloth · Today 00:58

Onlyme7575 · Yesterday 23:48

To me it sounds like,she is resentful that you put him up,and that has caused issues between them,she has been niggling at him and then he has been having a go at you for it.she hasn’t taken part in calls or anything either,and sounds like she resents you.

I mean I would resent my mil too if she gave her cheating son a place to leave didn’t check on me once after a month and a half after I’ve been her DIL for 20 years and I’m the mother to her grandchildren and my family has been torn apart by her son’s actions. She effectively condoned her son’s actions yeah I wouldn’t want you anyone near me or my family my husband or kids if you acted like that I’m trying to repair my marriage. Oh and how could I almost forget blaming the DIL for her husband MIL’s son cheating that’s the real cherry on top of the cake here

LunaChild · Today 01:22

I never comment on posts, I am a lurker however I need to comment on this one. From your replies it would appear you don’t like your DIL. You are blaming her for your son’s behaviour ie the calling you and shouting abuse, the affair…have you considered that maybe your son is just an absolute arsehole maybe?? Your comment about a happy husband doesn’t cheat is absolute bull. Myself and my ex had just had a baby, we were blissfully happy. He was the proudest partner and Dad, the man was on cloud nine. We were ticking along lovely then one day I spotted a text from a colleague…he’d only been having an affair with her for months. He was happy, he admitted he was but temptation took over and he decided to have an affair. You should be supporting your DIL because I can almost guarantee her heart is breaking and to have no support from her in laws is shameful. Your son did the dirty, you took him in which I don’t see an issue with but you should have supported your DIL and I don’t think it’s fair to call her a mug because she decided to work on her marriage.

ETA I don’t see an issue with taking him in as long as you called your DIL to let her know you were disgusted in him and she had your full support. If he has nowhere to go then you aren’t going to see him on the streets however you should have called her and told her your loyalties are lying with her because your son decided to cheat. But you didn’t!

ThreeDeafMice · Today 01:24

Did anyone post this page yet?

https://issendai.com/psychology/estrangement/missing-missing-reasons/

Here is an extract:

If your daughter thinks it’s a problem, IT IS A PROBLEM, whether you agree or not. SHE–not you–has the final say on whether she has a problem with you or not. Here again is a power struggle between you: HER: “This is a problem”, YOU: “I see no problem”. Guess who’s going to win this debate? Not you. [….]
This game of ‘I don’t understand what happened’ when you have been told in words what’s wrong is really counterproductive. Yes, it permits you to shield your ego/self esteem from criticism and ‘exposure’ of your inadequacies in the relationship–but it loses you the relationship.

The Missing Missing Reasons – Issendai

https://issendai.com/psychology/estrangement/missing-missing-reasons/

ThreeDeafMice · Today 01:31

Here’s another section, from a different page on the same site:

The parents and children had a wonderful relationship until something changed—the parents don’t know what, but they suspect their child’s new partner had something to do with it. And then their child dragged up a bunch of stuff from the distant past, most of which never happened, and blamed their parents for everything that went wrong in their own lives, and THEN they made a power play and cut their parents out of their lives to punish their parents. But their parents refuse to be controlled. They will reclaim their own lives, they will not knuckle under to their abusive, nasty, ungrateful children, and they will keep trying to contact their children to let them know they still love them.
….
However, most of the people who know why their children are estranged filter away from the group quickly. I don’t know where they go, but I suspect they find help in other groups—parents with drug-addicted children find groups about dealing with drug addicts, parents whose children are in the control of an abusive partner find groups about partner abuse. What’s left are the people who have no idea why their children left them. And that, my friends, is a vast and waving red flag.

squarecrow · Today 01:53

OP, if you actually care about your relationship with your DS or DGC, pay attention to those posts by @ThreeDeafMice

Afterthefact · Today 02:26

I don't think you've done anything wrong. You didn't question DS about his marriage issues & he didn't want to discuss it so as far as DIL knows you know jack shit about it - but is that the story your DS has told his wife - you won't know the answer to that.

Would she have appreciated you contacting her during the split - who knows - but if you had done you'd probably be accused of busybodying - and by not doing you're apparently the villain. Good for you standing up for yourself. Did she contact you at all, probably not.

It's difficult but it's their marriage and their problem, therapy is the way to go if they want to sort it out. Let them get on with it - there's only 2 people in a marriage & hurty words to you for giving him a place to stay should be appreciated by him not beating you with a stick.

RealityChecksNeeded · Today 03:14

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Pinkflamingo1513 · Today 03:37

A happy husband doesn’t cheat 😂 your son’s inability to stay faithful to his wife, surprisingly isn’t her fault. I have 2 boys myself, if in the distant future they marry and have children, if they were to cheat on their partner, I would be down on them like a tonne of bricks, a happy husband doesn’t cheat, bollocks.
Whilst housing him is one thing, making absolutely zero contact with his wife to even ask about your grandchildren is a disgrace and you should be ashamed of yourselves, your husband included.
Your darling son sounds just as bad as you and your daughter in law and grandchildren would be well rid of him and you as it goes!

lemmein · Today 05:20

I haven’t read the whole thread but I wonder, does your DD have a DH & in-laws OP? How do you think your DD would feel if her DH had behaved like your son has, and she, along with your DGC were ignored by the in-laws?

Perhaps you’ll be able to see it from your DILs POV if you can imagine it happening to someone you actually give a shit about (your DD & her DC)

kiwigrandma · Today 05:51

Hi Muminturmoil0! First of all in my opinion it is a MUST to sit down to 'air' any grievances face-to-face with your DS & DIL with your hubby or a supportive family/friend member. A lot of the time people have different memories that can be distorted - some take a bit of truth & add falsehoods to have another narrative sadly. Stick to your truth & voice that in a positive caring/understanding nature. If your DS & DIL say things that are not true - set them straight & keep your cool by agreeing to disagree if needed. I am very sorry to hear of your pain after your DS stayed with you & your husband for 6 weeks - he is being very disrespectful & unappreciated your loving hospitality in your home. Please make contact with them both to say (if you wish) that you & your hubby love & miss them all! My hubby & I, have 4 grandchildren aged; 14,10,5&1 - we could not live happily not seeing our grandchildren & our 2 grown daughters & their husband/partner. Anyways...take care of yourself, Muminturmoil0 & all the best to you & your hubby & family from, Kiwi Grandma😘

thepariscrimefiles · Today 05:56

SixtySomething · Yesterday 21:36

‘what grown woman doesn’t know not to offer unsolicited advice to new mothers under any circumstances?‘

This is so strange.
The older woman likely has looked after 2 or more children, perhaps hundreds or thousands if it happens to be her job too.
She sees the new mother struggling. I’m sorry but to offer a suggestion designed to help is totally normal and it’s batshit to consider it a social crime.
Tact is required, yes, but it’s a difficult tightrope being a MIL and we are allowed to get it wrong in our new role. We should not be told to issue these strange apologies and promises of improved behaviour if we don’t produce the desired behaviour. Not to mention threats of going NC .😫

There is nothing in OP's posts to indicate that her DIL was struggling with a new baby. It sounds as though OP insisted on giving her DIL unsolicited and unwanted advice and has made it very clear that it is her 'right' to do so because she has had two children and been around a lot of babies.

The majority of posters and people who voted think that OP is being unreasonable. The funny thing is that this isn't a disgruntled DIL posting about her MIL but the MIL herself who obviously expected everyone to be on her side.

From OP's own account, her DIL was responsible for maintaining OP's relationship with her grandchildren. Her DIL would regularly phone and keep OP up to date because her own son was 'too busy'.

OP herself has also confirmed that she and her husband never did the journey to visit her son, DIL and grandchildren as it was 'easier' for her son, DIL and two children to travel to her.

There is a constant refrain on Mumsnet from posters who say they would 'love to hear the other side'. In this scenario, we don't need to hear DIL's side as OP has damned herself out of her own mouth. She has never been a kind or caring MIL. She clearly prefers her DD to her son. She didn't contact her DIL once during the time her son moved in with her, not even to check that her grandchildren were OK, even though she still keeps in contact with her son's ex-girlfriend.

DIL's efforts to try and maintain a relationship between OP and her son and grandchildren are now over due to how OP has behaved. OP only has herself to blame.

Cetim · Today 06:33

Your son cheated on his wife. She forgave him and you call her a mug instantly without even knowing or caring to know any of the details? You don't see what she did as a brave and selfless act to keep her family and marriage together for the sake of your grandkids? You never labelled your son anything after what he did. You also haven't told us what exactly he has accused you of so it is hard to say who is right or wrong etc. And to instantly blame the dil with seemingly no evidence she has poisoned him is interesting. Has there been a history of animosity between you and the dil?
I know you didn't want to overstep and get involved after he cheated but maybe they saw that as a lack of support. It is hard to tell without more details of the conversation.

WhatMummyMakesSheEats · Today 06:47

I think people are focusing on the wrong thing about you supporting him through cheating and not trying to speak to the grandchildren (although that is very telling). There’s only one post where you actually list what he said you’ve done wrong and all you’ve said is ‘she didn’t say that at the time’ and then in the next post you say ‘we’ve done nothing wrong I’m not saying sorry’. So you are quite literally proving his point in writing, all he’s asked is for you to take some accountability for it and you are saying I will not apologise! I get that you didn’t know at the time but he’s telling you now and you refuse to hear it. They are having therapy, these will be coming up in therapy which is probably why you’re hearing it now. Your son might be unpacking stuff about you from before her too as you very briefly mentioned exes. Perhaps she never said it to your son at the time either and therapy has brought it out of her.

AFigureWalks · Today 07:31

I was with you until that, “Happy husband doesn’t cheat bullshit.”
A lying, selfish, deceitful husband does cheat. He sounds like an absolute horror and you can’t make him better.
This is all on him and you abandoned your DIL and grandchildren in their hour of need.

Fiddlesticks1 · Today 07:47

Still blinkered.

Swipe left for the next trending thread