Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

It’s a DIL one this time!

929 replies

Muminturmoil0 · 14/11/2026 22:53

Long time lurker, first time poster.
I know MILs get a rough ride on MN but I don’t know where else to go.
I really don’t believe IABU so probably the wrong board to post on and I’m sure some of you will say IABU but also hoping for some advice and also to vent.

DS has been with his wife for I don’t know maybe 20 years and married about 15. They have twin 10 yo DDs
Last year DS came to stay with us, saying his wife had kicked him out for cheating. We were upset but didn’t question him on it as he didn’t seem to want to talk about it. He stayed with us around 6 weeks and eventually went home to his wife and children, 100 miles away from us. I didn’t ask any info and he didn’t tell us any. Personally I think she’s a mug for having him back but apparently they’re having therapy and working on things, so I’ve not said anything.
Was having monthly calls with DS and DGDs after he left here but the wife wouldn’t show her face on the calls. We’ve had no visits from any of them.

Anyway DS has now called us with a barrage of abuse telling us what awful people we are and I’m shocked! We had him staying here when his wife kicked him out and never interfered. He says we’ve not been supportive, his wife has never liked us (first I’ve heard!) and DGDs find us difficult too (again, first I’ve heard!)
I can’t help but think DIL has poisoned DS and DGDs against us and I don’t know why she would, maybe embarrassment, but we’ve done nothing wrong. I’m now told we can’t speak to our DGDs until we take responsibility for our actions. What actions? We’ve done nothing. AIBU for thinking they can all fuck off! DS has pissed me off as well tbh for falling for this shit from his wife. My DD agrees with us and thinks they (mainly DIL) are the problem, so I don’t think it is us and it’s good to hear that it’s not just me and DH who think it.

Would be good to know what MNers think should happen next. I think it’s on DS and his wife to get in touch with us, but I just don’t know what to expect next. He put the phone down on me because he didn’t like that I was standing up for myself and not just apologising for made up accusations.
I know MILs are often hated on here, but remember some of us are good and sometimes DILs are not. So help on what to expect from them next and what might happen next for anyone who has been in a similar situation would be gratefully received.

Can give more info or background if needed, happy to answer questions if helps with context. We’ve always been a nice happy family, but looking back I have felt the distance from DS since he moved away to where his wife and her family are from. But interactions up until now have been fine, so I don’t know where this has all come from. Hence why I’m thinking DIL may have had a heavy hand in this.

Expecting some criticism, but hopefully more help that hate. TIA.

OP posts:
Summerhut2025 · Today 08:00

Muminturmoil0 · 14/11/2026 23:17

No didn’t contact her or the kids during that time, didn’t feel it was my place. Blood is thicker than water and all that and tbh I thought they would permanently split do didn’t think I’d see her again, and didn’t want DS to think I wasn’t supporting him (although I accept he was wrong to cheat)
Some might disagree with that, but I didn’t even think to get in touch with her. I’m sure in the same situation you’d do the same.
Once DS went back to her though I started up contact with the kids again, but as I say she never wanted to show her face.

This is where you went wrong. You should have contacted her she will have been going through absolute hell due to your son’s actions. She will think you don’t give a monkeys about your grandchildren and she’s given him an ultimatum and he’s had to choose his family. I would give her a call and have a chat and hear her side. I mean the marriage will end ultimately anyway and then your son will come crawling back either way. Telling her you support her whatever her decision on the marriage when he cheated would have been reasonable and your son should have been okay with you doing that. Going radio
silence on her during that time was where you went wrong I feel.

Zerosleep · Today 08:04

I do think you are unreasonable putting this all on your DIL when the abuse has come from your DS. However I do think the way he spoke to you sounds disgusting and it makes you wonder if there is a degree of her being resentful that you didn’t lay into your DS when he had the affair and turned up at your place. I would personally stay away. If he wants contact then he can call. Otherwise just don’t bother.

Harrizo82 · Today 08:18

I’ll be honest, your DS and you appear to be the most problematic at this point. He got kicked out for cheating, you took him in, chose not to interfere, chose not to check in on your DIL or DGDs who were probably going through a really hard time and felt alone, then support that decision with blood is thicker than water? Absolutely not! What about the blood of your DGDs?! You 100% should have checked in on them. Blood doesn’t mean a damn thing with that behaviour. IF your DIL has become upset I wouldn’t blame her. I’d be really hurt if my MIL didn’t check on me if DH had cheated. You need to apologise to her. Your DS needs to grow up and stop blaming everyone else for his problems. You need to have a word with yourself about excusing your DSs behaviours because he’s blood. (I read you don’t agree with cheating, but saying it’s out of character to behave this way etc is excusing his behaviours - he cheated. Maybe it is his character to behave badly!).

Kije · Today 08:24

Muminturmoil0 · 14/11/2026 23:26

I’m not placing blame but a happy husband doesn’t cheat. I don’t know if they had marriage problems before but he’s not going to cheat if he’s happy at home is he! He shouldn’t have done it but it does make me wonder if she knew she’d in some way pushed him to this, because why else would she have him back? I would no way have my DH back if he had cheated. I just can’t understand any it.
I am annoyed with DS after his call, make no mistake, but it was just so out of character. Contact from him has dwindled since he moved back to her, but he’s never said any or things before that he’s said on the phone. Does make me wonder if she given him an ultimatum.
Might call him when I know she’s not with him in case he wants to condone a different issue. Or get my DD (his sister to call), maybe he will say or act differently and tell the truth as to what’s going on. Keep flipping between that and just thinking they can fuck off now. Don’t know if I’m more angry or upset.

Sorry OP, I just can't get past this post of yours. I was going to read all your posts and get more of your side of the story, but it's clear that you have a mindset that's against your DIL. You imply by 'a happy husband doesn't cheat' that it's your DIL's fault that your precious son went off and saw someone else. 'She's in some way pushed him to this' - yeah we hear you. Whatever a man does is a woman's fault.

I don't know you or your son, and I have no idea if he really did cheat on his wife, but your attitude stinks. And why on earth would you say a foul thing like 'blood is thicker than water, after all' about not making contact with your own grandchildren (who ARE of your 'blood' if that's what matters to you)?! Honestly your posts sound as if they were written by someone in the 1930's.

Letstalkaboutitxx · Today 08:29

Although there are not many supportive replies there are still 41% so far saying YANBU 🤔

Franpie · Today 08:32

Muminturmoil0 · 14/11/2026 23:17

No didn’t contact her or the kids during that time, didn’t feel it was my place. Blood is thicker than water and all that and tbh I thought they would permanently split do didn’t think I’d see her again, and didn’t want DS to think I wasn’t supporting him (although I accept he was wrong to cheat)
Some might disagree with that, but I didn’t even think to get in touch with her. I’m sure in the same situation you’d do the same.
Once DS went back to her though I started up contact with the kids again, but as I say she never wanted to show her face.

Blood is thicker than water??

This woman has been a member of your family for 20 years and you didn’t even think to contact her to see how she was when your DS blew her life up??

You assumed they’d split up and that you’d never see her again??

And on top of all that, it sounds as though you haven’t spoken to her at all since over the past year??

Yeah, you’re not winning any MIL awards here. There is no way my MIL would behave like that. If DH cheated, he wouldn’t be able to run home to mummy. She’d kill him. And she would be there for me and my children without a shadow of a doubt.

I imagine her feelings about being very much on the outside of your family have come out in therapy and your DS has seen how unhealthy it is. You really do need to reflect.

kiwigrandma · Today 08:36

Cetim · Today 06:33

Your son cheated on his wife. She forgave him and you call her a mug instantly without even knowing or caring to know any of the details? You don't see what she did as a brave and selfless act to keep her family and marriage together for the sake of your grandkids? You never labelled your son anything after what he did. You also haven't told us what exactly he has accused you of so it is hard to say who is right or wrong etc. And to instantly blame the dil with seemingly no evidence she has poisoned him is interesting. Has there been a history of animosity between you and the dil?
I know you didn't want to overstep and get involved after he cheated but maybe they saw that as a lack of support. It is hard to tell without more details of the conversation.

Hi Cetim! I don't think the OP/Mum means "mug" as being rude...OP/Mum, probably is 'speaking' how she feels even though she is talking about her own son & his wife. Yes I agree it would take a lot to forgive cheating - the trust would be gone instantly - I don't think I would be so forgiving, though yes there are children involved. To your comment above about "overstepping/getting involved" - Mum & her hubby were supportive with taking their DS into their home for 6wks - looks to me that DS is very ungrateful. And yes I agree "more details of the conversation" would help create a better 'picture'. Enjoy your evening/day, Cetim ~ from; Kiwi Grandma😘

LaughingCat · Today 08:39

SixtySomething · Yesterday 23:54

You haven’t come across a baby where the baby gro was too tight on the feet? I certainly have.I gave those examples because they’re things that I’ve come across. Don’t you think your laughter emoji is a wee bit patronising? Respect cuts both ways, surely?

Exactly and if you can’t show respect, then you won’t receive any.

And while I, and none of my mum friends, have put our kids in babygrows that are too small I can see it happening if an illness or a broken washing machine or something similar has caused too much washing so you have to use an old one to see you through until the rest are clean and dry. My mum pointing it out to me would be fine and I’d tell her to butt out just as happily. My MIL telling me to dress my child appropriately in that kind of situation would be irritating, although I would understand it was well-meaning. But, like I say, mine has just been supportive and caring, and hasn’t gone all in with the ‘helpful advice’. So I’ve taken her advice when I’ve talked to her about child rearing more than most.

Can’t tell you how many times though, that complete strangers have stopped me or other mum-friends in the street to point out something they think could be better. Put a layer on, take a layer off, did you know she’s kicked off her shoe in the pram, should she be eating that, why isn’t she wearing a hat, have you tried rocking her, (and my personal favourite) there’s something terribly wrong and you need to get her to the hospital immediately, why are you just standing there with her (spoiler alert, she was 4 months old and just having a moment because life 😂). Our kids are all fine and there has never been a single time that other person has been right yet 🤦‍♀️. But we all play interfering old bat bingo and raise it in the group chats when someone does it 😂

Unless you’re really close, don’t offer advice without being asked for it. We’re already bombarded by advice online and irl. Most of us have trusted people we go to for it when needed, and trust medical professionals otherwise. Just because you worked out what worked for your kids, doesn’t mean it works for someone else or even makes any sense in their context. I’ll die on this hill.

LoudWriter · Today 08:46

Letstalkaboutitxx · Today 08:29

Although there are not many supportive replies there are still 41% so far saying YANBU 🤔

This is so interesting.

Any clues as to why this is? My only guess is that it's such an emotive topic that there are many MIL's voting YANBU because they sympathise with OP's situation, whilst also knowing it'd be bloody hard to argue against some of the crap she's spouted about happy husbands not cheating, etc.

WalmartWitney · Today 08:46

Muminturmoil0 · 14/11/2026 23:26

I’m not placing blame but a happy husband doesn’t cheat. I don’t know if they had marriage problems before but he’s not going to cheat if he’s happy at home is he! He shouldn’t have done it but it does make me wonder if she knew she’d in some way pushed him to this, because why else would she have him back? I would no way have my DH back if he had cheated. I just can’t understand any it.
I am annoyed with DS after his call, make no mistake, but it was just so out of character. Contact from him has dwindled since he moved back to her, but he’s never said any or things before that he’s said on the phone. Does make me wonder if she given him an ultimatum.
Might call him when I know she’s not with him in case he wants to condone a different issue. Or get my DD (his sister to call), maybe he will say or act differently and tell the truth as to what’s going on. Keep flipping between that and just thinking they can fuck off now. Don’t know if I’m more angry or upset.

Case closed. You've just revealed why DIL would'nt like you, if this is your POV. What a thing to say.

thebrowncatisback · Today 08:53

Something obviously came up in therapy which he attributes to his upbringing

you must try to find out what it is he blames you for and apologise

thebrowncatisback · Today 08:59

A happy husband doesn’t cheat?

so it’s his wife’s fault he can’t keep his co** in control?

disgusting comment

TomatoSoupandCheese · Today 08:59

Lyraloo · Today 00:27

I cannot believe anyone on here would side with you! You are delusional if you think you’re not part of the problem. Your son cheated on his wife, came to stay with you for weeks, and you now blame you DIL, saying he can’t have been happy and basically blaming her for that. You never contacted her or even your grandchildren during those weeks! It’s no wonder they think you favour your other grandchildren! You are a terrible mil and just want to blame your dil for your sons and your own failings. Look at yourself and your selfish son, you’re both the problem!

This is exactly what my MIL needs to hear. this thread is kind of validating as when you’re made to feel like you’re the problem you start to believe it. It’s easier to make the DIL the scapegoat.

thebrowncatisback · Today 09:01

sounds like you need to take a bit of accountability for upsetting your son instead of blaming it all on his wife

SpinandSing · Today 09:04

I actually can't believe this is for real. You seem to disrespect her for taking your useless son back and trying to forgive him. She won't be able to forgive him...not at this point...it will be a lot of work for her. And so much hurt will come out as he has betrayed her. She will have listed all the times she has swallowed down her feelings when you have hurt her - all those annoying little comments you have made over the years that she has let go. There will be so many times when she has gone so far for him, and put her own needs and feelings aside, that will feel like a complete and utter waste of her time and energy., You shouldn't disrespect her for finally saying everything she wants to...you should work through it and try to do better. You're lucky she lets you see the kids. I hope she gets some strength and kicks him out again...and has nothing to do wth you.

I don't think your daughter is a useful sounding board for you. You brought her up and you will both just be being defensive. Your son is the problem and has wounded his DW very deeply. Most couples get back together after an affair...they are so hurt and in so much pain that getting back together feels like it will make things better. It rarely does but the other partner needs time to heal and get stronger...before they finally kick the cheating spouse/partner to the kerb. You're witnessing the death of a relationship - don't let your son make it all about you.

Winniepoobear · Today 09:04

I remember kicking my dh out for "cheating" in inverted brackets because it was an emotional affair online with someone from the states ... anyway ... I kicked him out and my MIL blamed me ... said I was the reason he did it cos I must have been neglecting him emotionally and thats why he did it (for 16 mths)

It took a lot for me to forgive him, an im mean A LOT but one of the conditions were, that he told his MIL exactly whos fault it was, why he did it, with whom he did it, and he told her mot to blame me etc etc.

She did apologise to me and said she couldnt believe her son cud do something like that without a reason but realised that no reason makes that acceptable.

Can I ask, did u contact ur DIL while her son was living with you. I think maybe this is the reason its gone tots up now. You showed her no sympathy and made it look like you were on your sons side, when in fact he was in the wrong.

Had my MIL not apologised to ke, I would feel the same way your DIL feels now ... shes hurting that you showed her no empathy.

SixtySomething · Today 09:06

Letstalkaboutitxx · Today 08:29

Although there are not many supportive replies there are still 41% so far saying YANBU 🤔

So thank goodness for that.

I read post after post condemning OP in the worst terms the poster can think of.The range of insults used is impressive.
But it's all based on conjecture and how the poster chooses to look at the situation.
We don't know what actually happened. For all we know, DIL is a serial adulterer herself.
Personally I think the thread should be removed. It's unimaginable what it must be like to be on the receiving end of abuse like this. I just hope OP is no longer with us, for her sake and her wellbeing.

thepariscrimefiles · Today 09:07

Letstalkaboutitxx · Today 08:29

Although there are not many supportive replies there are still 41% so far saying YANBU 🤔

Many posters just read the first post and then vote. OP's subsequent posts show her views and behaviour in a much worse light, particularly about how she has treated her DIL who put in all the effort to try and build and maintain her MIL's relationship with her grandchildren. Having read all OP's posts, many people have found it difficult to defend her which are why most of the posts are supportive of OP's DIL and not OP herself.

ThreadGuardDog · Today 09:08

thepariscrimefiles · Yesterday 20:17

You're just parroting OP's misogynistic bollocks. Maybe a better question is why OP's son returned to his wife and children. I bet he couldn't wait to get away from his spiteful mother.

Agree. The OP’s comment is actually an oxymoron - I’m not placing blame but a happy husband doesn’t cheat.. Of course she’s placing blame, squarely on the shoulders of her DiL. And don’t get me started on the implication that if he’s not happy at home, then cheating is a perfectly reasonable and acceptable solution. The misogyny is off the scale.

ThreadGuardDog · Today 09:12

SixtySomething · Today 09:06

So thank goodness for that.

I read post after post condemning OP in the worst terms the poster can think of.The range of insults used is impressive.
But it's all based on conjecture and how the poster chooses to look at the situation.
We don't know what actually happened. For all we know, DIL is a serial adulterer herself.
Personally I think the thread should be removed. It's unimaginable what it must be like to be on the receiving end of abuse like this. I just hope OP is no longer with us, for her sake and her wellbeing.

Don’t agree. AIBU is well known for being brutally honest, so if she wasn’t prepared for that she should have posted on a different board. Her posts have been shockingly misogynistic and blaming of her DiL without presenting a shred of supporting evidence here for balance. That’s what posters are taking issue with.

SixtySomething · Today 09:16

LaughingCat · Today 08:39

Exactly and if you can’t show respect, then you won’t receive any.

And while I, and none of my mum friends, have put our kids in babygrows that are too small I can see it happening if an illness or a broken washing machine or something similar has caused too much washing so you have to use an old one to see you through until the rest are clean and dry. My mum pointing it out to me would be fine and I’d tell her to butt out just as happily. My MIL telling me to dress my child appropriately in that kind of situation would be irritating, although I would understand it was well-meaning. But, like I say, mine has just been supportive and caring, and hasn’t gone all in with the ‘helpful advice’. So I’ve taken her advice when I’ve talked to her about child rearing more than most.

Can’t tell you how many times though, that complete strangers have stopped me or other mum-friends in the street to point out something they think could be better. Put a layer on, take a layer off, did you know she’s kicked off her shoe in the pram, should she be eating that, why isn’t she wearing a hat, have you tried rocking her, (and my personal favourite) there’s something terribly wrong and you need to get her to the hospital immediately, why are you just standing there with her (spoiler alert, she was 4 months old and just having a moment because life 😂). Our kids are all fine and there has never been a single time that other person has been right yet 🤦‍♀️. But we all play interfering old bat bingo and raise it in the group chats when someone does it 😂

Unless you’re really close, don’t offer advice without being asked for it. We’re already bombarded by advice online and irl. Most of us have trusted people we go to for it when needed, and trust medical professionals otherwise. Just because you worked out what worked for your kids, doesn’t mean it works for someone else or even makes any sense in their context. I’ll die on this hill.

'But we all play interfering old bat bingo and raise it in the group chats when someone does it 😂'
Thank goodness I don't have to listen to you. Your attitude is awful. I'm sure anyone who offers their opinion means it kindly, Why can't you be thankful they're interested in your baby?
Why do you think you know it all? All this sneering at people who offer advice is pathetic. I remember the HV pointing out that the mittens on my DS's first babygro were too tight and he couldn't stretch out his hands. It sure was useful asit wouldnot have occurred to me. How can you have the arrogance to think you and only you know all there is to know about your baby?

thepariscrimefiles · Today 09:18

SixtySomething · Today 09:06

So thank goodness for that.

I read post after post condemning OP in the worst terms the poster can think of.The range of insults used is impressive.
But it's all based on conjecture and how the poster chooses to look at the situation.
We don't know what actually happened. For all we know, DIL is a serial adulterer herself.
Personally I think the thread should be removed. It's unimaginable what it must be like to be on the receiving end of abuse like this. I just hope OP is no longer with us, for her sake and her wellbeing.

JFC you're really clutching at straws to try and show OP's DIL in a bad light! I'm pretty sure that if OP's DIL was a serial adulterer, OP's son would have told OP as part of his defence and justification of his own infidelities and OP would definitely have included this in her many posts complaining about her DIL.

OP even admitted that it was her DIL who kept in touch regularly and who tried to facilitate her relationship with her grand-daughters when her own son couldn't be bothered to do this. OP certainly didn't appreciate her DIL's efforts.

OP made this thread because, due to her spectacular lack of self-awareness, she was confident that her unkind behaviour towards her DIL would be validated by posters on her thread. If any of the posts are genuinely abusive, Mumsnet will delete them if reported. However, it's beyond ridiculous that you think that OP is the victim here.

ThreadGuardDog · Today 09:19

thebrowncatisback · Today 08:53

Something obviously came up in therapy which he attributes to his upbringing

you must try to find out what it is he blames you for and apologise

I think it depends on the quality of the therapy. Some counsellors can steer people towards apportioning blame to others instead of taking responsibility for their own actions and it does seem as though DS is doing just that. The problem here is that as OP’s posts have continued they’ve revealed issues that point to at least some of it being justified.

AppleCerulean · Today 09:33

thebrowncatisback · Today 08:53

Something obviously came up in therapy which he attributes to his upbringing

you must try to find out what it is he blames you for and apologise

She knows what he blames her for. He gave her a list over the phone and she got furious that he dared confront her and refused to apologise. In the thread she has repeatedly insisted that she will not apologise for anything - she wants an apology from him!

SixtySomething · Today 09:54

thepariscrimefiles · Today 09:18

JFC you're really clutching at straws to try and show OP's DIL in a bad light! I'm pretty sure that if OP's DIL was a serial adulterer, OP's son would have told OP as part of his defence and justification of his own infidelities and OP would definitely have included this in her many posts complaining about her DIL.

OP even admitted that it was her DIL who kept in touch regularly and who tried to facilitate her relationship with her grand-daughters when her own son couldn't be bothered to do this. OP certainly didn't appreciate her DIL's efforts.

OP made this thread because, due to her spectacular lack of self-awareness, she was confident that her unkind behaviour towards her DIL would be validated by posters on her thread. If any of the posts are genuinely abusive, Mumsnet will delete them if reported. However, it's beyond ridiculous that you think that OP is the victim here.

'her spectacular lack of self-awareness,'
'you're really clutching at straws'
'it's beyond ridiculous that you think that OP is the victim here.'

It all belongs to a strange fictional world.
There is no reason to think OP is lacking in self awareness. She even said (perhaps her last post) that she would read the comments and think about them.

I'm not clutching at any straws. I simply think OP is being made into the villain in a strange communal work of fiction, when in fact little is known about the situation IRL

I think OP is being victimised in this thread. But the thread and the real world are two completely different things and don't probably have much in common.

Swipe left for the next trending thread