Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want parenting advice that isn’t ‘gentle’ but also isn’t aggressive

75 replies

toddlerstr · 12/11/2026 09:47

I’ve said aggressive as it often is on here. Is there a middle ground? I’m losing my way with my 3 yo. And my mind!

OP posts:
Seeline · 12/11/2026 09:49

Firm but fair.
Clear boundaries consistently applied.
Praise for good behaviour.
Reasonable, relatable consequences for bad.
No hitting, try and avoid shouting.
Have fun.

SilenceInside · 12/11/2026 09:50

I would hope that no parenting advice that's actually proper advice would be categorised as "aggressive". Every bit of parenting can be gentle as that's about how you interact with your child, surely?

What gentle parenting advice have you found issues with? What issues are you having with parenting at the moment?

If you have some boundaries and stick to them, kindly but firmly, that tends to cover most situations.

ToKittyornottoKitty · 12/11/2026 09:51

Advice on what in particular though? I don’t see lots of aggressive parenting of toddlers on here, firm isn’t aggressive. My advice is pick your battles, some stuff just isn’t worth the fight, but also some things are non negotiable - like holding hands on a road, it’s not up for debate or gentle parenting.

Arbourimage · 12/11/2026 09:51

Of course there’s a middle ground.

SilenceInside · 12/11/2026 09:53

It's not against gentle parenting to enforce boundaries like safety when near roads. I think people have a very weird idea of what gentle parenting is and seem to think it's totally permissive parenting with no boundaries.

toddlerstr · 12/11/2026 09:53

SilenceInside · 12/11/2026 09:50

I would hope that no parenting advice that's actually proper advice would be categorised as "aggressive". Every bit of parenting can be gentle as that's about how you interact with your child, surely?

What gentle parenting advice have you found issues with? What issues are you having with parenting at the moment?

If you have some boundaries and stick to them, kindly but firmly, that tends to cover most situations.

I don’t always find it helps to verbalise things and seems to exacerbate the situation a lot of the time. I suppose it looks like it should work but in practice it doesn’t.

OP posts:
toddlerstr · 12/11/2026 09:54

SilenceInside · 12/11/2026 09:53

It's not against gentle parenting to enforce boundaries like safety when near roads. I think people have a very weird idea of what gentle parenting is and seem to think it's totally permissive parenting with no boundaries.

I know there is a discussion about gentle parenting and permissive parenting but that is not what I am starting

OP posts:
Needlesnah · 12/11/2026 09:54

Seeline · 12/11/2026 09:49

Firm but fair.
Clear boundaries consistently applied.
Praise for good behaviour.
Reasonable, relatable consequences for bad.
No hitting, try and avoid shouting.
Have fun.

This. Raised 3 on my own so I had to have clear boundaries. I strongly disagree width ‘gentle’ parenting. They are strong, independent, thoughtful young adults now. And they phone/talk to me which I love.

INeedAnotherAlibi · 12/11/2026 09:54

I found ‘1 2 3 magic parenting’ book helpful at this age. I also love bombed (in a positive way, not the narcissistic way) the crap out of my DD. She is very determined and strong-willed and it was very hard work at that age. We got into a negative cycle. So I started praising all the tiny things, being really positive and that’s what helped to turn the corner. I am a fairly strict parent (she’s a teenager now and think I’m mega strict, mostly cos at 13 I won’t let her have social media!) but we have a lovely relationship.

toddlerstr · 12/11/2026 09:55

INeedAnotherAlibi · 12/11/2026 09:54

I found ‘1 2 3 magic parenting’ book helpful at this age. I also love bombed (in a positive way, not the narcissistic way) the crap out of my DD. She is very determined and strong-willed and it was very hard work at that age. We got into a negative cycle. So I started praising all the tiny things, being really positive and that’s what helped to turn the corner. I am a fairly strict parent (she’s a teenager now and think I’m mega strict, mostly cos at 13 I won’t let her have social media!) but we have a lovely relationship.

Thank you for this, sounds similar to my three year old, I can see they are wanting to connect with me but it’s happening in negative ways and I think we need a reset.

OP posts:
SilenceInside · 12/11/2026 09:55

You adapt to your child. Verbalising is a very wide range and would be different if dealing with a 10 year old or a 3 year old for example. You also wouldn't want to be trying to talk about something with a child who is not regulated as they won't be listening to you. You don't need to talk constantly and as the only way of enforcing boundaries.

Bestbeforenow · 12/11/2026 09:56

This book Easier Happier Parenting put solid ground under my feet. Couldn’t recommend it enough.

WhatNoRaisins · 12/11/2026 10:01

The part of gentle parenting that I've got no time for are the long scripts that they come up with. An overtired or frustrated toddler is not going to react to the barrage of words you sometimes get recommended. Keep instructions short and simple.

On a practical level I agree with a lot of PP about keeping firm boundaries. I also think with toddlers you're better off with a toddler proof home so that there is less conflict over stuff like them emptying cupboards or doing something dangerous. With transitional stuff like bedtime or leaving the house in think it helps to be as prepared as possible with the practical side and minimise distractions.

JLou08 · 12/11/2026 10:01

You need to adapt to your child. I've got 3 and they all needed a different approach. What are the situations your struggling with and how have you tried to manage it?

Seeline · 12/11/2026 10:01

toddlerstr · 12/11/2026 09:53

I don’t always find it helps to verbalise things and seems to exacerbate the situation a lot of the time. I suppose it looks like it should work but in practice it doesn’t.

I agree - at that age, getting down at their level and having an in depth discussion about feelings or why it's not a good idea to stick their fingers in the electrical socket, rarely works. Especially during a tantrum.
A firm, clear 'no', and then physical intervention (removal, relocation, grabbing hand etc - not smacking!) if that doesn't work is best for immediate danger.
Otherwise, a clear warning, followed by a clear 'no' and then distraction or removal can work.
I still think that a 'naughty step' (or whatever you want to call it) works well - it helps calm everyone down, including the parent. Then you have the chance for an age-appropriate explanation/talk about feelings/an apology/a cuddle after things have calmed.
For tantrums - ignore as much as possible whilst staying nearby to check that the child doesn't put themself in danger, and being on hand for a calming cuddle once things have started to improve.

Despositor · 12/11/2026 10:09

Personally half the trick in my opinion is finding a technique and sticking to it

The danger of too much advice is that you try and do a bit of everything and end up a bit paralysed by it

toddlerstr · 12/11/2026 10:10

WhatNoRaisins · 12/11/2026 10:01

The part of gentle parenting that I've got no time for are the long scripts that they come up with. An overtired or frustrated toddler is not going to react to the barrage of words you sometimes get recommended. Keep instructions short and simple.

On a practical level I agree with a lot of PP about keeping firm boundaries. I also think with toddlers you're better off with a toddler proof home so that there is less conflict over stuff like them emptying cupboards or doing something dangerous. With transitional stuff like bedtime or leaving the house in think it helps to be as prepared as possible with the practical side and minimise distractions.

If mine loses it if I say anything she just screams at me so it’s very hard to do the scripts if you like. Clinginess is also a problem.

OP posts:
Apotofrealcoffee · 12/11/2026 10:14

toddlerstr · 12/11/2026 09:47

I’ve said aggressive as it often is on here. Is there a middle ground? I’m losing my way with my 3 yo. And my mind!

Ive never hit, swore at, or humiliated my children. But im not afraid to show disapproval. Small children read facial expressions before they can understand emotional speech, it’s not fair to ‘calmly remove them but don’t lose your cool’ and expect them to realise they’ve done something wrong. This emotional grey rocking is why so many kids continue to act out; because the parent is so afraid to show disapproval despite the fact it’s needed.

So don’t be afraid of firm but fair - showing your disapproval through facial expressions and ‘you’ve made me sad/cross’. Keep it simple. Follow through every consequence. Lots of praise when they behave - that’s also key and easy to forget.

Seeline · 12/11/2026 10:16

toddlerstr · 12/11/2026 10:10

If mine loses it if I say anything she just screams at me so it’s very hard to do the scripts if you like. Clinginess is also a problem.

As I've said, there is no point rying to do anything mid-tantrum. Stay closeby and wait for it to finish. Then cuddle if they want, then discuss when everyone is calm.

Clinginess? She's 3. Kids that age often need to be close to their caregiver. I don't think that's something you can discipline away!

toddlerstr · 12/11/2026 10:19

She seems very irritable a lot of the time and it doesn’t take much at all to turn it from irritation to shouting and screaming or throwing. So for example she will be playing with a toy and it won’t do quite what she wants it to and she gets furious. She’ll suddenly start crying for no (apparent) reason and ask to be carried even if say we’re at home and there’s nowhere to carry her to. When she’s tired she gets very tactile but m roughly (she bent my finger back yesterday, wasn’t on purpose but still.)

OP posts:
RedLeicesterRedLeicester · 12/11/2026 10:20

https://www.instagram.com/katy_g_blog?rpxt=Nm91cmIwOTM5OHNm

’The Boundary System’ take a look.

I have found this useful. I used to be too much into the gentle style but this works better with mine and feels more naturally me.

SlowlySinkingNotDrowning · 12/11/2026 10:25

I think you’ve had tonnes of good advice already. I would say on my side that we very rarely shout but can get stern if needed. Shouting should be a last resort. I find less shouting tends to dial down the temperature a bit. In terms of what works when a child is already upset - I think that depends on the child. Mine definitely needs to be left to sit in a corner while she processes what she is cross about. But she isn’t destructive or anything. Then when she’s ready I’m always there for a cuddle if she wants and we can then debrief in what happened and how we might avoid the situation in the future (that bit is for older toddlers really).

Whyarepeople · 12/11/2026 10:26

I have two kids and am a former teacher. Having been around a lot of other parents, I'd say where things go wrong is when parents are unclear and inconsistent. As a teacher you have to be very very clear or chaos ensues and consistent on pain of death - if you appear to be 'unfair' or making up rules as you go, children will rebel and struggle to trust you.

The difficult thing about being clear and consistent is that it takes a lot of thought and planning, which is easier in a school situation and harder as a parent because life happens and sometimes difficult situations can't be avoided.

Don't overdo requests or directions - ask them to do some very specific things, then always follow through - you've asked, so they're going to do it, however that might need to happen. So if you ask them to get their shoes, they are going to get their shoes, even if that takes 20 minutes to achieve. Making requests specific and non-negotiable does two things - it shows the child you mean business and it also stops you from constantly badgering them. Fewer requests are easier to manage!

As much as possible don't put your 3 year old in situations you know they can't handle - give them enough responsibility/challenge so that they can do some things themselves and you can praise them, then step in when things get harder and short circuit any potential for things to go off track. So, for example, if they're difficult in the morning, consider getting up earlier/later (whatever might make them less grumpy!), pre-plan outfits, make food easy and start building up the steps to help them get dressed or get their stuff together. Try to include as many opportunities for success as possible and circumvent negative situations - if shoes are a big deal for example, leave those to the very last second, include a big reward, make it game, whatever might work to take the sting out of it. Be very clear on what you expect and give them a clear number of chances to do it - 3 usually works - then do something about it.

Nothing infuriates me more than seeing a parent asking a child to do something five times when it's clear they're not going to take any action. It annoys the child too - it's so wishy-washy that of course the child is going to feel like they can just not bother or they need to start playing up to get a reaction. Don't nitpick, keep poking or use a ton of words. Commands should be short and neutral, e.g. time to get shoes! and everything else should be positive. To begin with success should be very very easy. If your child just won't get the shoes then you engineer the situation that they're right next to the shoes when you say it, and as soon as they even go near the shoes you say 'great, you got the shoes!' They might think you're a bit nuts to start with but over time they'll see how easy it is get praise and it'll start to get more motivating. How quickly this works depends on the child and how chaotic the starting situation is.

The world is very annoying for three year olds. They're constantly over stimulated, tired and hungry. They're also curious to test out their own power and control and are rubbish at predicting the future. Essentially you have to save them from their own madness as much as possible while also giving them some sense of agency. Be wary of getting into 'constant correction' mode - it's annoying for both of you. It's good to just say something positive for no reason now and again. And some not so great behaviour can be ignored if it's not dangerous or disruptive.

Lomonald · 12/11/2026 10:29

Seeline · 12/11/2026 09:49

Firm but fair.
Clear boundaries consistently applied.
Praise for good behaviour.
Reasonable, relatable consequences for bad.
No hitting, try and avoid shouting.
Have fun.

This really, ĺ just want to add it is fine to give them choice but it has to be "this or that" little children can't cope with free rein imo.