Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want parenting advice that isn’t ‘gentle’ but also isn’t aggressive

75 replies

toddlerstr · 12/11/2026 09:47

I’ve said aggressive as it often is on here. Is there a middle ground? I’m losing my way with my 3 yo. And my mind!

OP posts:
Seeline · 12/11/2026 10:30

toddlerstr · 12/11/2026 10:19

She seems very irritable a lot of the time and it doesn’t take much at all to turn it from irritation to shouting and screaming or throwing. So for example she will be playing with a toy and it won’t do quite what she wants it to and she gets furious. She’ll suddenly start crying for no (apparent) reason and ask to be carried even if say we’re at home and there’s nowhere to carry her to. When she’s tired she gets very tactile but m roughly (she bent my finger back yesterday, wasn’t on purpose but still.)

This all seems quite normal for a 3 yo.
If she is getting frustrated with something, either show her how to do it, or suggest putting it away and trying a different toy for a while. We all get frustrated when something won't work the way we want it to!
If she is upset, then maybe say no to a carry, but give her a cuddle instead. Emotions are overwhelming at that age - she may be sad, scared, angry, tired but can't express it. You should be able to help identify it and reassure her with a cuddle.
Touching is normal when they are tires, but she shouldn't be hurting you. If she is rough, hold her hand firmly, and remind her that she needs to be gentle. demonstrate gentle stroking on her hand. If she continues to hurt then you move her away, telling her why.

Mosaic80 · 12/11/2026 10:30

I think the "How to talk so little kids will listen and listen so little kids will talk" book is good.

JLou08 · 12/11/2026 10:32

toddlerstr · 12/11/2026 10:19

She seems very irritable a lot of the time and it doesn’t take much at all to turn it from irritation to shouting and screaming or throwing. So for example she will be playing with a toy and it won’t do quite what she wants it to and she gets furious. She’ll suddenly start crying for no (apparent) reason and ask to be carried even if say we’re at home and there’s nowhere to carry her to. When she’s tired she gets very tactile but m roughly (she bent my finger back yesterday, wasn’t on purpose but still.)

It sounds like you need to tackle what is leading to the behaviour. She sounds overstimulated. A calmer environment with less noise so no TV in the background, no bright lights. Weighted soft toys or blankets. A dark den where she can just go and relax alone or with you just having a cuddle with no chat. Plenty of physical activity, climbing, balancing, running etc. My eldest needed to go to the playground or soft play everyday at that age or he would be bouncing off ghe walls.
When she is getting to the point of being overstimulated find something that calms her, for mine it's a walk or a bath.
Once she gets to the point of a tantrum try to just ignore it. It sounds like you trying to intervene makes it worse, she's not learning anything from being told off when she is in that state so just ignore. As someone above mentioned, have a child proofed home so you don't need to intervene for her safety when she gets to that point.
You can still hold firm boundaries without telling her off for a tantrum, if the tantrum is a response to a boundary eg no biscuit, let her ride out the tantrum and hold the boundary that she won't get a biscuit.
For the pinching, I'd move away and say I won't sit with you when you're hurting me. But you also need to make sure she can meet them needs for tactile input. Squeeze toys, play dough, pop it toys etc.

HorseandHeron · 12/11/2026 10:32

I read this book when DC were toddlers and I was really struggling.

Positive Discipline by Jane Nelsen

It changed my life. DH and I passed a toddler in mid tantrum the other day and recalled that our two didn't have meltdowns, despite one being autistic. I swear it is because I followed this guidance faithfully.

It may be out of date now - DC are both adults, so it probably has very little abput screen time unless it's been updated. But the basic advice transformed our home overnight. No fights, no raised voices, no meltdowns, no battles of will. It takes work and patience, but I'd way rather be patient than angry.

Amazon

Amazon

https://www.amazon.co.uk/Positive-Discipline-Jane-Nelson/dp/0345487672/ref=sr_1_2?adgrpid=189935326521&dib=eyJ2IjoiMSJ9.gSUmnhn60-q8DqGtvlKo_8ACdkfL_GC_GI7X5yJ6RUG8t2nZD5ZZHSDjiClM9WvxccWWCrW0qUsMQwPWuonxx4Y1Qm7ATbn6zqpCkLG0M8mN7dcAa3TSGYn4odJDYKqrwwqLFNPZQeU9s9edFc1bJC3ZzNwJ-tTW566aIFYOoV4RjZYrKN363JUJWzQqev3DZ-g0RQl_JmXNuV9SuQmfDuDv9wzEVczbJ_wxKINMZVE.Shkc5Z0wrgVefQeHZtJnWs4ob8Y4wg1nb86FL7iDU9Y&dib_tag=se&gad_source=1&hvadid=779290702291&hvdev=c&hvexpln=0&hvlocphy=1006703&hvnetw=g&hvocijid=8648732358490618593--&hvqmt=e&hvrand=8648732358490618593&hvtargid=kwd-301682606381&hydadcr=11919_2379575_6248&keywords=jane%20nelsen%20positive%20discipline&mcid=edce41d74db03f38be84cbc2b8fae271&qid=1794479118&sr=8-2&tag=mumsnet&ascsubtag=mnforum-am-i-being-unreasonable-5598918-to-want-parenting-advice-that-isnt-gentle-but-also-isnt-aggressive

HorseandHeron · 12/11/2026 10:41

toddlerstr · 12/11/2026 10:19

She seems very irritable a lot of the time and it doesn’t take much at all to turn it from irritation to shouting and screaming or throwing. So for example she will be playing with a toy and it won’t do quite what she wants it to and she gets furious. She’ll suddenly start crying for no (apparent) reason and ask to be carried even if say we’re at home and there’s nowhere to carry her to. When she’s tired she gets very tactile but m roughly (she bent my finger back yesterday, wasn’t on purpose but still.)

Positive parenting techniques are all about teaching them how to self-soothe - to calm themselves down. Instead of a naughty step (which I loathe - the notion that it is 'naughty' to have negative feelings is so damaging) you have a cosy corner - a place to go to calm down. It has the effect of the naughty step - the child has a time out, the parent has a break, but the place is soft with cushions and blankets, maybe a cuddly toy or a favourite book, a sippy cup with water. The child can leave as soon as they have calmed down and are ready to apologise or play nicely or whatever is needed of them. They don't have to sit there for a set number of minutes. The purpose is to feel calm, not to be told off.

There are scripts but not lectures. In a case like the toy annoying her, you might say: is that toy annoying you? Then after she's replied, whether she says yes or no, or kicks it, you say, 'It's horrible feeling all angry like that, isn't it? You deserve to feel nice and calm. Go and snuggle in your cosy corner until it's made you feel better, then come for a cuddle.' Sometimes they are calm in seconds, sometimes in minutes. But removing criticism and punishment from the scenario really does take the fuel from the fire.

I always think - as adults, do we respond better when we are stressed or upset, to being punished, judged, given arbitrary conditions, or when treated with compassion and trust that with a bit of time to unwind we will be back to normal? If we wouyldn;t respond well to naughty corners, being shouted at or hit, why on earth do we think children can, when they have far less ability to process a situation emotionally and rationally.

toddlerstr · 12/11/2026 10:44

It is largely normal @Seeline it’s just I feel like my capacity to deal with it is diminished a bit.

Thanks for the book recommendations.

OP posts:
Passaggressfedup · 12/11/2026 10:45

They as much to explain in advance what the is expected from them and what consequences will be if not complying. Remind them during event. If they refuse to comply, apply consequence. They will scream, shout etc...let them. When they've come down, discuss why they didn't comply and why they had to face the consequence.

Next time, Remind them of that particular event.

It worked brilliantly with my very challenging DS. I would remind them of that situation and how they didn't get their way when he was sure it would (I cancelled an outing 10 mins before!), and that would stop him right away. Still showed his frustration, but nowhere as bad and it was over in seconds rather than long and exhausting minutes!

Meand2Ls · 12/11/2026 10:46

I think the middle ground is not being able to be manipulated or guilt tripped by your child. They are tiny, they aren’t actually doing those things but people break when they cry and beg not to have the consequences. I have never made a threat I’ve not followed through with. If I’ve spent a fortune on a day out I’m never threatening that we can’t go because of bad behaviour because I know we will. Anything I say is a consequence of bad behaviour is one and my kids know that and no matter how much they scream, cry or beg will change my mind. I’m firm but I’m always fair and good behaviour is massively praised and rewarded as well. What this has resulted in for me is an almost 5 year old who I basically never have to tell off anymore, who is my little best friend and who I genuinely love being around and spending time with and I’m hoping my 2 year old will follow suit

tomorrowfollowstoday · 12/11/2026 10:48

toddlerstr · 12/11/2026 09:54

I know there is a discussion about gentle parenting and permissive parenting but that is not what I am starting

Then don't use the term 'gentle' incorrectly!

And don't deliberately contrast it with 'aggressive' to start a bunfight

tomorrowfollowstoday · 12/11/2026 10:50

toddlerstr · 12/11/2026 10:19

She seems very irritable a lot of the time and it doesn’t take much at all to turn it from irritation to shouting and screaming or throwing. So for example she will be playing with a toy and it won’t do quite what she wants it to and she gets furious. She’ll suddenly start crying for no (apparent) reason and ask to be carried even if say we’re at home and there’s nowhere to carry her to. When she’s tired she gets very tactile but m roughly (she bent my finger back yesterday, wasn’t on purpose but still.)

This is quite normal, with the exception of the roughness.

But loud upset at small things is natural.

Cheekycekyh · 12/11/2026 10:51

I have done a bit of research around this. The most successful parenting style is authoritiative.

I think gentle parenting came around because people didn’t like the word authorititve so wanted to rename it.

New generation of parents came along and didn’t realise gentle parenting was supposed to actually be authorititve parenting. And instead began permissive parenting.

Gentle parenting is now permissive parenting. Which is a very unsuccessful style.

So for you… search authoritive parenting online.

toddlerstr · 12/11/2026 10:53

I don’t think you’ve understood what I wanted from this thread; it isn’t the semantics around gentle parenting. I know what gentle parenting is and also what it is not. But if it doesn’t work then I have to modify my approach.

OP posts:
Snorlaxo · 12/11/2026 10:53

toddlerstr · 12/11/2026 10:19

She seems very irritable a lot of the time and it doesn’t take much at all to turn it from irritation to shouting and screaming or throwing. So for example she will be playing with a toy and it won’t do quite what she wants it to and she gets furious. She’ll suddenly start crying for no (apparent) reason and ask to be carried even if say we’re at home and there’s nowhere to carry her to. When she’s tired she gets very tactile but m roughly (she bent my finger back yesterday, wasn’t on purpose but still.)

Being frustrated is part of the learning process. She cries or gets furious because she’s little and doesn’t have the self control to do something like ask for help. If adults could get away with that behaviour then we’d do it too. I would let her be angry then when she calms down a little, offer to help or suggest a solution to her problem. Over time, she’ll hopefully transition to using her words (It’s too big to fit in there) rather than physically lash out but it takes practice.

Is she well hydrated and eaten something recently? An offer of a drink used to work some of the time for me.

I would also tell her that she has to speak “nicely” because you don’t understand shouting. Hopefully over time she will start calming down before asking you for a cuddle which is what I suspect she means by wanting to be carried when there’s nowhere to carry her to.

I don’t see many people suggesting aggressive solutions (I assume you mean smacking) I would class it as dealing with things like a teacher - firm but fair.

JadziaD · 12/11/2026 10:58

I think one problem that happens a lot is that parents have too high expectations of children. So it sounds to me like your 3 year old doesn't have a lot of resilience. Which is not weird. She's 3. So when she's doing something, and it's not working, she gets upset.

Your job is to help her work on this. With a few different elements to that work. One is to help her figure out how something works (or accept if it's not possible). One is to help her manage her disappointment. At this age, it might well be that's simply about heading it off before it happens with a distraction, or it might be with you being sympathetic to her upset while reiterating that sometimes this happens, followed by something positive - a new thing to do, priase for what she did do etc.

The complete meltdowns may well be overstimulation and/or overtiredness. Again, as parents of small children, it's our job to prevent these situations arising in the first place and then, as they get older, you can prevent them while explaining why and what you're doing so that they can then learn how to do it for themselves. And doing this will look different for every child. For DS, he needed to get out of the house every single day and it needed to be in the morning. That was non negotiable. For DD, she needed proper clear breaks between activities or events. She could not go from softplay straight to a playdate. that did not work for her.

augustusglupe · 12/11/2026 10:59

Needlesnah · 12/11/2026 09:54

This. Raised 3 on my own so I had to have clear boundaries. I strongly disagree width ‘gentle’ parenting. They are strong, independent, thoughtful young adults now. And they phone/talk to me which I love.

Yes all this.
I wasn’t afraid to say no and it was quite funny because DD grew up very confident and also just said no to things from an early age, no drama 😄
I was only 24 and parenting just came natural, mistakes and all.

And just what Needles said, she rings me everyday

SatinHeart · 12/11/2026 11:00

When small children are acting like dicks they are nearly always tired, hungry or overwhelmed (or some combination of these). Remembering that helped me stay calm through the screamy phases.

Also consequences and rewards both have to be immediate when they are that age. They throw something - you take it away or make them clear it up straight away. Don't ask them to do something good with a vague promise of a treat 'later'. Cognitively they can't process that yet.

Get down to their level. My youngest was much more receptive if I sat on the floor to talk to him rather than towering over him by standing.

Cheekycekyh · 12/11/2026 11:07

toddlerstr · 12/11/2026 10:53

I don’t think you’ve understood what I wanted from this thread; it isn’t the semantics around gentle parenting. I know what gentle parenting is and also what it is not. But if it doesn’t work then I have to modify my approach.

People are talking about it because you said somewhere between gentle and aggressive.

They are trying to help understand what you mean by that.
The 4 main styles go from…

GENTLER

  • Permissive
  • Authoritative
  • Authoritian
  • Abusive
MORE AGGRESSIVE

I assume you want authoritive but maybe you don’t. Do you mean between authoritive and abusive - in which case you are asking for places to find authoritarian parenting tips.

I don’t know OP. People are just trying to help you communicate your thoughts.

Theotherdays · 12/11/2026 11:09

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

RoseWylie · 12/11/2026 11:12

I have always found Tanya Byron's books good on this.

toddlerstr · 12/11/2026 11:14

Cheekycekyh · 12/11/2026 11:07

People are talking about it because you said somewhere between gentle and aggressive.

They are trying to help understand what you mean by that.
The 4 main styles go from…

GENTLER

  • Permissive
  • Authoritative
  • Authoritian
  • Abusive
MORE AGGRESSIVE

I assume you want authoritive but maybe you don’t. Do you mean between authoritive and abusive - in which case you are asking for places to find authoritarian parenting tips.

I don’t know OP. People are just trying to help you communicate your thoughts.

None of that is a discussion around what gentle parenting actually is though. All I meant was I don’t find gentle parenting helpful; equally the typical responses here are often quite aggressive (including an increasing number of posters advocating smacking.)

OP posts:
HotGrapefruit · 12/11/2026 11:15

Being strict isn't being aggressive.

BiggerIsAlwaysBetter · 12/11/2026 11:16

I think my tip is to remember that consistency builds trust.

No, your 3yo may not like whatever technique you employ, but they will feel safe knowing that whenever they act out they will get the same predictable handling response from you.

Why do you think your approach isn't working? I'm asking because we used the naughty step, and it was tedious and frustrating amd if you'd monitored that approach over 3 months, you'd have said it didn't work. But we stuck with it (because 3yo need more than 3 months to learn, it is a challenging period from 18m-school age) and our child is now measurably a beautifully behaved child.

My point is that yes, you might need to change technique if it isn't working, but "isn't working" can't be measured by changing the approach every two weeks or getting different outcomes from different parents (not saying you're doing those things, they are just examples)

HotGrapefruit · 12/11/2026 11:17

toddlerstr · 12/11/2026 10:19

She seems very irritable a lot of the time and it doesn’t take much at all to turn it from irritation to shouting and screaming or throwing. So for example she will be playing with a toy and it won’t do quite what she wants it to and she gets furious. She’ll suddenly start crying for no (apparent) reason and ask to be carried even if say we’re at home and there’s nowhere to carry her to. When she’s tired she gets very tactile but m roughly (she bent my finger back yesterday, wasn’t on purpose but still.)

Most of these examples sound pretty much like a three year old.

Is she getting enough sleep? She sounds quite crabby? What about pain?

Pulling my finger back would be a telling off. "That really hurt me. Say sorry." and put her down.

RocketPanda · 12/11/2026 11:19

My dc are all adults now but I found firmly saying that its fine to be angry/disappointed/sad but its not ok to throw toys/shout/hurt anyone. And then just be nearby but let them learn how to work through their feelings. There will be grumping and whinging but leave them to it.
For what its worth my dc can cope very well with negative feelings as adults and can express anger disappointment as well as happiness and excitement in healthy ways.

SevenYellowHammers · 12/11/2026 11:19

Seeline · 12/11/2026 09:49

Firm but fair.
Clear boundaries consistently applied.
Praise for good behaviour.
Reasonable, relatable consequences for bad.
No hitting, try and avoid shouting.
Have fun.

As above OP. Mainly enjoy it, it’s definitely goes too fast. One minute you’re making a shepherd’s outfit and the next you’re in IKEA and about to send them to uni! It is a trying, worrisome but joyful journey.