Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want parenting advice that isn’t ‘gentle’ but also isn’t aggressive

75 replies

toddlerstr · 12/11/2026 09:47

I’ve said aggressive as it often is on here. Is there a middle ground? I’m losing my way with my 3 yo. And my mind!

OP posts:
toddlerstr · 12/11/2026 11:20

HotGrapefruit · 12/11/2026 11:17

Most of these examples sound pretty much like a three year old.

Is she getting enough sleep? She sounds quite crabby? What about pain?

Pulling my finger back would be a telling off. "That really hurt me. Say sorry." and put her down.

Yes, I’m not saying otherwise, just looking how best to deal with it Smile

OP posts:
DarkForces · 12/11/2026 11:21

Lead with love
Accept tantrums are inevitable and can generally be safely ignored. I found dd used tantrums to get stuff out her system. If she was safe I'd leave her to it
Accept you're human too and apologise when you overreact or get it wrong
Remember parenting is a relationship, not a job. Adapt and build on what works for you and your child.

HotGrapefruit · 12/11/2026 11:21

Does she articulate why she is crying? Can you sit down with her and cuddle her at those points until she can think a bit about what's going on?

The lovebombing suggested above worked well for my v. clingy child. I'd basically have to grit my teeth and build it into our day, but it made a difference in terms of how secure she felt.

RocketPanda · 12/11/2026 11:22

And also that when they say sorry for shouting at you or hurting you say thank you for saying sorry instead of thats ok.

BreakfastClub80 · 12/11/2026 11:25

One thing I found in the earlier years, is that I sometimes felt that DD and I came to a point where my usual methods didn’t work and I would realise that she had moved into a new developmental phase. So things would tick along and then start feeling difficult. Once it got too difficult I’d realise I needed to change some aspects of my parenting to suit the new phase. Then we’d be ok again. Your comment that your capacity to deal with your DDs behaviour reminds me a little of how I’d feel when this happened.

tomorrowfollowstoday · 12/11/2026 11:27

toddlerstr · 12/11/2026 10:53

I don’t think you’ve understood what I wanted from this thread; it isn’t the semantics around gentle parenting. I know what gentle parenting is and also what it is not. But if it doesn’t work then I have to modify my approach.

Could you explain more clearly what you do want as I don't understand.

Is the issue that they don't do what you say, or are upset when you enforce a boundary?

TimetoPour · 12/11/2026 11:27

So often people are frightened of saying no to their children or feel they have to negotiate and over explain their reasons for saying no. It’s overwhelming and they get bored of listening. They shutdown before you’ve got your point across. Toddlers need short, firm, clear instructions. If you give them an option, give them two to pick from not free rein to do as they please.

If you can see they are getting frustrated, don’t wait for the melt down. Redirect them before it turns to anger.

Praise them when they are doing well and for persevering at tricky tasks before they lose it. If they are struggling with a toy or task then get down and work along side them so they can see how you are doing it but not take over.

Routine makes a massive difference. Getting up, doing things in order, everyday activities that are mundane but have to be done so we can move on to fun things. It creates a sense of stability. Giving a 5 minute warning before asking them to do something so they are not suddenly having to stop what they are enjoying.

Make things they don’t enjoy in to a game so it’s not so tedious and stops the stress before it starts. Give them a stopwatch to see how quickly they can put their toys away, ask them to help spy things in the supermarket, say I bet you can’t do xyz - I guarantee they will bust themselves to prove you wrong!

Correct the behaviour before it starts.

If it got to the point where they were doing something I didn’t like I would ask them to please stop, then told them to stop and what the consequences would be if they didn’t and followed through every time. It’s the same no matter what all age they are, you just tailor the consequences to something appropriate for their age. At 3 we would not be going to the park, at 5 they lose TV time, at 13 they would lose their WIFI privileges. They can cry, tantrum, call you mean, say they don’t love you etc but do not give in. It’s not mean, it keeps them safe and shows them that your boundaries are non negotiable and there for a reason.

HotGrapefruit · 12/11/2026 11:28

You have been a bit vague here and also said that we don't understand what you want from the thread: I'm wondering if your communication style is unclear generally, which is why you say that verbalising with her isn't working?

Could there be something in that?

Bitsostuff · 12/11/2026 11:29

Seeline · 12/11/2026 10:16

As I've said, there is no point rying to do anything mid-tantrum. Stay closeby and wait for it to finish. Then cuddle if they want, then discuss when everyone is calm.

Clinginess? She's 3. Kids that age often need to be close to their caregiver. I don't think that's something you can discipline away!

This is great advice for the parent of a single child with endless time. Meanwhile in the real world parents occasionally have to impose an agenda.

JuliaAgrippina · 12/11/2026 11:31

WhatNoRaisins · 12/11/2026 10:01

The part of gentle parenting that I've got no time for are the long scripts that they come up with. An overtired or frustrated toddler is not going to react to the barrage of words you sometimes get recommended. Keep instructions short and simple.

On a practical level I agree with a lot of PP about keeping firm boundaries. I also think with toddlers you're better off with a toddler proof home so that there is less conflict over stuff like them emptying cupboards or doing something dangerous. With transitional stuff like bedtime or leaving the house in think it helps to be as prepared as possible with the practical side and minimise distractions.

All this.

I used to take them out in morning and some afternoons to run off energy in larger rooms and with different toys than we had at home.

They could be creatively destructive so toddler proffed to minimise that and so not endless having arguments and focusing on none negotiable stuff - also found reminders that something would be happening shortly helped with transtions.

Remember another mother being shocked how easily I got her tired child ready to leave out house when she failed for ten minutes - coat with arm there - said arm she put it in - other arm - buttons you or me - got shoes there foot other foot - and walked to door - girl was smiling. Clear firm instrucstions which you make easy to do - set them up to succeed with them.

I think it can e very easy when tried to get into a negative cycle when you really need to sit down and think how do I avoid that again and how do I make that easier for all of us.

Peonies12 · 12/11/2026 11:47

I really like the book 'Good Inside', it has helped me a lot. Firm boundaries, but high warmth. Try to make most interactions positive or neutral. Lots of connection time where possible.

essasas · 12/11/2026 11:48

Janet Lansbury saved my bacon. Her podcast Unruffled is excellent and covers everything.

Authoritative parenting.

Peonies12 · 12/11/2026 11:49

And I really agree with a toddler proof house. And also pick your battles. Don't just say no, consider does it actually matter, for example, if they want to empty a drawer, fine, but we tidy together after. Instead of just saying no.

tomorrowfollowstoday · 12/11/2026 11:51

Peonies12 · 12/11/2026 11:49

And I really agree with a toddler proof house. And also pick your battles. Don't just say no, consider does it actually matter, for example, if they want to empty a drawer, fine, but we tidy together after. Instead of just saying no.

This - so many arguments can be avoided, saving parental energy for when it is more needed.

Maybeitllneverhappen · 12/11/2026 11:57

I think tone of voice is very important. I hear so many wishy-washy "don't do that" ; I'd ignore them too. Also don't repeat yourself dozens of times as they then don't bother to listen because they know you'll say the same thing 5 times. Practise the firm "look" too.

Maybeitllneverhappen · 12/11/2026 11:59

Oh, also try to do positive instructions instead of negative. "Do" rather than "don't".

BertieBotts · 12/11/2026 12:00

Anything involving much talking is no use at all for a 3yo. Even though they can often say a lot and e.g. repeat rules or reasons for rules, it doesn't mean they can reliably follow it or use self-talk to control their behaviour. That comes much later (more like 6+). Yes do talk to them obviously, it's very important to do that, but don't expect verbal directions, reasoning, explanation to do much in terms of behaviour management. Think like about the amount of language you'd expect a dog to understand - this a rough idea of the limit of language for behaviour management.

Mainly you're aiming to use control of the environment, trying to be one step ahead in terms of physical needs (hunger, thirst, toilet, temperature, movement, sleep/quiet rest, connection) and anticipating situations in advance to try to set them up for success, because mostly what will help is reinforcement of learnt behaviours so that they almost become automatic. Rather than trying to punish unwanted behaviour, figure out what you want to replace it with and encourage/reward that.

Plus, your body language is huge. If you're irritated and grumpy and tired they pick up on this and reflect it back to you, which looks rude and gets your back up. If you can muster energy to summon your inner Kids' TV presenter, it almost always helps. If you don't quite have the energy for this, then at least try to keep your voice low/slow/calm and soft, like a kind grandmother. Lots of deep breaths and leave plenty of time for everything if you can so you're less likely to be rushing and panicking.

If DC is struggling to handle a situation to the point they refuse to attempt it or have a lot of difficult behaviour around that situation, think whether you can acclimatise them to it more slowly by introducing them to a smaller/easier version, and work up. If they are doing it but are just upset, it can help to reframe this as being brave. It might still help to take a step back, but it's also OK if they are sometimes upset/frustrated/worried etc. Try not to get into a trap of constantly reassuring them or trying to fix every problem. Obviously some reassurance is good and normal, but if it gets too much it can increase anxiety rather than helping them learn that feeling anxious is one of a range of normal emotions which we all feel sometimes, and won't last forever.

This is the best course I've come across (it's just a playlist, so free)

https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLh9mgdi4rNeyEGNxBvNdOVlianDYgWuc9

I also really like Janet Lansbury, Unruffled and her older blog posts from ~2013. Not sure if the podcast is still as good as it always was, so if it's annoying, try the earlier episodes as it used to be great. She's respectful of the child as a person, without being a massive pushover, getting bogged down in emotions or overly wordy strategies which are doomed to failure. I really like her "confident momentum" and "I won't let you X"

Most social media parenting content is awful these days and extremely polarised to the point of being bonkers and/or peppered with lines of thought that tap into our fears (about DC future mental health or physical risk, most commonly) and I think this can be really counterproductive, so would highly recommend unfollowing anything you follow which makes you feel like this.

Before you continue to YouTube

https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLh9mgdi4rNeyEGNxBvNdOVlianDYgWuc9

moominontherun · 12/11/2026 12:02

I think authoritative (not to be confused with authoritarian, which is totally different!) parenting is probably along the lines you’re looking for. Janet Lansbury stuff appeals to me. It’s got more teeth than Sarah Ockwell Smith etc but is respectful and fair and I find it works well for my kids.

tomorrowfollowstoday · 12/11/2026 12:04

Maybeitllneverhappen · 12/11/2026 11:59

Oh, also try to do positive instructions instead of negative. "Do" rather than "don't".

Oh yes this - saying don't is very confusing - it leaves them uncertain.

Merryoldgoat · 12/11/2026 12:04

You want to be an ‘authoritative parent’ which is where true gentle parenting has its roots.

I have never hit my children or used significant ounishments, rarely raise my voice but absolutely do when necessary. Both have additional needs and one is non-verbal. They are 14 and 9.

Life it tough at times and quite full on but the children are well behaved and I’ve never had anything but praise about their behaviour.

There are lots of resources out there for authoritative parenting which is what I’d be aiming for.

Bigtrapeze · 12/11/2026 12:28

toddlerstr · 12/11/2026 10:19

She seems very irritable a lot of the time and it doesn’t take much at all to turn it from irritation to shouting and screaming or throwing. So for example she will be playing with a toy and it won’t do quite what she wants it to and she gets furious. She’ll suddenly start crying for no (apparent) reason and ask to be carried even if say we’re at home and there’s nowhere to carry her to. When she’s tired she gets very tactile but m roughly (she bent my finger back yesterday, wasn’t on purpose but still.)

If she is frustrated and cross with a toy, you could label that for her with a comment along the lines of, 'Are you feeling cross with your doll? We all feel cross sometimes.' The resultant discussion might yield some interesting information. How is her language? She might be in that phase where they have lots of strong emotions and nowhere near the language or understanding to communicate them.

When a child is upset, there is no point adding much language into the mix. None of us process language especially well during heightened emotional states and 3 year olds will be really unable to do this. If she wants to be carried, can you carry her? I appreciate there are sometimes practical problems. She sounds like she is learning to manage emotions and needs some physical reassurance.

I wouldn't let her hurt you though. Calmly say no, that hurts and if she persists, move away/distract her with something else. DD used to follow me from room to room hitting me as a 2 year old during a particularly unwelcome phase. She was mostly lovely and occasionally not. I wish I'd distracted her more.

Sometimes they don't need a consistent strategy to fix their behaviour but 20 minutes on your knee with a favourite book. I think the calmer you are, the quicker these things pass, or at least they feel that way, which is half of it. Act with kindness where you can but be firm about hitting/road safety/throwing pets down the stairs etc.

To prevent getting into a negative cycle, tell her how amazing she is whenever possible. If she does something you can't overlook, be clear that it can't be done. I quite like a 'house rule' approach. 'In our house, we don't hit. It hurts. Can you chose a book for me to read to you or should we play a game?' Then it's more about how everyone behaves rather than her getting it all wrong, which is a feeling that never makes anyone behave better.

Anytime I got really cross with mine was a misstep in retrospect. I don't want to be angry and I don't want her to be. She did/does push my buttons though so be nice to yourself if patience escapes you on occasion. Now we have hit teenage years, I stay calm, mostly, and it is magic. I see her tantrums as a chance to show her how she could react. Sometimes this requires me to take myself into another space to let the magic unfold as I remind myself that she doesn't mean it but is signalling that she is upset. 3 year olds and teenagers have similarities in full meltdown. It isn't personal but feels it. We think they should know better, and they do a while later, but in the grip of a hard to manage feeling they can't explain, they say and do things we would rather they didn't and they look to us for our reaction. The calmer you can be, the quicker they can regulate, which still feels way too long at the end of a busy day.

I hope this phase passes quickly. I too am not a fan of 'aggressive' parenting, am not using a complicated consequences system but equally I'm not letting her hit me. She got lots of choices over little things where I could but the adults made the big decisions without her input. At 3 you can choose your shoes but you're wearing a helmet on your bike.

Good luck, OP. She's lucky to have a parent giving this such careful thought.

looselegs · 12/11/2026 12:34

Seeline · 12/11/2026 09:49

Firm but fair.
Clear boundaries consistently applied.
Praise for good behaviour.
Reasonable, relatable consequences for bad.
No hitting, try and avoid shouting.
Have fun.

Absolutely this! I'm a childminder and this is how I've always done things, even with my own children. I don't shout, but I change the tone of my voice and am quite firm when needs be. Consequences are put in place when needed, children are warned of consequences and they're always carried out.
Children need firm, fair boundaries otherwise they will run rings round you for the rest of their lives

Cheekycekyh · 12/11/2026 12:52

toddlerstr · 12/11/2026 11:14

None of that is a discussion around what gentle parenting actually is though. All I meant was I don’t find gentle parenting helpful; equally the typical responses here are often quite aggressive (including an increasing number of posters advocating smacking.)

Sorry - I thought you didn’t want to talk about gentle parenting. You wanted to know what else there is so you can find the alternatives.

I do think it’s been quite unclear and I agree with a PP who says perhaps this is a communication issue.

Ie. I am mid 30s and think I have pretty good comprehension skills and can read between lines. Can and have asked follow up questions to ascertain what you actually mean/ want/ need. I am still none the wiser. So a youngster could potentially really be struggling to understand what you actually want them to do.

Anyway I don’t think I can help any further but others seem to be helping so will leave it. Goodluck 🌷

baobabsmoothie · 12/11/2026 12:59

toddlerstr · 12/11/2026 10:19

She seems very irritable a lot of the time and it doesn’t take much at all to turn it from irritation to shouting and screaming or throwing. So for example she will be playing with a toy and it won’t do quite what she wants it to and she gets furious. She’ll suddenly start crying for no (apparent) reason and ask to be carried even if say we’re at home and there’s nowhere to carry her to. When she’s tired she gets very tactile but m roughly (she bent my finger back yesterday, wasn’t on purpose but still.)

So when you pick her up/put her on your lap after she asks you to carry her, does she then ask you to carry her elsewhere?

Bridgertonisbest · 12/11/2026 13:11

HorseandHeron · 12/11/2026 10:41

Positive parenting techniques are all about teaching them how to self-soothe - to calm themselves down. Instead of a naughty step (which I loathe - the notion that it is 'naughty' to have negative feelings is so damaging) you have a cosy corner - a place to go to calm down. It has the effect of the naughty step - the child has a time out, the parent has a break, but the place is soft with cushions and blankets, maybe a cuddly toy or a favourite book, a sippy cup with water. The child can leave as soon as they have calmed down and are ready to apologise or play nicely or whatever is needed of them. They don't have to sit there for a set number of minutes. The purpose is to feel calm, not to be told off.

There are scripts but not lectures. In a case like the toy annoying her, you might say: is that toy annoying you? Then after she's replied, whether she says yes or no, or kicks it, you say, 'It's horrible feeling all angry like that, isn't it? You deserve to feel nice and calm. Go and snuggle in your cosy corner until it's made you feel better, then come for a cuddle.' Sometimes they are calm in seconds, sometimes in minutes. But removing criticism and punishment from the scenario really does take the fuel from the fire.

I always think - as adults, do we respond better when we are stressed or upset, to being punished, judged, given arbitrary conditions, or when treated with compassion and trust that with a bit of time to unwind we will be back to normal? If we wouyldn;t respond well to naughty corners, being shouted at or hit, why on earth do we think children can, when they have far less ability to process a situation emotionally and rationally.

Edited

We had a cuddle corner that was used for “time out”. There were cushions and blankets and books. We would go there together when things needed to be deescalated and once there’d been some calming down we might address the behaviour.

small children don’t have self regulation so they need support to develop that. And food, they get hangry very quickly, not sure when this stops tbh 🤣

New posts on this thread. Refresh page