Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To suggest you watch and share the film unauthorised absence - particularly if you work in schools/your child has SEN or difficultly attending school

773 replies

Frazzlesforever · 11/11/2026 20:31

This excellent short film Unauthorised Absence has been produced to highlight
the actual reality of what it is like for families whose children can't cope in school for whatever reason (SEN, mental health, anxiety etc) and how they are often punished rather than helped. It is a heatwrenching watch.

The story follows a single mother fighting a punitive education system when her autistic nine-year-old daughter experiences severe school distress and emotionally based school non-attendance (EBSNA). It stars Emily Bruni, Beatrice Flaherty, Cathy Tyson, and Anna Maxwell Martin.
It is on the longlist for the Best Short Film at the British Independent Film Awards.

It was crowd funded by parents and others whose childrens have suffered due to the system and aims to help change the dialogue around how these children and their parents are viewed. Both my children have had great difficulties in school one not being able to attend at all and the other forcing herself in until she had a severe breakdown while school told us they were both 'fine in school' - so I think it is really important to watch and share this.

(Please note - the film contains some pretty distressing scenes and there is some self harm. It is quite a difficult watch for anyone who has been through this with their family)

- YouTube

Enjoy the videos and music that you love, upload original content and share it all with friends, family and the world on YouTube.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dn8C7WuGv8g

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
TeawithMeerksy · 12/11/2026 16:43

DangerQuakeRhinoSnake · 12/11/2026 16:34

It's not abuse ffs. There is a balance.

I'd much rather have had a few smacked arses than spent my childhood (and potentially adulthood) in my bedroom crying and depressed.

I did have my share of them actually (from my mum - my dad was another thing entirely). But it wasn't because of not wanting to go into school. It was because I was a PITA in other ways. I harbour no resentment.

it is literally physical abuse. If one of my patients admitted to smacking kids I would be doing a safeguarding report.

but also - a child is distressed about something that is clearly causing them anxiety. Of course, it makes perfect sense to hit them. That will help. 👀

OneandFiveOnly · 12/11/2026 16:43

DangerQuakeRhinoSnake · 12/11/2026 16:34

It's not abuse ffs. There is a balance.

I'd much rather have had a few smacked arses than spent my childhood (and potentially adulthood) in my bedroom crying and depressed.

I did have my share of them actually (from my mum - my dad was another thing entirely). But it wasn't because of not wanting to go into school. It was because I was a PITA in other ways. I harbour no resentment.

So I can smack a colleague for being a PITA?

Why would smacking a child who is frightened and distressed to make them do as adults wished prevent a child from crying or being depressed? How would that be a preventative measure against MH issues?

Thatsalineallright · 12/11/2026 17:08

TeawithMeerksy · 12/11/2026 16:21

I’m sorry but WTF 🤣

I’ve been with DC for 16 years, we live round the corner from my parents and sisters, we have help from them all the time. DCs have lots of hobbies where they thrive. We implement every strategy we think might help. We saved up to stay in the area, which is known for being lovely. Tell me how school is not the problem, but me?

having a child struggling at school is awful enough, and makes you question all the time you are trying to get right… people do not need to hear that them being stressed about parenting a ND child is making it worse. I’ll just go to yoga and solve all my problems yeah?

Edited

You're reacting to something I didn't say.

Apotofrealcoffee · 12/11/2026 17:13

OneandFiveOnly · 12/11/2026 16:43

So I can smack a colleague for being a PITA?

Why would smacking a child who is frightened and distressed to make them do as adults wished prevent a child from crying or being depressed? How would that be a preventative measure against MH issues?

Edited

Well the kids are smacking everyone and throwing chairs even without the arse smacking… 🤷‍♀️

OneandFiveOnly · 12/11/2026 17:15

Apotofrealcoffee · 12/11/2026 17:13

Well the kids are smacking everyone and throwing chairs even without the arse smacking… 🤷‍♀️

Excellent. That makes it perfectly fine for adults to follow suit then

Another one advocating for abuse.

Apotofrealcoffee · 12/11/2026 17:17

OneandFiveOnly · 12/11/2026 17:15

Excellent. That makes it perfectly fine for adults to follow suit then

Another one advocating for abuse.

Edited

They didn’t throw chairs and wallop their teacher when discipline was actually a thing. Just observing. I’ve never smacked my own kids.

OneandFiveOnly · 12/11/2026 17:24

Apotofrealcoffee · 12/11/2026 17:17

They didn’t throw chairs and wallop their teacher when discipline was actually a thing. Just observing. I’ve never smacked my own kids.

But you’re advocating for others to?

DangerQuakeRhinoSnake · 12/11/2026 17:31

Oh yawn the same old arguments about smacking.

Many kids won't need it, but some kids could definitely benefit from it. In moderation of course. All the modern parenting techniques in the world won't work for some.

It's not 'convenience' for adults. It's a learning technique when kids don't yet have the capacity to understand our reasoning.

OneandFiveOnly · 12/11/2026 17:32

Apotofrealcoffee · 12/11/2026 17:17

They didn’t throw chairs and wallop their teacher when discipline was actually a thing. Just observing. I’ve never smacked my own kids.

And I can promise you, those things went on 30 years ago in secondary schools that I knew of.

Dicedpumpkin · 12/11/2026 17:48

They've had borstals, youth offenders centres, schools for 'maladjusted children", offsite behaviour units, approved schools (for persistant truants), pupil referral units in variation ever since the 1944 Education Act.

Many of these where when smacking and canes were common, yet still these varies things existed.

Velumental · 12/11/2026 17:55

DangerQuakeRhinoSnake · 12/11/2026 17:31

Oh yawn the same old arguments about smacking.

Many kids won't need it, but some kids could definitely benefit from it. In moderation of course. All the modern parenting techniques in the world won't work for some.

It's not 'convenience' for adults. It's a learning technique when kids don't yet have the capacity to understand our reasoning.

Noone benefits from being physically hurt.

No child benefits from their parent hitting them.

Long term the kids who have the worst mental health are those who have been physically punished. The ones with the worst out ones, highest suicide rats etc etc

Velumental · 12/11/2026 18:09

Apotofrealcoffee · 12/11/2026 17:17

They didn’t throw chairs and wallop their teacher when discipline was actually a thing. Just observing. I’ve never smacked my own kids.

'they' absolutely did! I'm 43, I went to a very well behaved Catholic grammar school and eventually here plenty went on. My brother went to the local secondary and some of the stories were wild. You're talking early 1990s.

Then you have the stories from my mum's generation both of teacher brutality and extreme behaviours.

What we didn't have back in the day was quite so much keeping account of every misbehaviour. That said we had a 'behavoour book' in our school where you got coded points, bad and good for behaviour. Detentions were rare but those points, ooft the fear!

DangerQuakeRhinoSnake · 12/11/2026 18:11

Velumental · 12/11/2026 17:55

Noone benefits from being physically hurt.

No child benefits from their parent hitting them.

Long term the kids who have the worst mental health are those who have been physically punished. The ones with the worst out ones, highest suicide rats etc etc

I disagree, respectfully, in some cases.

DangerQuakeRhinoSnake · 12/11/2026 18:12

Dicedpumpkin · 12/11/2026 17:48

They've had borstals, youth offenders centres, schools for 'maladjusted children", offsite behaviour units, approved schools (for persistant truants), pupil referral units in variation ever since the 1944 Education Act.

Many of these where when smacking and canes were common, yet still these varies things existed.

I was actually referring to parental physical discipline rather than institutional (which I do disagree with).

Dicedpumpkin · 12/11/2026 18:18

DangerQuakeRhinoSnake · 12/11/2026 18:12

I was actually referring to parental physical discipline rather than institutional (which I do disagree with).

What is meant was parental physical discipline cant have been that effective as all these institutions existed. If a parental smack was very effective and meant children were generally better behaved they wouldnt have needed the institutions.

DangerQuakeRhinoSnake · 12/11/2026 18:23

Dicedpumpkin · 12/11/2026 18:18

What is meant was parental physical discipline cant have been that effective as all these institutions existed. If a parental smack was very effective and meant children were generally better behaved they wouldnt have needed the institutions.

Well, if indeed the parents did for those children. Who knows?

ErmWhatNow · 12/11/2026 18:34

Apotofrealcoffee · 11/11/2026 21:28

School has never been LESS punitive. 2000s we had uniform inspections, Saturday detentions, teachers would actually shout at you, no screens just endless boring writing. At primary we had to sit facing the wall if we were naughty.

It’s not schools that have changed, it’s children

Bollocks. Have had children in the school system for over 20 years and have seen huge changes in that time, including a shift towards academies taking over secondary schools (last time I checked they were around 80% of secondary schools) with their authoritarian high pressure approach, suiting some children but not all.

There is less variety in schools available, and a huge increase in one size fits none all type systems.

Families are under more strain, with less money, more stress, more pressure.

At some point we need to make societal changes so that fewer people are being broken by it, and we need to stop blaming those most hurt.

Thatsalineallright · 12/11/2026 18:43

BruachAbhann · 12/11/2026 14:52

How do you explain the fact that when these kids are in an environment more suited to them they are able to thrive then? All they really need is to feel safe and listened to. When they are physically and emotionally safe they can begin to learn. Hard plastic chairs, harsh lighting, factory-style learning, being shouted at, rigid timetables, having to sit still and be quiet for the guts of 6 hours is just not a natural state of being for any child. Most children would find this difficult but for some it's a prison sentence and completely unbearable. Try seeing it from the perspective of other people.

I feel very fortunate that I was able to take my son out to homeschool him and in Ireland we have that right as parents. My son would love to be in a learning environment that suits him and surrounded by other children though. We've found things that work and he's well capable of concentrating for long periods of time in other settings. I know what works and what doesn't from experience. Children are naturally curious and want to learn and socialise. They just need the right environment where they can be free to learn in a way that suits them. They need to be supported to develop emotional and social skills, fine and gross motor skills, a love of reading and learning, learning through play.

It's actually not even just for ND kids, but for all kids. At the moment, we are raising little obedient, compliant factory workers for an age that doesn't exist anymore. The future generation will need to be able to think critically and be creative in an age where AI can do a lot of the grunt work. The whole educational system needs an overhaul, for the sake of all children, not even just the ones who are outwardly struggling and suffering.

I sort of agree with this, in that I think schools are a one-size-fits-most solution to education that by their nature are inflexible and cannot cater to everyone.

However, I think expecting schools to change much is unrealistic. There is no mass-education system that could meet the needs of all their pupils. Those of higher ability, lower ability; ones who need to fidget, and ones who need complete calm; ones who need to listen to music to regulate, and others who need silence; ones who thrive with half-days, and others who do better with longer hours etc.

What existed before our modern system was lots of homeschooling, Sunday schools, and private tutoring (with the majority of kids going straight into apprenticeships and work). Very few actually went to what we would consider school.

I think we'd have to move towards
that sort of mixed system of small-scale tutoring and homeschooling if we want real flexibility . But if parents are expecting full flexibility from schools alone then imo they'll remain disappointed.

Thatsalineallright · 12/11/2026 18:58

Scamworried · 12/11/2026 16:15

Seriously

I wasn't alone, I had a supportive spouse and wider family but it was still the worse period I have ever faced in my life. Being alone would have been worse but even with support life was awful.
2 parents (happy until school nearly destroyed our child - hard to be happy when your child is so unwell), a supportive network and limited money worries did not solve or reduce our childs school difficulties or distress

It really just meant that it effected everyone badly. My husband took on all the financial pressure, my other children have had some miserable years, I lost my career and earnings, my elderly parents have seen their beloved grandchild become a shell. My brother has taken on a lot of responsibilities.
My child trauma wasn't lessoned at all. And they carry guilt over the impact they know it had on us all.
It have been harder - doing it alone - without anyone who understands but it isn't an issue causes by single mothers

No where did I say it's an issue caused by single mothers

Dozens of posters are saying that a stressful environment at school has a negative effect on their children.

I'm saying that a stressful environment at home could then also have a negative effect. Money worries and no family support etc when parents are already dealing with children with very high needs would surely cause more stress.

This is, I think, shown clearly in the film when the mum is worried she'll lose her job and snaps at her DD.

TeawithMeerksy · 12/11/2026 19:07

Thatsalineallright · 12/11/2026 18:58

No where did I say it's an issue caused by single mothers

Dozens of posters are saying that a stressful environment at school has a negative effect on their children.

I'm saying that a stressful environment at home could then also have a negative effect. Money worries and no family support etc when parents are already dealing with children with very high needs would surely cause more stress.

This is, I think, shown clearly in the film when the mum is worried she'll lose her job and snaps at her DD.

Anyone can snap at their child regards of the stresses in their life - adult life in general is not without its worries.

what you have said, in my opinion, minimises the experience of any family dealing with EBSA etc by partly deflecting blame back in to them. I also think that any parent in these circumstances have enough to worry about without someone suggesting that the fact they are stressed is somehow rubbing off and making their child worse, thus creating a vicious circle. Without a doubt a harmonious family life benefits children but it is unfair to say that EBSA is made worse by home factors. Usually it’s because home is their safe place, and home looks different for everyone

OneandFiveOnly · 12/11/2026 19:11

DangerQuakeRhinoSnake · 12/11/2026 17:31

Oh yawn the same old arguments about smacking.

Many kids won't need it, but some kids could definitely benefit from it. In moderation of course. All the modern parenting techniques in the world won't work for some.

It's not 'convenience' for adults. It's a learning technique when kids don't yet have the capacity to understand our reasoning.

Decades of research proves you wrong

Thatsalineallright · 12/11/2026 19:12

TeawithMeerksy · 12/11/2026 19:07

Anyone can snap at their child regards of the stresses in their life - adult life in general is not without its worries.

what you have said, in my opinion, minimises the experience of any family dealing with EBSA etc by partly deflecting blame back in to them. I also think that any parent in these circumstances have enough to worry about without someone suggesting that the fact they are stressed is somehow rubbing off and making their child worse, thus creating a vicious circle. Without a doubt a harmonious family life benefits children but it is unfair to say that EBSA is made worse by home factors. Usually it’s because home is their safe place, and home looks different for everyone

Ok, so school is the only possible factor in EBSA and nothing else has the slightest hint of a positive or negative effect. No need to think of wider issues such as the loneliness epedemic or the financial pressures so many parents are under.

Scamworried · 12/11/2026 19:25

Thatsalineallright · 12/11/2026 19:12

Ok, so school is the only possible factor in EBSA and nothing else has the slightest hint of a positive or negative effect. No need to think of wider issues such as the loneliness epedemic or the financial pressures so many parents are under.

Emotional based school avoidance is the factor.

Many many people have posted their own experiences if the same child petrified of school able to attend a specialist school, or college, or groups and as adults work without ny of the issues they faced in the school causing EBSA.

Many people have commented that their other children didn't have EBSA but had the same home life and upbringing

If a child was petrified to go home would you think the issue was the park?

BruachAbhann · 12/11/2026 19:34

Thatsalineallright · 12/11/2026 18:43

I sort of agree with this, in that I think schools are a one-size-fits-most solution to education that by their nature are inflexible and cannot cater to everyone.

However, I think expecting schools to change much is unrealistic. There is no mass-education system that could meet the needs of all their pupils. Those of higher ability, lower ability; ones who need to fidget, and ones who need complete calm; ones who need to listen to music to regulate, and others who need silence; ones who thrive with half-days, and others who do better with longer hours etc.

What existed before our modern system was lots of homeschooling, Sunday schools, and private tutoring (with the majority of kids going straight into apprenticeships and work). Very few actually went to what we would consider school.

I think we'd have to move towards
that sort of mixed system of small-scale tutoring and homeschooling if we want real flexibility . But if parents are expecting full flexibility from schools alone then imo they'll remain disappointed.

I agree with you. There is not one mass education system that could suit everyone. Some children are fine with the current system but I think there needs to be options for other children who would thrive in a different environment. There shouldn't be a one size fits all approach because all children are different. Just as some adults like working in offices and some chose to do dangerous outdoor jobs, or physical jobs or trades or teaching or whatever.

The adult can decide an environment doesn't suit them and walk away though and go to where their strengths are valued and desired and where they feel fulfilled but the child can't. There aren't many other educational options for children who don't fit the norm. Everyone learns in a different way too. Some people are auditory learners, some are visual and some kinetic, where they learn through physical activity and hands-on experience.

I think it would be good if this was acknowledged and we weren't trying to force all children into the same learning system. I worked in the corporate world for about 5 years when I was younger and I remember feeling like I was serving a prison sentence so I changed when I could. That's what it's like for some kids in school except they are stuck there. And in fact it's even worse than that for them because I knew I could quit at any time but it feels like an eternal sentence for them.

Thatsalineallright · 12/11/2026 19:39

Scamworried · 12/11/2026 19:25

Emotional based school avoidance is the factor.

Many many people have posted their own experiences if the same child petrified of school able to attend a specialist school, or college, or groups and as adults work without ny of the issues they faced in the school causing EBSA.

Many people have commented that their other children didn't have EBSA but had the same home life and upbringing

If a child was petrified to go home would you think the issue was the park?

Using your analogy:

If something stressful happened at the park then I would think it more likely that the child would be stressed in general, potentially pushing them over the edge into refusing to go home.

If that child had a loving mother but no dad, no wider family, and no societal support then I also think they'd find it harder to regulate than a child with a whole network around them.

If their mother was at her wits end due to financial worries I think that would also be picked up on by the child, worsening their existing fears.

I think the mother is also much more likely to snap (in the film, leading to her child running into traffic) when carrying all of life's many burdens by herself with no help. If she didn't have any money worries, she could have remained calm even in the extremely difficult situation she's in.