Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not follow SIL’s parenting rules for my kids

1000 replies

InconsidetateSillySIL · 11/11/2026 13:44

I have three children aged 7, 5 and 2. My husband’s sister has one child, aged 2. She’s a single mum by choice.

My SIL has quite strong parenting preferences. She’s very anti-plastic toys and prefers everything to be wooden and pastel-coloured. She’s also very anti-screens and doesn’t allow sweets. That’s absolutely her choice, and I’m not criticising how she chooses to raise her child. My children, however, are fairly typical kids. We have brightly coloured plastic toys, toy swords, all sorts of things, and I don’t have a strict no-screen policy. I’m not saying they’ll be glued to an iPad all Christmas, but equally I’m not going to promise that they won’t have any screen time at all. I certainly won’t stop my children having chocolate or a mince pie on Christmas Day (especially the two eldest).

We’re all spending Christmas Day at my in-laws’ house, and SIL has messaged me saying that she appreciates we all have different parenting styles, but she’d prefer it if we didn’t bring any plastic toys, particularly around her toddler, and asked if we could have no screens for the duration of our stay to avoid a situation where her child might join in and watch something, and no sweet treats within sight of her child. I honestly don’t know how to respond. I have no intention of deliberately putting things in front of her child that she doesn’t want him playing with, I’m happy to respect her rules for the gifts to her child and I’m happy to be sensible and considerate. But I don’t think it’s reasonable to expect me to restrict what my own children can bring or play with or eat because she has decided that certain toys and activities aren’t acceptable for hers.

I feel like everyone in the family tends to bend over backwards to accommodate SIL’s preferences (because she’s had a traumatic few years in terms of love life and decided to have a baby solo), and I’m starting to resent the expectation that the rest of us should just go along with everything to avoid upsetting her. Would it be unreasonable to reply along the lines of “I completely respect that you have different rules for your child, I will of course respect your wishes for Freddie’s gifts (ie not gifting Freddie a brightly coloured plastic toy, an iPad, a chocolate Santa) but I can’t promise to follow those same rules with mine. I’ll obviously be considerate, but I need to parent my own children in the way that works for us.”

Or am I being unnecessarily difficult? It’s Christmas, and I don’t want to create family tension, but I also don’t want to spend the whole day feeling like I’m being told how to parent my children.

OP posts:
ConfusedExecutor · 11/11/2026 14:15

CoffeeAndACroissant · 11/11/2026 14:09

How old is the precious kid? I'm just curious because I'm wondering how she will cope when it's time for them to go to school. Or is she going to "home school" to avoid the absolute horror of contact with a plastic train? What about when they start getting invites to parties? "Sorry Cuthbert, you can't have any of the party food because it contains evil sugar!"

Poor child.

Anyway, I think you need to stand up to her and say it ain't happening because otherwise you'll have to do this for every get together. Plus she needs to realise her child is NOT the centre of the universe.

How old is the precious kid?

It is literally in the OP's second sentence...

"My husband’s sister has one child, aged 2."

JoshLymanSwagger · 11/11/2026 14:16

@InconsidetateSillySIL After that last update, I think you need to tell your DH that this is the last Family Christmas he will have with his Batshit Sis and Mum if they try to stop your kids having some fun, e.g. chocolate, screens and Lego.

He needs to give them an opportunity to be rational NORMAL or offer to stay at home.

It really is not too late to back out if these are going to be the rules that MIL insists on too.

SJM1988 · 11/11/2026 14:16

How long are you expecting to spend at your in-laws? All day? Are presents being opened there etc?

For a short amount of the day, I'd say maybe just maybe you could try and follow it but you can't promise.

If its all day, no way. I'd tell her sorry that won't work for you. If it becomes an issue with your SIL/MIL, then I'd seriously consider the kids and yourself not attending. Why should her wants for her child trump your wants for your children. She's honestly going to have bigger issues to deal with going forward with her parenting so might as well learn now she can't dictate that on other people.

wildnwilde · 11/11/2026 14:17

Basically she wants you to make it easy for her to parent her child . So you have to toe the line so she doesn't have to be the bad guy and say no to her own .tell her to do one .

InconsidetateSillySIL · 11/11/2026 14:17

AnneLovesGilbert · 11/11/2026 14:09

If you push back, which you absolutely should, will your PIL back you up or will they side with her and make things awkward for you and crap for your children?

It’s a funny one because they’ll back her, tut, sigh etc on the day if I am “not considerate enough”, particularly if it upsets SIL. Equally if I was to say that the rules are “not considerate enough” towards me and therefore we (along with my 3 children ie 75% of her grandchildren) won’t be attending, MIL would call DH in tears saying she feels so neglected, unimportant and sad that we’re missing it over something so small as following SIL’s rules.

OP posts:
Bearbookagainandagain · 11/11/2026 14:18

She's completely wrong to make those requests! The wooden toys thing is funny to me, because we had the same rules when our eldest was 2 😂😂... Oh dear, times have changed!

That said, some of it is easy to accommodate. It's only 1 day and it's Christmas, I don't see why your kids would need to bring any toys with them, they'll get plenty on the day!

I would respond that you cannot make choices about your kids presents based on her parenting choices, and therefore there will probably be some plastic toys amongst your kids presents.

Screens: is that really necessary on Christmas day? Up to you though.

Food related stuff: hell no! It's Christmas, your kids should be able to eat according to your rules. A 2 yo will barely care anyway. If they don't know what sweets are, they have no reason to ask for it.

PrettyPickle · 11/11/2026 14:18

This is one of those Mumsnet threads where I can see why people end up split almost 50/50. My instinct is that the OP is not unreasonable, but neither is the SIL completely unreasonable. The problem is that she's trying to control an environment that isn't her home and involves three older children who are well beyond toddlerhood.

The accommodation I think most families would naturally make is don't deliberately wave chocolate in front of the toddler, don't give the toddler sweets without permission, don't buy the toddler noisy plastic toys if the parents dislike them. Maybe encourage the older children to play particularly boisterous games elsewhere if it's upsetting the toddler. Those are fairly normal courtesies.

Where it starts to become difficult is expecting: no plastic toys at all, no screens at all, no sweets visible at all, throughout Christmas Day in a house full of other people's children. The elephant in the room is the ages. A two-year-old can largely be managed by their parent. A seven-year-old and five-year-old are old enough to notice when they're being asked to alter their Christmas because of someone else's rules.

And lets face it, in the real world this is an issue your SIL and her child will have to deal with every day: brightly coloured plastic toys, Paw Patrol and Peppa Pig,
biscuits and sweets, children with tablets on trains, birthday parties loaded with sugar. The lesson most parents eventually have to teach is not "these things don't exist" but "our family has different rules".

What struck me is that SIL's request seems to go beyond wanting her own boundaries respected. Respecting her boundaries would be: "Please don't offer Freddie sweets or screens." What she's actually asking is: "Please don't let your children have sweets or screens in Freddie's presence." That's a much bigger ask. I would probably reply

"Of course we'll respect your choices for Freddie and won't give him sweets or screens. We'll also be considerate about our own children. However, I can't promise that my children won't have Christmas treats or be allowed to use screens at all during the day because they are older and are already much further developed in their play style and activities given their ages, unlike a toddler and they are likely to be extremely upset if I deprive them of their normality and this could spoil it for everyone so I think there has to be some flexibility and accommodations on both sides. I will attempt to minimise issues and will not offer Freddie sweets, screens and plastic toys as I want us all to have the best Christmas possible."

That feels like a reasonable middle ground. The one thing I'd be wary of is the OP's comment about the family always accommodating SIL because she's a single mother by choice. That may well be true, but it also sounds as though there may be some existing resentment bubbling underneath this specific disagreement. Quite often on Mumsnet, the thread isn't really about the chocolate or the iPad. It's about years of feeling that one family member's preferences dominate everyone else's.

And, practically speaking, I suspect the two-year-old is going to be far more interested in what the seven-year-old cousins are doing than in whether a toy is made of natural wood and painted sage green. That's probably the parenting challenge SIL is really trying to solve.

wildnwilde · 11/11/2026 14:19

She can't dictate other children's Xmas . The world does not revolve around her and her toddler. If she wants things a certain way for her children that's up to her to enforce and deal with . She can't change how other ppl live . What's she going to do in a soft play or cafe .

PullingOutHair123 · 11/11/2026 14:19

Are you opening all your gifts at SIL's house?

If so, bonus points if you get your eldest an Xbox for Christmas (that has to be set up on SIL's TV immediately), your middle child a shit ton of lego to spread about, and your youngest a new big plastic toy kitchen with all the gadgets...

Or just suggest as expectations vary wildly, maybe you should rethink the day and maybe just pop over for an hour or two to exchange gifts and leave!

HiCandles · 11/11/2026 14:19

I'd offer what appears to be a compromise.
Hi SIL, thanks for messaging. I do understand where you're coming from and I certainly won't be encouraging DN to have the things you don't want him to. Quite happy to choose presents etc you'll both be happy with. I'm sure you can also understand that's it my children's Christmas too, and they will obviously want to do things they enjoy. Especially with the older ones, I don't really feel it's fair for them to be made not to have the usual Christmas treats and TV - we don't allow unlimited screen time anyway and will make sure any programmes are suitable for both 2yo. I'm also not planning myself on having absolutely no chocolate and mince pies- can only imagine the injustice the kids will feel if I refuse them treats but not the adults! That said, we'll be really careful to keep things out of reach of DN. I'm sure the kids will all love playing together and we're all looking forward to seeing you both.

user1471538275 · 11/11/2026 14:19

If your husband is as passive as you say I would not be going.

This will be a miserable Christmas and he's happy for you and your children to be made miserable so that he doesn't have to deal with his demanding and spoilt mother/sister.

muggart · 11/11/2026 14:19

Beenaroundabit · 11/11/2026 14:11

She's making a choice for her DC, and part of that choice is dealing with how other people choose to parent their own kids. Of course her DC is going to come into contact with other kids who eat sweets and have screen time - she's the one bucking the norm so she has to deal with the fall-out.

She's also chosen to solo parent. Which means things are going to be tough - ALL the responsibility is on her. But again, that on her and not you to limit your kid's experiences just because she can't afford stuff/hasn't got the capacity. And don't get me started on the fact her dcs dad isn't around - is she going to suggest your DH makes himself scarce so her DC doesn't start asking about their own dad??

Why should your kids go without to save her kid having a strop he's not allowed stuff?

Edited

I think a lot of these sorts of comments must be coming from older parents.

it is COMPLETELY normal for a 2 year old to be screen free and sweet-free in 2026.

obviously it’s not always going to happen if there are older siblings because that makes it harder. But is it incorrect to make it sound like her parenting values are out of sync with society.

JoshLymanSwagger · 11/11/2026 14:20

InconsidetateSillySIL · 11/11/2026 14:17

It’s a funny one because they’ll back her, tut, sigh etc on the day if I am “not considerate enough”, particularly if it upsets SIL. Equally if I was to say that the rules are “not considerate enough” towards me and therefore we (along with my 3 children ie 75% of her grandchildren) won’t be attending, MIL would call DH in tears saying she feels so neglected, unimportant and sad that we’re missing it over something so small as following SIL’s rules.

Depends who you want in tears on Christmas day...

Your kids

or MIL and SIL.

Easy choice for me - not so easy for you. Gin

InconsidetateSillySIL · 11/11/2026 14:20

@SJM1988we arrive in the morning on 24th and stay until afternoon 26th, so one full day and two half days. Presents will be opened there. Obviously I’ll get my nephew some wooden cars or maybe a wooden puzzle, something that’s entirely within her rules, but I’ll be getting my children presents from their list, and if that list contains some of the “forbidden items” then I’d rather make my kids happy than prevent SIL being upset

OP posts:
Notonthestairs · 11/11/2026 14:20

I’d give her a gentle brush off.
You have children at different stages.
The rules she applies to her 2 year old can’t sensibly be applied to your family.
But you are looking forward to catching up.
Then tune out.

Nothing you’ve mentioned about your parenting is particularly outrageous. If they want you there then accommodating a bit of Stick Man and some malteasers shouldn’t be too much.

Thr33lions · 11/11/2026 14:21

You’re not unreasonable and it’s frankly barmy that she thinks she can make up a random set of rules and expect everyone else to abide by them.

She needs to teach her kids that other people do other things rather the expecting everyone to pander to them to avoid upset otherwise they’ll be in for a big shock as they get older.

CharliePingPong · 11/11/2026 14:22

InconsidetateSillySIL · 11/11/2026 13:49

Sadly I can’t not go - we’ve signed up to do Xmas at my in laws this year as we alternate yearly

You might have agreed to do Christmas at the in-laws this year but that was before you were made aware of the ridiculous demands and rules it entails.

Stay at home and have a nice time. If your MIL and SIL start crying then that's their problem.

IronEverything · 11/11/2026 14:22

You're all nicer than me because I'd be sliding the poor cherub after eights on the sly.

saraclara · 11/11/2026 14:22

""Dear SIL, I appreciate and respect your parenting, but we parent differently, and I'm afraid I'm not going to introduce strict new rules to my children at Christmas, of all times. They will want to play with their presents (some of which, like the Lego, will be plastic) and we would normally enjoy some chill time watching something like The Snowman. We will encourage them to eat any sweets in their stockings away from little PFB, but I'm afraid that's the only concession we're prepared to make."

TheSnappyBluePoster · 11/11/2026 14:22

I don’t think it’s reasonable to expect me to restrict what my own children can bring or play with or eat because she has decided that certain toys and activities aren’t acceptable for hers.

You text her exactly that.

HiCandles · 11/11/2026 14:22

wildnwilde · 11/11/2026 14:17

Basically she wants you to make it easy for her to parent her child . So you have to toe the line so she doesn't have to be the bad guy and say no to her own .tell her to do one .

This exactly. Sounds like SIL needs to start learning that parenting frequently means saying no and being the bad guy, if you know it's best for your child. Which is why almost everyone ends up realising they'd better pick their battles and a few plastic toys and some chocolate coins on Christmas Day are not worth fighting over!

nomas · 11/11/2026 14:22

chirrupybird · 11/11/2026 13:49

It's a bit unreasonable that your children can't have any sweet treats on Christmas day, perhaps you can help them select toys that don't bend the rules too much and no screens should be OK for a day.

perhaps you can help them select toys that don't bend the rules too much

A bit unreasonable?

I wouldn't even deign to acknowledge these rules let alone avoid bending them.

DH should speak to MIL and say we're not playing by SIL's rules. If MIL kicks up a fuss, he should say we're having Christmas at home.

Does SIL really think her child won't come across other children having a treat / plastic toy?

GingerKombucha · 11/11/2026 14:23

We generally avoid screens (none Monday to Friday, a movie at the weekend) and sweets but we definitely allow them at Christmas and if others want to give them sweets or plastic toys (the grandparents often) we allow that as it's a small portion of the time. It seems insane to insist on others following her rules. Could you gently say that you see Christmas as similar for children as adults where more sugar than usual and some time vegging in front of the TV are integral to it in a way the rest of the year isn't?

JoshLymanSwagger · 11/11/2026 14:23

IronEverything · 11/11/2026 14:22

You're all nicer than me because I'd be sliding the poor cherub after eights on the sly.

That's devious! 🤣

ChilliFire · 11/11/2026 14:24

muggart · 11/11/2026 13:50

can’t you just give the chocolate and screens after her child has gone to bed?

i know this won’t be popular but I actually think it’s really hypocritical to say it’s unfair for you to have to follow her parenting knowing that if you put on a screen in front of her child then by default she will end up succumbing to your parenting. same with plastic toys and sweets. how is she reasonably going to keep her child away from that stuff too?

the best compromise is to keep it out of sight.

It’s not hypocritical at all. OP parents her children how she wants, the SIL parents her child how she wants. The OP isn’t imposing anything on the SIL, and if the SIL doesn’t like the idea of certain things around her dc at Christmas then she needs to find a way to entertain her dc so that her dc is otherwise occupied, rather than sucking all fun out of the day for 3 other children.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.
Swipe left for the next trending thread