Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not follow SIL’s parenting rules for my kids

1000 replies

InconsidetateSillySIL · 11/11/2026 13:44

I have three children aged 7, 5 and 2. My husband’s sister has one child, aged 2. She’s a single mum by choice.

My SIL has quite strong parenting preferences. She’s very anti-plastic toys and prefers everything to be wooden and pastel-coloured. She’s also very anti-screens and doesn’t allow sweets. That’s absolutely her choice, and I’m not criticising how she chooses to raise her child. My children, however, are fairly typical kids. We have brightly coloured plastic toys, toy swords, all sorts of things, and I don’t have a strict no-screen policy. I’m not saying they’ll be glued to an iPad all Christmas, but equally I’m not going to promise that they won’t have any screen time at all. I certainly won’t stop my children having chocolate or a mince pie on Christmas Day (especially the two eldest).

We’re all spending Christmas Day at my in-laws’ house, and SIL has messaged me saying that she appreciates we all have different parenting styles, but she’d prefer it if we didn’t bring any plastic toys, particularly around her toddler, and asked if we could have no screens for the duration of our stay to avoid a situation where her child might join in and watch something, and no sweet treats within sight of her child. I honestly don’t know how to respond. I have no intention of deliberately putting things in front of her child that she doesn’t want him playing with, I’m happy to respect her rules for the gifts to her child and I’m happy to be sensible and considerate. But I don’t think it’s reasonable to expect me to restrict what my own children can bring or play with or eat because she has decided that certain toys and activities aren’t acceptable for hers.

I feel like everyone in the family tends to bend over backwards to accommodate SIL’s preferences (because she’s had a traumatic few years in terms of love life and decided to have a baby solo), and I’m starting to resent the expectation that the rest of us should just go along with everything to avoid upsetting her. Would it be unreasonable to reply along the lines of “I completely respect that you have different rules for your child, I will of course respect your wishes for Freddie’s gifts (ie not gifting Freddie a brightly coloured plastic toy, an iPad, a chocolate Santa) but I can’t promise to follow those same rules with mine. I’ll obviously be considerate, but I need to parent my own children in the way that works for us.”

Or am I being unnecessarily difficult? It’s Christmas, and I don’t want to create family tension, but I also don’t want to spend the whole day feeling like I’m being told how to parent my children.

OP posts:
ItsCloudyToday · 12/11/2026 09:02

Nope. I wouldn’t be going at all. Not a chance that I’d be restricting my young children’s Christmas like that. They are moaning and kicking off anyway, so let them do it because you’re not attending, rather than because of all this stupidity. Much of a muchness.

MrsBennetsPoorNervesAreBack · 12/11/2026 09:04

Contact your MIL to explain that DSIL is making requests that you cannot comply with. Christmas is important to and you want your kids to have a happy, relaxed and joyful celebration. You are of course happy to be respectful of SIL's preferences for her own child, but you have a different approach to parenting and you aren't prepared to force them to abide by someone else's rather arbitrary rules. If this is going to cause friction, then you're happy to compromise and have Christmas at home so that everyone can do what's right for them, but you are not willing to go along with SIL's demands.

Thatsalineallright · 12/11/2026 09:04

HelpMyBlackLabradorVotesReform · 12/11/2026 08:28

Could you possibly have two different play areas at christmas? One that the puritans can use with wooden toys and grapes cut in 4 and one room for the normals with fun toys and sweets. Then SIL can stay in her safe space and everyone else can move around.

What's wrong with cutting up grapes?? They're a very real choking risk for a 2 yo.

2mumlife · 12/11/2026 09:08

Similar, but far less extreme example from our famly. My sister's 5 yr old has had a tablet since he was 2, gets dilute juice for breakfast and whatever he wants to eat. I have a 4 and 2yr old. We do very limited screen time, stick to water as much as possible, limit sweets etc.

I've never once asked or expected by sister not to bring her sons tablet or stop him watching it at grandparents house for christmas etc. You do you and all that.

And actually - we've had ZERO issues. My 4yr old has never been that interested in his tablet - she'll occasionally look for a moment, decide its boring, and go chat with granny in the kitchen. I actually think its been quite good for her to realise these things aren't interesting. She's grown up understanding that different families have different rules and thats ok. We generally relax some of our rules around family, because we are reasonable humans.

My sister makes me feel looked down on for my choices, despite the fact we never ask her to change hers despite it making some harder work for us. But your sister needs to learn to feel confident in maintaining the parenting boundaries she wants around others, and how to handle explaining to her own child that her family unit does things differently without imposing those rules on you.

sittingonabeach · 12/11/2026 09:09

NapsForTheWin · 12/11/2026 07:04

It's a bit more social if they do it on a shared TV. Or is that not done anymore? Or does SIL not want that screen either?

It's one day. The problem seems to be that DH has grown up to normalise placating his mother and SIL and doing whatever it takes to not upset them. To protect his own comfort. I had one of those too (he learned, sort of).

It’s 3 days

BunfightBetty · 12/11/2026 09:09

InconsidetateSillySIL · 11/11/2026 23:45

Thanks everyone! I really wasn’t expecting so many replies, and I’m grateful for all the advice and suggestions. Just to answer a few questions:

Christmas is at my PILs’ house, not SIL’s, although they live within walking distance. We’ll be staying overnight at PILs, so technically we could have chocolates or watch a Christmas film when Freddie isn’t around. But there are two issues with that. Firstly, we don’t know when he’ll leave, as he has a bedroom at PILs and could easily end up napping or sleeping overnight there. Secondly, I really don’t want to create a whole thing around perfectly normal Christmas activities or food for my children. Why should they have to hide their toys, or secretly scoff their chocolate before Freddie arrives? Why can’t they simply enjoy their Christmas while he’s there?

Not going isn’t really an option. That would mean tears from MIL, accusations that we’re depriving everyone of Christmas and, ultimately, DH having to deal with the fallout.

I’ve decided not to respond to SIL any further, at least for now, as several of you suggested. I think my position is clear and there’s not much more to say.
I did show the entire exchange to DH and explained that I’m genuinely concerned about how much we’re upsetting SIL by having different approaches to parenting. As his family often remind us, we need to look out for her and make sure she isn’t upset.
But, equally, I’m concerned about my own children. What if they’re upset because they can’t have the presents they’ve been looking forward to, or can’t play with their “forbidden” new toys? What if they want a Christmas treat, or to watch a festive film when they’re tired and can’t?
I said that perhaps the only way to avoid upsetting anyone is for us to simply not go. Although I’m not sure whether that would cause upset too!
I said all of this quite matter of factly, but DH wasn’t impressed. He accused me of being sarcastic, deliberately making things difficult and dramatising the situation. I asked him what exactly I was dramatising. People get upset, don’t they?

I’m honestly struggling to understand why SIL’s feelings seem to require so much consideration, while the impact on our own children is barely being discussed. Maybe I’ll just take a leaf out of SIL’s book and get upset when something doesn’t go my (or my kids’) way but trouble is DH knows me and knows I’m not a psycho.

I’m honestly struggling to understand why SIL’s feelings seem to require so much consideration, while the impact on our own children is barely being discussed.

Well, this is the question to ask him. Also, to ask him how he thinks your kids will feel if Santa doesn’t bring them the toys they want and they have to spend all day with no TV or sweet treats. Then ask him why SIL’s feelings trump theirs? And why children should be expected to demonstrate more capacity to regulate than a grown adult.

I expect he’ll get defensive, though. Sounds like this is deeply ingrained and he won’t want to examine it or run the gauntlet of calling it out with SIL and MIL. Currently it’s easier for him to pander to them and upset you and the kids. You’ll likely have to change that if you want him to change his approach. I’d not be letting it lie, personally, and I’d be prepared to go nuclear if necessary.

Thisismetooaswell · 12/11/2026 09:10

I really want to know whether 'no screens' means ipads, phones etc, or includes tv

JustaSongAboutPingPong · 12/11/2026 09:14

KarmenPQZ · 11/11/2026 14:01

Is SIL policing the no screens and sweet treats for everyone? Ie adults also aren’t allowed phones and pudding? If not then the answers no

That was exactly what I was thinking. Anyone who tells me I can’t have a mince pie when I want to on Christmas Day would get short shrift

ThreadGuardDog · 12/11/2026 09:17

Why is she such a killjoy ?

Thatsalineallright · 12/11/2026 09:17

NapsForTheWin · 12/11/2026 07:16

If MIL is pandering to SIL's wishes, there probably won't be dessert and cake served! Maybe a fruit platter instead.

Well that's slightly different, isn't it? It's up to PIL what they want to serve in their own home.

What would be unreasonable is trying to ban guests from bringing any chocolate/sweets with them (PIL). And extra unreasonable to try to ban guests from bringing chocolate to someone else's home (SIL).

But I do think OP is being a bit stubborn about the whole thing. She could show willing by making a few small changes e.g. her children won't use screens around the 2yo, they'll watch their cartoons when the toddler is napping, they won't give their younger cousin any sweets.

the7Vabo · 12/11/2026 09:19

Lacksie · 12/11/2026 08:48

Ok sure. Instead of being recognising she might be struggling and why that might be, just assume she is "highly emotionally manipulative" and "bratty". Demand understanding for oneself despite not being the one in emotional pain and provoke a confrontation. I'm sure that a lovely Christmas will ensue , everyone will feel better and family harmony will be strengthened!

“Provoke” a confrontation - so SIL really isn’t going to be held responsible for her actions is she?

The Op has very politely set out what her approach will be. If SIL makes an issue of that on the day that’s on her.

And yes an adult crying when they don’t get their own way is emotional manipulation.

SIL has support. She lives down the road from her parents and her son has his own bedroom is their house. Who says she’s “in pain” and the OP isn’t. We all have stuff going on in our lives.

DonorConceivedMe · 12/11/2026 09:20

sittingonabeach · 12/11/2026 01:12

Who the hell has a six month birthday.

She made the choice to have only one side of a family for her DC. I hope she is going to enable them to find out who their genetic dad is. I pity the child growing up with such an entitled mum and no other parent to dissipate that.

Stick to your guns OP, and hopefully you can bring some normality into that child’s life.

Agree 100%. SIL can avoid plastic and sugar all she likes but she’s done far worse to her child by deliberately depriving him of a father. And she’s made life much harder for herself by depriving herself of all the support that a partner would bring, and someone (potentially) to bounce ideas off.

OP as (almost) everyone else has said, YANBU. And I’m speaking as someone who favoured wooden toys, and avoided sugar and screens.

cantthinkofagoodusername2026 · 12/11/2026 09:20

I am a no-screens parent and minimise junk food, but to a point! We don't tend to keep junk in the house but DCs are allowed it when we're at parties, on holiday, visiting people etc. I would have some empathy for SIL if her DC had some allergies that prevented him eating a mince pie or similar, but seeing as it seems to be just her preference, I think it's a bit much.
I think your message to her was very well composed FWIW. Fingers crossed for a peaceful and conflict-free Christmas!

wildnwilde · 12/11/2026 09:21

The way freddi is being raised is actually unhealthy and restricted and will lead to him being secretibe and feeling guilty for wanting normal child experiences. He's going to come across children (normal) ones like yours throughout his life and find his childhood extremely structured. This isn't me saying his mum is wrong but she does need to teach him that their is a time and place for everything and she also needs to teach him that every family is different . Your sil needs to unclench or she will have a very long 18 years .

Schoolrunning · 12/11/2026 09:21

I think this is the crux of the issue, you have a husband problem. You are the default parent, your and your childrens feelings are of low priority to your husband. You need to stop backing down to your husband. Everyone can see how this will play out in your current set up, SIL will have a tantrum on Christmas Day and your husband will refuse the DC chocolate, screens and remove the plastic toys. You will be ganged up on and 'the problem'. You need to decide if you are going to put your foot down or allow you and your DC to be low priority going forward. Unless my DH was willing to back me up I wouldn't put my children through this.

CraftySeal · 12/11/2026 09:22

If as a child I was told no Christmas TV (what about The Snowman?!) and no chocolate or sweet things on Xmas day, I'd have been pretty damn disappointed. Also does she want no TV and sweet things for all the adults, or just the children?

I don't understand how your SIL being a single parent and you all being her/Freddie's only family has anything to do with it. It just reeks of an attempt at emotional blackmail and manipulation. I think you're taking the right stance.

wildnwilde · 12/11/2026 09:24

You're DH needs to advocate for his own children here . Your parents son law have a choice they either tell sil all are welcome and entitled to parent how they please or they accept that you won't be manipulated and accept your decision to spend Xmas at a place where you will enjoy yourselves without guilt or hissy fits .

godmum56 · 12/11/2026 09:24

BatsInHibernation · 12/11/2026 08:11

I would reply and say 'we will compromise as much as possible. My older two will want to bring some of their Christmas toys with them and I can't promise there will be no plastic. We won't bring screens. Not sure about sugar to be honest, my older two will definitely have dessert and some sweet treats but it won't be a chocolate fest'.

why?

wildnwilde · 12/11/2026 09:26

Thatsalineallright · 12/11/2026 07:14

This is a bit disingenuous.

If your 5 yo wants to watch a Christmas cartoon you can say something along the lines of "when we're in this house we don't watch cartoons" or "we didn't pack the iPad". You obviously don't have to name aunty Lucie.

Also, while I think your sil sounds unreasonable re treats etc, I think no screens around her 2 yo is fair enough. Screens aren't an inherent part of Christmas, your kids can do without their iPad for a day.

But definitely give them dessert and cake or whatever else. It's Christmas!

Thats up to sil to enforce tho . She can't go to soft play and demand every parent leaves their inpad at home . It sounds like she wants everyone else to dance to her tune so she doesn't have to enforce her own rules and deal with a tantrum .

CherryVanillaPie · 12/11/2026 09:27

InconsidetateSillySIL · 11/11/2026 15:01

She’s replied…

I just don’t understand why his cousins can’t make a few small adjustments for Freddie, especially when they’re older and should understand. He’s my only child and you guys plus our parents are the only family he has. I just want him to feel included and not like he has to be around things that I’m trying so hard to avoid for him. I don’t think it’s unreasonable to expect a bit of support from family, especially when I’m doing this on my own. I want him to grow up healthy and happy. It honestly makes me quite sad x

Here come the waterworks!

ChilliFire · 12/11/2026 09:27

notacooldad · 12/11/2026 08:31

To be fair, I don't think some of her rules are bad.

We wouldn't get our children swords, certainly not to take to someone's house over Christmas. Not only because of what they represent but because of the noise and intrusiveness of kids play fighting. I think its rather rude to take things that can cause loud , noisy play in some one else's house, especially at a gathering.

I also agree with her with screen time. The children will have other presents to play with. I would use it as an excuse to have a break from screens for a bit.

The no sweet treats is unreasonable though.

Im not saying you should bow down to her but reflect on you and your children's behaviours in someone else's home and a family visit.

Edited

Oh my god. The toy sword was an example. So many posters wittering on about toy swords when it could be any plastic toy- the point the OP was making was that children get attached to certain toys and, particularly when they’re younger, they want that toy all the time, whether that be a plastic sword, dinosaur, car, doll etc. If children are getting toys made of plastic for Christmas is it really fair to ban them from playing with their presents for 1.5 days? No it’s not.

Screen time doesn’t always include small screens, it also includes the tv. When young children get over excited and over whelmed on Christmas Day then it’s always easy to pop a short movie on to help them decompress and calm down. There is nothing wrong with that. Also, you say they don’t need a screen because they can play with their presents…except they can’t play with their presents because they’re all plastic!

OP doesn’t need you patronising her and implying her and her children don’t know how to behave in someone else’s home when there is nothing she has said or done to suggest otherwise.

Cakeandcoffee445332 · 12/11/2026 09:28

He's choosing the easy way out. You have to make his life harder, not easier. You should absolutely get upset and make it clear you are the one he needs to back first. He's placating MIL and SIL because it's easier. Give him hell. YOU matter too. You need to put yourself first.

anterenea · 12/11/2026 09:30

TeensNoMore · 12/11/2026 06:18

Compromise.
Screens in a chill out room that Freddie doesn't have access to.
Plastic toys for 1 day won't harm Freddie if he sees them.
No toy swords whilst at PIL, they are a safety risk anyway with over excited children and toddlers.
Sweets, SIL has to say no to Freddie, but equally maybe make sure tins etc are out of his reach.

This

FancyKitten · 12/11/2026 09:31

At Christmas? No. Not fair to your kids.

sittingonabeach · 12/11/2026 09:34

When people talk about not letting their DC have screens, does that mean TV as well?

Surely everything in moderation is key.

I probably wouldn’t take a toy sword with me due to possibility of something getting broken during a game, I wouldn’t just plonk a DC in front of a screen but I wouldn’t forbid screens (of any form) for 3 days. There are usually some great shows on tv for little DC over Christmas, things that can be watched by the whole family, what’s wrong with that. A little downtime with a screen whilst adults chat, again not horrendous.

If SIL’s rules are followed every Christmas, at what point will OP’s eldest be able to break free from them

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.