Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not follow SIL’s parenting rules for my kids

1000 replies

InconsidetateSillySIL · 11/11/2026 13:44

I have three children aged 7, 5 and 2. My husband’s sister has one child, aged 2. She’s a single mum by choice.

My SIL has quite strong parenting preferences. She’s very anti-plastic toys and prefers everything to be wooden and pastel-coloured. She’s also very anti-screens and doesn’t allow sweets. That’s absolutely her choice, and I’m not criticising how she chooses to raise her child. My children, however, are fairly typical kids. We have brightly coloured plastic toys, toy swords, all sorts of things, and I don’t have a strict no-screen policy. I’m not saying they’ll be glued to an iPad all Christmas, but equally I’m not going to promise that they won’t have any screen time at all. I certainly won’t stop my children having chocolate or a mince pie on Christmas Day (especially the two eldest).

We’re all spending Christmas Day at my in-laws’ house, and SIL has messaged me saying that she appreciates we all have different parenting styles, but she’d prefer it if we didn’t bring any plastic toys, particularly around her toddler, and asked if we could have no screens for the duration of our stay to avoid a situation where her child might join in and watch something, and no sweet treats within sight of her child. I honestly don’t know how to respond. I have no intention of deliberately putting things in front of her child that she doesn’t want him playing with, I’m happy to respect her rules for the gifts to her child and I’m happy to be sensible and considerate. But I don’t think it’s reasonable to expect me to restrict what my own children can bring or play with or eat because she has decided that certain toys and activities aren’t acceptable for hers.

I feel like everyone in the family tends to bend over backwards to accommodate SIL’s preferences (because she’s had a traumatic few years in terms of love life and decided to have a baby solo), and I’m starting to resent the expectation that the rest of us should just go along with everything to avoid upsetting her. Would it be unreasonable to reply along the lines of “I completely respect that you have different rules for your child, I will of course respect your wishes for Freddie’s gifts (ie not gifting Freddie a brightly coloured plastic toy, an iPad, a chocolate Santa) but I can’t promise to follow those same rules with mine. I’ll obviously be considerate, but I need to parent my own children in the way that works for us.”

Or am I being unnecessarily difficult? It’s Christmas, and I don’t want to create family tension, but I also don’t want to spend the whole day feeling like I’m being told how to parent my children.

OP posts:
JoshLymanSwagger · 11/11/2026 14:04

@InconsidetateSillySIL What exactly will she let your kids play with?
A stick?
You 7yo and 5yo will have a really shit Christmas if Aunty Batshit is allowed to rule the roost.

problembottom · 11/11/2026 14:05

Savvysix1984 · 11/11/2026 13:58

Let your dh deal with it. It’s his sister, he knows her better and will be more able to chat about it. If he decides to agree with her then you let him organise the toys/ snacks/ activities to keep the kids fed and entertained. If he doesn’t agree with her then he gets to deal with the possible fall out.

This is it for me. I'd forward the message onto your other half, it's for him to sort out. Why has she messaged you and not him?

InterestedDad37 · 11/11/2026 14:05

YANBU - she can parent her child how she likes, but she can't hide the world from it!
And while you seem to be the default parent of your two, I would definitely hand this one over to your husband to answer.

Savenny · 11/11/2026 14:06

I’m fascinated as to what would happen if her child came across some brightly coloured plastic…

user47639820987 · 11/11/2026 14:06

Honestly OP, with kids your ages most people stay home as its all about Santa and the kids enjoying their new toys - Perfect chance to realign things and stay home!

Meand2Ls · 11/11/2026 14:06

I have strong parenting preferences with all those things but I’ve always been of the attitude that I can only control how things are in my own house. Your SIL will go crazy trying to control every environment her child walks into. I would never put my children in an environment they would get made to feel uncomfortable about their day to day life. You either have to step up and less nicely explain to your SIL to leave your children alone or you don’t go. It doesn’t matter if you committed to going, it’s an invitation not a summons, make sure it works for you

muggart · 11/11/2026 14:07

MintTwirl · 11/11/2026 14:02

But you could flip it and say that SIL could just say no to her child. Plastic toys, chocolate and a bit of TV are all normal at Christmas, if she is choosing to go against the norm then she needs to deal with the consequences of her choices. I suspect she knows her dc will want a chocolate coin or be interested in a cartoon if it’s on and she doesn’t want to deal with it but that’s on her.

that’s not flipping it. that’s saying all the compromise should be done by sil and none by the op. my point allows for compromise on both sides- which is what compromise is.

sil is equally welcome at the xmas lunch so yes she can just have to sit it out and excuse herself for parts if it but personally i don’t think that’s a better solution than doing sweets and screens when the 2 year old is napping or asleep or otherwise occupied.

Ponderingwindow · 11/11/2026 14:08

I would not be denying children some sweets on Christmas. Especially when they are surrounded by adults indulging in their own variety of Christmas delicacies.

My child does understand being on best behavior at family events. We are an autistic family and know we all have to mask like crazy to be polite. I wouldn’t agree to take away everything she enjoys though. She would get some downtime with a screen. She would get to choose some toys that travel easily and that she won’t get upset if she has to share.

We would plan on how to get through the day and that would involve consideration of other people, but also of ourselves.

TheStepboardisfullofbitteroddos · 11/11/2026 14:08

I think your message is too apologetic.

Just say you understand she has her rules for her child and you have your own for yours.

I had similar ideas to her with my first but xmas for 3 kids, 2 in school is very different to one toddler. Let your children enjoy xmas, play with whatever toys they want. She can go in a different room or for a walk if she's very offended.

missymousey · 11/11/2026 14:08

Lol at no plastic toys and no sweets on Christmas day. Sorry that doesn't work for us.

user1471538275 · 11/11/2026 14:08

@Savenny Having met these children it's nothing compared to when they come across sweet treats (usually at a party)

You would never be able to prise a chocolate Santa from their little sticky hands.

Ladybird111 · 11/11/2026 14:08

“Hey, we won’t be changing our rules around those things for the kids over Christmas but will try to be as considerate as possible when little Jimmy is around. Looking forward to spending Christmas together”

AnneLovesGilbert · 11/11/2026 14:09

If you push back, which you absolutely should, will your PIL back you up or will they side with her and make things awkward for you and crap for your children?

AnneLovesGilbert · 11/11/2026 14:09

Ladybird111 · 11/11/2026 14:08

“Hey, we won’t be changing our rules around those things for the kids over Christmas but will try to be as considerate as possible when little Jimmy is around. Looking forward to spending Christmas together”

This is very good.

BiggerIsAlwaysBetter · 11/11/2026 14:09

You're only going for a day though, aren't you?

I wouldn't be packing a screen for a one day visit and so the only screen is a grandparent telly, which you let them answer if they ask about watching something.

And tbh i think you're making it more of a principled point than actually worried your kids will only want one certain plastic toy brought with them.

Surely there will be gifts there? And its just one day?

CoffeeAndACroissant · 11/11/2026 14:09

How old is the precious kid? I'm just curious because I'm wondering how she will cope when it's time for them to go to school. Or is she going to "home school" to avoid the absolute horror of contact with a plastic train? What about when they start getting invites to parties? "Sorry Cuthbert, you can't have any of the party food because it contains evil sugar!"

Poor child.

Anyway, I think you need to stand up to her and say it ain't happening because otherwise you'll have to do this for every get together. Plus she needs to realise her child is NOT the centre of the universe.

InconsidetateSillySIL · 11/11/2026 14:10

Ohcrap082024 · 11/11/2026 13:51

Pass this on to your DH. It’s his sister, let him deal with her nonsense.

Unless, is DH likely to agree with her to keep the peace?

It’s a genuinely bizarre family dynamic, but I’ll try to explain it.
SIL and MIL are very similar in that, if something doesn’t go their way, they burst into tears and expect everyone else to fix it.
SIL had a difficult time with relationships and eventually decided to become a solo mum using a sperm donor. I actually think that’s brave and admirable. However, since then, there’s been an expectation that family and friends should make allowances for her circumstances because she doesn’t have a partner and has supposedly had a harder deal than the rest of us.
If something upsets her, MIL gets involved and makes it everyone’s problem. For example, SIL was upset that nobody was coming to celebrate her baby’s six-month birthday, so invited us over at the last minute. We already had plans and declined. Another time, I mentioned a Disney trip for our children, which SIL can’t afford, and that also caused upset. On both occasions, MIL took my husband to task, called him repeatedly and made a huge drama out of SIL being upset.
My husband therefore tends to take the path of least resistance. He’d probably rather get the children to eat chocolate in secret or leave their plastic toys at home than deal with the fallout.
I’m the opposite. I’d rather SIL and MIL be upset with me than have my children miss out on normal things to accommodate her. I don’t know whether SIL is deliberately manipulative or simply used to getting her way, but the whole family seems to revolve around managing her feelings, and I’m getting increasingly fed up with it.

OP posts:
FuckoffeeBeforeCoffee · 11/11/2026 14:10

I would ignore and carry on as usual.

ParisBalloons · 11/11/2026 14:11

I'd point out the children would be upset not to have their toys and sweets on Christmas Day and you aren't willing to do that. Mine always looked forward to watching the Snowman or the Gruffalo or something, they'd definitely want to play with their new toys and eat chocolate coins and would be very disappointed to have to follow the rules of a two year old. As would I if someone told me I couldn't watch the Strictly Christmas special with a box of Bendicks.

We solved this kind of problem by insisting that we would have all our Christmases at home while the kids were young and I will say that was one boundary I never regretted setting. Every year on MN I am grateful all over again that we stuck to it!

lazyarse123 · 11/11/2026 14:11

chirrupybird · 11/11/2026 13:49

It's a bit unreasonable that your children can't have any sweet treats on Christmas day, perhaps you can help them select toys that don't bend the rules too much and no screens should be OK for a day.

Why should she? Sil is perfectly reasonable to have these rules for her child she cannot dictate how others behave. Personally I wouldn't go Christmas day is a time for treats and enjoying yourself.

MellowSubmarine · 11/11/2026 14:11

Absolutely not.

What is she actually asking - are you opening presents at your in-laws’? If so, is she saying that any plastic presents need to be left at home and opened another time? If not, is she saying that a 2 year old with a new favourite toy that they’ve just opened and might be plastic has to leave that toy at home in order to go to grandma’s house?

Is she expecting your children to not have pudding after Christmas dinner?

The no screen time wouldn’t be a massive issue for me because we don’t really watch any on Christmas Day. But it’s not her house - is she going to tell her parents off if they want to sit and watch a bit of tv after Christmas dinner?

ETA - I hadn’t seen your post about how your MIL enables this. I simply wouldn’t go for Christmas if I thought that my young children might get told off by their grandma for having a chocolate coin because it’s upset their aunt. Or be told they can’t play with a new present they’ve opened.

Beenaroundabit · 11/11/2026 14:11

She's making a choice for her DC, and part of that choice is dealing with how other people choose to parent their own kids. Of course her DC is going to come into contact with other kids who eat sweets and have screen time - she's the one bucking the norm so she has to deal with the fall-out.

She's also chosen to solo parent. Which means things are going to be tough - ALL the responsibility is on her. But again, that on her and not you to limit your kid's experiences just because she can't afford stuff/hasn't got the capacity. And don't get me started on the fact her dcs dad isn't around - is she going to suggest your DH makes himself scarce so her DC doesn't start asking about their own dad??

Why should your kids go without to save her kid having a strop he's not allowed stuff?

EvelynBeatrice · 11/11/2026 14:13

Oh dear. I’d say no nicely. To prevent your own children from having access to their own toys, whether old favourites or new, is unlikely to make for a happy Christmas experience for them.

AgentPidge · 11/11/2026 14:13

Oh gosh, I respect her trying to do her best for her kid/the planet, but little Freddie is going to be one mixed-up kid if she sticks to this once he's about four, unless he's surrounded by similar families ( does she live in Totnes?!).
Seriously, I didn't have a TV as a child. I could only watch it at friends' houses. Guess what I said my hobby was when I was asked at career guidance? Watching TV! My mother was mortified because everyone else had swimming, ballet etc.
Good luck at Christmas!

SandyCastles · 11/11/2026 14:14

Is it your PIL house or her house?

If you are genuinely planning on being considerate around her child and using common sense, then there is nothing more you can do.

I'd just message and say you understand her viewpoint, but being older children, you aren't prepared to ban them from things they enjoy at home as it's not fair to them, especially at Christmas, so while you'll all be careful not to expose Freddie to things that she doesn't like him to have, you can't guarantee it I'm afraid.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.
Swipe left for the next trending thread