No, we had a dogs dinner of a bill that was all big on principle and statements without any serious consideration of how it would be implemented, work in reality tie in with existing laws and protections. A huge number of groups and people who would be most affected, or expected to carry out the process of assessment and implementation of assisted dying had issues with supporting that particular bill, even if they were supporters of assisted dying.
The Lords debates and discussions were very comprehensive and informative, a sort of buffer of serious politics against a half-arsed bill of ' we want this, make it happen now' and ' its the only form of compassion/right side of history' attitudes of the bills most ardent supporters. It was fabulous to see and hear all sorts of real world issues getting examined and discussed, from the issues of coercion and abuse, social pressure, attitudes to disability to the practicalities of ' so who would do this, where, when and how, and how would we regulate and train them?, to the more abstract ' is this how society should best deal with these issues?. The debates were exactly what was needed and took a long time because there was so much to debate and consider, given the bill was a list of lobbying points that hadn't really been tested and tempered by discussion with other affected groups. I felt really encouraged by the discussions in the Lords - where across party lines and loyalties, and bringing in expertise from many areas, a group of serious people looked at as many angles and perspectives as possible to see how the bill might really work. I want my elected and appointed representatives to be able to try and test ideas, rather than blindly trotting through the lobbies because its the party line, or they promised their celebrity mate that they would vote for it.
To bring the bill back unaltered, in an attempt to force it through via an obscure parliamentary rules was a supremely arrogant move and I am glad it backfired. Having the bill raised and the subsequent debates was great though, as it forced MPs. the Lords and many other people to really deal with difficult topics - ageing, illness, palliative care, death and how we best deal with these, rather than the glib presentation of the original bill which seemed to think the whole thing would be easy. Hopefully this increased focus might lead to some improvements eg in palliative care provision and funding and potentially to any future proposals for assisted dying being better drafted and more considered.