Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that every diagnosis of dementia should come with the offer of assisted dying

973 replies

CurdinHenry · 08/11/2026 13:38

Is there really anyone who would hear this news and want to see it out to the bitter end?

It enrages me that I might go out that way and so might everyone I love.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
researchers3 · 16/11/2026 15:32

Loveofeclairs · 08/11/2026 13:43

I voted YABU. I’m leaning towards legalising assisted dying but I don’t think it should be automatically offered on any diagnosis. People might feel pressured into it because they don’t want to be a burden and that shouldn’t really be a consideration at all.

I think i agree with this.

I am pro assisted in general but I wouldn't specifically target dementia as opposed to other life limiting illnesses.

Cantbefucked · 16/11/2026 16:01

Late to the thread but after years of nursing in adult emergency wards? Thankfully not now, I think its definitely about time we took this seriously. When you witness what a person goes through with advanced dementia its heartbreaking. So many times I seen someone who obviously at one point was like us, with capacity, to trying to eat their own shit.
HOW IS THAT DIGNIFIED!? Oh I could go on and on about this topic. Also witnessing freaking out with pure fear because they cant think straight!

They say we are under so much pressure and strain... no wonder. In an ideal world we would have a cure or THE BEST care for our loved ones but we dont and never will. We had not long ago made leaflets of how not to rape women and children ffs.
Its all fucked.

I say this for anyone who has no quality of life, people who maybe have long term illness who cannot look after themselves and are beyond miserable with it.

We should have a choice!!!! So sick of humans trying to make out we are so good for prolonging suffering life !!!!

Gloriia · 16/11/2026 17:24

'So many times I seen someone who obviously at one point was like us, with capacity, to trying to eat their own shit.HOW IS THAT DIGNIFIED!? Oh I could go on and on about this topic. Also witnessing freaking out with pure fear because they cant think straight!'

You were a nurse??

It isn't dignified, true. No one has suggested it is. Many illnesses are far from dignified. Many involve altered behaviour or 'freaking out' as you kindly put it.

The debate isn't about if dementia is lovely or not. It isn't.

The debate is about how once you start having suicide pills available it will become a slippery slope. As an alleged ex nurse you may have experienced those suffering with burns, stroke patients, MND sufferers, patients with brain tumours who too may 'freak out' at times. What would you suggest for those poor people? Or are they ok, they deserve a bit of nursing care?

We should offer care and compassion for anyone who is living in an altered and challenging state.

Cantbefucked · 16/11/2026 19:06

@Gloriia

I done nursing duties yes (support) and believe me I had every single sympathy going for these poor people. Can you imagine being so upset you are freaking out because you cannot recognise where you are or who you are?? Thats torture and cruel to keep that going.
As for the other illnesses you have mentioned - if they didnt want to live with what they have because their quality of life is very poor, it should be their right to end it.

Its not about others people's conscience - its all about THEM.

If I ever have it I dont want to be here or have my children deal with it.

Hope I have worded it better.

MortenHarketsarms · 17/11/2026 07:58

HermioneWeasley · 08/11/2026 14:04

on a diagnosis I would like to be able to specify assisted dying in advance while I have capacity to do so. The problem with dementia is that by the time things have got bad enough to have no quality of life, you don’t have capacity to consent or take action.

I’d like to be able to say when I am at x point, please gather my loved ones and send me on my way quickly and peacefully.

Came to say pretty much exactly this. I would probably go further and suggest all of us should have the right to specify our wishes - or not should we choose not to - before any diagnosis. I watched my father die with this terrible disease and it’s the thing I fear most for myself and other loved ones. If I were able now to specify I want assisted dying should I ever reach x point I wouldn’t hesitate.

QforCucumber · 17/11/2026 10:04

I think the crux of it comes down to where is the line drawn @CurdinHenry ?

FIL has Alzheimer's, we've been told likely will have been seeing signs of it evolving over the last 10 years or so, but diagnosis only came 18 months ago. He still lives at home alone and manages fine day to day making breakfast and coffees etc, takes his meds with a phone call reminder, has recently had his car removed by his sons, and if left to do his own shopping would only buy milk and bread on repeat. Conversations' are often repeated but he gets there in the end on taking things in, remembers who we all are but sometimes forgets the kids names. Also - is in complete denial that he has Alzheimer's and the dr's only gave him the leaflets as something to look out for (so wouldn't ever have accepted at the time that AD would have been a possibility, because he 'doesn't have it')

so - should he be taking the pills now? or is there a specific point in which he has to firstly accept the illness, then make the choice - but likely by then wouldn't have the capacity to make this choice himself either.

CarnelianSwan · 17/11/2026 10:47

Not me because it opens up a whole can of worms. People will be arguing that if people with dementia can request assisted dying then why can't people with non-life limiting conditions like mental health difficulties etc. They will be bringing the issue to the courts, claiming discrimination and that their human rights are being violated. It will open the floodgates and eventually it's assisted dying for all and young people with treatable conditions will be able to request to be killed.

https://www.theguardian.com/society/article/2024/may/16/dutch-woman-euthanasia-approval-grounds-of-mental-suffering

That young woman should have been given appropriate mental health support rather than having her death facilitated by the state.

Dutch woman, 29, granted euthanasia approval on grounds of mental suffering

Zoraya ter Beek, who has chronic depression, anxiety, trauma and unspecified personality disorder, expected to end her life soon

https://www.theguardian.com/society/article/2024/may/16/dutch-woman-euthanasia-approval-grounds-of-mental-suffering

BIossomtoes · 17/11/2026 11:11

People will be arguing that if people with dementia can request assisted dying then why can't people with non-life limiting conditions like mental health difficulties etc.

There’s no logic to that. Dementia is terminal.

PencilsInSpace · 17/11/2026 14:37

BIossomtoes · 17/11/2026 11:11

People will be arguing that if people with dementia can request assisted dying then why can't people with non-life limiting conditions like mental health difficulties etc.

There’s no logic to that. Dementia is terminal.

A few pages back you and several others were arguing that people should be able to just go and buy 'euthanasia pills' for themselves - a position more extreme than any current AD law in any country.

How can you now pretend there would not be pressure to widen the criteria beyond terminal conditions?

Secretseverywhere · 17/11/2026 14:40

CarnelianSwan · 17/11/2026 10:47

Not me because it opens up a whole can of worms. People will be arguing that if people with dementia can request assisted dying then why can't people with non-life limiting conditions like mental health difficulties etc. They will be bringing the issue to the courts, claiming discrimination and that their human rights are being violated. It will open the floodgates and eventually it's assisted dying for all and young people with treatable conditions will be able to request to be killed.

https://www.theguardian.com/society/article/2024/may/16/dutch-woman-euthanasia-approval-grounds-of-mental-suffering

That young woman should have been given appropriate mental health support rather than having her death facilitated by the state.

Reading that article, it does seem like she was given help. She talks about the various treatment undertaken. The support she has been given in her personal life.

I think that suffering is subjective and what is unbearable for one may not be for another. It reminds me of the young British man (Daniel James)who went to dignitas after an accident left him a quadriplegic. I think there was the same “should have been supported” arguement but he had been and he’d tried to adjust but ultimately decided that his suffering was unbearable snd chose to end his life.

Really it should be between patients and their doctors with independent reviews which seems to be what happened in the Dutch case. It took over three and a half years between her request to be euthanised and it actually happening.

Secretseverywhere · 17/11/2026 14:41

QforCucumber · 17/11/2026 10:04

I think the crux of it comes down to where is the line drawn @CurdinHenry ?

FIL has Alzheimer's, we've been told likely will have been seeing signs of it evolving over the last 10 years or so, but diagnosis only came 18 months ago. He still lives at home alone and manages fine day to day making breakfast and coffees etc, takes his meds with a phone call reminder, has recently had his car removed by his sons, and if left to do his own shopping would only buy milk and bread on repeat. Conversations' are often repeated but he gets there in the end on taking things in, remembers who we all are but sometimes forgets the kids names. Also - is in complete denial that he has Alzheimer's and the dr's only gave him the leaflets as something to look out for (so wouldn't ever have accepted at the time that AD would have been a possibility, because he 'doesn't have it')

so - should he be taking the pills now? or is there a specific point in which he has to firstly accept the illness, then make the choice - but likely by then wouldn't have the capacity to make this choice himself either.

I k

Secretseverywhere · 17/11/2026 14:58

I know in the Netherlands you can choose a future point at which you’d like to end your life depending on the disease progression. The idea is when you have full capacity you are diagnosed, then make a request of your doctor, undertake counselling then make a second request. The paperwork is onerous, the process takes the best part of a year.

Then you get on with the business of living. If at some point in the future when you have lost capacity and reach your predetermined point (often no longer being able to live independently) in progression of disease thats when your wishes regarding death kick in. It may never happen, most people will die before needing to go into a home.

To me it seems better as you don’t lose out on years where you are enjoying living life by needing to die whilst still having full capacity.

BIossomtoes · 17/11/2026 20:52

PencilsInSpace · 17/11/2026 14:37

A few pages back you and several others were arguing that people should be able to just go and buy 'euthanasia pills' for themselves - a position more extreme than any current AD law in any country.

How can you now pretend there would not be pressure to widen the criteria beyond terminal conditions?

I simply pointed out that dementia is terminal. It wasn’t an invitation to an argument.

Gloriia · 17/11/2026 21:47

Secretseverywhere · 17/11/2026 14:58

I know in the Netherlands you can choose a future point at which you’d like to end your life depending on the disease progression. The idea is when you have full capacity you are diagnosed, then make a request of your doctor, undertake counselling then make a second request. The paperwork is onerous, the process takes the best part of a year.

Then you get on with the business of living. If at some point in the future when you have lost capacity and reach your predetermined point (often no longer being able to live independently) in progression of disease thats when your wishes regarding death kick in. It may never happen, most people will die before needing to go into a home.

To me it seems better as you don’t lose out on years where you are enjoying living life by needing to die whilst still having full capacity.

If only it were so simple. Thing is people change their minds, they 'think oh I'd rather be dead than <insert chronic medical condition>, then they find actually they can cope and want to enjoy whatever they can.

However they have this lovely signed form saying they'll off themselves whenever they need this or that. Family know all about if so surely you can see how pressure will creep in?

The Netherlands?

https://www.theguardian.com/society/article/2024/may/16/dutch-woman-euthanasia-approval-grounds-of-mental-suffering

A 29 yr old with mh problems?? I think the Netherlands is a perfect example of the slippery slope tbh rather than anything to applaud.

PencilsInSpace · 17/11/2026 23:02

BIossomtoes · 17/11/2026 20:52

I simply pointed out that dementia is terminal. It wasn’t an invitation to an argument.

You said there was no logic to @CarnelianSwan 's statement.

Clearly there is. People will push for the criteria to be widened. You have provided evidence of that yourself.

BIossomtoes · Yesterday 08:09

PencilsInSpace · 17/11/2026 23:02

You said there was no logic to @CarnelianSwan 's statement.

Clearly there is. People will push for the criteria to be widened. You have provided evidence of that yourself.

There was no logic as that post implied that dementia isn’t terminal.

PencilsInSpace · Yesterday 08:30

BIossomtoes · Yesterday 08:09

There was no logic as that post implied that dementia isn’t terminal.

How? I didn't get that at all from @CarnelianSwan 's post.

Either way, I'm struggling to see the relevance because you are not someone who believes AD should only be available for terminal conditions. You want it on demand for any condition or none.

You are not bothered by the risk of a slippery slope because you want to start at the bottom anyway.

BIossomtoes · Yesterday 08:56

you are not someone who believes AD should only be available for terminal conditions. You want it on demand for any condition or none.

No I’m not and no I don’t. Try rereading my posts.

PencilsInSpace · Yesterday 10:41

BIossomtoes · 14/11/2026 08:18

Me too.

I have read your posts.

Here you are agreeing with the idea that people should be able to just buy 'euthanasia pills' for themselves. Simple and easy.

Perhaps you need to read posts more carefully before you agree with them if this is not something you think.

BIossomtoes · Yesterday 11:35

I think I should be able to if I receive a dementia disagnosis. HTH although I suspect there will be something else now. I’m not engaging with you any more.

Gloriia · Yesterday 14:03

PencilsInSpace · Yesterday 10:41

I have read your posts.

Here you are agreeing with the idea that people should be able to just buy 'euthanasia pills' for themselves. Simple and easy.

Perhaps you need to read posts more carefully before you agree with them if this is not something you think.

Yes some folk really do think it should be as simple and easy as putting our pets to sleep.
Thankfully it isn't the majority view so we can only hope that sense continues to prevail.

Squidlette · Yesterday 21:07

Gloriia · Yesterday 14:03

Yes some folk really do think it should be as simple and easy as putting our pets to sleep.
Thankfully it isn't the majority view so we can only hope that sense continues to prevail.

But I think this would be great. I could stop being scared of a dementia- ridden future; knowing that if I get diagnosed, I can just go.

Secretseverywhere · Yesterday 23:56

Gloriia · Yesterday 14:03

Yes some folk really do think it should be as simple and easy as putting our pets to sleep.
Thankfully it isn't the majority view so we can only hope that sense continues to prevail.

Generally polls show strong support for assisted dying. For terminal illnesses it’s above 70% in ipsos/ yougov and has been trending upwards for years. So I’d argue it is a majority view!

Politicians seem to lack backbones and flock around which ever opinion a noisy minority is shouting about. I do think assisted dying will get in eventually though.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread