Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that every diagnosis of dementia should come with the offer of assisted dying

973 replies

CurdinHenry · 08/11/2026 13:38

Is there really anyone who would hear this news and want to see it out to the bitter end?

It enrages me that I might go out that way and so might everyone I love.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
WaynesWhirled · 08/11/2026 21:32

BIossomtoes · 08/11/2026 21:10

And this kind of post makes me doubt that you support assisted dying.

Why? The idea that it’s ok to tell people that if they love their families more than themselves they should choose assisted dying is abhorrent. Nobody should be pressured into it. That really isn’t an unusual position for a supporter of legalisation- in fact I’d hope it was the default.

EstoyRobandoSuCasa · 08/11/2026 21:33

DuckFilledPlatitude · 08/11/2026 21:11

One issue is that some people seem to have a rose-tinted view of dementia - the example upthread of people singing and clapping along to the TV is a perfect example.

It isn't like that at the end stages, or certainly not for everyone. If end stage dementia were universally like a sitcom idea of old people in a care home singing along to Beatles tribute bands and having amusingly incoherent conversations, we wouldn't need this debate at all.

That was the final stage for two of my relatives before they died from infections. One had spent nearly nine years in a care home before reaching that point. My friend's dad had a similar death from pneumonia, albeit only a few months after moving into residential care. Infections are one of the leading causes of death for people with dementia.

One relative still spoke in sentences, but had started spitting food out instead of swallowing it - a sign that she might be approaching the end. The other relative could only say the occasional word or phrase, but remained jolly and laughed a lot. She could no longer sing along to music, but enjoyed the visits of a live performer who sang and played the keyboard.

MrMucker · 08/11/2026 21:37

I.find your take on dementia terrible.
You talk of foul behaviour, demented erratic living, impossible breakdown of personality.
But these are your interpretations from the outside.
Having cognitive decline is terrible for the sufferer, but far less so when cared for with patience, understanding and initiative. You can have dementia quite happily all the way til the end, as long as you have the right care around you to support you as you lose capability.
You confuse disability and inconvenience, you're not the only one and it's so sad.
Society generally needs a bit of a shake up in this regard, but sadly dementia remains obscured into mere nuisance by ever deepening shortfalls in adult care generally.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 08/11/2026 21:40

Jane3212 · 08/11/2026 21:28

The people who put that bill forward refused lots of sensible protective amendments, so I didn't trust them.

Moreover, while the Lords are unelected, the bill was not in any manifesto which it arguably should have been for people to have a say. It is a huge issue to be introduced without a manifesto

It was actually even worse than that, Jane
There was a lot of braying about "judicial oversight" being included in the original bill, only for the proposed measures to be removed as the process went on, and no answer at all to how this would have been handled even if it had remained, given the pressures on court time

The appalling Kim Leadbeater - who couldn't even be straightforward about its removal - tried to claim a "panel of experts" would be better, but this was clearly disingenuous since she must have known such people are pretty busy too

https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/assisted-dying-judge-plus-kim-leadbeater-psychiatrists-b2695770.html

DuckFilledPlatitude · 08/11/2026 21:40

EstoyRobandoSuCasa · 08/11/2026 21:33

That was the final stage for two of my relatives before they died from infections. One had spent nearly nine years in a care home before reaching that point. My friend's dad had a similar death from pneumonia, albeit only a few months after moving into residential care. Infections are one of the leading causes of death for people with dementia.

One relative still spoke in sentences, but had started spitting food out instead of swallowing it - a sign that she might be approaching the end. The other relative could only say the occasional word or phrase, but remained jolly and laughed a lot. She could no longer sing along to music, but enjoyed the visits of a live performer who sang and played the keyboard.

That is lovely to hear and it does reinforce the point that no two patients are alike.

Sadly, it isn't like that for my mum - she just sits or lies in silence, all day, every day.

Even if it were an option, I could not consent to euthanasia on her behalf, I don't know for sure what she would have wanted when she was still able to decide.

But I know for certain I do not want that for myself.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 08/11/2026 21:44

The idea that it’s ok to tell people that if they love their families more than themselves they should choose assisted dying is abhorrent

Very true, @WaynesWhirled, but the fact it was suggested reveals exactly the potential for coercion which many are worried about

BIossomtoes · 08/11/2026 21:46

MaeshoweDragon · 08/11/2026 21:17

kicking out, scratching, pulling my face away from them, clamping my mouth shut... followed by crying, screaming, begging them not to kill me, saying "I've changed my mind", "would you hold your own mother down and kill her", "murderers, you just like killing old ladies", "please, please don't kill me, I don't want to die....", "help me..."

Might cause a bit of distress to the person who is expected to just get on with it.

And I’m accused of hyperbole.

BIossomtoes · 08/11/2026 21:49

Jane3212 · 08/11/2026 21:28

The people who put that bill forward refused lots of sensible protective amendments, so I didn't trust them.

Moreover, while the Lords are unelected, the bill was not in any manifesto which it arguably should have been for people to have a say. It is a huge issue to be introduced without a manifesto

Opinion polls show 75% public approval for legalising assisted suicide.

https://publications.parliament.uk/pa/bills/lbill/59-01/112/en/5901112en07.htm

LadySlipper · 08/11/2026 21:50

Yes, I agree with you. My mum is one of 7 sisters and they are all taking turns getting it from the eldest on down. The first two are gone, the next one is in the throes of it and there's one more before my mum's turn. When my turn comes along I have no intention of seeing it out until the end.

CurdinHenry · 08/11/2026 21:50

MrMucker · 08/11/2026 21:37

I.find your take on dementia terrible.
You talk of foul behaviour, demented erratic living, impossible breakdown of personality.
But these are your interpretations from the outside.
Having cognitive decline is terrible for the sufferer, but far less so when cared for with patience, understanding and initiative. You can have dementia quite happily all the way til the end, as long as you have the right care around you to support you as you lose capability.
You confuse disability and inconvenience, you're not the only one and it's so sad.
Society generally needs a bit of a shake up in this regard, but sadly dementia remains obscured into mere nuisance by ever deepening shortfalls in adult care generally.

I think some people get a revolting thrill from the idea of making others exist in this state while pretending they're on a spiritually superior plane. I think you are probably one.

OP posts:
Newsenmum · 08/11/2026 21:57

kitex · 08/11/2026 19:45

I would welcome it. It would give me a way out.

You don’t think it should be something that is available and you can personally choose it when you wish, as opposed to it being offered to you. There is a big difference.

Have you actually had that diagnosis?

Enigma54 · 08/11/2026 21:57

It’s all so terrifying. I have two incurable cancers. As it is, my pain isn’t particularly well controlled ( despite best efforts and short of a hospice stay in a ten bedded hospice, which I may not may not get a place in).

I dread to think what is to come. I just want a pain free dignified death. Something tells me this isn’t going to happen ( even in 2026).

TeethAreImportant · 08/11/2026 21:59

CurdinHenry · 08/11/2026 13:38

Is there really anyone who would hear this news and want to see it out to the bitter end?

It enrages me that I might go out that way and so might everyone I love.

My mum always used to say (when we saw how her pwn mum went downhill), promise you'll put a pillow over my face if I ever get like that. She's now starting to go the same way as my grandmother, and sometimes I wonder what she'd choose if the option was there. Does she still think like she did then? It's so awful to go through, but also to witness. It's going through grief twice, the first stage for a really long time that ramps up instead of getting easier. Then the second part when they actually go and then feeling guilty because you're relieved.

Newsenmum · 08/11/2026 22:00

CurdinHenry · 08/11/2026 21:50

I think some people get a revolting thrill from the idea of making others exist in this state while pretending they're on a spiritually superior plane. I think you are probably one.

I completely disagree. I think people are just different. And almost enforcing one thing to the detriment of others is appalling. Sure, choose it if you wish. However the two people I knew who had it didnt magically want to be guilted into dying immediately with their diagnosis. They fucking deserve to be treated and living as long as their life is worth living. There is a point where this changes and perhaps this point can be discussed but it needs to come from the person who is suffering,
nohody else.

BriarTime · 08/11/2026 22:01

CurdinHenry · 08/11/2026 21:23

That's the point

We think we are better than animals yet we make our parents suffer in ways we never would a dog

That’s because society values humans more than animals. It’s prepared to euthanise animals because the stakes of that are regarded as so much lower than doing it to humans. It’s precisely because ‘we think we’re better than animals’ that that’s the case. It’s also why the historical animalisation of certain groups of humans has been used to round them up and wipe them out.

Newsenmum · 08/11/2026 22:03

TeethAreImportant · 08/11/2026 21:59

My mum always used to say (when we saw how her pwn mum went downhill), promise you'll put a pillow over my face if I ever get like that. She's now starting to go the same way as my grandmother, and sometimes I wonder what she'd choose if the option was there. Does she still think like she did then? It's so awful to go through, but also to witness. It's going through grief twice, the first stage for a really long time that ramps up instead of getting easier. Then the second part when they actually go and then feeling guilty because you're relieved.

Im now thinking of a third person. He’s been told he’s in early stages and he is doing everything to live his life to the full and be with his wife and grandchildren. The idea that he should be given an assisted dying leaflet along with his diagnosis is very upsetting. He will already feel pressure about being a burden. Let him enjoy the time he has and wants to do things.

CurdinHenry · 08/11/2026 22:05

BriarTime · 08/11/2026 22:01

That’s because society values humans more than animals. It’s prepared to euthanise animals because the stakes of that are regarded as so much lower than doing it to humans. It’s precisely because ‘we think we’re better than animals’ that that’s the case. It’s also why the historical animalisation of certain groups of humans has been used to round them up and wipe them out.

I mean whatever, life is finite and we're all going to die fairly soon in the geological sense. If you want to experience hell on earth beforehand by all means go for it but you shouldn't be allowed to decide for me.

OP posts:
sprigatito · 08/11/2026 22:05

CurdinHenry · 08/11/2026 21:50

I think some people get a revolting thrill from the idea of making others exist in this state while pretending they're on a spiritually superior plane. I think you are probably one.

I think you’re projecting your fear of your own mortality onto dementia sufferers, and your posts have been crass and deliberately cruel. We all have our opinions 🤷🏻‍♀️

dreamiesformolly · 08/11/2026 22:07

DuckFilledPlatitude · 08/11/2026 21:11

One issue is that some people seem to have a rose-tinted view of dementia - the example upthread of people singing and clapping along to the TV is a perfect example.

It isn't like that at the end stages, or certainly not for everyone. If end stage dementia were universally like a sitcom idea of old people in a care home singing along to Beatles tribute bands and having amusingly incoherent conversations, we wouldn't need this debate at all.

You're quite right. I say that as someone who has just come to bed wiped out after a day of helping to look after my mother who has dementia and lives with me and who has had a bad day today (meaning, consequently, that mine's not been great either!). But she still has good days too, and in a way I think that's partially informing my reservations about AD. Admittedly she's not at end stage, so it's not exactly the same scenario as you describe, but in general terms applying AD to a dementia patient while they still have some quality of life left is an absolute moral/ethical minefield imo.

Additionally, given how hard it is caring for a relative with dementia, I also worry that relatives could pressure a person into signing something while still of sound mind because they don't want to end up caring for that person further down the line. Hopefully it's unlikely, but I don't think it's impossible given all the talk of people being a 'burden' that always gets bandied around on threads such as this one.

Cally62 · 08/11/2026 22:07

MrMucker · 08/11/2026 21:37

I.find your take on dementia terrible.
You talk of foul behaviour, demented erratic living, impossible breakdown of personality.
But these are your interpretations from the outside.
Having cognitive decline is terrible for the sufferer, but far less so when cared for with patience, understanding and initiative. You can have dementia quite happily all the way til the end, as long as you have the right care around you to support you as you lose capability.
You confuse disability and inconvenience, you're not the only one and it's so sad.
Society generally needs a bit of a shake up in this regard, but sadly dementia remains obscured into mere nuisance by ever deepening shortfalls in adult care generally.

There are several types of dementia and associated behaviour.
You are exceptionally fortunate to not know the real effects of dementia, not only on the person suffering, and it is a horrendous suffering for most people with dementia and their loved ones.
Do you think that having dementia is living in a joyful state of oblivion.
Believe me when I say it is a fucking horrendous illness that robs a person of their life and before they are no longer here the person grieves, loved ones grieve, they grieve for years and years, for the life they once had and for the absolute gut wrenching loss of life before your person has actually died.
There is no help out there to ease the pain of dementia.
Why have we decided that assisted dying is the path we would go down, because if a suicide attempt were to fail and many do who knows what life or lack of life it would be like.

CurdinHenry · 08/11/2026 22:08

sprigatito · 08/11/2026 22:05

I think you’re projecting your fear of your own mortality onto dementia sufferers, and your posts have been crass and deliberately cruel. We all have our opinions 🤷🏻‍♀️

So you think dementia suffers soiling themelves and sexually assaulting their daughters on visiting day are just enjoying themselves in a way I'm too narrow to understand...?

OP posts:
dreamiesformolly · 08/11/2026 22:08

Enigma54 · 08/11/2026 21:57

It’s all so terrifying. I have two incurable cancers. As it is, my pain isn’t particularly well controlled ( despite best efforts and short of a hospice stay in a ten bedded hospice, which I may not may not get a place in).

I dread to think what is to come. I just want a pain free dignified death. Something tells me this isn’t going to happen ( even in 2026).

So sorry you're going through this. I can't even imagine.

Witchlite · 08/11/2026 22:10

I read on here about people with Alzheimer’s carrying on happily, or contentedly to the end. I’m really happy for those people.

My DM died two years ago now, she was amazing and single handedly bought up my two brothers and I. She was a strong, cultured and determined woman, who achieved a lot in her life. We loved and admired her.

when the Alzheimer’s became apparent (she was in denial for a long time) and because she was self funding, we were given a list of care agencies - that’s it. She had become very close to her dog during Covid, almost dependent. There were no homes that would take the dog, which left her children.

This became the worst 4 years of our lives. Strong and determined became stubborn and intransigent- my lovely liberal mother became abusive and rude. As though all filters disappeared and the stream of consciousness was so very hurtful. This was not my mother - she was gone and while we would catch glimpses, it was all for very hurtful.

i do know she would have hated it, if she was conscious of it. I do know she was scared, really frightened and confused most of the last few years.

She died from a fall, where she cracked 3 ribs and broke her wrist. At A&E these weren’t treated as they were more concerned about the bump on her head (found out the fall was caused by mini strokes) and when asked she said she was fine and there was no pain. She must gave been in such pain. I took her back to A&E 2 days later (she was discharged that day as she found the hospital scary so doctors didn’t admit her) she lost consciousness in A&E and died 5 days later without regaining consciousness.

tThe last few years of her life were hell for her and hell for us.

There were no delightful day cuddling a dolly or enjoying food. It was just pure hell. Not everyone experiences this disease the same way. There should be a choice, but it must never be forced.

should I get this disease, I would like the chance to opt for death, once certain stages had been reached. This is for me and my family. If a dog was kept alive as my mother lived her final months, we would be reported to the RSPCA.

CurdinHenry · 08/11/2026 22:10

Men and women by the way. Very common for old ladies to shriek very detailed sexual stuff. Nurse friend of mine wonders if it's stuff they did (or abuse they suffered?) or just fantasy coming to the surface as the brain deteriorates.

OP posts:
dreamiesformolly · 08/11/2026 22:11

kitex · 08/11/2026 21:28

A person would explicitly and voluntarily request assisted dying. A person would be able to change their mind and withdraw their request at any point in the process.

Including if they had dementia?