Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that hotdesking is shit and dehumanising for staff who work in an office

213 replies

CurdinHenry · 01/11/2026 14:54

Does anyone still have their "own" desk these days? What sort of sector are you in?

OP posts:
Anarchy99 · 03/11/2026 11:16

Those saying how lonely you are when hot-desking - do you not have contact with your teams remotely? Why is it more lonely working in the office than working at home?

Truinio · 03/11/2026 11:18

EscCtrl · 02/11/2026 16:38

1200 employees, 3 days a week = 3,600 employee work days a week.
60 desks, assuming full on 7 day work week, and 3 (eight-hour) shifts a day = 1,260 desk work days a week.
Those Americans should "do the math".

Yes, it’s utterly idiotic. Although we don’t work shifts and only a 5 day week. But that’s big US corporates for you. Sold all the regional offices and massively downsized the head office during COVID for huge cost savings, now want us all “back to the (non-existent) office.”

ChocolateApples · 03/11/2026 11:35

Anarchy99 · 03/11/2026 11:16

Those saying how lonely you are when hot-desking - do you not have contact with your teams remotely? Why is it more lonely working in the office than working at home?

Being sat in a crowded room where you don't know people/aren't part of things can be more lonely than being home alone. How hotdesking works in practice varies wildly from office to office. I think dehumanising is a bit hyperbolic, but there can definitely be a bit of that. It can lead to an office where you feel like nothing more than a cog. I do think feeling part of the place you work matters psychologically and it's easy to lose that. I've seen a relatively close knit office sort of drift off due to various factors.

LlynTegid · 03/11/2026 11:44

ChocolateApples · 03/11/2026 11:35

Being sat in a crowded room where you don't know people/aren't part of things can be more lonely than being home alone. How hotdesking works in practice varies wildly from office to office. I think dehumanising is a bit hyperbolic, but there can definitely be a bit of that. It can lead to an office where you feel like nothing more than a cog. I do think feeling part of the place you work matters psychologically and it's easy to lose that. I've seen a relatively close knit office sort of drift off due to various factors.

I agree. If you have shared desks, at least keep them such that you will be near to your team who come in.

Auburngal · 03/11/2026 13:01

Anarchy99 · 03/11/2026 11:07

Why not?

Maybe not cables but everyone should use their own keyboard and mouse. People use my office when I wfh but hygiene-wise, I don’t want people using my equipment.

These are work issued cables and mouse

nomas · 03/11/2026 13:05

TouchMyBumThisIsLife · 01/11/2026 15:08

It's a great way to try new food.

I find all sorts to munch on in each new keyboard.

🤣

And also Envy

Anarchy99 · 03/11/2026 13:06

Auburngal · 03/11/2026 13:01

These are work issued cables and mouse

Yes I understand that.

thoughtitwasright · 03/11/2026 13:14

Anarchy99 · 03/11/2026 11:16

Those saying how lonely you are when hot-desking - do you not have contact with your teams remotely? Why is it more lonely working in the office than working at home?

I find being in the office and seeing everyone chatting with their teams and having catch ups makes me feel shit - I feel so lonely and isolated which I don't really notice at home. I only occasionally work with one other person in my home office and we don't often overlap as we're not in 5 days a week so most days I have minimal small talk for the 12 hours I'm commuting/in the office. It's depressing to be honest.

Anarchy99 · 03/11/2026 13:16

ChocolateApples · 03/11/2026 11:35

Being sat in a crowded room where you don't know people/aren't part of things can be more lonely than being home alone. How hotdesking works in practice varies wildly from office to office. I think dehumanising is a bit hyperbolic, but there can definitely be a bit of that. It can lead to an office where you feel like nothing more than a cog. I do think feeling part of the place you work matters psychologically and it's easy to lose that. I've seen a relatively close knit office sort of drift off due to various factors.

I don’t work directly with anyone in my office and have to go to other locations frequently where I don’t know anyone. When I am in the office I shut my door and get on with my job. You go in, you do your job, you speak to the people you want or need to speak to (at the office or at another one) and you go home.

Close knit offices are often problematic in many ways. When the onus is on that, it can be an issue. I turned down a good job because I was told at the interview that the company was ‘more like family’ 🤢

But if someone struggles working around people they don’t know, perhaps hybrid working and hot desking isn’t for them.

Anarchy99 · 03/11/2026 13:21

thoughtitwasright · 03/11/2026 13:14

I find being in the office and seeing everyone chatting with their teams and having catch ups makes me feel shit - I feel so lonely and isolated which I don't really notice at home. I only occasionally work with one other person in my home office and we don't often overlap as we're not in 5 days a week so most days I have minimal small talk for the 12 hours I'm commuting/in the office. It's depressing to be honest.

So it is the social element you miss?

I have good friends in the workplace but can go days without talking to them even though they sit about 10 ft from my office.

I come in, put my earbuds in,
shut the door and work. I’m in contact with my teammates by Teams or phone and it works just fine.

EndorsingPRActice · 03/11/2026 13:31

I quite like hot desking as long as I'm secure in my role. 10 years ago I started in a new office 3 days a week and owing to childcare commitments couldn't start until 9:30am, by which time all the desks in my team's allocated plot were taken and I had to find a free desk, often a long way away from the team. It was isolating and difficult to pick the job up. But now I'm fully secure in the role and quite like a day with a different group of people where I am relativelyhidden from management...

thoughtitwasright · 03/11/2026 13:34

Anarchy99 · 03/11/2026 13:21

So it is the social element you miss?

I have good friends in the workplace but can go days without talking to them even though they sit about 10 ft from my office.

I come in, put my earbuds in,
shut the door and work. I’m in contact with my teammates by Teams or phone and it works just fine.

I can do that too but I find it all quite meaningless, like I'm going through the motions so I can tick an attendance requirement. I don't particularly care about socialising but I would like to feel like the act of going to the office was somewhat meaningful. Because it's not I find myself feeling isolated and lonely. I've been remote for 7 or 8 years so it's not the act of working alone/remotely, I only come away from office days feeling like that.

curious79 · 03/11/2026 13:37

when I was in an office it was a bit tedious finding a place that wasn't hard on the back - lots of us ended up on sofas etc. But I enjoyed the variety and moving around

Blanketpolicy · 03/11/2026 13:51

Don’t like hot desking at all.

Firstly the practicalities of having to carry a load of shite in and out the office (shared lockers too and not allowed to leave anything overnight). So can’t leave a water bottle, chargers, cables, cardigan if cold, change of shoes if wearing boots outdoors, pads pens, paracetamol, etc in desk at work, need to carry in and out every day.

Then socially, team gets split up and we all end up sitting apart which means social conversations don’t happen as don’t want to walk up to their desk when others around them from other teams are trying to work etc. So I can pay a small fortune to traipse all the way into the city, barely talk to anyone the office, then traipse all the way back home again.

So I tend to WFH as much as possible as I see no benefit to going in and it is just a faff, I only go in if absolutely necessary.

LuckyHazelFox · 03/11/2026 13:52

Freshrain · 01/11/2026 15:23

I mean 'dehumanising' sounds a bit melodramatic, but I agree hotdesking is shit.

Ridiculous hyperbole in using that word!

Anarchy99 · 03/11/2026 14:07

thoughtitwasright · 03/11/2026 13:34

I can do that too but I find it all quite meaningless, like I'm going through the motions so I can tick an attendance requirement. I don't particularly care about socialising but I would like to feel like the act of going to the office was somewhat meaningful. Because it's not I find myself feeling isolated and lonely. I've been remote for 7 or 8 years so it's not the act of working alone/remotely, I only come away from office days feeling like that.

Is changing jobs an option?

dracn · 03/11/2026 14:34

I don’t like hot-desking but it’s not the worst thing in the world. You just have to make sure you don’t sit next to anyone too annoying.

One thing I hate is being told to “make it work” when faced with an impossible situation. No, HR, you are literally paid to not introduce these problems and to offer solutions when they arise.

I problem solve all the time in my role. There’s no way I would be allowed to tell someone to “make it work” or “figure it out” in my job, so why is it ok for others?

Freshrain · 03/11/2026 16:47

I come in, put my earbuds in, shut the door and work. I’m in contact with my teammates by Teams or phone and it works just fine.

So what's the point of going into an office ?

All the time wasted on the commute. All the cost of the commute. All the pollution of thousands of people commuting when they aren't actually communicating with anyone when they are there?

I don't understand why any employer would want to pay for office space (and all the add ons, like cleaning, security, utilities, toilet paper, soap, etc etc) if their staff don't need to be in the same space, and do their job(s) in isolation other than meetings on Teams.
Leave the roads and trains empty for the people who work in all the jobs that need to be face to face / in person.

ChocolateApples · 03/11/2026 17:05

Anarchy99 · 03/11/2026 13:16

I don’t work directly with anyone in my office and have to go to other locations frequently where I don’t know anyone. When I am in the office I shut my door and get on with my job. You go in, you do your job, you speak to the people you want or need to speak to (at the office or at another one) and you go home.

Close knit offices are often problematic in many ways. When the onus is on that, it can be an issue. I turned down a good job because I was told at the interview that the company was ‘more like family’ 🤢

But if someone struggles working around people they don’t know, perhaps hybrid working and hot desking isn’t for them.

That last sentence would cut a huge amount of people out of a lot of jobs they'd be generally suited to!

You don't have to be a family in a toxic sense, but the relationships built in the workplace are important in terms of helping us do our jobs effectively. And in terms of older staff modelling thing to younger ones. I've learnt a huge amount informally from colleagues who were in the office with me just because someone overheard something. Thar doesn't happened if you are separated and only connect on Teams.

Anarchy99 · 03/11/2026 17:09

Freshrain · 03/11/2026 16:47

I come in, put my earbuds in, shut the door and work. I’m in contact with my teammates by Teams or phone and it works just fine.

So what's the point of going into an office ?

All the time wasted on the commute. All the cost of the commute. All the pollution of thousands of people commuting when they aren't actually communicating with anyone when they are there?

I don't understand why any employer would want to pay for office space (and all the add ons, like cleaning, security, utilities, toilet paper, soap, etc etc) if their staff don't need to be in the same space, and do their job(s) in isolation other than meetings on Teams.
Leave the roads and trains empty for the people who work in all the jobs that need to be face to face / in person.

As I’m not on the board of directors, it’s not my call. I would be happy to work from home but that isn’t company culture.

sashh · 04/11/2026 05:06

Greenmouldycheese · 01/11/2026 15:17

I wouldnt say its dehumanizing. I hot desk and it really doesnt bother me in the slightest. I still feel human.

I don't. I have a few issues that mean I need my computer set up a particular way so hot desking is not disability friendly.

Flymyprettiesflies · 04/11/2026 06:15

RaggedRocks · 01/11/2026 15:17

Presumably its first come, first served. A great incentive to get up early and get to work early.

We have an online booking system so you know if you have a desk and which one it is.

HollaHolla · 04/11/2026 06:25

Yup, I hate it. I work for a Uni, and I have an adapted workstation, with standing desk, etc. I get priority for it. But, if I need to book a non-usual (I''m usually in Mon & Weds), day, then someone else will probably have it booked. Which means I have to move someone off their booked workstation. It's horrible. I also don't know half the folk in my wider team. It makes me not want to go in.

HollaHolla · 04/11/2026 06:28

Oh, and I'm fed up having to cart my laptop, charger, mouse, headset, all everywhere with me, at all times.

DeftGoldHedgehog · 04/11/2026 06:32

How does it with the DSE set up? I've got a stress shoulder injury and will probably need rests and aids. Some may be portable but a lot of it is about having things aligned properly each time also. And I do have my own desk but still got it wrong. DH hot desks but people tend to take the same desk in the same area if they can. If you can't sit with colleagues it defeats the object of being in an office with people!

Swipe left for the next trending thread