Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that hotdesking is shit and dehumanising for staff who work in an office

213 replies

CurdinHenry · 01/11/2026 14:54

Does anyone still have their "own" desk these days? What sort of sector are you in?

OP posts:
EBearhug · 02/11/2026 12:55

Witchyhoures · 02/11/2026 12:48

I guess if it made the end product cheaper or paid staff more then fine.
But some people have foot rests and special chair adjustments etc.
tbh i would just choose to be sat away from the bosses as i dont like feelibg im being watched even if im not doing anything wrong

We have a few chairs around with signs like, "Joe Bloggs chair - do not adjust." Peripherals like keyboards and mice aren't shared anyway.

HandPulledNoodles · 02/11/2026 13:00

Dehumanising is a bit dramatic and probably shows you dont have a real understanding of legitimate dehumansing behaviour.

Annoying? Yes. Not conducive to a good working environment? Absolutely.

I have my own office inside a bigger office where there's hotdesking. I have a yearly battle with our estates team to keep it that I fight tooth and nail to keep.

RaggedRocks · 02/11/2026 13:00

I worked somewhere with a strictly no eating at desks policy. I learned to suck crisps one by one, so I wouldn't get caught out by making crunching nosies.

bardabunga · 02/11/2026 14:38

RaggedRocks · 02/11/2026 11:10

Presumably, you can have your own desk as a reasonable adjustment.

I'm retired now, and have never had the problem personally. Hopefully employers who do have this system make reasonable adjustments for the relevant staff.

Sladuf1 · 02/11/2026 15:27

MistyMountainTop · 01/11/2026 23:38

I do believe that hot desking and working at the dining table on a dining chair are setting a lot of people up for back, neck and shoulder problems in later life. You don't realise what a fine machine your body is until it goes wrong, and it's often too late to do anything about it.

Completely agree with you about this. A few years ago I had to sit at a desk that sounded the opposite to one @TeenLifeMum mentioned on page 2, 10 posts down. Whereas Jane (in TeenLifeMum’s example) had a raised desk, the one I had to sit at felt ridiculously low. To the point it reminded me of desks you’d sat at between Years 1-3 in primary school.

This desk had been adapted for a colleague, who had already left, so goodness’ knows why it was still in the office. I mentioned I was finding it uncomfortable to sit at and was doing my best to get up and move about. Nothing happened. Within 3 weeks, I started noticing tingling in my ring and pinky finger. A few weeks after that, both fingers and the left side of my hand were numb.
I ended up taking sick leave and leaving the job. However, my affected hand didn’t return to normal for months afterwards, following hand therapy plus wearing a splint.
It was a compressed ulnar nerve.

TraitorOrFaithful · 02/11/2026 16:15

To me, hot desking is the flip side of not being required to come in to work every day. It's great being able to work from home two or three days a week, but it's not reasonable to expect my desk to sit empty on those days- it's perfectly reasonable for management to want to save on office space. So while I'd prefer to have my own desk, it's worth not having one if that means I can wfh for part of the week.

If you work in an office full time and never wfh then I can see why you'd prefer your own allocated desk.

TheLastSilverSaint · 02/11/2026 16:17

MistyMountainTop · 01/11/2026 23:38

I do believe that hot desking and working at the dining table on a dining chair are setting a lot of people up for back, neck and shoulder problems in later life. You don't realise what a fine machine your body is until it goes wrong, and it's often too late to do anything about it.

All the chairs are very adjustable ergonomic ones where I work, and you can also book an adjustable height desk if you need to stand up regularly. A couple of people who have health conditions that can't be managed by adjusting a normal office chair have their own special chairs which are labelled as theirs.

I agree about people working at their dining tables etc. My employer provides a proper office desk and chair for us to work from home if we want one, but obviously that doesn't work for people who don't have a space for the extra furniture at home. Having said that, where I work we have a choice on whether to come into the office or work from home, so people who don't have suitable space for homeworking just tend to come into the office most days.

EscCtrl · 02/11/2026 16:21

timeserved · 02/11/2026 06:46

My office is 6 m x 11 m, has a desk, meeting table for 8, bookcases an armchair, a sofa and a coffee table. The lighting is quite poor though.

Just missing the drinks cabinet. 😀

EscCtrl · 02/11/2026 16:38

Truinio · 01/11/2026 15:05

Yep it’s shit. We have 1200 employees in the UK and one office (in London) with 60 hotdesks and our American parent has issued a return to office mandate saying that everyone needs to be in the office at least 3 days a week. We have been told to ‘make it work’.

1200 employees, 3 days a week = 3,600 employee work days a week.
60 desks, assuming full on 7 day work week, and 3 (eight-hour) shifts a day = 1,260 desk work days a week.
Those Americans should "do the math".

Gwenna · 02/11/2026 18:06

CurdinHenry · 01/11/2026 21:55

Blanket statements about those who can't respect the humanity of people who need to be treated with dignity in order to perform their jobs effectively are the opposite of thoughtless

"👀"

Sorry but you’re going on about clitoridectomies in Sudan and making frankly ridiculous statements on top of that. You’re not making any sense. Are you bored or something? 👀👀

HoraceCope · 02/11/2026 19:31

i agree op it is depersonalizing
i am sure it can decrease job satisfaction and increases insecurity

Namechangedoverandover · 02/11/2026 19:35

RaggedRocks · 02/11/2026 11:10

Presumably, you can have your own desk as a reasonable adjustment.

In our government building we hot desk and there are so many desks allocated for staff with reasonable adjustments, it's getting ridiculous.

Fair enough if you have a profound disability, but if If you have a soft touch manager you can get one for any minor condition which wouldn't get you an allocated desk in any other organisation. This just reduces the pool of desks for the silent majority and breeds resentment.

Half the desks are rise and fall and they are different colours colours for those with sensory needs. So why, do so many staff need allocated desks when they only come unto the office for one or a couple of days a week? To those not familiar with the work area you don't know when the staff member is due in because the desk sign doesn't say. Just that it is an allocated desk with no other information. So you have to wait until after 10am to sit in it or risk sitting there earlier but need to move if they come in and no other desks are then available anywhere.

You are also, tripping over all the specialist allocated chairs which are stored in an iconvenient area. Even though when the building was being designed they made such a pitch about the new office chairs being suitable for the vast majority of staff.

No booking system in place either. And don't get me started on our quiet rooms which should only be used for one to one performance sessions, delivering training, customer Teams meetings but which instead are used as personal offices for the whole day with visits from their mates! Then we can't find one when needed for that chat with a manager or needing to collaborate on something with a colleague without disruptions for 30 minutes or an hour or two.

I feel so much better after that rant.

G5000 · 02/11/2026 19:48

people who only go in once in a blue moon really shouldn't complain about hot desking in the same sentence. What do you want, the employer to rent a huge building to keep hundreds of empty desks reserved just in case, each used once per month?

Oh and eating at your desk is grim. Crumbs, drips but also the slurping and crunching, really not necessary. Don't you have a break room?

CurdinHenry · 02/11/2026 21:49

Gwenna · 02/11/2026 18:06

Sorry but you’re going on about clitoridectomies in Sudan and making frankly ridiculous statements on top of that. You’re not making any sense. Are you bored or something? 👀👀

Edited

I was replying to someone else who raised the topic. Are you ok?

OP posts:
Auburngal · 02/11/2026 22:09

I was hot-desking in 2004. Working in a call centre. We were given cases to store our headset, paper forms (some things had to fill one in), notes, pens. Then when finished your shift, you put your case in your numbered slot on the shelving

Now in the civil service, my job requires to be in once a week, most CS jobs you are required to be in 3 days out of 5. They do ask the newbies to attend 3 3 times a week for the first 2-3 months after academy. In my department, there are 62 desks and 145 on the books. Out of the 62 desks, 6 or 7 are assigned to one colleague due to various adjustments etc. All of these colleagues with special adapted desks, do one shift at home. We hotdesk. All of us have a work laptop which we take into the office. Then plug in the cables to use the laptop via the two monitors and keyboard on each desk. When I WFH, I use the laptop screen as my second monitor.

It doesn’t bother me to hotdesk

foodlovefood · 02/11/2026 22:40

We hot desk over 4 offices in different parts of the campus. There are 15 of us split in 3 teams. But most people stick to the same desk in the same office. We have drawers we put our stuff in at the end of the day. We work 1 day at home on a set day as don’t have enough desks for someone in each day.

I am team lead so I end up hot desking in different offices so I can spend a day with each team. Then 1 day in my office and 1 at home. It works as have a laptop I plug into a docking station. Rucksack is my office and coffee in each area.

works well for me. I like routine. My office can be used as a quiet space 4 days a week. Feel more part of a team than sitting away from my teams

Rainbowstar1432 · 02/11/2026 22:43

Gingering · 01/11/2026 15:23

We hot desk. I’ve been at the company 3 years and wouldn’t say I knew my colleagues at all as I barely ever sit next to anyone I know. I drive 45 mins to work to send emails or join zoom calls then drive home. Not talking to anyone during the day is really depressing and lonely as I’m a sociable, chatty person. Most of my colleagues have been there at least 15 years, have got to know everyone pre-COVID and hot desking and have little issue with it. I’m staying at the company as I need the cash but it does depress me to go into work. I in no way feel part of a team.

Edited

Same. Commute to the office, sit next to randoms, speak to nobody in real life, sit on Teams all day. Commute home. Pointless

Puddypuds · 03/11/2026 07:59

I sit at the same desk everyday because I'm in every day but having moved from a traditional work space to the new building, and new hot desking set up, I absolutely agree that the job has lost its soul. The desks are set up to avoid virtually any meaningful human interaction. The camaraderie has vanished as has the support. If you're having a bad day you just put your head down and avoid drawing attention to yourself. Back in the day the support, in the field I work in, made the job. It also improved your ability to interact with customers on a human level. We're now faceless organisation inside and out!

rwalker · 03/11/2026 08:04

Your being ridiculous
find a desk and sit at it
I’ve done it the only bug bare is that you have to be personally more organised and bring with you everything you want
rather than when you have your own desk you can leave all your shit in the draws

dehumanising is completely dramatic

Pedallleur · 03/11/2026 08:28

Nincompoo · 01/11/2026 15:17

We have hot desks but we’ve all chosen our favourite and stick to it 😆

had this at my last job. Sit down at a desk and the person next to me says I'm saving that desk for X. Is X here now or is that just bs? Didn't make me popular but hey go and complain. Also you go to a desk and some cf has 'borrowed' the USB c, the hdmi cable, the hub charger, all of these.

movinghomeadvice · 03/11/2026 08:29

Having my own desk is one of the (many) things I love about being a teacher.

noramoo · 03/11/2026 08:54

I agree OP it's a pain in the backside - I am an office manager and at my last firm it was a constant struggle of people "claiming" desks despite it being hot desking and me then being shot as the messenger when someone sat at "their" desk. Was a midsize 50 person finance firm. Current company have allocated desks thank god.

Auburngal · 03/11/2026 11:00

One thing I don’t get with hot-desking are those who remove the mouse, HMDI cables etc. Why?

Anarchy99 · 03/11/2026 11:07

Auburngal · 03/11/2026 11:00

One thing I don’t get with hot-desking are those who remove the mouse, HMDI cables etc. Why?

Why not?

Maybe not cables but everyone should use their own keyboard and mouse. People use my office when I wfh but hygiene-wise, I don’t want people using my equipment.

Truinio · 03/11/2026 11:13

Gingering · 01/11/2026 15:23

We hot desk. I’ve been at the company 3 years and wouldn’t say I knew my colleagues at all as I barely ever sit next to anyone I know. I drive 45 mins to work to send emails or join zoom calls then drive home. Not talking to anyone during the day is really depressing and lonely as I’m a sociable, chatty person. Most of my colleagues have been there at least 15 years, have got to know everyone pre-COVID and hot desking and have little issue with it. I’m staying at the company as I need the cash but it does depress me to go into work. I in no way feel part of a team.

Edited

This is exactly what my company is suggesting we do. None of my team are based in the UK. So I get to go to London 3 days a week, at £50 a pop train fare, to do exactly what I do at home, but with a lot more background noise, and only one small screen rather than the three nice screens I have in my office at home.

Luckily my boss (not based in the UK) has told me to ignore it. Lots of managers just fiddling the figures for their reports.

Swipe left for the next trending thread