Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that hotdesking is shit and dehumanising for staff who work in an office

213 replies

CurdinHenry · 01/11/2026 14:54

Does anyone still have their "own" desk these days? What sort of sector are you in?

OP posts:
Flibberyjibbert · 01/11/2026 21:25

I'm a clinician so hot desk in between patients. I have never felt "dehumanised" by it. I imagine if I was forced in to sex work, or had my clitoris removed through FGM, or was held in modern day slavery I'd feel dehumanised. Sharing a desk, not so much.

Lobsterteapot · 01/11/2026 21:27

Absolutely @Flibberyjibbert
My mate recently became a NHS consultant and didn’t have a desk let alone a hot desk for the first few days 😂

Wincher · 01/11/2026 21:34

I hot desk but we do have a booking system, can only book desks up to 45 days in advance. Normally once a week when checking into my desk booking I book the next dates I can book. We have two days a week when our team is in and we tend to sit at the same desks, certainly the same bank of desks. We have packs of antibacterial wipes near each bank of desks and the expectation is that we all wipe down our mice/keyboards/desk at the end of the day.

I think with all that in place it works pretty well! We are an organisation of about 200 office-based staff and moved out of a too-big building after lockdown. Now we have about 60 desks. Generally easy enough to get a desk even if you forgot to book, though Wednesdays can be a challenge.

Wincher · 01/11/2026 21:35

Oh yeah and there are lockers available for staff but I don’t feel I need one

WarmHiker · 01/11/2026 21:35

Dehumanizing? Are you always this dramatic about everything?

PrincessFairyWren · 01/11/2026 21:35

PauliesWalnuts · 01/11/2026 15:34

I am in the public sector and we have to hot desk 50%. The main problem is that we only have “day” lockers - nothing can be left overnight. You have to literally schlep everything in - laptop, headset, day book, pens - not great when you are a cycle commuter and also have to bring in your clothes and shoes on a 9 mile hilly commute. I’d like to bring a packed lunch but there’s just no room in my backpack.

I got desk and I hate it. We are required to change sites mid week due to desk availability. I have folders I take with me plus a pencil case, etc because I can’t even leave a pen or a hair elastic behind. I just bought a trolley on wheels to put all my stuff in and showed up for work last week, like a wheelie suitcase.

i absolutely loathe it and it is impacting my feelings about a job I otherwise like.

Freshrain · 01/11/2026 21:37

CurdinHenry · 01/11/2026 17:30

No, I think you need to (look up ageism while you're at it!).

Don't be daft - that's not agism, it is just stating facts, that, if you were working in an office 20 years ago, you were more likely to have been used to having your own desk, whereas those who entered the workforce in the last 10 years are much less likely to have ever had one.

I speak as someone who is now retired.

I had my own desk up until about 2014. Factually, some younger MNers won't have been at work before then.

Fleabagpeabag · 01/11/2026 21:39

Depends whetger there are enough desks. We have 8 between 40. Two of them have been personalised by senior colleagues so no one else uses them. Will add my role means that I am only using said desk for 1/3 my working week, but it's still pretty crap.

Gwenna · 01/11/2026 21:39

CurdinHenry · 01/11/2026 15:27

Yes, I think being treated as an interchangeable pawn on a desk plan instead of a person with an identity and a permanent presence is dehumanising. I think if you don't understand that you're not a very thoughtful person.

I don’t find hot-desking dehumanising. It takes a bit of getting used to but if you focus on your job you don’t notice it. Your attitude and competence at work give you your identity, not a desk and chair. Also - blanket statements about the overall thoughtfulness of those who disagree with you kinda makes you appear the thoughtless one 👀

Freshrain · 01/11/2026 21:40

Lobsterteapot · 01/11/2026 17:52

We hot desk and hand a locker each so I keep a basket with wipes/posh tea bags/paracetamol etc. It’s fine tbh, can’t bear all the crap people used to keep on their desks. Surely most workplaces are clear desk policy since 9/11 anyway?

Surely most workplaces are clear desk policy since 9/11 anyway?

No.

What would it have to do with 9/11 ?

Freshrain · 01/11/2026 21:47

localnotail · 01/11/2026 17:59

I would not see it as an issue as long as I have access to my own computer. Why does it matter?

It is nicer, because you have your chair at the right height, for example.
I've never worked anywhere where staff had lockers, so having your own desk drawers was useful to keep things like your snacks / coffee / hand cream / paracetamol / sanitary products / tea bags and the like. People would have a warm cardi or fleece on the back or their chair quite often, too.

Before everywhere went paperless, you'd also have things like your stapler / spare staples, hole punch, plastic wallets, pens or pencil and notepad etc etc, though I realise you wouldn't need thoem anymore Grin

I worked mostly at home and out on site in the later years of my career, and quite frankly, didn't mind where I put my laptop down - it was nice to upgrade from typing something up whilst it was balanced on your lap in the car - BUT, it is human nature to like to sit in the same place when you go somewhere regularly (ie those who have to be in the office 2 or 3 days every week).

If you observe people anywhere you go often, you'll find people sit in the same places, be that in the pub, in Church, at choir, or even most people's own living room. Just normal human nature.

CurdinHenry · 01/11/2026 21:49

Flibberyjibbert · 01/11/2026 21:25

I'm a clinician so hot desk in between patients. I have never felt "dehumanised" by it. I imagine if I was forced in to sex work, or had my clitoris removed through FGM, or was held in modern day slavery I'd feel dehumanised. Sharing a desk, not so much.

Yes that's so true workers' rights in the UK are pointless for as long as clitoridectomy exists in Sudan
........

OP posts:
CurdinHenry · 01/11/2026 21:50

While we are at it let's legalise theft because it's not as bad as carving off someone's vulva

OP posts:
sillylittlerabbit · 01/11/2026 21:54

It’s the trade off for being able to work from home, really - the jobs where I had my own desk, we were expected in 5 days a week.
I agree it doesn’t my create team camaraderie and I think it’s down to individual managers to offset that, but it’s not as easy as sitting together 5 days a week.

However do I want to go back into the office full time…? No, it feels far more human to decide when I would benefit from being there in person.

CurdinHenry · 01/11/2026 21:55

Gwenna · 01/11/2026 21:39

I don’t find hot-desking dehumanising. It takes a bit of getting used to but if you focus on your job you don’t notice it. Your attitude and competence at work give you your identity, not a desk and chair. Also - blanket statements about the overall thoughtfulness of those who disagree with you kinda makes you appear the thoughtless one 👀

Edited

Blanket statements about those who can't respect the humanity of people who need to be treated with dignity in order to perform their jobs effectively are the opposite of thoughtless

"👀"

OP posts:
CurdinHenry · 01/11/2026 21:55

sillylittlerabbit · 01/11/2026 21:54

It’s the trade off for being able to work from home, really - the jobs where I had my own desk, we were expected in 5 days a week.
I agree it doesn’t my create team camaraderie and I think it’s down to individual managers to offset that, but it’s not as easy as sitting together 5 days a week.

However do I want to go back into the office full time…? No, it feels far more human to decide when I would benefit from being there in person.

It's not though is it. Because the office is pointless and hotdesking proves it.

OP posts:
Motherhubbardscupboard · 01/11/2026 22:06

I have been working for almost 30 years and have never had my own desk. I find it absolutely no bother at all and have never given it much thought. Current set up (in large corporate with London and regional offices) is that you book a desk on an app. We also have a few desks available that can't be booked in advance and are first come first served. I use my laptop keyboard, and have my own mouse, so have never thought about germs. I would however love my own chair as they are not all the same and I find some of them uncomfortable, so I try to swap them round if I'm in early enough.

DancingLions · 01/11/2026 22:07

When I started in an office I had my own desk. Few bits and pieces on it, plant etc. Then we went to clear desks and hot desking. My mood plummeted. I know plenty of people would find it ridiculous but I just can't deal with it. My home is full of stuff because I like having things around me. I can't bear sitting at a barren space for 8 hours straight.

In the end I took a lower paid role purely because it was wfh and I could have my desk set up as I like.

People have jumped on the word dehumanising and yes maybe that's not exactly the right word but I get what the OP means. You dont feel valued as person.

IntentionallyAsymmetrical · 01/11/2026 22:07

I am broadly in favour of hot desking.

Allocated desks only work if absolutely everyone has one and no one has to share - including the person who only works one day a week. Otherwise, people who do not have their own desks have to wander round the office to find a free desk and often have to move personal effects and clutter out of the way. I know this because I was in that position - I was full time but split between two office and I had to 'hot desk' on allocated desks.

The problem with everyone having allocated desks is that it leads to waste because the office will never be 100% occupied due to holidays, part-time colleagues and other absence.

You might argue the clutter problem could be solved by not allowing personal items to be left on desks but if people have to clear their desks anyway, they might as well hot desk.

Anywherebuthere · 01/11/2026 22:18

It was fine. We hot desked within our own teams and sometimes department. Most people knew or recognise who is from what team. Some know each other better than others.

Clear desk policy so nothing personal or otherwise is ever left out to mark ownership of a particular desk. Anything personal is locked away in your own pedestal.

It's the best way to utilise space and work alongside different people as not everyone is in at the same time.

CurdinHenry · 01/11/2026 22:22

Anywherebuthere · 01/11/2026 22:18

It was fine. We hot desked within our own teams and sometimes department. Most people knew or recognise who is from what team. Some know each other better than others.

Clear desk policy so nothing personal or otherwise is ever left out to mark ownership of a particular desk. Anything personal is locked away in your own pedestal.

It's the best way to utilise space and work alongside different people as not everyone is in at the same time.

Edited

So why have offices?

OP posts:
Lobsterteapot · 01/11/2026 22:23

Freshrain · 01/11/2026 21:40

Surely most workplaces are clear desk policy since 9/11 anyway?

No.

What would it have to do with 9/11 ?

Think it goes back to earlier terrorist attacks but the idea is to minimise the amount of confidential paperwork left out.
This is a good idea generally for obvious reasons and we all saw the paper fluttering about after 9/11

PrettyLittleRose · 01/11/2026 22:25

CurdinHenry · 01/11/2026 15:27

Yes, I think being treated as an interchangeable pawn on a desk plan instead of a person with an identity and a permanent presence is dehumanising. I think if you don't understand that you're not a very thoughtful person.

Couldn't agree more. My workplace does it, but I only have to be in 2-3 days a month thank F.

Lobsterteapot · 01/11/2026 22:25

CurdinHenry · 01/11/2026 21:50

While we are at it let's legalise theft because it's not as bad as carving off someone's vulva

Well that’s a quote I wasn’t expecting to read on Mumsnet!

Screamingabdabz · 01/11/2026 22:26

Flibberyjibbert · 01/11/2026 21:25

I'm a clinician so hot desk in between patients. I have never felt "dehumanised" by it. I imagine if I was forced in to sex work, or had my clitoris removed through FGM, or was held in modern day slavery I'd feel dehumanised. Sharing a desk, not so much.

Jeez so as long as we aren't getting our genitals pulverised one way or another then it’s all good eh? We should just put up and shut up? Work in crap conditions without complaining? Ok got it. Back to the workhouse conditions of Victorian era we go! 🙄

Op YANBU.