Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to be absolutely livid with current state of Reception class?

428 replies

NotSoCheerySnail · 21/10/2026 00:53

My 4yo started Reception in September and has already had several incidents involving other children: one child allegedly stabbed her in the upper lip with a pencil and repeatedly snatches and breaks things belonging to her. Another child bit her finger during her first week and her shoulder the following week. Today, a third child apparently threw a dice at her face, leaving her with a bruised lip. The same girl also keeps taking her water bottle & refuses to give it back (my DD has a bottle with spray function that apparently creates “the bottle envy”).

I spoke to the teacher, asking whether my daughter might be provoking the other children. She said my daughter is very well-behaved and isn’t provoking anyone. However, she also said there are simply too many children and their behaviour is difficult to manage.

its a small village school, their Reception class has 28 children. What is going on? Is it just normal behaviour for small kids? I have an older child but I never remember him being hurt like that. Do parents not teach their children how to behave around others anymore or is our school particularly bad at managing their behaviour? Do we just carry on hoping the kids will outgrow it or what do we do? My DD went to pre school with some of these kids but never has she been hurt like that in there.

OP posts:
AgeingMillennial · 24/10/2026 13:30

roaringdragon · 24/10/2026 13:26

People can’t have it all ways. They can’t not have DC in mainstream and object to funding specialist provision and EOTAS/EOTIS/C. It doesn’t work like that.

Some DC would cost less if there were more state SS.

Although my DC wouldn’t. It would still be inappropriate for provision to be made in a school or college for DS1&3. They would still cost a lot - a lot more than £100k. If DS1’s EOTAS provision was cut, it wouldn’t save the state money, his continuing care funding would increase, significantly. If DS3’s EOTIS provision was cut, it wouldn’t save money because his social services package would increase.

And this is another issue. Now we have people with not just one but multiple kids needing expensive packages and taxis. This was unheard of 30 years ago. Why?

These families will be costing the taxpayer hundreds of thousands a year, more if you consider taxis, DLA etc. It’s unaffordable

roaringdragon · 24/10/2026 13:34

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

No, it wouldn’t.

roaringdragon · 24/10/2026 13:35

AgeingMillennial · 24/10/2026 13:28

It does work like that.

The very expensive placements do not offer value for money. Very few of these kids will ever go on to lead taxpaying, law abiding, independent lives.

They don’t have to go to mainstream but that doesn’t automatically mean the alternative should be as expensive as it is now.

There is far more to be considered than whether a child will go on to live independently and work. It is shortsighted to only consider them.

AgeingMillennial · 24/10/2026 13:36

roaringdragon · 24/10/2026 13:35

There is far more to be considered than whether a child will go on to live independently and work. It is shortsighted to only consider them.

It’s not. You can’t offer the economy ‘soft value’. If somebody’s unlikely to ever work, and will live off benefits, what’s the point in a very expensive education? There isn’t one. Of course that doesn’t mean give up on them but the legal bar of what has to be provided is far too high in many cases. Hence why it’s being removed.

suburburban · 24/10/2026 13:40

Autumngirl5 · 24/10/2026 12:42

I realise I am going to be blasted for this. My children are all adults but I find it incredulous when I hear about schools and children's behaviour now. I’m just glad I am not having to cope with it. I do think much of it is due to poor or lazy parenting, lack of common sense and discipline. SEN is sometimes used as an excuse for bad behaviour also. Those poor teachers.

I think you have a good point

roaringdragon · 24/10/2026 13:40

AgeingMillennial · 24/10/2026 13:36

It’s not. You can’t offer the economy ‘soft value’. If somebody’s unlikely to ever work, and will live off benefits, what’s the point in a very expensive education? There isn’t one. Of course that doesn’t mean give up on them but the legal bar of what has to be provided is far too high in many cases. Hence why it’s being removed.

If DS1 doesn’t receive the support in his very expensive package, he would, in the longer run need a higher amount of support and a higher ratio of staff - for his physical health, for his mental health, developmentally and in order to keep him and others safe.

For example, DS1’s very expensive package means he spends less time in hospital and means he has fewer outpatient appointments and home visits by NHS staff. DS1’s very expensive package means the ICB pay less for his continuing care provision now. When he finishes education the cost of that will increase, but it would increase more if his needs weren’t met now. DS1’s very expensive package means he can continue to live at home. Without the package, the state would be forced to house him. All professionals involved agree that would need to be an individual placement. So there wouldn’t be any shoving him in residential care, a shared home or a facility. I could continue giving other examples where saving money in the short term would increase the money spent on DS1 in the long term.

AgeingMillennial · 24/10/2026 13:43

roaringdragon · 24/10/2026 13:40

If DS1 doesn’t receive the support in his very expensive package, he would, in the longer run need a higher amount of support and a higher ratio of staff - for his physical health, for his mental health, developmentally and in order to keep him and others safe.

For example, DS1’s very expensive package means he spends less time in hospital and means he has fewer outpatient appointments and home visits by NHS staff. DS1’s very expensive package means the ICB pay less for his continuing care provision now. When he finishes education the cost of that will increase, but it would increase more if his needs weren’t met now. DS1’s very expensive package means he can continue to live at home. Without the package, the state would be forced to house him. All professionals involved agree that would need to be an individual placement. So there wouldn’t be any shoving him in residential care, a shared home or a facility. I could continue giving other examples where saving money in the short term would increase the money spent on DS1 in the long term.

I’m just not sure it’s as black and white a picture as you paint here.

I object to the premise that unless we spend hundreds of thousands a year on somebody they’ll cost millions. It’s like the taxpayer is being held to ransom by increasingly unaffordable demands.

roaringdragon · 24/10/2026 13:46

AgeingMillennial · 24/10/2026 13:43

I’m just not sure it’s as black and white a picture as you paint here.

I object to the premise that unless we spend hundreds of thousands a year on somebody they’ll cost millions. It’s like the taxpayer is being held to ransom by increasingly unaffordable demands.

Believe it, don’t believe it. I don’t care. You don’t know DS1 or his disabilities. You haven’t got a clue. It isn’t just my view. It is the view of every professional involved in DS1’s care. Even the LA acknowledged it - a SAR revealed that.

Vinvertebrate · 24/10/2026 13:48

AgeingMillennial · 24/10/2026 13:36

It’s not. You can’t offer the economy ‘soft value’. If somebody’s unlikely to ever work, and will live off benefits, what’s the point in a very expensive education? There isn’t one. Of course that doesn’t mean give up on them but the legal bar of what has to be provided is far too high in many cases. Hence why it’s being removed.

By that rationale, what’s the point of keeping anyone alive after age 67 ish? It sounds more like you just don’t like children with non-approved (by you) disabilities.

But if it makes you feel better, DH and I have paid tax in six figures for most years in the last 2 decades. I presume you are in the same position, since you are so concerned about “taxpayers’” money being wasted on disabled children.

If I’d been running off to relieve DS’ teacher every 5 minutes, I wouldn’t have paid my share of that, obviously. And I’d be costing the taxpayer more in a residential MH facility.

T1Dmama · 24/10/2026 13:50

I don’t know what’s happened these past few years but my friend is a teacher and has been for 20 plus years.
last year she told me that ALL the TA’s from the upper school (equivalent of juniors) were being pulled out of classes and were ALL being put into reception classes. So all the 7-11 year old classes were going from a teacher and at least 1 TA to just a teacher!… reception classes were then presumably having at least 3 teaching assistants each… if not more!
she said this was due to the extremely high level of children entering reception with extreme behavioural issues and / or SEN.
This year I’ve asked her how her new class is (she teaches year 4 or 5) and she’s told me there is one student who makes her want to quit to her job! The student is what I’d assume between 8 & 10 & my friend says they have full blown tantrums like a toddler, lay on the floor kicking and screaming, my friend can’t take her out of the class and leave her other 29 students, but can’t put the student outside the classroom alone either!…. Student is disrupting the learning ability of the whole class which is just awful!
I do not agree with pupils like this (whatever their diagnosis) being allowed to attend mainstream schools. They disrupt the whole class and it’s so unfair on all the other pupils… my daughter had a
child in care join her class in year 4, she was abusive and used to strike the teacher, she’d run out of class and hide sending the whole school into lockdown, I was actually relieved when lockdown happened during covid and we could homeschool! Thankfully the child did not come back after lockdown!

So many children have ECHP’s now that say 1:1 but the funding isn’t there and they simply aren’t getting the support they need.

I don’t know what happened years ago but we never ever had this behaviour when I was at school and we still had class sizes of 30!

daffodilandtulip · 24/10/2026 13:56

EYFS is wild lately. I’ve been bruised and bleeding on more than one occasion.

sausageth · 24/10/2026 14:00

Autumngirl5 · 24/10/2026 12:42

I realise I am going to be blasted for this. My children are all adults but I find it incredulous when I hear about schools and children's behaviour now. I’m just glad I am not having to cope with it. I do think much of it is due to poor or lazy parenting, lack of common sense and discipline. SEN is sometimes used as an excuse for bad behaviour also. Those poor teachers.

Nah, you're just saying what alot of people are thinking.

Vinvertebrate · 24/10/2026 14:21

AgeingMillennial · 24/10/2026 13:17

Well said. We’re all tired now.

I’m sorry that you’re tired, but you are not as tired as the average SEND parent, honestly. Many of us have kids that don’t sleep. (I haven’t had a full night since early 2016). We have to fight for every scrap of resource our DC need, whilst also fighting attitudes like those on this thread.

Trust me, if something as elementary as giving DS the odd bollocking and saying “no” more frequently could fix this nightmare, I would have done it years ago. For my own well-being and sanity as well as DS.

Vinvertebrate · 24/10/2026 14:22

sausageth · 24/10/2026 14:00

Nah, you're just saying what alot of people are thinking.

They may be thinking it, but judging from the number of deletions on this thread, it’s still ableist hate speech and has not become socially acceptable in most circles. Thankfully.

PenelopeShadow · 24/10/2026 14:45

I think you're wrong there @Vinvertebrate

It only takes one or two people to complain about a post and it can be deleted and there are one or two people on this thread, including yourself, who might feel justified in doing that.

But, you are kidding yourself if you think that attitudes aren't changing. Many many parents are asking themselves why violent children have a right to sit alongside their children in class, frightening them and their teacher.

I don't know why those children are violent and, frankly, I don't care because my child being poked in the eye with a compass suffers whatever the reason. can anyone, who has a non violent child in a primary school disagree with that.

So, don't feel that because one or two deletions on a vested thread means that most people are comfortable with violent children sitting next to and potentially harming their own children, including SEN children.

They're not and nor should they be. Get yourself down to the school gate and listen to what parents are saying. They might not say it to the parent of a violent child but when you're not there, you can bet that they are.

Attitudes are changing-even a year ago the OP would have been roundly castigated for starting this thread but now, apart from a handful of prolific posters, not so much.

Most of us do not want violent dangerous children in our classrooms. Attitudes are changing and changed laws will follow.

In the meantime, measures will be put in place like an expectation that a violent child will be handed over to its parents until a secure place can be found and if it can't...it's still not my child's problem.

Will it be overnight? No. But it's coming.

it's been an experiment and it's failed. More of us have to say it in order to encourage those who agree but are too cowed to say it, to get on board.

Onbdy · 24/10/2026 14:46

ownedbymydogs · 21/10/2026 04:07

Welcome to UK primary schools today. Why more parents aren’t up in arms is beyond me. I’ve worked in schools for decades and the violence is normalised to a level that would have other workplaces closed down.

There are no punishments, just ‘restorative conversations’, and definitely no exclusions. We all have to bow to the great god of SEN (especially most SEN children who just want a calm place to learn) and use it to excuse the most appalling behaviour.

And yet all we bloody talk about is ‘safeguarding’.

The teacher probably isn’t inexperienced. Just exhausted and planning her escape.

Exactly this! No it’s not acceptable OP. Teachers are coping with much more extreme behaviour and they are powerless to issue consequences. If they raise any issues or ask for support then they are judged and made to feel that it’s their fault.
Take it from a former teacher, parents need to be raising these issues and taking action because short of leaving (as many are doing) there isn’t anything teachers can do to improve the situation.

Kirbert2 · 24/10/2026 15:14

PenelopeShadow · 24/10/2026 14:45

I think you're wrong there @Vinvertebrate

It only takes one or two people to complain about a post and it can be deleted and there are one or two people on this thread, including yourself, who might feel justified in doing that.

But, you are kidding yourself if you think that attitudes aren't changing. Many many parents are asking themselves why violent children have a right to sit alongside their children in class, frightening them and their teacher.

I don't know why those children are violent and, frankly, I don't care because my child being poked in the eye with a compass suffers whatever the reason. can anyone, who has a non violent child in a primary school disagree with that.

So, don't feel that because one or two deletions on a vested thread means that most people are comfortable with violent children sitting next to and potentially harming their own children, including SEN children.

They're not and nor should they be. Get yourself down to the school gate and listen to what parents are saying. They might not say it to the parent of a violent child but when you're not there, you can bet that they are.

Attitudes are changing-even a year ago the OP would have been roundly castigated for starting this thread but now, apart from a handful of prolific posters, not so much.

Most of us do not want violent dangerous children in our classrooms. Attitudes are changing and changed laws will follow.

In the meantime, measures will be put in place like an expectation that a violent child will be handed over to its parents until a secure place can be found and if it can't...it's still not my child's problem.

Will it be overnight? No. But it's coming.

it's been an experiment and it's failed. More of us have to say it in order to encourage those who agree but are too cowed to say it, to get on board.

I don't think it is pp who is kidding themselves. Discrimination laws would have to be changed to allow disability discrimination and obviously that wouldn't only affect denying disabled children an education. It would apply to all people with disabilities and wouldn't be a good look for any government.

Potential changes are currently in motion which would actually encourage more SEND children in mainstream, not less. So it is currently going in the opposite direction if anything.

Vinvertebrate · 24/10/2026 16:02

PenelopeShadow · 24/10/2026 14:45

I think you're wrong there @Vinvertebrate

It only takes one or two people to complain about a post and it can be deleted and there are one or two people on this thread, including yourself, who might feel justified in doing that.

But, you are kidding yourself if you think that attitudes aren't changing. Many many parents are asking themselves why violent children have a right to sit alongside their children in class, frightening them and their teacher.

I don't know why those children are violent and, frankly, I don't care because my child being poked in the eye with a compass suffers whatever the reason. can anyone, who has a non violent child in a primary school disagree with that.

So, don't feel that because one or two deletions on a vested thread means that most people are comfortable with violent children sitting next to and potentially harming their own children, including SEN children.

They're not and nor should they be. Get yourself down to the school gate and listen to what parents are saying. They might not say it to the parent of a violent child but when you're not there, you can bet that they are.

Attitudes are changing-even a year ago the OP would have been roundly castigated for starting this thread but now, apart from a handful of prolific posters, not so much.

Most of us do not want violent dangerous children in our classrooms. Attitudes are changing and changed laws will follow.

In the meantime, measures will be put in place like an expectation that a violent child will be handed over to its parents until a secure place can be found and if it can't...it's still not my child's problem.

Will it be overnight? No. But it's coming.

it's been an experiment and it's failed. More of us have to say it in order to encourage those who agree but are too cowed to say it, to get on board.

I am not sure whether you are being deliberately obtuse, looking for an argument, or whether you genuinely can’t grasp the simple point that I and others are making. Almost everything in your post is counterfactual, illogical, or both.

Nobody sensible wants violent children in MS. It’s awful for everyone - those whose education is disrupted and those who are disruptive, because often that behaviour is a distressed child in fight-or-flight mode. Attitudes may well change, but public opinion rarely reflects reality. If it was up to the public, we’d still have capital punishment, for example. As it is, the state (thankfully) hasn’t executed anyone for half a century.

To make the kind of changes you’re advocating, ie to kick disabled DC out of education and provide them with nothing but gruel and a blackboard, the UK would have to remove the state’s responsibility to educate children. We cannot have a credible rule that removes the right from certain children only, and it’s not even worth debating, because it simply won’t ever happen.

So if we accept that a right to education includes educating children whose disabilities don’t meet the Penelope-approved-standard, then we need to find a way of educating certain SEND children in a way that does not disrupt the other children. Unfortunately, the only current way to secure specialist provision is to fail horribly in MS, and I suspect we agree that is 100% wrong.

The point that I and others are making is that current SEND reforms mean the disruptive child’s route out of MS is even LESS likely to happen. The presumption is MS and the government has generously allocated c. two pence to each MS school to provide the kind of resources generally only available in specialists while charge a fortune. Can you see the flaw in this plan yet?

So when SEND parents refer to our DC’s right to an education, we don’t mean “at the expense of other DC”. We agree that is takes far too long to remove a disregulated child, but want to point out first that is not our fault, and second, that everyone’s DC are going to have to get used to a higher level of needs being met in MS, because that is exactly what the government is planning. I don’t want it, you don’t want it, but here we are. I’ve signed several petitions and written to/met with my MP about it. What have you done, other than berate strangers on here?

I am also not sure what you’re objecting to. My child was born disabled. He has level 3 autism, diagnosed at age 3. He has seen specialists since age 1, and has cost the LA and the NHS a small fortune. Do you accept that his disability is real? If so, would you object to other disabled children receiving an education that is more costly than average? I imagine that higher education cost applies to blind or deaf children, for example. Do you also object to that? If not, why not?

The idea that the NHS - which rations everything from knee replacements to antibiotics - would waste so much money on something that could be avoided is just nonsense. Ditto for the LA - the cost of SEND is higher than anticipated, but the solution to that is not to remove rights from vulnerable children.

If you don’t accept that his disability - or the disability of others like him - is real, what makes you think you know better than countless professors, psychiatrists, educators and charities that have worked with ND people - in their many and varied presentations - for decades? It’s just nonsense, isn’t it? Demonstrably so.

fwiw before I had DS I probably had sympathy with the “just needs a bit more parenting” point of view. Then DS came along, different from birth, did the polar opposite of what all the parenting books told me to expect, and I realised that the “more parenting” view was unmitigated horseshit.

Happyhappyday · 24/10/2026 16:19

sideorderofgossip · 21/10/2026 01:11

The teacher sounds inexperienced.

28 is a normal size class.

Only in the UK! Our district aims for 18. 28 is not even legal as a ratio unless you have 3 adults at all times.

LathkillDale · 24/10/2026 16:30

AgeingMillennial · 24/10/2026 13:30

And this is another issue. Now we have people with not just one but multiple kids needing expensive packages and taxis. This was unheard of 30 years ago. Why?

These families will be costing the taxpayer hundreds of thousands a year, more if you consider taxis, DLA etc. It’s unaffordable

Edited

You may not have heard of it, but we did 28 years ago, working for a charity, supporting the parents of children with a group of specific, co morbid SEN.

We frequently heard parents telling us, about how 2/3/4 of their DC had related SEN, and we often recognised the parent had some of the traits to a lesser degree as well. Some even started with “I went to a special school and now my DC is struggling….!”

DD1 was at a specialist school where there were say two siblings, who may have had more siblings in different specialist schools, according to their diagnosis. Conditions that have genetic transmission didn’t appear out of nowhere in the last ten years! It’s just more children, especially girls went undiagnosed and left to struggle on their own; or maybe they were better suited to secondary moderns, where they could do practical subjects like cookery, needlework, etc and weren’t expected to do 8 GCSEs. They could leave school and go work in a factory or retail at 16.

Autumngirl5 · 24/10/2026 17:41

Vinvertebrate · 24/10/2026 13:02

How public-spirited of you. I’m sure you say the same thing to children born with heart defects or those suffering from cancer? “Sounds like a you problem, off you pop!”

Edited

What a horrible and ridiculous comment!

Kirbert2 · 24/10/2026 17:55

Autumngirl5 · 24/10/2026 17:41

What a horrible and ridiculous comment!

But telling pp that her disabled child is her problem and her problem only to the point her child shouldn't have the legal right to an education isn't horrible and ridiculous?

Her child can't help his disability any more than her other examples. What's the difference?

Vinvertebrate · 24/10/2026 18:29

Autumngirl5 · 24/10/2026 17:41

What a horrible and ridiculous comment!

You choose the disability, if you don’t like those ones. Apply the PP’s comments about disabled DS being “my problem” to any other type of children’s needs that the state may try to meet. And then ask yourself why my son’s needs should be treated differently?

He was born disabled. He has never had a friend, been invited to a birthday party or watched a film/TV.

He had to fail horribly in MS before the state would provide the help he needed.

He will likely never live independently, but is studying science and maths at greater depth (despite missing months of school - unlawfully) in specialist provision. His IQ is higher than mine (which isn’t too shabby either).

What would you like me to do with him, and why doesn’t the same apply to other disabled children?

Autumngirl5 · 24/10/2026 18:54

Vinvertebrate · 24/10/2026 18:29

You choose the disability, if you don’t like those ones. Apply the PP’s comments about disabled DS being “my problem” to any other type of children’s needs that the state may try to meet. And then ask yourself why my son’s needs should be treated differently?

He was born disabled. He has never had a friend, been invited to a birthday party or watched a film/TV.

He had to fail horribly in MS before the state would provide the help he needed.

He will likely never live independently, but is studying science and maths at greater depth (despite missing months of school - unlawfully) in specialist provision. His IQ is higher than mine (which isn’t too shabby either).

What would you like me to do with him, and why doesn’t the same apply to other disabled children?

I hoped it may have been obvious that I was referring to children who are simply badly behaved and not children who have a serious disability.

roaringdragon · 24/10/2026 19:07

Autumngirl5 · 24/10/2026 18:54

I hoped it may have been obvious that I was referring to children who are simply badly behaved and not children who have a serious disability.

The person @Vinvertebrate was responding to was talking about a child, @Vinvertebrate DS, with a significant disability.

Swipe left for the next trending thread