I am not sure whether you are being deliberately obtuse, looking for an argument, or whether you genuinely can’t grasp the simple point that I and others are making. Almost everything in your post is counterfactual, illogical, or both.
Nobody sensible wants violent children in MS. It’s awful for everyone - those whose education is disrupted and those who are disruptive, because often that behaviour is a distressed child in fight-or-flight mode. Attitudes may well change, but public opinion rarely reflects reality. If it was up to the public, we’d still have capital punishment, for example. As it is, the state (thankfully) hasn’t executed anyone for half a century.
To make the kind of changes you’re advocating, ie to kick disabled DC out of education and provide them with nothing but gruel and a blackboard, the UK would have to remove the state’s responsibility to educate children. We cannot have a credible rule that removes the right from certain children only, and it’s not even worth debating, because it simply won’t ever happen.
So if we accept that a right to education includes educating children whose disabilities don’t meet the Penelope-approved-standard, then we need to find a way of educating certain SEND children in a way that does not disrupt the other children. Unfortunately, the only current way to secure specialist provision is to fail horribly in MS, and I suspect we agree that is 100% wrong.
The point that I and others are making is that current SEND reforms mean the disruptive child’s route out of MS is even LESS likely to happen. The presumption is MS and the government has generously allocated c. two pence to each MS school to provide the kind of resources generally only available in specialists while charge a fortune. Can you see the flaw in this plan yet?
So when SEND parents refer to our DC’s right to an education, we don’t mean “at the expense of other DC”. We agree that is takes far too long to remove a disregulated child, but want to point out first that is not our fault, and second, that everyone’s DC are going to have to get used to a higher level of needs being met in MS, because that is exactly what the government is planning. I don’t want it, you don’t want it, but here we are. I’ve signed several petitions and written to/met with my MP about it. What have you done, other than berate strangers on here?
I am also not sure what you’re objecting to. My child was born disabled. He has level 3 autism, diagnosed at age 3. He has seen specialists since age 1, and has cost the LA and the NHS a small fortune. Do you accept that his disability is real? If so, would you object to other disabled children receiving an education that is more costly than average? I imagine that higher education cost applies to blind or deaf children, for example. Do you also object to that? If not, why not?
The idea that the NHS - which rations everything from knee replacements to antibiotics - would waste so much money on something that could be avoided is just nonsense. Ditto for the LA - the cost of SEND is higher than anticipated, but the solution to that is not to remove rights from vulnerable children.
If you don’t accept that his disability - or the disability of others like him - is real, what makes you think you know better than countless professors, psychiatrists, educators and charities that have worked with ND people - in their many and varied presentations - for decades? It’s just nonsense, isn’t it? Demonstrably so.
fwiw before I had DS I probably had sympathy with the “just needs a bit more parenting” point of view. Then DS came along, different from birth, did the polar opposite of what all the parenting books told me to expect, and I realised that the “more parenting” view was unmitigated horseshit.