Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to be absolutely livid with current state of Reception class?

428 replies

NotSoCheerySnail · 21/10/2026 00:53

My 4yo started Reception in September and has already had several incidents involving other children: one child allegedly stabbed her in the upper lip with a pencil and repeatedly snatches and breaks things belonging to her. Another child bit her finger during her first week and her shoulder the following week. Today, a third child apparently threw a dice at her face, leaving her with a bruised lip. The same girl also keeps taking her water bottle & refuses to give it back (my DD has a bottle with spray function that apparently creates “the bottle envy”).

I spoke to the teacher, asking whether my daughter might be provoking the other children. She said my daughter is very well-behaved and isn’t provoking anyone. However, she also said there are simply too many children and their behaviour is difficult to manage.

its a small village school, their Reception class has 28 children. What is going on? Is it just normal behaviour for small kids? I have an older child but I never remember him being hurt like that. Do parents not teach their children how to behave around others anymore or is our school particularly bad at managing their behaviour? Do we just carry on hoping the kids will outgrow it or what do we do? My DD went to pre school with some of these kids but never has she been hurt like that in there.

OP posts:
GoodChocolate · 23/10/2026 22:10

herecomestheairfryer · 23/10/2026 20:54

My DD is 4th year medicine and said about 70% of her year sat their exams in the designated room for those with SEN. A lot of people self identify now, which isn't always helpful.

It's an absolute pisstake!

Minniena · 23/10/2026 22:13

roaringdragon · 22/10/2026 10:42

I hope those calls home aren’t leading to unlawful, informal exclusions.

do you think violent children should remain in a mainstream school?

roaringdragon · 23/10/2026 22:23

Minniena · 23/10/2026 22:13

do you think violent children should remain in a mainstream school?

Wanting schools to follow the correct process and act lawfully isn’t the same as thinking all DC should be in mainstream schools.

In fact, for those who MS isn’t the right place for, following the correct process builds evidence to support the need for a different setting.

Although there is a right to MS except in very specific circumstances which is a high bar for the LA to prove.

Kirbert2 · 23/10/2026 23:03

Minniena · 23/10/2026 22:13

do you think violent children should remain in a mainstream school?

Do you think schools should be allowed to break the law?

Of course not every child belongs in mainstream but schools still need to follow the correct procedures.

Daisy4569 · 24/10/2026 04:21

Sounds similar to our experience. Was supposed to be a good school but just one thing after another in reception, we went through all the normal procedures but my little one started hating going as it all built up. We moved schools (a little reluctantly in case the problem was common) but they absolutely love school now. Not ideal but some schools/classes just aren’t a a good fit.

Vinvertebrate · 24/10/2026 08:32

Minniena · 23/10/2026 22:13

do you think violent children should remain in a mainstream school?

Well the Department for Education certainly does, because their SEND plan is basically that. No legally enforceable rights for SEND children to receive the provision advised by specialists = cram as many in MS as possible for as long as we can get away with it.

Vinvertebrate · 24/10/2026 08:35

roaringdragon · 23/10/2026 22:23

Wanting schools to follow the correct process and act lawfully isn’t the same as thinking all DC should be in mainstream schools.

In fact, for those who MS isn’t the right place for, following the correct process builds evidence to support the need for a different setting.

Although there is a right to MS except in very specific circumstances which is a high bar for the LA to prove.

And ime LA’s just love reminding SEND parents of their absolute right to leave their child in MS for as long as they wish, even if the school says it can’t meet needs. “Feel free to save us as much money as possible - it’s your right, and bugger the other kids and parents”.

The system absolutely stinks, for everyone.

DarkFate · 24/10/2026 08:44

My son is autistic and need strict boundaries and discipline. He gets this at home (he’s 11 and in year 6) he struggles to navigate social situations, therefore I supervise him closely at parks and remove him if necessary and explain things to him.

At school, he is allowed to do what he wants. There is very little discipline. They get “two minute chats” for bad behaviour. He doesn’t care, he zones the teacher out. He knows he can run amok. In year one the teacher phoned me about it. I explained this to her. I said he likes rules and boundaries. One warning, then tell him he loses his golden time. He did it once, he mostly behaved the rest of the year.

The next year, the teacher phones, I say the same “we can’t do anything outside the behaviour policy” I said well don’t phone me then, I’ve told you how to make him behave better, you won’t do it. I’m miles away at work what can I do. When I explain it to him at home, he thinks he’s allowed to do what he wants as there’s no consequences at school. She asked me to give him consequences at home. I said no, he won’t undersrand that, won’t respect you and I don’t bring him in on a Monday and ask you to discipline him at school for stuff that went on at home.

I finally moved him to a school with actual consequences and he’s doing much better!

PenelopeShadow · 24/10/2026 09:14

roaringdragon · 23/10/2026 16:29

If the school is sending DC home during the day, they need to follow the correct procedure and formally suspend. Just sending them home informally is an unlawful informal exclusion. The school shouldn’t be calling home and requesting parents come in to deal with DC either.

The school absolutely should be calling home and telling (not requesting) that parents come in to deal with their own DC.

Why?

Because it would mean that my child and her classmates would enjoy a peaceful atmosphere, not in fear, and might actually learn something.

The behaviour of one child should not be allowed to destroy the peace, happiness and education of 29 others.
Why is my child and her classmates expected to sacrifice all that.
The principle of The Greater Good comes into play here.

It is fucking mad and, in my experience, a growing number of us are pissed off with it.

That's that and if the law doesn't allow it then the law should be changed forthwith. Mr Burnham would find it would be a very, very popular move.

roaringdragon · 24/10/2026 11:32

PenelopeShadow · 24/10/2026 09:14

The school absolutely should be calling home and telling (not requesting) that parents come in to deal with their own DC.

Why?

Because it would mean that my child and her classmates would enjoy a peaceful atmosphere, not in fear, and might actually learn something.

The behaviour of one child should not be allowed to destroy the peace, happiness and education of 29 others.
Why is my child and her classmates expected to sacrifice all that.
The principle of The Greater Good comes into play here.

It is fucking mad and, in my experience, a growing number of us are pissed off with it.

That's that and if the law doesn't allow it then the law should be changed forthwith. Mr Burnham would find it would be a very, very popular move.

Thankfully, the law disagrees with you.

Unlawfully excluding DC doesn’t actually help any DC in the school. It often means DC whose parents want their DC in a different setting actually spend longer in maisntream. The exact opposite of what you want.

Widespread unlawful exclusions like you want would also increase the cost to the state as more parents pursued DD claims.

Those who don’t want some or all SEN DC in MS often also object to money being spent on SEN DC. I hope you realise DC not being in mainstream is costly.

I also hope you took part in the SEN Reform consultations. If the SEN Reforms go ahead as proposed more DC with SEN will be in MS. Sadly, too many parents of DC without SEN think it doesn’t matter, their DC don’t have SEN. SEN and SEN Reforms affect everyone.

PenelopeShadow · 24/10/2026 11:45

The law is out of date and no longer fit for purpose and believe me, in five years time, it will no longer exist in a form that allows the majority of class pupils to suffer in order to accommodate one pupil.

When parents are the one asked to inconvenience themselves, not other children, not the teacher, you will soon find a big improvement.

That's natural justice, common sense and fair and that's what most people-albeit not on people on this vested thread-want.

roaringdragon · 24/10/2026 11:51

Nice bit of parent blame. You can’t magic SEN out of child no matter how much you want to blame the parents or inconvenience them.

If you really cared about fairness, you would be in uproar about schools and LAs acting unlawfully.

in five years time, it will no longer exist in a form that allows the majority of class pupils to suffer

Clearly you haven’t read anything about the SEN Reforms then.

PenelopeShadow · 24/10/2026 12:13

As you are aware, I have never said you can "magic" SEN out of children.

I am concerned with the majority of children who are forced to share classrooms with violent and disruptive pupils, SEN or not.

Those children are paying for this. They are unhappy, often fearful, not getting the attention they deserve and their education is being impacted.

Why are those children paying the price? It is not on.

The Greater Good is to have the parents come up and take the violent child out and thus instead of a class of 30 upset children, you now have one upset child and 29 happy ones. You sound as if the you don't give a shit about those children.

If my child is hit on the head by a flying chair, thrown by a child who is frequently out of control, should I think it is a price worth paying?

I don't and there is a groundswell of voices starting to whisper, who will one day shout, that the safety and education of 29 children trumps the needs of one.

You can put as much faith as you like in the current law and reforms but be aware, those things can change and as parents of frightened children raise their voices and refuse to accept that 29 children pay a price, these current laws will be quickly dismantled.

Whole classes should not suffer because of one child and you know that's the case and if you don't, you should give your head a wobble.

AgeingMillennial · 24/10/2026 12:14

NotSoCheerySnail · 21/10/2026 00:53

My 4yo started Reception in September and has already had several incidents involving other children: one child allegedly stabbed her in the upper lip with a pencil and repeatedly snatches and breaks things belonging to her. Another child bit her finger during her first week and her shoulder the following week. Today, a third child apparently threw a dice at her face, leaving her with a bruised lip. The same girl also keeps taking her water bottle & refuses to give it back (my DD has a bottle with spray function that apparently creates “the bottle envy”).

I spoke to the teacher, asking whether my daughter might be provoking the other children. She said my daughter is very well-behaved and isn’t provoking anyone. However, she also said there are simply too many children and their behaviour is difficult to manage.

its a small village school, their Reception class has 28 children. What is going on? Is it just normal behaviour for small kids? I have an older child but I never remember him being hurt like that. Do parents not teach their children how to behave around others anymore or is our school particularly bad at managing their behaviour? Do we just carry on hoping the kids will outgrow it or what do we do? My DD went to pre school with some of these kids but never has she been hurt like that in there.

Parents just aren’t disciplining. Their kids shitty behaviour is dismissed as ‘developmentally age appropriate’ or ‘biologically normal’ and they don’t get a grasp on it early enough. They then flail around trying to put boundaries in when the kid reaches 6 or 7 and when that fails it’s the enviable CAMHS/assessment referral.

AgeingMillennial · 24/10/2026 12:15

roaringdragon · 24/10/2026 11:51

Nice bit of parent blame. You can’t magic SEN out of child no matter how much you want to blame the parents or inconvenience them.

If you really cared about fairness, you would be in uproar about schools and LAs acting unlawfully.

in five years time, it will no longer exist in a form that allows the majority of class pupils to suffer

Clearly you haven’t read anything about the SEN Reforms then.

Edited

I mean, is it it SEN? Where were the chair throwing SEN kids 30 years ago? And no they were not ‘in institutions’. They were instead full of kids with actual physical and learning disabilities.

roaringdragon · 24/10/2026 12:21

PenelopeShadow · 24/10/2026 12:13

As you are aware, I have never said you can "magic" SEN out of children.

I am concerned with the majority of children who are forced to share classrooms with violent and disruptive pupils, SEN or not.

Those children are paying for this. They are unhappy, often fearful, not getting the attention they deserve and their education is being impacted.

Why are those children paying the price? It is not on.

The Greater Good is to have the parents come up and take the violent child out and thus instead of a class of 30 upset children, you now have one upset child and 29 happy ones. You sound as if the you don't give a shit about those children.

If my child is hit on the head by a flying chair, thrown by a child who is frequently out of control, should I think it is a price worth paying?

I don't and there is a groundswell of voices starting to whisper, who will one day shout, that the safety and education of 29 children trumps the needs of one.

You can put as much faith as you like in the current law and reforms but be aware, those things can change and as parents of frightened children raise their voices and refuse to accept that 29 children pay a price, these current laws will be quickly dismantled.

Whole classes should not suffer because of one child and you know that's the case and if you don't, you should give your head a wobble.

Expecting there to be a big improvement just because a child’s parents are ‘inconvenienced’ is expecting SEN to magically disappear.

The SEN Reforms are going to push more into mainstream. You might not like that, you might think things will change, but you obviously haven’t read anything about the SEN Reforms and the direction of travel.

It is not that I “don't give a shit about those children”. I care about all children. I just disagree with you on how to do that. IMO, meeting the needs of DC with SEN benefits all. Unlawfully excluding DC doesn’t help anyone. It means more DC with SEN spend longer in mainstream. It means more DC with SEN don’t have their needs met. It costs the state more in the long run. And all these things have an effect on all DC, not just those with SEN. All DC are entitled to receive an education. Not just the ones who fit neatly into the box.

roaringdragon · 24/10/2026 12:23

AgeingMillennial · 24/10/2026 12:15

I mean, is it it SEN? Where were the chair throwing SEN kids 30 years ago? And no they were not ‘in institutions’. They were instead full of kids with actual physical and learning disabilities.

Edited

Any child who is displaying behaviour to the level they are repeatedly being unlawfully, informally excluded, meets the legal definition of having SEN.

DC with SEN existed 30 years ago. Some were not in maisntream. Some were in institutions, though. They weren’t just for DC with PD and LD.

AgeingMillennial · 24/10/2026 12:24

roaringdragon · 24/10/2026 12:23

Any child who is displaying behaviour to the level they are repeatedly being unlawfully, informally excluded, meets the legal definition of having SEN.

DC with SEN existed 30 years ago. Some were not in maisntream. Some were in institutions, though. They weren’t just for DC with PD and LD.

There were wayyyyyy fewer of them. It HAS risen in the last 10 years. By a lot. Why?

PenelopeShadow · 24/10/2026 12:27

I des[pair at you @roaringdragon and can't be bothered to argue the toss.

Instead, I put my faith in the view that my view is one shared by most parents whose children "fit in the box" to use your term and who don't want them paying with their childhood and education.

They want the parents of that child to be summoned to the school each and every time they do something violent. There is nothing unreasonable about that.

Six year old children crying because they know one child is making their lives a misery and people like you defending it because you think the majority should suffer. and that majority includes non-violent SEN children who are even more terrified!

My last word to you is that you are living in a Fools' Paradise if you think that people will stay quiet about this.

roaringdragon · 24/10/2026 12:30

AgeingMillennial · 24/10/2026 12:24

There were wayyyyyy fewer of them. It HAS risen in the last 10 years. By a lot. Why?

There hasn’t been such a big increase in the proportion of DC with SEN as some like to believe. The most recent statistics released this year show 20.8% of pupils have SEN. In 2010, it was 20.9% or 21.1% (depending on which statistics you look at - I think it is a rounding issue adding up SA, SA+ and SSEN). In 2005, it was 18%.

Vinvertebrate · 24/10/2026 12:30

PenelopeShadow · 24/10/2026 11:45

The law is out of date and no longer fit for purpose and believe me, in five years time, it will no longer exist in a form that allows the majority of class pupils to suffer in order to accommodate one pupil.

When parents are the one asked to inconvenience themselves, not other children, not the teacher, you will soon find a big improvement.

That's natural justice, common sense and fair and that's what most people-albeit not on people on this vested thread-want.

Respectfully, in the time you’ve spent posting on here, you could have written to your MP asking them to oppose the SEND reforms for the benefit of the majority of children. There is no point posting on here - none of us can do anything about it. We are all stuck with a crap system in which parents have to leave their SEND DC in MS, often disrupting others, to get a sniff of a specialist place. Nobody here is condoning it.

The carnage you are describing is literally future government strategy on SEND. It’s intended to appease LA’s who think proper SEND provision costs too much. Your comment that “this won’t be the case in 5 years” is the opposite of reality. There will be more SEND kids in MS in 5 years, and more children and parents expected to simply suck it up.

Nobody is saying that 29 children should suffer because of 1. But the reforms will make that more likely, and are regressive. It’s the equivalent of abolishing speed limits because issuing tickets is too costly for the police budget.

roaringdragon · 24/10/2026 12:32

PenelopeShadow · 24/10/2026 12:27

I des[pair at you @roaringdragon and can't be bothered to argue the toss.

Instead, I put my faith in the view that my view is one shared by most parents whose children "fit in the box" to use your term and who don't want them paying with their childhood and education.

They want the parents of that child to be summoned to the school each and every time they do something violent. There is nothing unreasonable about that.

Six year old children crying because they know one child is making their lives a misery and people like you defending it because you think the majority should suffer. and that majority includes non-violent SEN children who are even more terrified!

My last word to you is that you are living in a Fools' Paradise if you think that people will stay quiet about this.

Edited

I don’t want parents to stay quiet about the lack of SEN support. I would be glad if they supported parents of DC with SEN to improve SEN provision. I would be happy if they took an interest in the SEN Reforms and spoke out about their concerns about pushing more into mainstream.

Parents are unreasonable if they condone schools and LAs acting unlawfully.

I didn’t say the majority should suffer. Stop making nonsense up.

Vinvertebrate · 24/10/2026 12:38

They want the parents of that child to be summoned to the school each and every time they do something violent. There is nothing unreasonable about that.

You clearly cannot conceive of a world in which a child can behave like this despite being parented appropriately, disciplined, having consequences for actions, etc. You are utterly wrong.

As I posted upthread, I am a lawyer with a decade of senior leadership behind me before DS came along. DH had a similar career path in medicine. Respectfully, it’s not us, it’s DS, and if the school had “summoned” me every time DS kicked off, I would have told them to jog on. Perhaps less politely.

He’s absolutely fine in specialist - calm, learning well and happy as a pig in mud. We all knew what he needed, but it took 2 years. Your ire would be better directed at the LA.

Autumngirl5 · 24/10/2026 12:42

I realise I am going to be blasted for this. My children are all adults but I find it incredulous when I hear about schools and children's behaviour now. I’m just glad I am not having to cope with it. I do think much of it is due to poor or lazy parenting, lack of common sense and discipline. SEN is sometimes used as an excuse for bad behaviour also. Those poor teachers.

Vinvertebrate · 24/10/2026 12:42

roaringdragon · 24/10/2026 12:30

There hasn’t been such a big increase in the proportion of DC with SEN as some like to believe. The most recent statistics released this year show 20.8% of pupils have SEN. In 2010, it was 20.9% or 21.1% (depending on which statistics you look at - I think it is a rounding issue adding up SA, SA+ and SSEN). In 2005, it was 18%.

The only convincing factor I’ve read about the purported SEND increase relates to parental age. Older parents tend to have higher rates of autistic children and we’re having (first) DC much later these days. We are older parents with an autistic DS, fwiw.

Swipe left for the next trending thread