Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to be absolutely livid with current state of Reception class?

428 replies

NotSoCheerySnail · 21/10/2026 00:53

My 4yo started Reception in September and has already had several incidents involving other children: one child allegedly stabbed her in the upper lip with a pencil and repeatedly snatches and breaks things belonging to her. Another child bit her finger during her first week and her shoulder the following week. Today, a third child apparently threw a dice at her face, leaving her with a bruised lip. The same girl also keeps taking her water bottle & refuses to give it back (my DD has a bottle with spray function that apparently creates “the bottle envy”).

I spoke to the teacher, asking whether my daughter might be provoking the other children. She said my daughter is very well-behaved and isn’t provoking anyone. However, she also said there are simply too many children and their behaviour is difficult to manage.

its a small village school, their Reception class has 28 children. What is going on? Is it just normal behaviour for small kids? I have an older child but I never remember him being hurt like that. Do parents not teach their children how to behave around others anymore or is our school particularly bad at managing their behaviour? Do we just carry on hoping the kids will outgrow it or what do we do? My DD went to pre school with some of these kids but never has she been hurt like that in there.

OP posts:
AgeingMillennial · 24/10/2026 12:46

Autumngirl5 · 24/10/2026 12:42

I realise I am going to be blasted for this. My children are all adults but I find it incredulous when I hear about schools and children's behaviour now. I’m just glad I am not having to cope with it. I do think much of it is due to poor or lazy parenting, lack of common sense and discipline. SEN is sometimes used as an excuse for bad behaviour also. Those poor teachers.

I think they honestly, genuinely, in good faith cannot tell that their child doesn’t have SEN and instead does not have proper boundaries, routines and habits.

PenelopeShadow · 24/10/2026 12:47

Vinvertebrate · 24/10/2026 12:30

Respectfully, in the time you’ve spent posting on here, you could have written to your MP asking them to oppose the SEND reforms for the benefit of the majority of children. There is no point posting on here - none of us can do anything about it. We are all stuck with a crap system in which parents have to leave their SEND DC in MS, often disrupting others, to get a sniff of a specialist place. Nobody here is condoning it.

The carnage you are describing is literally future government strategy on SEND. It’s intended to appease LA’s who think proper SEND provision costs too much. Your comment that “this won’t be the case in 5 years” is the opposite of reality. There will be more SEND kids in MS in 5 years, and more children and parents expected to simply suck it up.

Nobody is saying that 29 children should suffer because of 1. But the reforms will make that more likely, and are regressive. It’s the equivalent of abolishing speed limits because issuing tickets is too costly for the police budget.

There is plenty of point of posting on here because that is how a change in attitudes is often detected. Violent children have no place in MS, whether the violent child has SEN or not. Other children should not have to accept it, whether they have SEN or not.

The more parents who say that violent children should be removed from class-kept at home if that is cheapest and there is no-where else-makes the view more acceptable.

People can see that it is perfectly acceptable to say, " No, I do not want that chair flinging child, who bites, pinches, screams and kicks to be sitting next to my child and I don't give a shit if his parents have to come to the school every day and remove him."

That is a normal response.

Unless, you are happy to go to work and be bitten, punched, stabbed, screamed at, have your hair set on fire and have flying missiles thrown at you. If you're not, why do you think children and their teachers should accept it?

As more children are sacrificed, more parents will say it and eventually, eventually, there will be no shame attached to it and violent children will no longer be tolerated in main stream.

There will be those who disagree-generally those with an agenda.

roaringdragon · 24/10/2026 12:56

Wanting schools (and LAs) to act lawfully (and that includes following the correct, lawful suspension process where appropriate) and wanting DC with SEN to have their needs met, which will benefit all DC, isn’t the same as wanting the majority to suffer.

All DC are entitled to education. No-one can be forced to accept EHE. No-one can be forced to accept provision at home - case law shows us this. Forcing DC to remain at home might be cheaper in the immediate, but it costs the state more in the long run. Very short sighted of you to want DC hidden away at home.

Oh and I am hit, kicked, bitten, head-butted daily. Precisely nothing to do with my parenting. Everything to do with DS1’s complex needs. All the professionals, and there are many, involved agree.

Thankfully DS1 isn’t in mainstream. It would be completely the wrong place for him. Any school would be. He has an expensive EOTAS package. Something which many of the same parents who object to DC with SEN being in MS also object to. Something which is going to become less common if the SEN Reform proposals go ahead because the proposals plan to restrict EOTAS/EOTIS/C.

If wanting all DC to have their needs met and receive a suitable and appropriate education and wanting schools and LAs to act lawfully is an agenda, then, yes, I have an agenda.

Vinvertebrate · 24/10/2026 12:58

My DS has done all of those things - flung a chair at a teacher, kicked, hit, bitten etc. He remains a child who is legally entitled to an education (and I’d bet my house that his IQ is higher than the average MN’er). It doesn’t matter how how many parents complain - all civilised countries rightly educate children as a matter of law.

I have never suggested that violence is acceptable in MS. I have said that it’s inevitable children like DS remain in MS too long, unless there is a radical improvement in the system by which LA’s allocate specialist resources. The SEND proposals make the current situation worse, not better.

It’s a bit of a straw man really, because nobody is actually condoning the thing you are complaining about. But fwiw I would not have obediently trotted along to school and removed DS. Ever. It’s only by making it a “them” problem - at least between 9am and 3pm - that the LA eventually got off its useless, bloated backside and made sure DS had a suitable education environment. And if it took me (legally qualified for 25 years) 2 years to force the LA’s hand, you can imagine how long it takes the average kid. And if the reforms are implemented, there will be no legal route to any provision other than MS.

AgeingMillennial · 24/10/2026 13:00

Vinvertebrate · 24/10/2026 12:58

My DS has done all of those things - flung a chair at a teacher, kicked, hit, bitten etc. He remains a child who is legally entitled to an education (and I’d bet my house that his IQ is higher than the average MN’er). It doesn’t matter how how many parents complain - all civilised countries rightly educate children as a matter of law.

I have never suggested that violence is acceptable in MS. I have said that it’s inevitable children like DS remain in MS too long, unless there is a radical improvement in the system by which LA’s allocate specialist resources. The SEND proposals make the current situation worse, not better.

It’s a bit of a straw man really, because nobody is actually condoning the thing you are complaining about. But fwiw I would not have obediently trotted along to school and removed DS. Ever. It’s only by making it a “them” problem - at least between 9am and 3pm - that the LA eventually got off its useless, bloated backside and made sure DS had a suitable education environment. And if it took me (legally qualified for 25 years) 2 years to force the LA’s hand, you can imagine how long it takes the average kid. And if the reforms are implemented, there will be no legal route to any provision other than MS.

He’s your son. He’s your problem, to put it simply. Not theirs.

AgeingMillennial · 24/10/2026 13:01

roaringdragon · 24/10/2026 12:56

Wanting schools (and LAs) to act lawfully (and that includes following the correct, lawful suspension process where appropriate) and wanting DC with SEN to have their needs met, which will benefit all DC, isn’t the same as wanting the majority to suffer.

All DC are entitled to education. No-one can be forced to accept EHE. No-one can be forced to accept provision at home - case law shows us this. Forcing DC to remain at home might be cheaper in the immediate, but it costs the state more in the long run. Very short sighted of you to want DC hidden away at home.

Oh and I am hit, kicked, bitten, head-butted daily. Precisely nothing to do with my parenting. Everything to do with DS1’s complex needs. All the professionals, and there are many, involved agree.

Thankfully DS1 isn’t in mainstream. It would be completely the wrong place for him. Any school would be. He has an expensive EOTAS package. Something which many of the same parents who object to DC with SEN being in MS also object to. Something which is going to become less common if the SEN Reform proposals go ahead because the proposals plan to restrict EOTAS/EOTIS/C.

If wanting all DC to have their needs met and receive a suitable and appropriate education and wanting schools and LAs to act lawfully is an agenda, then, yes, I have an agenda.

They can’t follow the law

There are now so many children with such significant behavioural and personality problems demanding expensive packages that they can’t actually fulfil it

LAs are all in debt to the tune of millions

Vinvertebrate · 24/10/2026 13:02

AgeingMillennial · 24/10/2026 13:00

He’s your son. He’s your problem, to put it simply. Not theirs.

How public-spirited of you. I’m sure you say the same thing to children born with heart defects or those suffering from cancer? “Sounds like a you problem, off you pop!”

AgeingMillennial · 24/10/2026 13:04

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Vinvertebrate · 24/10/2026 13:07

(And you’re wrong - for a change - as a matter of law, fwiw.) My son’s education is very much the LA’s legal responsibility and I’m not going to relieve them of it - it’s not in my son’s interests or mine to do so.

If it’s too expensive, maybe closing all the LA specialist provision was a bit of a fuck up? Because now they’re paying the private sector to deliver the same thing at £100k per head. Whoops!

roaringdragon · 24/10/2026 13:07

AgeingMillennial · 24/10/2026 13:01

They can’t follow the law

There are now so many children with such significant behavioural and personality problems demanding expensive packages that they can’t actually fulfil it

LAs are all in debt to the tune of millions

Schools and LAs can follow the law. Lack of funding, resources and staffing are not lawful excuses. Besides, it is shortsighted. Not meeting needs now costs more in the long run.

If LAs need more money, they could start by looking at the money they waste on representation defending indefensible cases they know they are going to lose, mostly against unrepresented parents. For example, over the years, my LA has spent 6 figures defending appeals I have made to the FtT for DSs’ EHCPs. Barristers, solicitors, paralegals. Including a very nice sum to a barrister to turn up late on the morning of one final hearing and concede. That isn’t including the money the LA has spent on internal staff dealing with my appeals to SENDIST. Every one of my appeals has been successful. They LA knew I would be successful yet spent an inordinate amount of money defending them. Neither does it include the costs the LA has incurred when I have pursued JR proceedings, their costs related to my complaints and LGO claims, or a small claims court case.

roaringdragon · 24/10/2026 13:08

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

You are wrong. Having a high IQ doesn’t mean pp’s DS can understand of that he can use his intelligence in the real world. Even the DWP understand high IQ doesn’t mean one can use it in the real world. It doesn’t mean personality issue.

AgeingMillennial · 24/10/2026 13:09

roaringdragon · 24/10/2026 13:07

Schools and LAs can follow the law. Lack of funding, resources and staffing are not lawful excuses. Besides, it is shortsighted. Not meeting needs now costs more in the long run.

If LAs need more money, they could start by looking at the money they waste on representation defending indefensible cases they know they are going to lose, mostly against unrepresented parents. For example, over the years, my LA has spent 6 figures defending appeals I have made to the FtT for DSs’ EHCPs. Barristers, solicitors, paralegals. Including a very nice sum to a barrister to turn up late on the morning of one final hearing and concede. That isn’t including the money the LA has spent on internal staff dealing with my appeals to SENDIST. Every one of my appeals has been successful. They LA knew I would be successful yet spent an inordinate amount of money defending them. Neither does it include the costs the LA has incurred when I have pursued JR proceedings, their costs related to my complaints and LGO claims, or a small claims court case.

And the defence figure will still be cheaper than whatever it is you were arguing for them to provide. Thats the sad reality.

AgeingMillennial · 24/10/2026 13:10

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Vinvertebrate · 24/10/2026 13:10

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

I’m actually very pleased that neurodevelopmental disability has had so little impact on your life that you are able to deny its existence.

roaringdragon · 24/10/2026 13:11

AgeingMillennial · 24/10/2026 13:09

And the defence figure will still be cheaper than whatever it is you were arguing for them to provide. Thats the sad reality.

They could still oppose an appeal without spending the figures they do on representation to defend it.

And looking at the wider picture rather than just my DC, it can be cheaper in the short term, because it kicks the can down the road, but it isn’t cheaper in the long term.

PenelopeShadow · 24/10/2026 13:12

roaringdragon · 24/10/2026 12:56

Wanting schools (and LAs) to act lawfully (and that includes following the correct, lawful suspension process where appropriate) and wanting DC with SEN to have their needs met, which will benefit all DC, isn’t the same as wanting the majority to suffer.

All DC are entitled to education. No-one can be forced to accept EHE. No-one can be forced to accept provision at home - case law shows us this. Forcing DC to remain at home might be cheaper in the immediate, but it costs the state more in the long run. Very short sighted of you to want DC hidden away at home.

Oh and I am hit, kicked, bitten, head-butted daily. Precisely nothing to do with my parenting. Everything to do with DS1’s complex needs. All the professionals, and there are many, involved agree.

Thankfully DS1 isn’t in mainstream. It would be completely the wrong place for him. Any school would be. He has an expensive EOTAS package. Something which many of the same parents who object to DC with SEN being in MS also object to. Something which is going to become less common if the SEN Reform proposals go ahead because the proposals plan to restrict EOTAS/EOTIS/C.

If wanting all DC to have their needs met and receive a suitable and appropriate education and wanting schools and LAs to act lawfully is an agenda, then, yes, I have an agenda.

But he is not a problem other children should have to endure, is he, if he was in MS.

You keep banging on about the law. Unlike those that Moses carried down the mountain, they are not writ on tablets of stone.

And that's why forums where people can say-This Far and no Further. The majority of people, who don't post but can see them now know that a fair amount of people do not think that a violent child should ever be on the chair next to theirs.

That's why laws are changed. They are in your favour now, They won't always be.

Your violent child is not my child's problem. he is not the problem of her classmates-some of whom are SEN. In what world is that fair?

I don't know why i keep responding to you because as long as your violent child is catered to, all the others who "fit in a box" as you disparagingly say, can fuck off as you don't care.

There are more of us with non violent well behaved children-including SEN children- and the time when we accept our children being shat on is is coming to an end and the law will eventually reflect this.

Attitudes change and the law follows. And that really is that from me.

AgeingMillennial · 24/10/2026 13:17

PenelopeShadow · 24/10/2026 13:12

But he is not a problem other children should have to endure, is he, if he was in MS.

You keep banging on about the law. Unlike those that Moses carried down the mountain, they are not writ on tablets of stone.

And that's why forums where people can say-This Far and no Further. The majority of people, who don't post but can see them now know that a fair amount of people do not think that a violent child should ever be on the chair next to theirs.

That's why laws are changed. They are in your favour now, They won't always be.

Your violent child is not my child's problem. he is not the problem of her classmates-some of whom are SEN. In what world is that fair?

I don't know why i keep responding to you because as long as your violent child is catered to, all the others who "fit in a box" as you disparagingly say, can fuck off as you don't care.

There are more of us with non violent well behaved children-including SEN children- and the time when we accept our children being shat on is is coming to an end and the law will eventually reflect this.

Attitudes change and the law follows. And that really is that from me.

Edited

Well said. We’re all tired now.

roaringdragon · 24/10/2026 13:18

PenelopeShadow · 24/10/2026 13:12

But he is not a problem other children should have to endure, is he, if he was in MS.

You keep banging on about the law. Unlike those that Moses carried down the mountain, they are not writ on tablets of stone.

And that's why forums where people can say-This Far and no Further. The majority of people, who don't post but can see them now know that a fair amount of people do not think that a violent child should ever be on the chair next to theirs.

That's why laws are changed. They are in your favour now, They won't always be.

Your violent child is not my child's problem. he is not the problem of her classmates-some of whom are SEN. In what world is that fair?

I don't know why i keep responding to you because as long as your violent child is catered to, all the others who "fit in a box" as you disparagingly say, can fuck off as you don't care.

There are more of us with non violent well behaved children-including SEN children- and the time when we accept our children being shat on is is coming to an end and the law will eventually reflect this.

Attitudes change and the law follows. And that really is that from me.

Edited

But he is not a problem other children should have to endure, is he, if he was in MS.

If he were in MS, the quickest way to ensure he wasn’t in MS would be for the school (and LA) to act lawfully rather than the school unlawfully informally excluding him.

Yes, laws can change. What you are failing to realise is if the proposals in the SEN Reforms go ahead, it will mean they change in the opposite direction to that you want.

Fair doesn’t mean hiding Dc away at home. It means all having their needs met, some of which will happen outside of MS (see my first point about that).

all the others who "fit in a box" as you disparagingly say, can fuck off as you don't care.

I haven’t said that at all. In fact, I said the opposite. I explicitly said I care about all DC. Stop making rubbish up.

AgeingMillennial · 24/10/2026 13:20

roaringdragon · 24/10/2026 13:18

But he is not a problem other children should have to endure, is he, if he was in MS.

If he were in MS, the quickest way to ensure he wasn’t in MS would be for the school (and LA) to act lawfully rather than the school unlawfully informally excluding him.

Yes, laws can change. What you are failing to realise is if the proposals in the SEN Reforms go ahead, it will mean they change in the opposite direction to that you want.

Fair doesn’t mean hiding Dc away at home. It means all having their needs met, some of which will happen outside of MS (see my first point about that).

all the others who "fit in a box" as you disparagingly say, can fuck off as you don't care.

I haven’t said that at all. In fact, I said the opposite. I explicitly said I care about all DC. Stop making rubbish up.

But the public don’t want either option which is
a) put them in mainstream school so they can assault everyone around them and ruin the learning environment or
b) pay 100,000 per kid to send them plus taxi to some ‘soft therapy’ school that will see them on UC when they leave anyway

Vinvertebrate · 24/10/2026 13:24

AgeingMillennial · 24/10/2026 13:20

But the public don’t want either option which is
a) put them in mainstream school so they can assault everyone around them and ruin the learning environment or
b) pay 100,000 per kid to send them plus taxi to some ‘soft therapy’ school that will see them on UC when they leave anyway

Ah okay, so the public would like them to simply not exist? How might that be achieved, exactly? 🙄

AgeingMillennial · 24/10/2026 13:26

Vinvertebrate · 24/10/2026 13:24

Ah okay, so the public would like them to simply not exist? How might that be achieved, exactly? 🙄

No I want them to go to cheaper, more basic facilities where they are not in a position to assault other people. Sadly the very expensive education usually offers no societal return. We need to be realistic .

roaringdragon · 24/10/2026 13:26

AgeingMillennial · 24/10/2026 13:20

But the public don’t want either option which is
a) put them in mainstream school so they can assault everyone around them and ruin the learning environment or
b) pay 100,000 per kid to send them plus taxi to some ‘soft therapy’ school that will see them on UC when they leave anyway

People can’t have it all ways. They can’t not have DC in mainstream and object to funding specialist provision and EOTAS/EOTIS/C. It doesn’t work like that.

Some DC would cost less if there were more state SS.

Although my DC wouldn’t. It would still be inappropriate for provision to be made in a school or college for DS1&3. They would still cost a lot - a lot more than £100k. If DS1’s EOTAS provision was cut, it wouldn’t save the state money, his continuing care funding would increase, significantly. If DS3’s EOTIS provision was cut, it wouldn’t save money because his social services package would increase.

roaringdragon · 24/10/2026 13:28

AgeingMillennial · 24/10/2026 13:26

No I want them to go to cheaper, more basic facilities where they are not in a position to assault other people. Sadly the very expensive education usually offers no societal return. We need to be realistic .

There aren’t any ‘facilities’ for DS1. That is the whole reason he has EOTAS/EOTIS. There isn’t even an AP who will accept him for 1hr with his own 2:1 staff on top of their staff.

There aren’t any schools for DS3. The whole point of EOTAS/EOTIS is that it is inappropriate for provision to be made in a school.

AgeingMillennial · 24/10/2026 13:28

roaringdragon · 24/10/2026 13:26

People can’t have it all ways. They can’t not have DC in mainstream and object to funding specialist provision and EOTAS/EOTIS/C. It doesn’t work like that.

Some DC would cost less if there were more state SS.

Although my DC wouldn’t. It would still be inappropriate for provision to be made in a school or college for DS1&3. They would still cost a lot - a lot more than £100k. If DS1’s EOTAS provision was cut, it wouldn’t save the state money, his continuing care funding would increase, significantly. If DS3’s EOTIS provision was cut, it wouldn’t save money because his social services package would increase.

It does work like that.

The very expensive placements do not offer value for money. Very few of these kids will ever go on to lead taxpaying, law abiding, independent lives.

They don’t have to go to mainstream but that doesn’t automatically mean the alternative should be as expensive as it is now.

AgeingMillennial · 24/10/2026 13:29

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Swipe left for the next trending thread