Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to be absolutely livid with current state of Reception class?

428 replies

NotSoCheerySnail · 21/10/2026 00:53

My 4yo started Reception in September and has already had several incidents involving other children: one child allegedly stabbed her in the upper lip with a pencil and repeatedly snatches and breaks things belonging to her. Another child bit her finger during her first week and her shoulder the following week. Today, a third child apparently threw a dice at her face, leaving her with a bruised lip. The same girl also keeps taking her water bottle & refuses to give it back (my DD has a bottle with spray function that apparently creates “the bottle envy”).

I spoke to the teacher, asking whether my daughter might be provoking the other children. She said my daughter is very well-behaved and isn’t provoking anyone. However, she also said there are simply too many children and their behaviour is difficult to manage.

its a small village school, their Reception class has 28 children. What is going on? Is it just normal behaviour for small kids? I have an older child but I never remember him being hurt like that. Do parents not teach their children how to behave around others anymore or is our school particularly bad at managing their behaviour? Do we just carry on hoping the kids will outgrow it or what do we do? My DD went to pre school with some of these kids but never has she been hurt like that in there.

OP posts:
Monty36 · 21/10/2026 16:59

Poor little soul. I feel for your daughter.
I am afraid the school need to manage poor behaviour and not look the other way. Difficult parents will be the reason why they do. But you cannot have a coward as a teacher.
And your little girl needs to learn to stand up for herself. And not be bullied. Which she is at the moment. In their own small way. Tell her to shout, snatch back. And not let it go. They might find someone else to bully.

Eviebeans · 21/10/2026 17:03

GoodChocolate · 21/10/2026 06:25

The number of children in a class is much less significant than WHO those children are!!

Exactly this- it only takes one of those children to have severe additional needs that are not met for the dynamic to change completely

PenelopeShadow · 21/10/2026 17:06

Kirbert2 · 21/10/2026 16:38

Again, not really. Since any child can live down a muddy trench and be eligible for school transport if it is deemed to be unsafe. Not just SEND children.

Why only physically disabled children, out of curiosity?

Because it might be difficult for a physically disabled child in a small car or a bus. In that case, then yes, free transport should be provided.

@DontBuyAnotherBook Autism has become a very broad church. It ranges from children who cannot walk, see, hear, talk and wear nappies to ill disciplined or anxious children.

Absolutely everything that can be done should be done for that child and no-one would begrudge it. Sadly, as more children-naughty children-are given a label, there will be less money and resources as they too draw from the same pot.

Is it difficult for your child to physically fit into your private car or to use a bus?

If so, then yes, your child should have free transport. Who would argue against that?

If not, why don't you get him to school?

Why is the responsibility of your neighbours paying their council tax to pay for it?

I really am interested.

Anyway, we've strayed a long way from the OP and her child who is suffering upset on a daily basis by children whose poor behaviour is judged to be a special need. I suppose it does demonstrate just how wide the definition of special needs has become.

It needs tightening.

That won't happen overnight but as more parents become pissed off with those naughty children ruining the schooling of theirs, it will start to gain momentum.

roaringdragon · 21/10/2026 17:06

@PenelopeShadow school transport isn’t linked to EHCPs. All CSA DC, whether they have an EHCP or not, are entitled to (non-stressful) transport if they meet the eligibility criteria for school transport. Not all receiving transport have an EHCP. Similarly, not all with an EHCP are eligible for transport.

Benefits aren’t linked to EHCPs either. Benefits (do you mean DLA?) are based on needs, not whether there is an EHCP in place. You can get DLA without an EHCP.

Because it might be difficult for a physically disabled child in a small car or a bus. In that case, then yes, free transport should be provided.

The same can apply to some DC with non-physical disabilities?

as more children-naughty children-are given a label, there will be less money and resources as they too draw from the same pot.

Support is based on needs, not diagnosis.

Kirbert2 · 21/10/2026 17:15

PenelopeShadow · 21/10/2026 17:06

Because it might be difficult for a physically disabled child in a small car or a bus. In that case, then yes, free transport should be provided.

@DontBuyAnotherBook Autism has become a very broad church. It ranges from children who cannot walk, see, hear, talk and wear nappies to ill disciplined or anxious children.

Absolutely everything that can be done should be done for that child and no-one would begrudge it. Sadly, as more children-naughty children-are given a label, there will be less money and resources as they too draw from the same pot.

Is it difficult for your child to physically fit into your private car or to use a bus?

If so, then yes, your child should have free transport. Who would argue against that?

If not, why don't you get him to school?

Why is the responsibility of your neighbours paying their council tax to pay for it?

I really am interested.

Anyway, we've strayed a long way from the OP and her child who is suffering upset on a daily basis by children whose poor behaviour is judged to be a special need. I suppose it does demonstrate just how wide the definition of special needs has become.

It needs tightening.

That won't happen overnight but as more parents become pissed off with those naughty children ruining the schooling of theirs, it will start to gain momentum.

Which can also be the case for some children with other disabilities. That's why it isn't just for physically disabled children.

A diagnosis also isn't required for a child to be eligible for support.

Constantrunner · 21/10/2026 17:28

Children far away from a school were always transported, but it was in a minibus rather than taxis. The minibus used to wait outside my school for the children living rurally.

DontBuyAnotherBook · 21/10/2026 17:39

PenelopeShadow · 21/10/2026 17:06

Because it might be difficult for a physically disabled child in a small car or a bus. In that case, then yes, free transport should be provided.

@DontBuyAnotherBook Autism has become a very broad church. It ranges from children who cannot walk, see, hear, talk and wear nappies to ill disciplined or anxious children.

Absolutely everything that can be done should be done for that child and no-one would begrudge it. Sadly, as more children-naughty children-are given a label, there will be less money and resources as they too draw from the same pot.

Is it difficult for your child to physically fit into your private car or to use a bus?

If so, then yes, your child should have free transport. Who would argue against that?

If not, why don't you get him to school?

Why is the responsibility of your neighbours paying their council tax to pay for it?

I really am interested.

Anyway, we've strayed a long way from the OP and her child who is suffering upset on a daily basis by children whose poor behaviour is judged to be a special need. I suppose it does demonstrate just how wide the definition of special needs has become.

It needs tightening.

That won't happen overnight but as more parents become pissed off with those naughty children ruining the schooling of theirs, it will start to gain momentum.

He is currently non verbal, in nappies uses reins and we are about to purchase a harness for the car as he tried to escape the car seat on the motorway. He probably won't go to a SEN place until we finish fighting for an EHCP. Currently refusing to assess him at the moment. Is he disabled enough for you? I currently push him in a pushchair to his mainstream school. What a weird thing to want to penny pinch over.

DontBuyAnotherBook · 21/10/2026 17:40

Also they aren't just handing a diagnosis over because they are a bit naughty but that does sort of give away your mindset to be honest.

DontBuyAnotherBook · 21/10/2026 17:41

My point was anyway that not all Sen kids are violent. Plenty of NT kids are as well.

Kirbert2 · 21/10/2026 17:46

DontBuyAnotherBook · 21/10/2026 17:39

He is currently non verbal, in nappies uses reins and we are about to purchase a harness for the car as he tried to escape the car seat on the motorway. He probably won't go to a SEN place until we finish fighting for an EHCP. Currently refusing to assess him at the moment. Is he disabled enough for you? I currently push him in a pushchair to his mainstream school. What a weird thing to want to penny pinch over.

and this is part of the problem too. Why can't we save money with LA's refusing to assess children who very clearly need EHCP's which forces appeals etc and ultimately costs more money than seeing that a child who is non verbal and in nappies clearly needs an EHCP.

That is what needs looking into to try and save money.

roaringdragon · 21/10/2026 17:59

Constantrunner · 21/10/2026 17:28

Children far away from a school were always transported, but it was in a minibus rather than taxis. The minibus used to wait outside my school for the children living rurally.

Where it is appropriate, shared transport is provided now.

It wasn’t always a minibus in the past.

Constantrunner · 21/10/2026 18:05

roaringdragon · 21/10/2026 17:59

Where it is appropriate, shared transport is provided now.

It wasn’t always a minibus in the past.

Good. I am older and it was a minibus unless exceptional circumstances. Even the local special school had a minibus to pick up kids.

roaringdragon · 21/10/2026 18:09

Constantrunner · 21/10/2026 18:05

Good. I am older and it was a minibus unless exceptional circumstances. Even the local special school had a minibus to pick up kids.

Transport to special schools now is shared transport (bus, minibus, shared taxi) unless circumstances dictate otherwise.

sausageth · 21/10/2026 18:18

ownedbymydogs · 21/10/2026 04:07

Welcome to UK primary schools today. Why more parents aren’t up in arms is beyond me. I’ve worked in schools for decades and the violence is normalised to a level that would have other workplaces closed down.

There are no punishments, just ‘restorative conversations’, and definitely no exclusions. We all have to bow to the great god of SEN (especially most SEN children who just want a calm place to learn) and use it to excuse the most appalling behaviour.

And yet all we bloody talk about is ‘safeguarding’.

The teacher probably isn’t inexperienced. Just exhausted and planning her escape.

Thank you for bravely voicing how 98% of teachers are feeling right now.

PenelopeShadow · 21/10/2026 18:20

DontBuyAnotherBook · 21/10/2026 17:39

He is currently non verbal, in nappies uses reins and we are about to purchase a harness for the car as he tried to escape the car seat on the motorway. He probably won't go to a SEN place until we finish fighting for an EHCP. Currently refusing to assess him at the moment. Is he disabled enough for you? I currently push him in a pushchair to his mainstream school. What a weird thing to want to penny pinch over.

Then you should be one of the ones up in arms.

More and more children, many of whom have behavioural difficulties simply because they have never been told NO-are also invited to claim from the same resources that your child is entitled to.

Are you happy with that? Do you think they are as disabled as your child and that they should be viewed as no different.

One day, there will be so many of them-all claiming to be just as disabled as your child- that what is in the pot will be bugger all and you will not get everything that you should.

In your case-that should be everything that you ask for on your child's behalf@ absolutely everything.

So, wake up and smell the coffee.

Also, don't make ridiculous statements such as

"is that disabled enough for you?" !

What's that supposed to mean? It is supposed to shame me?

Because it would only shame me if you had included all that information in the original post which you addressed to me.

You didn't. maybe you expected me to guess.

But know this, you should be in the camp that demands that the definition of "Disabled" should be narrowed for the sake of children like yours and of children like mine, who is expected to be put up with appalling behaviour from naughty children who ruin her school experience.

plasticplate · 21/10/2026 18:34

PenelopeShadow · 21/10/2026 16:30

Thanks for explaining @Kirbert2 but it does seem that an EHCP is indeed linked to financial benefits.

I may be getting heartless but it seems to me that, unless a child is physically disabled then it is up to parents to get their child to school, even if the only way to that school is down a muddy trench.

Why on earth should I have to contribute if the parents can't drive, don't have a car and then choose to live down a muddy trench. I don't really care about "Whataabaat."

Maybe every child-apart from physically disabled child-should have a free bus pass and, if that doesn't suit, then it is the parents' problem.

In the same way that-in almost every case-it is the parents' responsibility to make sure their child is toilet trained, able to do as they are told, is non-violent and does not threaten others before they send them to school.

Pretty basic really but it does seem that some people want their physically well child to be carried to school, fed for free, have their arse cleaned and allowed to call the shots. No matter if it sends council tax bills sky high and makes life a misery for the teacher and the majority of other children.

I think there is already a kick back about how special needs are defined and not before time. I long for the day when an OP comes on, describes some shitty behaviour from their naughty child and the first reply isn't: Is he ND?

Happily, I think the pudding has been well and truly over egged.

I don't think you would have wanted my non physically disabled child sitting next to you on a bus.
Also non physically disabled doesn't mean a wheelchair or buggy isn't used.

DontBuyAnotherBook · 21/10/2026 18:45

Kirbert2 · 21/10/2026 17:46

and this is part of the problem too. Why can't we save money with LA's refusing to assess children who very clearly need EHCP's which forces appeals etc and ultimately costs more money than seeing that a child who is non verbal and in nappies clearly needs an EHCP.

That is what needs looking into to try and save money.

Edited

Indeed. It is ridiculous. The LA think they are saving money but in the long run they aren't and they know they will need to issue him an EHCP. Come and observe these kids.

Redlocks28 · 21/10/2026 18:49

YYURYYUCICYYUR4ME · 21/10/2026 15:05

After a discussion about primary class sizes, I got my very old class photos, from the 60s / 70s out. Every class was over 30 and one 34, this in Inner London. No TAs in the classroom and certainly never had an issue with behaviour on the scale of today. So how did our teachers manage?

Because they didn’t have a significant number of pupils wth SEND in their class?

Because they had autonomy over what they taught and weren’t trying to teach a narrow curriculum that didn’t suit large swathes of the class.

Because they could use sanctions if there was poor behaviour.

Supportive parents

for starters

Forton26 · 21/10/2026 18:50

Bushmillsbabe · 21/10/2026 10:55

Funding cuts are also definitely having an impact. Every class at DD's school used to have 2 TA's, and any 1 to 1 EHCP support was on top of this. Now there is minimal class TA support, it only goes on 1 to 1's as that's all they can afford.

So children who are struggling but dont qualify for an EHCP get little to no support, and if no idea what they are doing, will naturally start chatting or playing. Get further and further behind as move up the school.

I don't blame the teachers, I blame this government for reducing funding, and parents for not instilling values around positive behaviour in their children, and the push for inclusion when it just doesn't work for many children

The failures in education such as lack of real funding go much further than this government’. It’s successive ones over many years.

My siblings school were cutting Tas long before this goverment came in.

Bushmillsbabe · 21/10/2026 19:16

Forton26 · 21/10/2026 18:50

The failures in education such as lack of real funding go much further than this government’. It’s successive ones over many years.

My siblings school were cutting Tas long before this goverment came in.

Edited

I can only speak for my daughters school, but the most significant cuts only came in last 2 years. The head has said the same - the tories sent them lots of silly rules and targets etc, but at least they funded them reasonably well. The unfunded teacher pay rise, together with recent big cuts to HNB funding, has had a huge impact. Put that together with the nhs challenges meaning children are taking much longer to have their needs identified, and the council cuts delaying ehcps, and they are in crisis

Kirbert2 · 21/10/2026 19:37

DontBuyAnotherBook · 21/10/2026 18:45

Indeed. It is ridiculous. The LA think they are saving money but in the long run they aren't and they know they will need to issue him an EHCP. Come and observe these kids.

Yep.

Not to mention the money that could be saved with accepting that some children need specialist provision from the start of their education and refusing, even with an EHCP in place, on the basis that there's no evidence the child wouldn't cope in mainstream simply because they haven't yet attended mainstream when everyone knows that the child requires specialist provision and then again, parents have no choice but to appeal and go to tribunal.

There's so many places where LA's could save money themselves.

Vinvertebrate · 21/10/2026 20:05

DontBuyAnotherBook · 21/10/2026 18:45

Indeed. It is ridiculous. The LA think they are saving money but in the long run they aren't and they know they will need to issue him an EHCP. Come and observe these kids.

Well they won’t for much longer will they? Goodbye, legally enforceable rights. Hello, disruptive children with a “package” sitting next to yours in MS with no alternative that either parents or school can insist on.

it’s cheaper though. 🤷‍♀️

Kirbert2 · 21/10/2026 20:08

Vinvertebrate · 21/10/2026 20:05

Well they won’t for much longer will they? Goodbye, legally enforceable rights. Hello, disruptive children with a “package” sitting next to yours in MS with no alternative that either parents or school can insist on.

it’s cheaper though. 🤷‍♀️

Very true.

If the SEND changes go through, it's going to get far, far worse.

DontBuyAnotherBook · 21/10/2026 20:38

Vinvertebrate · 21/10/2026 20:05

Well they won’t for much longer will they? Goodbye, legally enforceable rights. Hello, disruptive children with a “package” sitting next to yours in MS with no alternative that either parents or school can insist on.

it’s cheaper though. 🤷‍♀️

I don't get your point? My son will be one of the children who should be in a SEN provision but stuck in mainstream. I hope people have signed the petitions about it before moaning about kids like mine being in their kids classroom.

roaringdragon · 21/10/2026 20:42

Some DC with SEN not receiving the support they need and are entitled to is not the fault of other DC with SEN who are receiving support or their parents. It doesn’t make the parents ‘sharp-elbowed’, ‘demanding’ or ‘unreasonable’. DC don’t receive provision they are eligible for in law.