Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to be absolutely livid with current state of Reception class?

428 replies

NotSoCheerySnail · 21/10/2026 00:53

My 4yo started Reception in September and has already had several incidents involving other children: one child allegedly stabbed her in the upper lip with a pencil and repeatedly snatches and breaks things belonging to her. Another child bit her finger during her first week and her shoulder the following week. Today, a third child apparently threw a dice at her face, leaving her with a bruised lip. The same girl also keeps taking her water bottle & refuses to give it back (my DD has a bottle with spray function that apparently creates “the bottle envy”).

I spoke to the teacher, asking whether my daughter might be provoking the other children. She said my daughter is very well-behaved and isn’t provoking anyone. However, she also said there are simply too many children and their behaviour is difficult to manage.

its a small village school, their Reception class has 28 children. What is going on? Is it just normal behaviour for small kids? I have an older child but I never remember him being hurt like that. Do parents not teach their children how to behave around others anymore or is our school particularly bad at managing their behaviour? Do we just carry on hoping the kids will outgrow it or what do we do? My DD went to pre school with some of these kids but never has she been hurt like that in there.

OP posts:
Kirbert2 · 21/10/2026 15:08

Marieb19 · 21/10/2026 14:04

If poorly behaved children are sent home, maybe their parents would start parenting

Laws would have to change for that to happen. Right now, exclusions have to be a last resort and even more so if SEND is involved

PenelopeShadow · 21/10/2026 15:08

YYURYYUCICYYUR4ME · 21/10/2026 15:05

After a discussion about primary class sizes, I got my very old class photos, from the 60s / 70s out. Every class was over 30 and one 34, this in Inner London. No TAs in the classroom and certainly never had an issue with behaviour on the scale of today. So how did our teachers manage?

It's a head scratcher isn't it?

NotSoCheerySnail · 21/10/2026 15:09

Meeesh · 21/10/2026 14:51

This is increasingly becoming the norm in many schools. Large class sizes, more children with differing needs in mainstream classes with very few TAs or 1:1 staff.

You use the words apparently and allegedly ... do you mean that you think these things happened? Why does a 5 yr old need a fancy water bottle... they are the bane of every teachers life!

HR habit! I wasn’t there and I’m using my 4 year old’s words. I actually wasn’t notified of any of those incidents at the pick up (apart from the first finger bite and only after we came back the next day and the teacher told us she was meant to say it but things got very busy at the end of the day). When discussing with their class teacher she neither confirmed nor denied any of these. She just said that my daughter is well behaved and did nothing wrong it’s just a difficult class to manage.

OP posts:
Ablondiebutagoody · 21/10/2026 15:12

YYURYYUCICYYUR4ME · 21/10/2026 15:05

After a discussion about primary class sizes, I got my very old class photos, from the 60s / 70s out. Every class was over 30 and one 34, this in Inner London. No TAs in the classroom and certainly never had an issue with behaviour on the scale of today. So how did our teachers manage?

I suspect because back then teachers were allowed to teach the lessons and discipline the naughty kids. Today, they have to pander to the "reasonable adjustments" of a third of the class. Including allowing some to smash the place up, destroy classmates stuff and be violent towards them. Kids getting up whenever they want or ducking out of the lesson to play lego whenever they feel "overwhelmed". Its total chaos and we are failing these kids.

Kirbert2 · 21/10/2026 15:24

YYURYYUCICYYUR4ME · 21/10/2026 15:05

After a discussion about primary class sizes, I got my very old class photos, from the 60s / 70s out. Every class was over 30 and one 34, this in Inner London. No TAs in the classroom and certainly never had an issue with behaviour on the scale of today. So how did our teachers manage?

The Warnock report based on SEND wasn't published until 1978 which led to the Education Act 1981. This established a statutory right to education for children with SEND and LA's were then required to provide support and accommodations.

Dweetfidilove · 21/10/2026 15:25

I'm sorry this has been your experience. Sounds absolutely horrid!
I'll be amazed if anyone learns anything in such a chaotic environment. Classrooms seem to be run by feral little beasts who hit, spit, bite amd all sorts without consequence. Poor teachers seem to do little more than observe / crowd control. ☹️.
I don't even have any advice, just empathy for you and your child.

PenelopeShadow · 21/10/2026 15:32

In the 80's, in Romford, Special Needs were taken care of by Miss Morrison in a stationary cupboard. The special needs consisted of helping those who needed a bit extra in catching up with reading and writing.

Those who needed a lot of help were what was then called 'statemented'. Statementing was no linked to taxis, sensory rooms or benefits. It seemed to work well. Maybe because it wasn't linked to money and special allowances, parents weren't always happy to have their child statemented.

Those who were ill disciplined had their needs dealt with in quite another way.

All children were safe from flying chairs, yelling and biting. That helped their basic need and right to an education.

Kirbert2 · 21/10/2026 15:46

PenelopeShadow · 21/10/2026 15:32

In the 80's, in Romford, Special Needs were taken care of by Miss Morrison in a stationary cupboard. The special needs consisted of helping those who needed a bit extra in catching up with reading and writing.

Those who needed a lot of help were what was then called 'statemented'. Statementing was no linked to taxis, sensory rooms or benefits. It seemed to work well. Maybe because it wasn't linked to money and special allowances, parents weren't always happy to have their child statemented.

Those who were ill disciplined had their needs dealt with in quite another way.

All children were safe from flying chairs, yelling and biting. That helped their basic need and right to an education.

EHCP's aren't linked to taxis or benefits either? I was relieved when my son got his EHCP because it meant he could actually go to school with the correct support in place.

PenelopeShadow · 21/10/2026 15:58

Are they not? @Kirbert2

Why are councils paying taxis to take non physically disabled children to school? I
hear posters on here saying their child has one. I recall one poster was pissed off that their child had to share a taxi with another child, as they were anxious.

The bill is a national disgrace.

Can my child get one?

Enigma54 · 21/10/2026 16:03

YYURYYUCICYYUR4ME · 21/10/2026 15:05

After a discussion about primary class sizes, I got my very old class photos, from the 60s / 70s out. Every class was over 30 and one 34, this in Inner London. No TAs in the classroom and certainly never had an issue with behaviour on the scale of today. So how did our teachers manage?

Discipline. Kids who stepped out of line were disciplined. None of this restorative stuff that gets dished out these days. Good discipline allowed the teachers to teach and the kids to learn.

CaptainMyCaptain · 21/10/2026 16:12

Enigma54 · 21/10/2026 16:03

Discipline. Kids who stepped out of line were disciplined. None of this restorative stuff that gets dished out these days. Good discipline allowed the teachers to teach and the kids to learn.

But parents only want other people's children to be disciplined not their own hence the many threads on MN about too many rules in school.

Kirbert2 · 21/10/2026 16:13

PenelopeShadow · 21/10/2026 15:58

Are they not? @Kirbert2

Why are councils paying taxis to take non physically disabled children to school? I
hear posters on here saying their child has one. I recall one poster was pissed off that their child had to share a taxi with another child, as they were anxious.

The bill is a national disgrace.

Can my child get one?

All children are eligible for transport to school if the only appropriate school is a certain distance away and/or it is deemed unsafe to walk due to e.g no pavements.

SEND children are eligible if their disability and/or SEN means they can't safely walk to school. Evidence is also required and then the LA assess the evidence to see if the child is eligible. EHCP's can be used as evidence but it isn't a requirement so no, isn't at all linked to a child having an EHCP.

I'd say that it's more likely a child with an EHCP is more likely to get school transport as an EHCP is required for a child to access alternate provision and alternate provisions can be miles away. If a child without SEND needed to attend a school miles away for an appropriate reason such as rural or if they didn't have a safe way of walking to school such as no pavements then they would have transport provided too.

Alphabet1spaghetti2 · 21/10/2026 16:18

Ablondiebutagoody · 21/10/2026 15:12

I suspect because back then teachers were allowed to teach the lessons and discipline the naughty kids. Today, they have to pander to the "reasonable adjustments" of a third of the class. Including allowing some to smash the place up, destroy classmates stuff and be violent towards them. Kids getting up whenever they want or ducking out of the lesson to play lego whenever they feel "overwhelmed". Its total chaos and we are failing these kids.

Edited

Yes there were consequences which were followed through. Firm, clear boundaries and expectations also massively helped as everyone knew what they had to do, and exactly what would happen if you didn’t.
Before anyone complains, we didn’t have any physical punishments such as smacking or the cane/shoe in our school either. Parents largely supported the schools and also followed up with their own punishments for poor behaviour.
Not something that happens today.

twoshedsjackson · 21/10/2026 16:28

As to class size; I was part of the "bulge year" and my reports for the first two years in junior school state, at the top of the sheet: "Number in Class:50" but we were ruthlessly streamed and corporal punishment was not unknown, I thought it unfair, even though I was on the right side of the deal, that boys could be caned. I was in Lower A, and all but three of us went on to grammar schools. I think the B and C classes were a bit smaller.
One big difference was the approach to special needs. Below a certain level of ability, children were deemed ineducable, and outside the education system.
In fact, when I left teacher training, one of my fellow young teachers got her deputy headship incredible early, because she was posted to a school which had previously been set up to care for children who were considered too low in ability for any attempt being made to educate them; rather, they were cared for and kept occupied. Her brief was to encourage staff to begin to work along more educational lines.
Many of the of the learning difficulties which are now familiar terms were not even recognized, let alone diagnosed; for example in my first year of teaching, one of my pupils was mentioned for having dyslexia, as a relatively new idea for most staff. For children with real but undiagnosed difficulties, these were very far from the "good old days"

PenelopeShadow · 21/10/2026 16:30

Thanks for explaining @Kirbert2 but it does seem that an EHCP is indeed linked to financial benefits.

I may be getting heartless but it seems to me that, unless a child is physically disabled then it is up to parents to get their child to school, even if the only way to that school is down a muddy trench.

Why on earth should I have to contribute if the parents can't drive, don't have a car and then choose to live down a muddy trench. I don't really care about "Whataabaat."

Maybe every child-apart from physically disabled child-should have a free bus pass and, if that doesn't suit, then it is the parents' problem.

In the same way that-in almost every case-it is the parents' responsibility to make sure their child is toilet trained, able to do as they are told, is non-violent and does not threaten others before they send them to school.

Pretty basic really but it does seem that some people want their physically well child to be carried to school, fed for free, have their arse cleaned and allowed to call the shots. No matter if it sends council tax bills sky high and makes life a misery for the teacher and the majority of other children.

I think there is already a kick back about how special needs are defined and not before time. I long for the day when an OP comes on, describes some shitty behaviour from their naughty child and the first reply isn't: Is he ND?

Happily, I think the pudding has been well and truly over egged.

CruCru · 21/10/2026 16:35

Marieb19 · 21/10/2026 14:04

If poorly behaved children are sent home, maybe their parents would start parenting

My brother’s children’s school does this - they ring the parents and get them to pick the children up early if they behave badly. It helps that a lot of the parents work from home - but it means that a lot of parents dread getting the call from school.

DontBuyAnotherBook · 21/10/2026 16:37

VashtaNerada · 21/10/2026 01:44

Many teachers believe there has been an increase in challenging behaviour and SEND in recent years due to a whole host of factors. I don’t know what the solution is, sadly.

Why presume it is SEN? My fairly severe autistic four year old has started school and has not been aggressive at all.

Kirbert2 · 21/10/2026 16:38

PenelopeShadow · 21/10/2026 16:30

Thanks for explaining @Kirbert2 but it does seem that an EHCP is indeed linked to financial benefits.

I may be getting heartless but it seems to me that, unless a child is physically disabled then it is up to parents to get their child to school, even if the only way to that school is down a muddy trench.

Why on earth should I have to contribute if the parents can't drive, don't have a car and then choose to live down a muddy trench. I don't really care about "Whataabaat."

Maybe every child-apart from physically disabled child-should have a free bus pass and, if that doesn't suit, then it is the parents' problem.

In the same way that-in almost every case-it is the parents' responsibility to make sure their child is toilet trained, able to do as they are told, is non-violent and does not threaten others before they send them to school.

Pretty basic really but it does seem that some people want their physically well child to be carried to school, fed for free, have their arse cleaned and allowed to call the shots. No matter if it sends council tax bills sky high and makes life a misery for the teacher and the majority of other children.

I think there is already a kick back about how special needs are defined and not before time. I long for the day when an OP comes on, describes some shitty behaviour from their naughty child and the first reply isn't: Is he ND?

Happily, I think the pudding has been well and truly over egged.

Again, not really. Since any child can live down a muddy trench and be eligible for school transport if it is deemed to be unsafe. Not just SEND children.

Why only physically disabled children, out of curiosity?

DontBuyAnotherBook · 21/10/2026 16:40

PenelopeShadow · 21/10/2026 15:58

Are they not? @Kirbert2

Why are councils paying taxis to take non physically disabled children to school? I
hear posters on here saying their child has one. I recall one poster was pissed off that their child had to share a taxi with another child, as they were anxious.

The bill is a national disgrace.

Can my child get one?

Disability isn't just physical.

DontBuyAnotherBook · 21/10/2026 16:41

Why would it bother you if my autistic son needs transport to a special school that we think he probably needs @PenelopeShadow ?

FreshInk · 21/10/2026 16:44

I work in primary education and this isn’t normal at all.

iwant2cats · 21/10/2026 16:46

Predictably enough the thread has just become a rant about ill disciplined children of today and how life was better when we hit them.

I sometimes think I went to an exceptionally bad school as there were plenty of discipline problems in the 80s, and the teaching was generally very poor (‘there’s a textbook’ sort of approach.)

If you look at the literacy and numeracy levels now compared to 1986 it’s markedly better now, which does suggest some effective teaching is taking place despite Armageddon apparently happening in most classrooms.

Kirbert2 · 21/10/2026 16:46

DontBuyAnotherBook · 21/10/2026 16:41

Why would it bother you if my autistic son needs transport to a special school that we think he probably needs @PenelopeShadow ?

and this is where it confuses me.

If we want children with SEND to have appropriate education, for some of them, it will be a special school. Some of them can be miles away so transport is often required.

But then some people seem to complain that a SEND child is in mainstream when they clearly require alternate provision.

Surely people understand that alternate provision including transport requires money? If not then SEND children will just have to stay in mainstream and yes, some of them will be disruptive and violent because mainstream doesn't meet their needs.

CruCru · 21/10/2026 16:48

Granville82 · 21/10/2026 11:31

There's so much suicidal empathy around now, we have trouble as a society clearly identifying bad behaviour and creating accountability around it. Instead we always want to frame the perpetrator somehow as a victim too.

When we do this, outcomes get worse and worse, because even having expectations is considered somehow mean.

I think it’s partly that we are more accepting as a society now. Usually this is a positive but it can go the other way. It is a bold woman who tells a friend that she really does need to have her child toilet trained before they start school. Instead she is more likely to murmur that she is sure that there will be lots of children in the same position and that the teacher will be used to it. As a result, a load of time in Reception is spent on toilet training and accidents.

Similarly, a child who bites (!) would have had people saying “He bites?!? What do you mean? Do you actually mean … bites?!? He’s four”. There was an attitude that this sort of thing just isn’t possible and can’t be tolerated.

I remember my brother (much younger) having a friend over who bent his fingers right back. My Mum said that if he did it again, she would take him home. He did and she did (much to the other mum’s embarrassment).

ElsieMc · 21/10/2026 16:57

Dd2 was in a village school combining three years, a total of 39 pupils taught by a teaching Headteacher. Strict man but excellent teacher. There were behavioural issues amongst a few so certainly not perfect. I dont think 28 is an issue op. It is who is in the class and how it is managed.

My GD1 is in a largish class and thriving at an urban infant school rated Good overall. I am impressed with the school and she has really come on. Credit where credit is due. So many local parents attempting to get their children places in the local outstanding school though. Better your child is happy tbh.

Swipe left for the next trending thread