Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not trust MIL to babysit on holiday, meaning no date nights for DH?

388 replies

wrdmym · 18/10/2026 20:36

We’re going on holiday next year for DH’s 40th birthday with his parents, and he expects us to have a few date nights while we’re there, with his parents looking after our two DC (DD will be 5 and DS around 20 months).

The problem is that I don’t trust his mum to look after them unsupervised. DH thinks his parents are lovely grandparents who have never done anything wrong, and sees me as cold towards his mum.

A few examples of why I feel the way I do:

  1. MIL came over with a really chesty cough when my youngest was a newborn (10 weeks). She said she’d had it for a while, but we hadn’t seen her for 3 weeks and she definitely wasn’t coughing then. Didn’t bother to warn us. DH thought it was no big deal.
  2. When DD was 2, a magnet came off a toy that MIL “kindly” bought for our 2 year old, at MIL’s house. MIL’s immediate reaction was “I hope my the cat didn’t eat it!” I was sitting there thinking, what about the toddler in the house? Swallowing a magnet can be extremely dangerous. Why was the cat her first concern?
  3. She once pointed at a crow and told DD as a joke “Look, Robin.” English is DD’s second language, and I find it frustrating that she introduces unnecessary confusion when DD is learning about the world.
  4. She regularly places hot tea on very low coffee tables and it’s almost like a game of who gets to it first - me or one of the children burning themselves.

None of these incidents has resulted in a serious injury, thankfully. DH sees them as minor things, but I see a pattern of poor judgement and a lack of awareness around young children.

I find her incredibly frustrating, rude and inconsiderate but I have no problem with the grandparents spending time with the children when we’re there. We see them about once per month for 6-8 hours and once a year come to stay at their house for 2-3 nights. What I don’t want is to leave them in MIL’s sole care while we’re out for dinner, particularly with a baby and a young child.

DH thinks I’m being unreasonable because they’re the children’s grandparents and he wants us to have some time together on holiday. I think date nights are optional, and I’m not going to leave my children with someone I don’t trust just to make them happen.

AIBU? Would you leave your children with grandparents you didn’t trust to make sensible decisions about their safety, or would you arrange alternative childcare and accept that date nights might not be possible?

OP posts:
YourHazelQuail · 19/10/2026 20:21

As a grandparent, we get 'use' to there not being small children in our homes all the time and may not get things right or too your liking. If it really is that big an issue. Remember one day you might be desperate for child care and she may be your only option!

LowlandLucky · 19/10/2026 20:23

They sound dangerous, goodness knows how your husband made it to adulthood.

ThisCraftyAquaHedgehog · 19/10/2026 20:30

Why on earth are you going on holiday with them? You clearly don't get along.

Goosevolcano · 19/10/2026 20:31

Not a chance I would leave my children with them, YANBU

PissedOff2020 · 19/10/2026 20:40

I like to vote without reading any replies and seeing the score - I’m glad most people agree YABU.

The Robin comment is quite ridiculous - you really have a lot of dislike for this woman hey? The fact you think this is a valid reason to feel she can’t care for your children is ludicrous:

As for the magnet - yes annoying she thought about the cat, but I assume she just as she’s used to the cat being there. Silly, but doesn’t mean she loves the cat more… that fact it’s still grating on you is disproportionate to what happened.

The cough, sounds like she already knew it wasn’t contagious given she’s had it a while and her husband didn’t have it.

The only real thing are the hot drinks - have you or husband asked her not to do it?

I think you’ve got issues with her outside of this. I suspect you didn’t like her before you had children.

Manthide · 19/10/2026 20:40

My df spent months telling dd3 that grass was orange and carrots were green! She's 18 and still occasionally comes out with the wrong colour but she adores df and he her! I have 4gc and still put cups of coffee on low surfaces but obviously am aware where gc are. I think you are being a bit precious, you'll be on holiday so presumably only toys you bring will be around.

MyDandyUmberDuck · 19/10/2026 20:44

As some one who always gets a cough lasting 4 weeks after a cold I would say she could be very correct in saying not contagious just extended lung inflammation caused by the virus but I don’t know if she seemed ill beyond the cough or if she was coughing in little ones face. Given you were both their with the 2 year old I’d presume you were watching and would have seen if they’d picked up and swallowed the magnet whereas no one was watching the cat so reasonable to assume toddler fine but hope cat didn’t eat it. Couldn’t begin to do much more than an eye roll and move on from the bird thing. The hot drink thing annoying I acknowledge as someone who can be guilty of this themself. 😳. I don’t think these 4 examples together make her seem incapable of looking after a child and you really need to move on and forgive rather than holding onto resentment over such occasions. Can I ask if you are prone to anxiety at all? I used to suffer quite badly and would hold onto small events and play them over in my mind, catastrophising and getting myself wound up about stuff years later that didn’t end up mattering in the grand scheme.

Hereandthereupupthestairs · 19/10/2026 20:53

Eeek poor PIL. You are a piece of work.

bigboykitty · 19/10/2026 20:59

Eek. Poor you. Your MIL is a piece of work.

Timeforachange26 · 19/10/2026 21:11

wrdmym · 18/10/2026 20:47

@NuffSaidSam
handing a child a toy where the magnet comes off is nbd?

How would she know the magnet would come off

Oooohthatsfancy · 19/10/2026 21:15

Stick0rTwist · 19/10/2026 15:57

I hope my sons never bring home a wife like you 🤣 talk about uptight

I was thinking exactly the same thing.

Babayagahaha · 19/10/2026 21:22

wrdmym · 19/10/2026 16:13

@FatMrsHoot why dose them up on calpol?!

its not that I worry she’ll repeat one of the examples exactly, more that the examples show her absolutely terrible judgement and lack of awareness.

In your opinion.

The only truly dangerous one is the cups of tea.

The magnet one wasn't even a magnet if it was in operation. The robin/crow one is ridiculous anyway and a 3 week old cough isn't contagious.

BluenoseGers · 19/10/2026 21:22

You are not being unreasonable and for people saying you are being unreasonable at her showing up with a cold they are lucky to have never witnessed there child hospitalised with RSV which happened to my 10 week old at the time because someone else came around with a cold

SplishSplash123 · 19/10/2026 21:26

Bitsostuff · 18/10/2026 21:39

So what did you do when you had a baby and one of your other children got sick - banish then to the garden shed? Second and third children are around colds and bugs from the get go.

OP hasn't said if she was breastfeeding or not - but just to note that the antibodies in breastmilk will adapt to anyone who is unwell that the mother is in close contact with. So a breastfed baby whos mum/dad/sibling is ill will stand a much better chance of fighting it off than catching something from someone outside the household.

In any event, it's a question of reasonable reduction of risk. You can't banish a child from the house, but you could ask someone who doesn't need to come and visit to stay away. If nothing else, I think it is disrespectful also to a newly postpartum woman, who is probably tired enough already without adding in an illness, to expose her to germs.

EmeraldShamrock000 · 19/10/2026 21:27

Do not go on a family holiday together if your relationship isn’t good with MIL.
It will be hell for everyone.
You can hire a sitter while on holiday.
The cup of tea can be changed to a cup with a lid if you do allow her babysit. You sound extremely anxious about this.

saraclara · 19/10/2026 21:29

BluenoseGers · 19/10/2026 21:22

You are not being unreasonable and for people saying you are being unreasonable at her showing up with a cold they are lucky to have never witnessed there child hospitalised with RSV which happened to my 10 week old at the time because someone else came around with a cold

She didn't turn up with a cold. She turned up with a lingering cough.

BeUmberMember · 19/10/2026 21:32

As a great grandmother in the lovely big gated soft play centre wearing just socks (no shoes allowed !) I am inches behind my 20 month old great grandaughter frightened she might fall down steps or off a trampoline or even bang heads with another child. Meanwhile my granddaughter and other young mums are sitting in the cafe chatting with their coffees totally unconcerned ! Usually, I think the older generations are much more cautious and aware of dangers than the childrens parents. I insist she has reins on whilst walking outside with me, as one slip of the hand and she will be off and under a car! Am sure your children will be safe with their grandparents, just warn them about hot drinks and those tiny little batteries that can fall out of hearing aids and even some toys.

Bepo77 · 19/10/2026 21:36

I thought I was hard work when I had a newborn but this is next level

Scottishskifun · 19/10/2026 21:46

I can understand the trepidation on the basis that they are your most precious thing but there is a balance for options here.

You and DH could put children to bed before going out and have a late dinner that way MIL will have minimal to do. If youngest wakes then it's just into the room to settle no cups of tea in sight.
My mum has come on holiday with us and this is what we do as its easier for her and it works well. We also do the same if we have a babysitter!

CJsGoldfish · 19/10/2026 21:49

wrdmym · 18/10/2026 22:07

@MissMoneyFairy
yes the MIL dreams of babysitting, has offered countless times but knows we’ve always declined. I have a suspicion that DH wants this date night not because we don’t get enough dates in UK (we have a very good nanny) but as a “treat” for his mummy

And it sounds like you don't as a 'punishment' because you very clearly do not like her and likely never have 🤷‍♀️

YABU but you were never going to accept that as an answer so wondering why you even posted? Obviously you will continue to use your children this way

Ladygodalmighty · 19/10/2026 21:53

If you feel your children are not safe with your MIL trust your gut. If the worst was to happen and your toddler was scalded by a hot cup of tea, you would never forgive yourself. That would be a date night that neither you or your husband or the grandparents would ever forget!

Miss1983 · 19/10/2026 22:00

I totally agree with the hotel drink. I bought my mother a special coffee cup with a lid for this reason.. hardly gets used tbh as it does not keep her coffee hot enough for her which i feel is less important than my child getting burnt. I feel at a loss with grandparents these days and just focus on being best parent I can be.

I think its best to just go with your gut. Its not nice when people make out you are crazy nor confuse children the crow thing was just unnecessary imo but your mil has weird sense of humor.

Walksinwild · 19/10/2026 22:03

I have PIL like this. Don't do date night as you won't be able to relax.
Luckily DH agrees with me and our DC have rarely been left with them. They have done a few hours here and there when I was in hospital having DC2. They have asked a few times if they could have them for the weekend but we've always said no.
Examples-MIL made a dinner totally not suited to kids, she suggested they have a bowl of custard for dinner instead.
FIL drives very fast breaking limits always.
Mil-suggested the kids just stay up until they fell asleep-cute them both having a meltdown and me taking an age calming and getting them to sleep.
PIL never think ahead about prepping food, when we are with them I always have to prompt for a meal to be made.

SixtySomething · 19/10/2026 22:03

SirenScream · 19/10/2026 18:37

I wouldnt trust the MIL.
If you do let her have the children & something goes wrong your husband's misplaced loyalty will lead him to defend the matriarch

Matriarch, huh? It's actually his Mum.

Miss1983 · 19/10/2026 22:08

Walksinwild · 19/10/2026 22:03

I have PIL like this. Don't do date night as you won't be able to relax.
Luckily DH agrees with me and our DC have rarely been left with them. They have done a few hours here and there when I was in hospital having DC2. They have asked a few times if they could have them for the weekend but we've always said no.
Examples-MIL made a dinner totally not suited to kids, she suggested they have a bowl of custard for dinner instead.
FIL drives very fast breaking limits always.
Mil-suggested the kids just stay up until they fell asleep-cute them both having a meltdown and me taking an age calming and getting them to sleep.
PIL never think ahead about prepping food, when we are with them I always have to prompt for a meal to be made.

Omg sounds like a nightmare!! Im glad ur DH is onside. Sometimes its just easier not accepting the help as tiring as it maybe when u need time out .. literally my life atm