Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Selling inherited house when sibling living in it

655 replies

Dutchhouse14 · 16/10/2026 11:50

Our DM passed away a few months ago and her will divides everything equally between me and my 2 siblings.
Im the sole executor.
Dsis ,mid 50s, has always lived at home, never moved out. Towards the end of mums life she became her carer.
She works limited hours although she has increased these with overtime since mum passed away but full time contracts are non existent in her sector.
Shes used to pay a small amount of housekeeping but this stopped when she was made redundant from full time work about 10 years ago.
DMs house is in a bad state of repair, none of us can afford to maintain it . Me and my other sibling want to sell.
But DSis is resisting ,not replying to texts, avoiding phones calls, went out when estates agents came round for valuations etc
She has limited income and savings but could get a small mortgage and with proceeds of sale she could get a 1 bed flat.
My other sibling agrees we need to sell but doesn't want to upset dsis and is generally very good at avoidance! They are happy to give Dsis a much bigger share ie 50% I would prefer 40% which i think is realistic for dsis to buy somewhere.
So ive become the wicked witch of the West in Dsis eyes and shes taking it all out on me, well basically stopped talking to me.
WIBU to put the house on the market?
Probate has been granted.
Anyone know what the legal situation is?
I dont want to fall out with Dsis, I love her, but she seems filled with resentment for me and frankly has said some very hurtful things.
Ive always been there for her but shes never ever reciprocated or supported me when ive needed it.
Although I live with DH and DC, the money would really help my future, my pension etc and I dont want to give my share to Dsis, which is what I think she really wants as shes used to being in charge of DMs money , always lived here so I think basically considers everything as hers.
Just dont know how to move things forward or if im being unreasonable selling the house and wanting my share

OP posts:
sittingonabeach · 21/10/2026 06:15

Boreded · 21/10/2026 01:55

Continuing healthcare doesn’t cover dementia or Alzheimer’s, it would only cover someone with significant additional medical needs, eg. My paraplegic dad who ended up being unable to live at home without carers.

You’ve even made the previous poster’s point by quoting that she was turning down any care her mum had to pay for. That’s not financially controlling, it’s protecting her mum’s money and home

Surely better that the mum got the right care. I’m carer for my DM but I know at some point she will need more experienced care than I can give so should go into a home

Seajaye · 21/10/2026 06:47

Do you think there is a chance that you sister woukd intend leave whatever she leaves at the time she dies to her nephew's and nieces, so indirectly the money might still comes back to your side of the family eventually. Or alternatively, if you could all agree to have a higher proportion of the estate now, you could put now put a second charge on the property she buys with the proceeds for the extra share, to make sure the amount does come back when she eventually dies..

I still reckon given the facts and her means to house herself at her age, that her suggestion of 50/25/25 split of the estate is reasonable compromise and well within the realms of what a court order might end up at if the will was challenged on the basis of reasonable financial provision. Of course you can take your chances and go to court if you think you have a defence to any claim. Go and get done proper legal advice.

If your brother wants to ' stay out of it'' he could also choose relinquish all or part of his share to you,

You do have options her to treat her more decently than it's coming across.

sittingonabeach · 21/10/2026 06:55

The sister was illegally managing the DM’s finances, you shouldn’t be using DM’s bank card etc to pay for things, especially if she had dementia and couldn’t consent. It should have gone through POA. I do wonder if there is a reason she is being cagey about her savings

Feelfreee · 21/10/2026 08:16

Dutchhouse14 · 21/10/2026 00:34

Mum always treated us equally and fairness was really important to her, so Im pretty sure she intended everything to be shared equally as per her will. However she would have wanted us to help Dsis as necessary and definitely wouldn't want her to be homeless.
Im trying to involve Dsis with decision, she wont meet the estate agent but has agreed we can go with him and I think accepts the house needs to be sold.
Ive spoken with my brother about delaying putting it on the market until after xmas to give her more time, I feel so guilty but he would prefer to keep momentum as its been hard to reach this far and we are both a bit concerned if we dont do it now we will just have the same painful conversations again in January or spring and it will drag on and be like the elephant in the room.
Shes still lashing out at me, ( never Dbro!) Ive tried talking about her future plans and said im happy to help and support in anyway I can, speak to mortgage advisor with her, help with solicitors re future purchase, help house hunt, will help with move, decorate etc. I said about working out a purchase budget but she wont disclose her savings to me or talk about getting a mortgage, Ive suggested a 40/30/30 split in her favour but I dont want to give more than that if she cant be open and honest with me about her financial situation, DH thinks the fact shes being so secretive probably means she has more than I think. If she genuinely needs more im happy to rethink the split but I cant do it without first knowing if she can get a mortgage or what her savings are, as the inheritance would really help me and my 4 DC.

If im being honest when DM first became ill ( dementia) I did think her caring for DM was quid pro quo as she'd never moved out and DM financially supported her all her life, no rent or bills etc . As mum deteriorated it was very difficult to care for her and really she should have had more carer visits or been in a care home for the last couple of years as Dsis really needed more help but she blocked any suggestions. When mum died it was almost a relief as it was her time and very peaceful. Dementia is a long goodbye but its obviously heartbreaking and a massive change for Dsis who lived with DM her whole life.
Im sure we will get there in the end and hopefully we will still all be talking to each other and Dsis may even get to like her own place, even if its smaller, and a fresh start , I hope so anyway.

She’s lived rent and bill free all her life! She probably has significantly more savings than you. Stop asking for an unequal split! It’s should be split equally 3 ways.

BeUmberMember · 21/10/2026 08:40

Well done you for finally getting your sister to agree to have an estate agent visit. The sooner the better, it will be in everyone's best interests in the end and I hope she appreciates your love and support.

WhereAreTheTrueGreens · 21/10/2026 09:04

Dutchhouse14 · 21/10/2026 00:34

Mum always treated us equally and fairness was really important to her, so Im pretty sure she intended everything to be shared equally as per her will. However she would have wanted us to help Dsis as necessary and definitely wouldn't want her to be homeless.
Im trying to involve Dsis with decision, she wont meet the estate agent but has agreed we can go with him and I think accepts the house needs to be sold.
Ive spoken with my brother about delaying putting it on the market until after xmas to give her more time, I feel so guilty but he would prefer to keep momentum as its been hard to reach this far and we are both a bit concerned if we dont do it now we will just have the same painful conversations again in January or spring and it will drag on and be like the elephant in the room.
Shes still lashing out at me, ( never Dbro!) Ive tried talking about her future plans and said im happy to help and support in anyway I can, speak to mortgage advisor with her, help with solicitors re future purchase, help house hunt, will help with move, decorate etc. I said about working out a purchase budget but she wont disclose her savings to me or talk about getting a mortgage, Ive suggested a 40/30/30 split in her favour but I dont want to give more than that if she cant be open and honest with me about her financial situation, DH thinks the fact shes being so secretive probably means she has more than I think. If she genuinely needs more im happy to rethink the split but I cant do it without first knowing if she can get a mortgage or what her savings are, as the inheritance would really help me and my 4 DC.

If im being honest when DM first became ill ( dementia) I did think her caring for DM was quid pro quo as she'd never moved out and DM financially supported her all her life, no rent or bills etc . As mum deteriorated it was very difficult to care for her and really she should have had more carer visits or been in a care home for the last couple of years as Dsis really needed more help but she blocked any suggestions. When mum died it was almost a relief as it was her time and very peaceful. Dementia is a long goodbye but its obviously heartbreaking and a massive change for Dsis who lived with DM her whole life.
Im sure we will get there in the end and hopefully we will still all be talking to each other and Dsis may even get to like her own place, even if its smaller, and a fresh start , I hope so anyway.

Your poor sister must have been on her knees at times. Looking after a person with dementia is exhausting. She probably needs time to process not siblings money grabbing around her.

I used to work in a building society. The relatives scrabbling around when a customer died after the money was always a sick moment. Give carers time to grieve. The money settlements can wait a bit.

WhereAreTheTrueGreens · 21/10/2026 09:05

Seajaye · 21/10/2026 06:47

Do you think there is a chance that you sister woukd intend leave whatever she leaves at the time she dies to her nephew's and nieces, so indirectly the money might still comes back to your side of the family eventually. Or alternatively, if you could all agree to have a higher proportion of the estate now, you could put now put a second charge on the property she buys with the proceeds for the extra share, to make sure the amount does come back when she eventually dies..

I still reckon given the facts and her means to house herself at her age, that her suggestion of 50/25/25 split of the estate is reasonable compromise and well within the realms of what a court order might end up at if the will was challenged on the basis of reasonable financial provision. Of course you can take your chances and go to court if you think you have a defence to any claim. Go and get done proper legal advice.

If your brother wants to ' stay out of it'' he could also choose relinquish all or part of his share to you,

You do have options her to treat her more decently than it's coming across.

Edited

This

Seeingadistance · 21/10/2026 09:07

It is entirely possible that the resident’s sister’s actions were less altruistic and selfless than some posters are assuming. My reading of the situation is tending towards the resident sister’s insistence on caring for the mother herself actually preventing the provision of more suitable care. She refused additional carers as recommended by professionals, she was content for her mother to be bed bound at an earlier stage than need be.

The fact that she took control inappropriately of her mother’s finances, refused respite for her mother - on grounds of cost, and was reluctant to accept help even from family could also be seen as a form of coercive control and/or a desire to hide inadequacies of care. She would also be aware that if her mother went into a care home earlier then the house would have to be sold earlier to pay for that care and she would have had to find alternative housing earlier and without the benefit of inheritance to come.

From what the OP has said, I reckon her sister was motivated in part (possibly significantly) by financial considerations and by fear of the prospect of having to stand on her own two feet, in terms of finances and housing, for the first time in late middle age.

There’s an air of desperation about her - trying to push back against reality.

Aluna · 21/10/2026 09:17

Seeingadistance · 21/10/2026 09:07

It is entirely possible that the resident’s sister’s actions were less altruistic and selfless than some posters are assuming. My reading of the situation is tending towards the resident sister’s insistence on caring for the mother herself actually preventing the provision of more suitable care. She refused additional carers as recommended by professionals, she was content for her mother to be bed bound at an earlier stage than need be.

The fact that she took control inappropriately of her mother’s finances, refused respite for her mother - on grounds of cost, and was reluctant to accept help even from family could also be seen as a form of coercive control and/or a desire to hide inadequacies of care. She would also be aware that if her mother went into a care home earlier then the house would have to be sold earlier to pay for that care and she would have had to find alternative housing earlier and without the benefit of inheritance to come.

From what the OP has said, I reckon her sister was motivated in part (possibly significantly) by financial considerations and by fear of the prospect of having to stand on her own two feet, in terms of finances and housing, for the first time in late middle age.

There’s an air of desperation about her - trying to push back against reality.

Totally agree. It’s deeply concerning that she refused to use their mother‘s money to pay for care, which wasn’t her money, and actually failed to care for her properly to the point that she was bedbound when it wasn’t appropriate. That’s not care at all. That’s a kind of abuse.

AlexandraCarrington · 21/10/2026 09:19

Your poor sister must have been on her knees at times. Looking after a person with dementia is exhausting.

Then why didn't she seek more help?

WhereAreTheTrueGreens · 21/10/2026 09:21

dicentra365 · 16/10/2026 15:16

I think this is a much more humane approach and takes account of the caring that has been done, and the fact that this is family and not a business. Credit to you for understanding the sacrifice your sister has made. I can't get my head round all these people saying 'it's yours - take it'.

People vary considerably some are carers and some are in it for themselves. You can see the selfish loud and clear on this thread, they have absolutely no idea of the impact of caring for others. Even just living there helps an elderly relative.

Some people are humane and others callous and selfish.

Aluna · 21/10/2026 09:24

WhereAreTheTrueGreens · 21/10/2026 09:04

Your poor sister must have been on her knees at times. Looking after a person with dementia is exhausting. She probably needs time to process not siblings money grabbing around her.

I used to work in a building society. The relatives scrabbling around when a customer died after the money was always a sick moment. Give carers time to grieve. The money settlements can wait a bit.

This is ridiculous. I’ve cared for my elderly parents for the last few years, although I now have a lot of help from carers. My siblings are much less involved. I’m not claiming a larger chunk of inheritance because of it. This was my life choice.

sittingonabeach · 21/10/2026 09:40

WhereAreTheTrueGreens · 21/10/2026 09:21

People vary considerably some are carers and some are in it for themselves. You can see the selfish loud and clear on this thread, they have absolutely no idea of the impact of caring for others. Even just living there helps an elderly relative.

Some people are humane and others callous and selfish.

Edited

But did the sister here help her DM in the right way. Family were advised she needed more care, sister refused. DM ended up bed bound when she didn’t need to be.

If this had been a parent looking after a child and the parent had ignored medical advice and kept them away from professional help I’m sure posters would not be so sympathetic towards them. But because this was an elderly relative it was fine for the sister to do this and take over the finances illegally

Boreded · 21/10/2026 09:44

BruFord · 21/10/2026 02:09

@Boreded Yes, but why? I suppose we think differently on this subject as I see the Mum's money as for her own benefit in her final years. Refusing to spend it on her care seems like the wrong decision to me.

She didn't want to use mums money for carers. I had to arrange OH to come out and get a hoist ,special chair so mum wasn't just in bed, dsis had accepted she had to stay in bed. The hoist really needs 2 carers to move mum, sister refused and said she'd do it herself,

I'm always encouraging my elderly Dad to spend his savings on himself as that's what they're for. If he couldn't handle his own money anymore, I would definitely want to spend his money on making him more comfortable. Her Mum's money didn't need protecting at the end of her life, more of it should've been spent on her IMO.

Edited

Yes I tell my mum to spend every penny on herself too, but if it was come live with me or go into a home I would do what protected the assets first (if feasible)

Im not even saying that’s what the carer was doing, my dad had 2 carers himself to support him before he eventually had to go into a care home, and he was so resistant to it originally because of the loss of dignity. We don’t know why the carer daughter was reluctant, it could be because mum didn’t have money to pay for it, it could be that she was protecting her dignity as long as possible.

Arguing out the hypotheticals doesn’t change the situation. And I genuinely believe that no (good) parent would want to see their child end up without a home so quickly after their death that it is actually almost cruel, just so that the siblings can claim their inheritance.

The inheritance isn’t going anywhere, so why no grace period of a year or two to get back into work and build up some savings etc

sittingonabeach · 21/10/2026 09:55

Boreded · 21/10/2026 09:44

Yes I tell my mum to spend every penny on herself too, but if it was come live with me or go into a home I would do what protected the assets first (if feasible)

Im not even saying that’s what the carer was doing, my dad had 2 carers himself to support him before he eventually had to go into a care home, and he was so resistant to it originally because of the loss of dignity. We don’t know why the carer daughter was reluctant, it could be because mum didn’t have money to pay for it, it could be that she was protecting her dignity as long as possible.

Arguing out the hypotheticals doesn’t change the situation. And I genuinely believe that no (good) parent would want to see their child end up without a home so quickly after their death that it is actually almost cruel, just so that the siblings can claim their inheritance.

The inheritance isn’t going anywhere, so why no grace period of a year or two to get back into work and build up some savings etc

She’s got savings

Seeingadistance · 21/10/2026 10:01

Boreded · 21/10/2026 09:44

Yes I tell my mum to spend every penny on herself too, but if it was come live with me or go into a home I would do what protected the assets first (if feasible)

Im not even saying that’s what the carer was doing, my dad had 2 carers himself to support him before he eventually had to go into a care home, and he was so resistant to it originally because of the loss of dignity. We don’t know why the carer daughter was reluctant, it could be because mum didn’t have money to pay for it, it could be that she was protecting her dignity as long as possible.

Arguing out the hypotheticals doesn’t change the situation. And I genuinely believe that no (good) parent would want to see their child end up without a home so quickly after their death that it is actually almost cruel, just so that the siblings can claim their inheritance.

The inheritance isn’t going anywhere, so why no grace period of a year or two to get back into work and build up some savings etc

I think we can guess why the sister was so reluctant for her mother to have more carers or go into a home. It’s because she would have lost access to her mother’s money and she would have had to find somewhere else to live so the house could be sold to pay for care.

Boreded · 21/10/2026 10:17

Seeingadistance · 21/10/2026 10:01

I think we can guess why the sister was so reluctant for her mother to have more carers or go into a home. It’s because she would have lost access to her mother’s money and she would have had to find somewhere else to live so the house could be sold to pay for care.

Or maybe, it’s because she didn’t want them to see the magical unicorn in the garden…because right now if we are just making up ideas I prefer this one

OVienna · 21/10/2026 10:25

Boreded · 21/10/2026 10:17

Or maybe, it’s because she didn’t want them to see the magical unicorn in the garden…because right now if we are just making up ideas I prefer this one

Your scenario is made up too.

Seeingadistance · 21/10/2026 10:32

Boreded · 21/10/2026 10:17

Or maybe, it’s because she didn’t want them to see the magical unicorn in the garden…because right now if we are just making up ideas I prefer this one

You do understand that care costs? That the costs have to be met by person being cared for?

So the alternative to the resident sister taking on the carer role herself would have meant no longer having her living costs and bills paid by her mother and at some point, once her mother’s savings were exhausted, the sale of the house she was living in.

That’s reality - not made up.

Aluna · 21/10/2026 10:39

Boreded · 21/10/2026 09:44

Yes I tell my mum to spend every penny on herself too, but if it was come live with me or go into a home I would do what protected the assets first (if feasible)

Im not even saying that’s what the carer was doing, my dad had 2 carers himself to support him before he eventually had to go into a care home, and he was so resistant to it originally because of the loss of dignity. We don’t know why the carer daughter was reluctant, it could be because mum didn’t have money to pay for it, it could be that she was protecting her dignity as long as possible.

Arguing out the hypotheticals doesn’t change the situation. And I genuinely believe that no (good) parent would want to see their child end up without a home so quickly after their death that it is actually almost cruel, just so that the siblings can claim their inheritance.

The inheritance isn’t going anywhere, so why no grace period of a year or two to get back into work and build up some savings etc

Her mother had a house and that is normally sold to pay for care costs if there aren’t sufficient funds to pay for care in her home.

Of course that wouldn’t suit the sister as she needs somewhere to live.

PorridgeEater · 21/10/2026 10:54

You would need to have a definite buyer for the house in order to know what it would sell for (often less than estate agent's valuation - they may overvalue to get the business). Then there are sale costs / legal fees to be paid. Even with a 40% split your sister may only end up with around £100,000 or not much more / maybe less. Don't know what property prices are like in your area but that won't go very far.
There's nothing to stop you looking at prices in your area but your sister may be aware that there really isn't much (or anything) she could afford. It's very harsh for her to be put in this position when her world has just been turned upside down. You may need a more realistic idea of what is possible for her.

Ethelspagetti · 21/10/2026 11:08

I’d push ahead regardless of Christmas. Otherwise she may change her mind!

Silverbirchleaf · 21/10/2026 11:44

Ethelspagetti · 21/10/2026 11:08

I’d push ahead regardless of Christmas. Otherwise she may change her mind!

I bc agree. put plans in place.

Seeingadistance · 21/10/2026 11:54

To those who’re of the opinion that the resident sister won’t be able to afford to buy a home of her own.

I’m the same age as her. If my parents had housed me and met my living costs, including buying me a car, for my whole adult life, I would have a LOT of money in the bank. In addition, the sister received a redundancy payment 10 years ago which she seems not to have spent.

There’s a good chance that the sister could afford to buy herself somewhere to live right now with her own savings.

Sewingbeedamned · 21/10/2026 12:54

Boreded · 21/10/2026 10:17

Or maybe, it’s because she didn’t want them to see the magical unicorn in the garden…because right now if we are just making up ideas I prefer this one

You are right that we don’t know why. But this behaviour is well documented in cases of elder abuse so it is at least a red flag. 🚩