Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Selling inherited house when sibling living in it

655 replies

Dutchhouse14 · 16/10/2026 11:50

Our DM passed away a few months ago and her will divides everything equally between me and my 2 siblings.
Im the sole executor.
Dsis ,mid 50s, has always lived at home, never moved out. Towards the end of mums life she became her carer.
She works limited hours although she has increased these with overtime since mum passed away but full time contracts are non existent in her sector.
Shes used to pay a small amount of housekeeping but this stopped when she was made redundant from full time work about 10 years ago.
DMs house is in a bad state of repair, none of us can afford to maintain it . Me and my other sibling want to sell.
But DSis is resisting ,not replying to texts, avoiding phones calls, went out when estates agents came round for valuations etc
She has limited income and savings but could get a small mortgage and with proceeds of sale she could get a 1 bed flat.
My other sibling agrees we need to sell but doesn't want to upset dsis and is generally very good at avoidance! They are happy to give Dsis a much bigger share ie 50% I would prefer 40% which i think is realistic for dsis to buy somewhere.
So ive become the wicked witch of the West in Dsis eyes and shes taking it all out on me, well basically stopped talking to me.
WIBU to put the house on the market?
Probate has been granted.
Anyone know what the legal situation is?
I dont want to fall out with Dsis, I love her, but she seems filled with resentment for me and frankly has said some very hurtful things.
Ive always been there for her but shes never ever reciprocated or supported me when ive needed it.
Although I live with DH and DC, the money would really help my future, my pension etc and I dont want to give my share to Dsis, which is what I think she really wants as shes used to being in charge of DMs money , always lived here so I think basically considers everything as hers.
Just dont know how to move things forward or if im being unreasonable selling the house and wanting my share

OP posts:
AsbestosExpert · 18/10/2026 18:37

AlexandraCarrington · 18/10/2026 17:42

I think more information is required here:

None of that makes any difference to the executor's legal duty, which is to execute the will as written.

Is your sister in a relationship or has ever been in one?

What has that to do with anything?

But it does have a bearing on the costs decision on an order for sale - unless she vacates the executor has to apply for an order for sale, which is heard in court, and has to take into account the resident sisters circumstances.

The court can decide to hand her the house outright (unlikely) a bigger share of the estate or a lifetime right to reside, or turf her out!

But once it goes "to law" the executor will be advised as to the outcome by the court, and that can usurp or more likely delay the action of the will, possibly for the resident sisters lifetime.

NovemberMorn · 18/10/2026 18:37

In reply to Lsquiggles
She also said her sister really loved and cared for her mum, putting her own life on hold for the last 5 years of their mothers life. She didn't trust anyone else to do the job like she did, which when you see the conditions of some residential homes (and I have) is understandable.

The mum isn't here now, but maybe the thought of being taken out of the family home and placed in care, or even having the intrusion of carers coming into her home three times a day, filled her with dread.

The will was made before the mum needed full-time care, which the sister provided. Maybe it would have been written out differently when circumstances changed. I think if the mum was still able to communicate in the last years, the family should get together and talk over what was said...if anything.

My own mum didn't make a will, she left me 2 letters, one contradicted the other in a couple of ways. I worked out (by her writing) which letter was written last and followed that one.

GabriellaFaith · 18/10/2026 19:13

Gloriia · 16/10/2026 11:59

Your dm should've seen this was going to happen and left the whole thing to her dd living there as you and your other dsis have your own homes.

As she didn't all you can do is get legal advice and get it on the market if you dont want to let her carry on living there. Such a shame for everyone involved that it's come to this.

Sorry about your dm Flowers

Sorry, but why should one child get everything and 2 nothing?!

Shes already been living like a teenager rent free for years in a house, which could potentially be argued as 'fair' due to her caring.

But she needs to stop acting like a spoilt brat, grow up and sort herself out. And if the place is in a tip and impacting the value, I'd be looking to see how to oust her sooner. I don't think she has any rights to be there now.

NovemberMorn · 18/10/2026 19:21

GabriellaFaith · 18/10/2026 19:13

Sorry, but why should one child get everything and 2 nothing?!

Shes already been living like a teenager rent free for years in a house, which could potentially be argued as 'fair' due to her caring.

But she needs to stop acting like a spoilt brat, grow up and sort herself out. And if the place is in a tip and impacting the value, I'd be looking to see how to oust her sooner. I don't think she has any rights to be there now.

You sound nice.🙄

Tuesdayschild50 · 18/10/2026 19:27

Its split 3 ways and fairly your sis is unreasonable not you.
You have a family a life of your own bills etc just because she cared for mum doesn't mean she is more entitled.
That situation was always gping to come to an end
You need a solicitor.

TheStepboardisfullofbitteroddos · 18/10/2026 19:33

She sounds awful!

She's had the estate subsidising her for her entire life, why on earth should she get a larger share now?!

Being abusive shouldn't equal getting money off you.

I'd start talking about her paying rent to the other 2 of you- after all she's still benefiting out of the estate. What's 66% of the rental value?

JamesFrond · 18/10/2026 19:46

NovemberMorn · 18/10/2026 19:21

You sound nice.🙄

Yes, let’s all be nice and kind and give our sisters our inheritance against the wishes of our mothers.

BruFord · 18/10/2026 20:15

NovemberMorn · 18/10/2026 18:37

In reply to Lsquiggles
She also said her sister really loved and cared for her mum, putting her own life on hold for the last 5 years of their mothers life. She didn't trust anyone else to do the job like she did, which when you see the conditions of some residential homes (and I have) is understandable.

The mum isn't here now, but maybe the thought of being taken out of the family home and placed in care, or even having the intrusion of carers coming into her home three times a day, filled her with dread.

The will was made before the mum needed full-time care, which the sister provided. Maybe it would have been written out differently when circumstances changed. I think if the mum was still able to communicate in the last years, the family should get together and talk over what was said...if anything.

My own mum didn't make a will, she left me 2 letters, one contradicted the other in a couple of ways. I worked out (by her writing) which letter was written last and followed that one.

Edited

@NovemberMorn Yes, but she'd been financially supported by her parents for decades in a way that her siblings weren't. It was a lovely thing to care for her Mum, but in purely financial terms, her Mum had "prepaid" for that care over the years by enabling her DD to keep all of her salary for herself - imagine never having to pay for your housing and never paying a household bill - I'm also in my 50's and I don't think I know anyone who's been subsidized to that extent.

I agree that the OP and her brother should give their sister more time to come to terms with the situation, but she does need to face it and not expect them to continue subsidizing her the way her parents did. Either she buys them out of the house (I think she probably has the money) or she moves.

Casualuser · 18/10/2026 20:21

Read your updates, your sister sounds like a bully. I bet she has thousands in the bank, subbed from your mums income.
I can see why your mum left the property to all three of you now.
Id go through the motions of attempting to support her find housing informally, then mediation, keeping a paper trail so youve done everything in your power to support her before going to court for an order to sell.
Sorry for your loss op.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 18/10/2026 20:41

With over 20 years of FT work and no living expenses, she could have quarter of a million or more stashed away, plus all the interest she'll have accrued. It could be closer to half a million. I suspect that she could buy her siblings out of the house, she just don't want to part with the money - OP says that she was also reluctant to spend on their Mum so that would make sense

OP also said that the sister refuses to disclose what she has in savings, @BruFord, which perhaps isn't surprising if she's managed to save whatever-it-is at least partly by living for free

I wonder if she's considered that, if it comes to a legal case, she may be obliged to reveal this - at which point things may look somewhat different

BruFord · 18/10/2026 21:25

Puzzledandpissedoff · 18/10/2026 20:41

With over 20 years of FT work and no living expenses, she could have quarter of a million or more stashed away, plus all the interest she'll have accrued. It could be closer to half a million. I suspect that she could buy her siblings out of the house, she just don't want to part with the money - OP says that she was also reluctant to spend on their Mum so that would make sense

OP also said that the sister refuses to disclose what she has in savings, @BruFord, which perhaps isn't surprising if she's managed to save whatever-it-is at least partly by living for free

I wonder if she's considered that, if it comes to a legal case, she may be obliged to reveal this - at which point things may look somewhat different

@Puzzledandpissedoff Yes, I think she'd got a comfortable nest egg, I don't know how she couldn't with no living expenses. Probably significantly more than her siblings!

ReadingSoManyThreads · 18/10/2026 22:33

As executor you need to execute this according to the Will, as you know. So if DBro wants to give her more, he can sort that out of his own share AFTER it has been sold and settled. Personally, I don't think either of you should be subsidising her, as even though she was her carer, she has saved substantially from living at very low cost.

Personally, if I were you, I would leave the selling subject until New Year. But then, I wouldn't let it go. You'll need to steam ahead with it, but I'd definitely wait and not push it this side of Christmas.

ReadingSoManyThreads · 18/10/2026 22:35

I would NOT be asking her for rent, as then it would form a tenancy and it will be a great deal harder to get her out.

BruFord · 18/10/2026 23:10

ReadingSoManyThreads · 18/10/2026 22:35

I would NOT be asking her for rent, as then it would form a tenancy and it will be a great deal harder to get her out.

Absolutely @ReadingSoManyThreads, they don't want to form a tenancy under any circumstances. I agree that waiting until after the New Year is the best approach.

TheMadGardener · 18/10/2026 23:45

OP, when I read this it rang many bells for me! Let me tell you what happened in my family... (settle down, it's storytime!)

Two siblings fell out in 1968 and never spoke again. The sister, when in her 30s, (in the 1970s) moved back in with retired parents and basically lived off them, never paid any household expenses. The brother lived locally, had proper job and own house, still saw parents but completely estranged from sister.

Elderly father dies in 1989. Sister continues to live with mother even though she is not a kind and loving carer and they often argue. House falls into disrepair. Other relatives not allowed in. Eventually in 1997 the mother dies. No will.

Brother obtains letters of administration for estate (executor as such). Goes round to see sister to say house must be sold and estate split. He VERY KINDLY offers to split 70 - 30 in sister's favour since he already has a house and she will need to get her own place. Sister tells him to f**k off, says she is going to continue living in the house and considers it hers, slams the door in his face.

Brother consults lawyers and spends a year and a few thousand pounds sending letters to sister urging her to agree to house sale. Sister stops answering letters and won't listen to reason. Brother eventually gives up and the estate is left in limbo, with sister living in the increasingly dilapidated house not talking to rest of family, FOR TWENTY-ONE YEARS!!!!

2016 - Brother dies (both siblings now in their 80s)

2018 - Crisis when pipe bursts, house floods, has no water or electricity or heating and gaping holes in roof. Other family members are finally allowed in and discover state of house. The sister is hospitalised and forced to reluctantly agree she cannot continue living in house as it is unfit. (She's 81/82 at this point).

Family members get together with social services and sister is rehoused by council in sheltered housing. Family nominates a person (me!!!) to apply for more letters of administration and finally sort out the estate which has been in abeyance since 1997. Much legal advice is taken. House is sold as a fixer-upper (but is in very touristy location so still gets good price for a ruin). Money is split between sister and the brother's widow/children. Brother's legal costs from 1997 are deducted from sister's share. Finally everything is settled, only 21 years late!

Take heed from my family saga - ignore your siblings and use your position as executor to insist on forcing the sale. You will get grief over it, but in a year or so it will all calm down. Don't let your sister stay as a squatter for the next 21 years while the house falls down!

Best of luck.

OneoftheWeddingPeople · 19/10/2026 07:44

Oh god what a nightmare! Poor you having to sort that all out!

LilacReader · 19/10/2026 09:25

Please be careful - I've seen this before. The Living-At-Home child/adult did everything they could to put a dampner on all of the attempts to sell. Even when they did manage to sell the house the LAH child made such a problem that the buyers pulled out. In the end the house was sold but at a fraction of the price as by that time everyone just wanted a quick sale and end of all the problems.

Seeingadistance · 19/10/2026 09:31

I can see this playing out in the ways described by TheMadGardener and LilacReader unfortunately. The resident sister has clearly “failed to launch” and is more like a teenager in the body of a middle aged woman. Her responses so far aren’t rational and she has a lengthy background of not really engaging with reality, preferring to dig her heels in while burying her head in the sand.

Continuing with what has turned into a catalogue of clichés, I think the OP has to simply rip the plaster off by acting quickly and decisively. Giving the resident sister more time is likely to make the whole process just as painful but over an extended period of time.

MrsBananaman · 19/10/2026 10:11

AngelRoja · 18/10/2026 14:45

I think you are underestimating the cost of 5 years of care. The rates for private care live in care at present is around 900 to 1300 pounds a week depending on the region. Hourly will be 20 to 25 an hour. An agency or care homes will cost more. At minimum you are looking at 52,000 a year. Multiply that by five years....

But that’s not OP’s money she’s “saved” it’s her mother’s, and subsequently her own!

My comment was in reply to the suggestion that OP’s sister has saved OP money by caring for her mother, but she did it for her own benefit and to preserve her inheritance, of which she now feels entitled to the lions share.

OVienna · 19/10/2026 10:48

Casualuser · 18/10/2026 20:21

Read your updates, your sister sounds like a bully. I bet she has thousands in the bank, subbed from your mums income.
I can see why your mum left the property to all three of you now.
Id go through the motions of attempting to support her find housing informally, then mediation, keeping a paper trail so youve done everything in your power to support her before going to court for an order to sell.
Sorry for your loss op.

We have similar situation to this evolving in our family where the Live at Home is going to prevail.

Whatever I may think of the remaining parent's reasons for this and conviction that LAH needs protecting, she does HAVE reasons.

It is significant to me that the OPs parent left the will the way she did and did not appoint the LAH in any executor role. If she was that worried about her, she would have done things differently (life share in the property, etc.) She may have felt she'd already had enough support throughout her life, she may be aware of significant savings amassed which the others don't know about.

This detail is important - it is VERY telling she won't disclose this.

ED to add: OP I have read your updates on your mum's care at the end and your sister refusing help.

The OP's mum may also have felt that the LAH did not secure the care she needed - for financial reasons that would ultimately benefit the LAH. Maybe she actually was a bully to the mum!

OP - just execute the will as your mum left it and be done with it.

Yorkshirelass50 · 19/10/2026 10:51

I'm amazed at the amount of people saying she's been living like a teenager. She has been caring for her mother presumably with severe mobility needs (hoist required) for five years. There's nothing more adult than caring for an elderly person 24/7. It's exhausting!

Plenty of women stay at home caring for children. Are they living like teenagers too?

Studyunder · 19/10/2026 11:25

So she refused additional carers or a care home for you mum in order to save money (which your mums money and would have made her life more comfortable. She didn’t register POA and logged onto your mum’s banking and used your mum’s cash card. She financially abused your mum for her own benefit and now you’re saying she should get a larger share of the inheritance? Your mum requested the money to be shared evenly. I would be respecting your mum’s wishing and not be bullied/ guilt tripped or whatever you want to call it, into giving more than her share.

NovemberMorn · 19/10/2026 12:04

JamesFrond · 18/10/2026 19:46

Yes, let’s all be nice and kind and give our sisters our inheritance against the wishes of our mothers.

I have never suggested that the sister/carer be given the house against the wishes of her mother.
I have suggested amongst other things she should be given time. (they all should) to come to terms with the death of their mum, which will enable the sister to come to terms with the fact she has to move out of the family home.

NovemberMorn · 19/10/2026 12:19

BruFord · 18/10/2026 20:15

@NovemberMorn Yes, but she'd been financially supported by her parents for decades in a way that her siblings weren't. It was a lovely thing to care for her Mum, but in purely financial terms, her Mum had "prepaid" for that care over the years by enabling her DD to keep all of her salary for herself - imagine never having to pay for your housing and never paying a household bill - I'm also in my 50's and I don't think I know anyone who's been subsidized to that extent.

I agree that the OP and her brother should give their sister more time to come to terms with the situation, but she does need to face it and not expect them to continue subsidizing her the way her parents did. Either she buys them out of the house (I think she probably has the money) or she moves.

Edited

We have no idea how much money the sister has. We do know the OP is not waiting for the inheritance, and we know she is willing to give the carer sister more than her share, which is good.
The sister is a first time buyer in her mid fifties, she is going to need plenty.
According to figures, the average price of a one bedroom flat in my area is around £200.000.

We agree, and I think the majority do, that more time is needed, and I do think it's worth speaking to a solicitor to get clarification on how long they will legally have to sort out the will.

sittingonabeach · 19/10/2026 12:20

Yorkshirelass50 · 19/10/2026 10:51

I'm amazed at the amount of people saying she's been living like a teenager. She has been caring for her mother presumably with severe mobility needs (hoist required) for five years. There's nothing more adult than caring for an elderly person 24/7. It's exhausting!

Plenty of women stay at home caring for children. Are they living like teenagers too?

She wasn’t caring for the whole of her adult life. She’s in her 50s. What was she doing for the previous 30 years?

I am carer for my DM so I know how relentless it can be, and I am responsible for her finances under POA. I am not taking advantage of her finances though

Looks like this sister has been taking advantage of her situation. Which responsible adult would expect her elderly parent (before care was needed) to fund her living situation. When more care was needed why wouldn’t you choose the best route rather than the one which helped your financial situation.

How many threads on MN state you can’t expect an inheritance. Whereas this sister appears to have positioned herself to try and get maximum inheritance to the detriment of others including her DM

Swipe left for the next trending thread