Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask how to avoid 2nd home rate stamp duty

534 replies

Stampdutywoes · 13/10/2026 13:22

Hear me out before you attack.

Currently living in rental property after splitting with ex partner. We own the home he is living in jointly.
The landlord of my rental wants to sell and I would like to buy it but the additional 5% stamp duty rate for what would count as a second home is a killer.
Are there any conveyancing solicitors who could advise on how to avoid (not evade) this extra 5%?

OP posts:
AnonyMumAuDHD · 15/10/2026 02:19

Been pondering this from all angles. Even wondered about a property trust. But I keep coming back to the same question - if the first property is worth £2m, WHY would you deprive yourself of access to those funds whether to invest in a home or elsewhere? I know ex likes the house, and perhaps you are the party leaving and feel guilty so don’t want to mess his life up any more, but really you both have to be practical and realistic.

The complicated manner of owning 2 properties in this way has SD, CGT and IHT implications - that all go away of you both just sell the first shared home and start over.

And that is while you are both single - if either of you find new partners, the complexity will increase exponentially, especially if a new woman takes a shine to the first house. And what the ex falls in love and decides to leave his share of the houses to that new partner? You would not be able to evict her and access your share then either.

Honestly, I think worrying about stamp duty evasion is the last thing you should focusing on - you both need to sell the first house. Given you both seem emotionally entangled despite your separation, otherwise you wouldn’t be exploring the ideas here, I feel you might be wiser to try to free yourselves properly.

Q2C4 · 15/10/2026 06:19

AnonyMumAuDHD · 15/10/2026 00:37

No. It does not mean that there is no one in the property at all, but that there is no single person living there as their primary home.

‘Resident’ is defined: ‘in relation to any dwelling, [resident] means an individual who has attained the age of 18 years and has his sole or main residence in the dwelling.’ [per Section 6(5) of the Local Government Finance Act 1992].

As I said above, you cannot have two main residences, nor are you allowed to choose - the council concerned with charging evaluates which property is your primary residence according to where your family life is situated.

But if OP has her main residence (family life) in one house and can evidence her separation from her husband who has his main residence in the other property, there is no property without a resident?

Or is a married couple deemed to only have one residence between them until they divorce?

Stampdutywoes · 15/10/2026 08:00

AnonyMumAuDHD · 15/10/2026 02:19

Been pondering this from all angles. Even wondered about a property trust. But I keep coming back to the same question - if the first property is worth £2m, WHY would you deprive yourself of access to those funds whether to invest in a home or elsewhere? I know ex likes the house, and perhaps you are the party leaving and feel guilty so don’t want to mess his life up any more, but really you both have to be practical and realistic.

The complicated manner of owning 2 properties in this way has SD, CGT and IHT implications - that all go away of you both just sell the first shared home and start over.

And that is while you are both single - if either of you find new partners, the complexity will increase exponentially, especially if a new woman takes a shine to the first house. And what the ex falls in love and decides to leave his share of the houses to that new partner? You would not be able to evict her and access your share then either.

Honestly, I think worrying about stamp duty evasion is the last thing you should focusing on - you both need to sell the first house. Given you both seem emotionally entangled despite your separation, otherwise you wouldn’t be exploring the ideas here, I feel you might be wiser to try to free yourselves properly.

The existing property isn’t worth anywhere near £2million, that figure was just picked out of the air to illustrate why he could afford to pay half for the new cheaper property but couldn’t buy me out of the old one.

I understand all your points make sense logically but it doesn’t all come down to logic in our situation.

OP posts:
Stampdutywoes · 15/10/2026 08:02

Q2C4 · 15/10/2026 06:19

But if OP has her main residence (family life) in one house and can evidence her separation from her husband who has his main residence in the other property, there is no property without a resident?

Or is a married couple deemed to only have one residence between them until they divorce?

Not married in our case

OP posts:
Alphavilla · 15/10/2026 08:04

Stampdutywoes · 13/10/2026 14:16

Let me get my tiny violin out. People with zero homes don’t have to pay stamp duty and they had the opportunity to study, work and save as we have done.

Explain to me why it is any different financially to if we each owned one of the houses rather than each owning half of both houses, given that we live separately.

The stamp duty rules apply to a ‘major interest’ in land. That major interest has a monetary value of at least £40,000. So if your share of the existing property has a value of £40,000 or more then you are liable for the higher rate SDLT on your next property. Is not a case of two halves of a house make one each!!

the only legitimate way of not paying higher SDLT is to dispose of your existing interest in the first property.

MeandT · 15/10/2026 08:08

Unwitting quote of the week from OP!

" it doesn’t all come down to logic in our situation."

You don't say 😳

Stampdutywoes · 15/10/2026 08:45

MeandT · 15/10/2026 08:08

Unwitting quote of the week from OP!

" it doesn’t all come down to logic in our situation."

You don't say 😳

😀

OP posts:
MeandT · 15/10/2026 09:01

I think I started reading this thread 2 days ago thinking 'jesus, what a chancer!'.

At this point, hand on heart, all I can say is.

GOOD LUCK!!! Flowers

Stampdutywoes · 15/10/2026 09:05

MeandT · 15/10/2026 09:01

I think I started reading this thread 2 days ago thinking 'jesus, what a chancer!'.

At this point, hand on heart, all I can say is.

GOOD LUCK!!! Flowers

Oh dear, I’m getting sympathy now 😂😂😂

OP posts:
AnonyMumAuDHD · 15/10/2026 10:10

Q2C4 · 15/10/2026 06:19

But if OP has her main residence (family life) in one house and can evidence her separation from her husband who has his main residence in the other property, there is no property without a resident?

Or is a married couple deemed to only have one residence between them until they divorce?

Yes - married couples are deemed to have only one primary property - their family [married] life is together [notionally, legally and financially], even if DH spends 4-5 days a week in the second property for work and one of your kids is there 8m of the year for university LOL - we checked this out thoroughly. The only way to establish two separate primary homes for two people is to dissolve the family tie - ie by divorcing.

OP isn’t married though, so - on paper - the only ties are via their jointly owned property. It might raise a flag at council tax office, but if they do an avadavat (legal declaration) witnessed by their solicitor to state that they are a separating couple, but required to continue to co-mingle their finances for a period, it should satisfy them. Tbh, though, given the cost of all the legal stuff to arrange their affairs around the fact that OP’s ex doesn’t want to leave his house and OP is reluctant to force him, I’d still be advising her as a friend to try to harden up and be practical. It’ll cost more that the second property stamp duty charge in the long run to administer all of this and it leaves OP’s very vulnerable as she will have no direct/sole control over her assets - and therefore her life.

AnonyMumAuDHD · 15/10/2026 10:15

Stampdutywoes · 15/10/2026 08:00

The existing property isn’t worth anywhere near £2million, that figure was just picked out of the air to illustrate why he could afford to pay half for the new cheaper property but couldn’t buy me out of the old one.

I understand all your points make sense logically but it doesn’t all come down to logic in our situation.

Thing is - it should. You need a good friend in real life you give you a little shake (and a hug). By pandering to whatever it is that makes you feel you can’t insist on selling the first house and make a clean break - you leave yourself vulnerable and ensure the ex has a lasting influence - and control - over your life.

My fear is that he is using his reluctance to sell, and your feelings towards him, to continue to manipulate after you have separated… and he will be able to continue to do so?

Tillow4ever · 15/10/2026 11:16

You really aren’t helping yourself on this thread - comments you make completely change a situation sometimes, and that will affect the advice you can be given.

For example, you originally said about the house your ex living in being worth £2m, then later said that value was made up, then you referred to your old home as an “estate” but one of your latest comments says the house is worth “nowhere near £2m” - in which case it’s likely just a house and not an estate at all.

Another example is being adamant he is an ex, but then making comments about how you like to have your own space, how it gives you the best in a relationship without the drudgery, basically making it sound like you are still together but choosing to live independently.

Both of these are actually pretty crucial to getting good advice.

Trying to get the full picture here, advice will change depending on the answers, so i have a few questions:

How old are you both?

How long were you in a relationship for?

Were you ever married to each other?

I know you said you don’t have kids together, do either of you have children of your own?

Are you genuinely separated? Or are you separated but hook up on occasion? Or actually together but living apart for “tax avoidance” reasons?

Who’s decision was it to end the relationship?

It all sounds amicable… what was the reason it ended and is there any chance you might get back together? Are you hoping you might?

Have either of you been seeing anyone else since you separated?

Is it 5 years or longer since you split up?

What is the actual reason for wanting to stay connected in this way?

What are the actual values of the 2 properties (roughly as I know you say you don’t have a valuation of property 1)?

It very much feels like one of you is being manipulated/controlled if you’ve genuinely split up. However, I suspect you haven’t split up, the fact you’re so tight you’ve come to MN AIBU (and not even posting in legal) for advice on avoiding tax that you’d already worked out you need to pay rather than pay a professional, makes me think you’re trying to find ways to avoid paying certain taxes… but I think you’re both fools because you haven’t taken advice on what to do and how and you’ve instead likely created yourselves even bigger tax issues. Either that or you rent the place you say you’re living in for when you need your own space, the landlord has decided after 5 years they want to sell and now you’re panicking at the idea of losing your sanctuary so trying to find a way to buy it and keep tax low.

Stampdutywoes · 15/10/2026 13:02

Tillow4ever · 15/10/2026 11:16

You really aren’t helping yourself on this thread - comments you make completely change a situation sometimes, and that will affect the advice you can be given.

For example, you originally said about the house your ex living in being worth £2m, then later said that value was made up, then you referred to your old home as an “estate” but one of your latest comments says the house is worth “nowhere near £2m” - in which case it’s likely just a house and not an estate at all.

Another example is being adamant he is an ex, but then making comments about how you like to have your own space, how it gives you the best in a relationship without the drudgery, basically making it sound like you are still together but choosing to live independently.

Both of these are actually pretty crucial to getting good advice.

Trying to get the full picture here, advice will change depending on the answers, so i have a few questions:

How old are you both?

How long were you in a relationship for?

Were you ever married to each other?

I know you said you don’t have kids together, do either of you have children of your own?

Are you genuinely separated? Or are you separated but hook up on occasion? Or actually together but living apart for “tax avoidance” reasons?

Who’s decision was it to end the relationship?

It all sounds amicable… what was the reason it ended and is there any chance you might get back together? Are you hoping you might?

Have either of you been seeing anyone else since you separated?

Is it 5 years or longer since you split up?

What is the actual reason for wanting to stay connected in this way?

What are the actual values of the 2 properties (roughly as I know you say you don’t have a valuation of property 1)?

It very much feels like one of you is being manipulated/controlled if you’ve genuinely split up. However, I suspect you haven’t split up, the fact you’re so tight you’ve come to MN AIBU (and not even posting in legal) for advice on avoiding tax that you’d already worked out you need to pay rather than pay a professional, makes me think you’re trying to find ways to avoid paying certain taxes… but I think you’re both fools because you haven’t taken advice on what to do and how and you’ve instead likely created yourselves even bigger tax issues. Either that or you rent the place you say you’re living in for when you need your own space, the landlord has decided after 5 years they want to sell and now you’re panicking at the idea of losing your sanctuary so trying to find a way to buy it and keep tax low.

I’m not going to reply to all of this as you are being quite rude saying that we are tight and fools. If you read my posts properly, I didn’t say it was worth 2 million, I said “ say it was worth 2 million ….” when I was replying to statements saying that he could buy me out if he could contribute 50% to buying the rental.

Nothing we have done to date regarding the properties has been to evade or even avoid tax and of course we would take proper professional advice before making any decisions. That isn’t mutually exclusive with raising a post about it on MN and enjoying the batshit craziness resulting from that.

OP posts:
Tillow4ever · 15/10/2026 16:52

Stampdutywoes · 15/10/2026 13:02

I’m not going to reply to all of this as you are being quite rude saying that we are tight and fools. If you read my posts properly, I didn’t say it was worth 2 million, I said “ say it was worth 2 million ….” when I was replying to statements saying that he could buy me out if he could contribute 50% to buying the rental.

Nothing we have done to date regarding the properties has been to evade or even avoid tax and of course we would take proper professional advice before making any decisions. That isn’t mutually exclusive with raising a post about it on MN and enjoying the batshit craziness resulting from that.

So evading the questions doesn’t make you look any less dodgy.

Stampdutywoes · 15/10/2026 18:36

Tillow4ever · 15/10/2026 16:52

So evading the questions doesn’t make you look any less dodgy.

Why so rude? And what on earth makes you think I would want to give you all that information?

OP posts:
MsDitsy · 15/10/2026 23:38

Stampdutywoes · 13/10/2026 13:22

Hear me out before you attack.

Currently living in rental property after splitting with ex partner. We own the home he is living in jointly.
The landlord of my rental wants to sell and I would like to buy it but the additional 5% stamp duty rate for what would count as a second home is a killer.
Are there any conveyancing solicitors who could advise on how to avoid (not evade) this extra 5%?

Reading most of your responses, it sounds like you still have a lovely relationship with your ex and have a soft spot for your former home which sounds like it's large and quirky and something I'd want to keep too.

I can't offer any advice but understand why you wouldn't want to pay second home tax when you are actually using it as your sole residence.

Hopefully you will get some legal advice that will save you some money at least.

Stampdutywoes · 15/10/2026 23:47

MsDitsy · 15/10/2026 23:38

Reading most of your responses, it sounds like you still have a lovely relationship with your ex and have a soft spot for your former home which sounds like it's large and quirky and something I'd want to keep too.

I can't offer any advice but understand why you wouldn't want to pay second home tax when you are actually using it as your sole residence.

Hopefully you will get some legal advice that will save you some money at least.

Thank you, that’s really kind

OP posts:
OutAndAbouting · 16/10/2026 01:33

Stampdutywoes · 13/10/2026 21:05

Tens of thousands is a lot of money to us, hence the original question, but we can manage to cover it if we can get the property at a good price.

Well why on earth are you considering managing all of these wangles?

Tillow4ever · 16/10/2026 05:50

Stampdutywoes · 15/10/2026 18:36

Why so rude? And what on earth makes you think I would want to give you all that information?

It’s not rude to ask questions of someone who has come to a public forum and asked people to help them.

It is, however, rude of the person making that request, to go on the attack when people say things they don’t want to hear.

As for WHY you’d want to give that info / because it’s all relevant to receive accurate advice!

I’m starting to think you aren’t here in good faith though, as any genuine person would have provided most of that information in their OP, or at least when requested. You just seem to want to keep the thread going as long as possible by writing antagonistic replies to people.

Cyclingmummy1 · 16/10/2026 08:57

MsDitsy · 15/10/2026 23:38

Reading most of your responses, it sounds like you still have a lovely relationship with your ex and have a soft spot for your former home which sounds like it's large and quirky and something I'd want to keep too.

I can't offer any advice but understand why you wouldn't want to pay second home tax when you are actually using it as your sole residence.

Hopefully you will get some legal advice that will save you some money at least.

That's the point, isn't it? She already owns a home therefore this is a second home. The fact it's 'quirky' and she 'has a soft spot for it' doesn't change the legal situation.

Stampdutywoes · 16/10/2026 16:30

Tillow4ever · 16/10/2026 05:50

It’s not rude to ask questions of someone who has come to a public forum and asked people to help them.

It is, however, rude of the person making that request, to go on the attack when people say things they don’t want to hear.

As for WHY you’d want to give that info / because it’s all relevant to receive accurate advice!

I’m starting to think you aren’t here in good faith though, as any genuine person would have provided most of that information in their OP, or at least when requested. You just seem to want to keep the thread going as long as possible by writing antagonistic replies to people.

Edited

It is rude to call me tight, foolish and dodgy. You are the one being antagonistic, not me.

OP posts:
Stampdutywoes · 16/10/2026 16:34

OutAndAbouting · 16/10/2026 01:33

Well why on earth are you considering managing all of these wangles?

No wangles being considered. Either we get the place at a good enough price to offset at least some of the higher rate stamp duty or we don’t bother buying it.

OP posts:
KeepPumping · 16/10/2026 18:54

usernamealreadytaken · 14/10/2026 13:55

And how do you think most people who buy a second property as a holiday home got the cash to do that? It wasn’t delivered by fairies, they worked for it...

Most of them used London Equity, thankfully drying up now.

AnnoyedAsAllHeck · 17/10/2026 22:51

Stampdutywoes · 13/10/2026 14:28

I’m chuckling away

I hope you are still "chuckling" when you both sell your homes or your heirs do and they have to pay CGT on both properties.
I am hoping you will sell them both while you both are alive and you enjoy your ex paying a lot less in CGT than you end up having to pay. 😎

Stampdutywoes · 17/10/2026 23:21

AnnoyedAsAllHeck · 17/10/2026 22:51

I hope you are still "chuckling" when you both sell your homes or your heirs do and they have to pay CGT on both properties.
I am hoping you will sell them both while you both are alive and you enjoy your ex paying a lot less in CGT than you end up having to pay. 😎

How spiteful

OP posts: