Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is sending nice buns into school showing off?

301 replies

Luce1234 · 12/10/2026 22:18

Possibly very much overthinking here, but it is my daughters birthday on Wednesday (turning 9) her class normally take a sweet treat/cake in on on their birthdays, this is fine with the parents and no one has allergies (know this from several parties). I love baking but never really do it much, last year I made and took in some cupcakes, I'm a home baker but can turn out a decent cupcake, planning to do it this year again but my husband has said that I shouldn't, that it is very much attention seeking and very 'look at me" This isn't my intention at all, I have most of the ingrediants in the cupboard all ready, it'll only cost me about £4 to make 36 buns, I only have to buy the butter and some icing sugar. I have boxes already that I bought in bulk from Temu and tbh I just like baking. But I would hate to be talked about by any of the mum's, or for people to think that I'm attempting to show off, parents would see them as they are normally given out last thing. Should I just buy some shop bought cake or buns, which would cost me more money and not be as nice? I'm inclined to think that my husband is been harsh, they will look nice when done, but I reckon people will still be able to tell that they are homemade and that I haven't spent loads of money buying them. Thanks.

OP posts:
Littlecrake · 13/10/2026 09:08

I don’t gaf about hygiene - most people aren’t so disgusting that their food will make me ill. I do have a “school mum friend” who won’t eat homemade stuff - she has other hang-ups too, but I don’t think it’s that common.
I would rather homemade than shop, generally, and much prefer cakes to sweets.
I have a kid with allergies but his 3 siblings were all in classes where “nobody has allergies”. It’s a pita when they have unlabelled food -I really like to know what’s in the crumbs in my car and on my floor just in case - but ds with allergies would not in a million years eat it. Benedict’s law has come in very recently and schools that were a bit lax may well be tightening up.
But are we talking bun/fairy cake or cupcake? I don’t really want my kid being given a huge cupcake with half a pound of buttercream on top. I know it’s “just a one off for a birthday” but it’s 30 times a year, plus the kids actual party, plus the number of times it happens at clubs and activities, plus family birthdays and celebrations, and sometimes you just want to do a bit of home baking for tea without thinking “omg this with be the twelfth cake this kid has had in the last 5 days”. Some people are happy for their kids to be given a “one off for a birthday” sugar-fest multiple times a week but given the frequency I would be much happier with a small bun/fairy/butterfly cake than a large, heavily buttercreamed cupcake. I realise other people don’t agree and that’s fine but on a population level we are fucking enormous now and kids are bearing the brunt of indulgent adult lifestyles. I kind of get what the DH is saying too. The “culture” of the school is a low key token, and his kid is arriving with a tray of individual boxes with elaborately decorated cakes. Some people will be snits about it but it’s questionable whether these people should be the priority on your kids birthday. One of my dc would be embarrassed if I did it on his bday but the others would like it.

Monty36 · 13/10/2026 09:15

I can see where you hubby is coming from. But he might be thinking about it related to work.
There were always people who ‘brought in cakes’. It used to be an activity often done by people in my experience to boost popularity.
There are considerations around allergies to consider. Best not to these days. Leave well alone. You only need one child who is allergic and you will have problems galore.

runnerducky · 13/10/2026 09:16

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 13/10/2026 08:40

Completely agree. It goes hand in hand with an inability to recognise genuine risks, such as children spending most of their lives online, or not grasping that you can't leave it to children to take the lead on toilet training or it might just not happen, or that the supposedly hygienic mass produced food is stuffed full of additives that you wouldn't find in home-cooked food.

I agree with both these posts. We’ve sleptwalk into a situation where people are happier chucking their children ultra-processed ‘kid’ snacks with all sorts of weird shit in it, or overpriced nutrition-free ‘wafers’ than eating a homemade cake. Big food has really done a number of so many of us. So many people I know now are so chronically anxious about everything. It must be exhausting. It’s exhausting to listen to frankly. And it absolutely passes on to the kids. Anxiety breeds anxiety. Many of my anxious friends have kids with behavioural issues or ‘quirks’ that are born from that anxiety and so the cycle continues.

Eat the cake, eat real food, get dirty, chill the fuck out.

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 13/10/2026 09:19

Check school policy - there was a law change very recently. If that allows home made cakes, make the cakes.

It's a lovely thing to do. A few people may be weird about it, but someone will always find a reason to complain or be contrary. Don't let them control your life.

And that last point applies to your husband as well as strangers. Does he often belittle you? Try to make you doubt yourself and what other people think or say about you? That's a worrying trait.

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 13/10/2026 09:26

The cake box thing passed me by. When I hand out baked goods (still happens at parkrun sometimes) I take them in a metal or plastic cake tin and people pick out what they want. If OP is planning to put cakes in individual boxes that may be what her husband thinks will look a bit try hard.

Sartre · 13/10/2026 09:28

I did it once in reception for DS’s birthday. It’s possible people thought I was showing off or a dick but I don’t care. They’ve taken little packs of Percy pigs in since. I like Percy’s because they’re veggie.

Bogofftosomewherehot · 13/10/2026 09:28

I've binned "homemade" from school, especially if I've thought the child had a hand in making them, Too many spoon lickers and finger lickers out there.

My MiL is immaculate and her house is showroom standard, but I know every meal comes with a dose of spit. No thanks.

Fasthorses · 13/10/2026 09:29

It wont only cost you £4. Not for 36.
A box of eggs alone is £2 and you'll need the whole box to do 36 cupcakes, a 250g block of butter is £2 and you need a whole block at least to butter ice 36 cupcakes plus a block or more to actually bake 36 cupcakes, thats before sugar, self raising flour, icing sugar for icing, 36 cupcake cases which again will cost you a pound of two. Then you've already spent on 36 little boxes off temu, even if that was only a pound or two I'd guess it'll cost you more like £9-£10 overall. It certainly wont cost only £4.

Totaldramallama · 13/10/2026 09:37

I think it's quite sad that people won't eat homemade cake due to some paranoia about germs. Germs that are everywhere and don't actually do anything to harm you. I've never heard of anyone becoming actually unwell from a homemade cake. Shop bought cake is, on the whole, disgustingly sweet, full of crap, and wrapped in plastic.

Dollymylove · 13/10/2026 09:44

Sleepyjeancheeredup · 12/10/2026 22:37

I worked at a school years ago, helped kids prepare food one lesson, it was a sweet treat to be shared at home. Dear God. I couldn't believe how lax the teacher was, luckily for the people who were eating these treats I had wipes with me and hair ties and prevented some disgusting habits from going on during that process. Yes, they were kids, but it really made me reconsider what happens in the making of home made food.

From that day on I have never, ever eaten anything not properly prepared by a source which is held to health code standards, or by someone I know personally and well,

Edited

How can you be sure that workers at the local bakery are not pissing in the cake mix? 🤣🤣

Namechangewegovyjune26 · 13/10/2026 09:45

Fasthorses · 13/10/2026 09:29

It wont only cost you £4. Not for 36.
A box of eggs alone is £2 and you'll need the whole box to do 36 cupcakes, a 250g block of butter is £2 and you need a whole block at least to butter ice 36 cupcakes plus a block or more to actually bake 36 cupcakes, thats before sugar, self raising flour, icing sugar for icing, 36 cupcake cases which again will cost you a pound of two. Then you've already spent on 36 little boxes off temu, even if that was only a pound or two I'd guess it'll cost you more like £9-£10 overall. It certainly wont cost only £4.

If she already has most of that stuff though?

TattieSconeEggAndBacon · 13/10/2026 09:45

Cascadia · 13/10/2026 09:06

People who think they/ their children are at greater risk from a homemade cupcake than a UPF supermarket one are terrible at assessing risk.

100% agree.

SonK · 13/10/2026 09:47

I think it's a great idea, in fact I remember when I was in primary school over 20 years ago a mum brought two massive trays of baked goods for her son's birthday - they were brought so not homemade, but we're fresh and the smell was delicious.

All the children were so excited because it was just different and the teachers really enjoyed it too.

Who cares what other mums will say or think, do what you want OP and I hope your daughter has a fabulous birthday on Wednesday!

ToffeePennie · 13/10/2026 09:47

Totaldramallama · 13/10/2026 09:37

I think it's quite sad that people won't eat homemade cake due to some paranoia about germs. Germs that are everywhere and don't actually do anything to harm you. I've never heard of anyone becoming actually unwell from a homemade cake. Shop bought cake is, on the whole, disgustingly sweet, full of crap, and wrapped in plastic.

It’s not always paranoia about germs. Sometimes it’s being concerned about ingredients. My youngest son attends a theatre class with a child who is so severely allergic to nuts that they have to eat in a separate room to their friends. I now keep an entirely nut free house to allow my son to sit with his friend and have lunch together.
Natasha’s law and Benedict’s law exist because Natasha and Benedict were both fed things they were told was totally safe. They weren’t safe. There is no way for parents to know if they have been fed an allergen at school with homemade cupcakes. At least with packaged ones we have all the ingredients.

OffTheMap · 13/10/2026 09:49

Sleepyjeancheeredup · 12/10/2026 22:35

No, it's not showing off, but just buy something from a shop. I never eat anything prepared by strangers in their own home. You could be naked, with your cat licking the spoon, adding arsenic to the mixture with every third stir.

Yes, I get that's a bit unlikely but you definitely see the point.

I definitely do not see the point.

The children have been to each others parties and survived. Do you prevent your Dc eating homemade sandwiches and birthday cake at parties?
Do you have such trust in commercial production and would rather your kids eat UPF?

Bikergran · 13/10/2026 09:51

FFS. What has it come to that making a few trays of cupcakes is "showing off"? Are our collective cooking skills so meagre these days? I could do these without thinking in between other tasks.

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 13/10/2026 09:54

I don’t like your DH attitude towards you, does he often try to dampen your sparkle and things you enjoy?

OffTheMap · 13/10/2026 09:55

My friend and I made enough buns (yes BUNS…before everything was branded ‘cupcakes’) for the entire primary school for Red Nose Day , the ingredients were published in the newsletter, they got a bun (BUN) as part of taking part in the dress-up fundraiser and not one parent declined for their Dc to eat a homemade bun (decorated with icing and a red nose)

OffTheMap · 13/10/2026 09:57

OP: enjoy making the cakes. Enjoy celebrating your DD’s birthday. Stop over thinking it.

MN is populated by those most in retreat from normal life.

floopyboop · 13/10/2026 09:57

Awww I love this tradition. My mum only did it for me once - not homemade, but two smallish shop bought chocolate cakes. It was for my 9th birthday and I'd just moved schools due to terrible bullying and I think my mum wanted to make sure I made some friends and gave a positive impression. They certainly went down well! Agree that kids won't care one way or the other if they're homemade (too young to appreciate it really) but if you can do it I think you should! Honestly probably healthier than whatever you'd get in Tesco.

OffTheMap · 13/10/2026 09:58

ToffeePennie · 13/10/2026 09:47

It’s not always paranoia about germs. Sometimes it’s being concerned about ingredients. My youngest son attends a theatre class with a child who is so severely allergic to nuts that they have to eat in a separate room to their friends. I now keep an entirely nut free house to allow my son to sit with his friend and have lunch together.
Natasha’s law and Benedict’s law exist because Natasha and Benedict were both fed things they were told was totally safe. They weren’t safe. There is no way for parents to know if they have been fed an allergen at school with homemade cupcakes. At least with packaged ones we have all the ingredients.

The OP said: there aren’t ally allergy issues in this case.

Totaldramallama · 13/10/2026 10:06

ToffeePennie · 13/10/2026 09:47

It’s not always paranoia about germs. Sometimes it’s being concerned about ingredients. My youngest son attends a theatre class with a child who is so severely allergic to nuts that they have to eat in a separate room to their friends. I now keep an entirely nut free house to allow my son to sit with his friend and have lunch together.
Natasha’s law and Benedict’s law exist because Natasha and Benedict were both fed things they were told was totally safe. They weren’t safe. There is no way for parents to know if they have been fed an allergen at school with homemade cupcakes. At least with packaged ones we have all the ingredients.

There are multiple comments on this thread about people not eating homemade food due to hygiene concerns, not allergies. Op is already aware of allergies in the class

ThanksItHasPockets · 13/10/2026 10:13

It is not relevant that there are no allergy issues in the class to the best of OP's knowledge. Benedict's Law requires stringent whole-school allergy policies and in the vast majority of schools this means a ban on homemade baked goods.

JustGoogleIt15 · 13/10/2026 10:15

NetZeroZealot · 13/10/2026 07:48

It’s a lovely thing to do OP.

ignore the weird hygiene freaks who would prefer to stuff themselves with upf enriched crap from the supermarket.

Don't be ridiculous

Sahara123 · 13/10/2026 10:18

Monty36 · 13/10/2026 09:15

I can see where you hubby is coming from. But he might be thinking about it related to work.
There were always people who ‘brought in cakes’. It used to be an activity often done by people in my experience to boost popularity.
There are considerations around allergies to consider. Best not to these days. Leave well alone. You only need one child who is allergic and you will have problems galore.

In my office there’s always a tin of biscuits or cakes on the go. Homemade stuff gets devoured! One of my cakes went down particularly well, my colleague asked if I would make one as her daughter’s wedding cake, I was very honoured.