Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is sending nice buns into school showing off?

301 replies

Luce1234 · 12/10/2026 22:18

Possibly very much overthinking here, but it is my daughters birthday on Wednesday (turning 9) her class normally take a sweet treat/cake in on on their birthdays, this is fine with the parents and no one has allergies (know this from several parties). I love baking but never really do it much, last year I made and took in some cupcakes, I'm a home baker but can turn out a decent cupcake, planning to do it this year again but my husband has said that I shouldn't, that it is very much attention seeking and very 'look at me" This isn't my intention at all, I have most of the ingrediants in the cupboard all ready, it'll only cost me about £4 to make 36 buns, I only have to buy the butter and some icing sugar. I have boxes already that I bought in bulk from Temu and tbh I just like baking. But I would hate to be talked about by any of the mum's, or for people to think that I'm attempting to show off, parents would see them as they are normally given out last thing. Should I just buy some shop bought cake or buns, which would cost me more money and not be as nice? I'm inclined to think that my husband is been harsh, they will look nice when done, but I reckon people will still be able to tell that they are homemade and that I haven't spent loads of money buying them. Thanks.

OP posts:
Chromm · 13/10/2026 10:28

People are thanked profusely where I work when they bring in home-made cake. The idea that it’s showing off is just so bizarre and mean-spirited. That’s without the hygiene-anxiety. What’s wrong with people.

ViciousCurrentBun · 13/10/2026 10:40

I was not one of the worriers about home baked goods till a really nice Mum from the school, gate invited me back for coffee. Her cat was sat on the kitchen counter, I have always had and love cats. She offers me a sandwich, I said no thanks just because I was not hungry. She made the sandwich on the counter top where the cats arse had been, so I was glad I said no. Not on a board or a plate directly on the counter top. Maybe she was just one in a million but after that I’m more wary of home baked stuff.

Honeypickle · 13/10/2026 10:42

Check with the school, primary probably may be okay but my children’s secondary school won’t allow homemade food given out - think allergy based concerns rather than hygiene!

Runnermumof2 · 13/10/2026 11:07

We aren't allowed to bring in treats to school, but I think this is lovely. Much nicer than shop bought. Don't let your husband ruin it. If it brings you happiness, go for it.

Simini · 13/10/2026 11:12

I think it is a really lovely gesture and more people should home bake. It's the opposite of look at me. It's economic, eco friendly and also shares an important message to your kid, the other kids in the class and to the parents that the nicest things in life don't have to cost a fortune. I think homemade cupcakes are lovely. Maybe more mums will do the same after you do it. Your husband is wrong. 100%

Fasthorses · 13/10/2026 11:13

Namechangewegovyjune26 · 13/10/2026 09:45

If she already has most of that stuff though?

Did she get it for free? No, she paid money for it. Just because she already has it in, doesnt mean she didnt pay for it!

Simini · 13/10/2026 11:16

Also, re any concerns about hygiene....they do not have to eat it.....it's the thought that counts. I actually think the world is becoming an incredibly sad place when we trust factory produced food over someone hard work and thoughtful baking.....have you ever read about the legal amounts of rat pee and other waste products allowed in manufactured food? It is worse in the USA but we still have margins in this country.....

GreatFish · 13/10/2026 11:16

Kids love stuff like this.

Hedgehogbrown · 13/10/2026 11:29

Do you think men would have this worry? Do men ever get told they are showing off or bragging to other Dad's? No! It's just something to keep women quiet. You bring in those buns and if anyone doesn't like it they can fuck off!

AlwaysExtraHot · 13/10/2026 11:53

Hedgehogbrown · 13/10/2026 11:29

Do you think men would have this worry? Do men ever get told they are showing off or bragging to other Dad's? No! It's just something to keep women quiet. You bring in those buns and if anyone doesn't like it they can fuck off!

Exactly.
God, this is why women don't rule the world; we're all too busy second-guessing ourselves and/or policing other women.

purser25 · 13/10/2026 12:17

Guess I am lax I tend to think if it has been cooked at a relatively high temperature that gets rid of the germs. Maybe I like cake too much. Why pay a small fortune for shop stuff when you can make it cheaper at home.

Linnende · 13/10/2026 12:24

Luce1234 · 12/10/2026 22:18

Possibly very much overthinking here, but it is my daughters birthday on Wednesday (turning 9) her class normally take a sweet treat/cake in on on their birthdays, this is fine with the parents and no one has allergies (know this from several parties). I love baking but never really do it much, last year I made and took in some cupcakes, I'm a home baker but can turn out a decent cupcake, planning to do it this year again but my husband has said that I shouldn't, that it is very much attention seeking and very 'look at me" This isn't my intention at all, I have most of the ingrediants in the cupboard all ready, it'll only cost me about £4 to make 36 buns, I only have to buy the butter and some icing sugar. I have boxes already that I bought in bulk from Temu and tbh I just like baking. But I would hate to be talked about by any of the mum's, or for people to think that I'm attempting to show off, parents would see them as they are normally given out last thing. Should I just buy some shop bought cake or buns, which would cost me more money and not be as nice? I'm inclined to think that my husband is been harsh, they will look nice when done, but I reckon people will still be able to tell that they are homemade and that I haven't spent loads of money buying them. Thanks.

Did your husband get out if the wrong side of the bed? Lovely idea, you should go ahead and make the cakes. You are not showing off, just being kind😊

Luce1234 · 13/10/2026 12:55

Thanks for all the comments, sorry that it has caused a bit of friction amongst some of you. I think I'll give it a miss, I didn't even think about allergies, just with knowing none of the class have them from past parties, just assumed that it was ok, wasn't aware that there are now actual laws in place, wouldn't want to put the teachers in a difficult position. I hate navigating school, it's a total minefield ☹️

OP posts:
Luce1234 · 13/10/2026 13:02

Also, with the Bun debate, they are cupcakes, we just call them Buns in these parts, cupcakes always seems abit American (not that there is anything wrong with that) I don't do same amount of icing as on shop bought cupcakes, they'd be climbing the walls 😅

OP posts:
DraigCymraeg · 13/10/2026 13:02

Luce1234 · 12/10/2026 22:18

Possibly very much overthinking here, but it is my daughters birthday on Wednesday (turning 9) her class normally take a sweet treat/cake in on on their birthdays, this is fine with the parents and no one has allergies (know this from several parties). I love baking but never really do it much, last year I made and took in some cupcakes, I'm a home baker but can turn out a decent cupcake, planning to do it this year again but my husband has said that I shouldn't, that it is very much attention seeking and very 'look at me" This isn't my intention at all, I have most of the ingrediants in the cupboard all ready, it'll only cost me about £4 to make 36 buns, I only have to buy the butter and some icing sugar. I have boxes already that I bought in bulk from Temu and tbh I just like baking. But I would hate to be talked about by any of the mum's, or for people to think that I'm attempting to show off, parents would see them as they are normally given out last thing. Should I just buy some shop bought cake or buns, which would cost me more money and not be as nice? I'm inclined to think that my husband is been harsh, they will look nice when done, but I reckon people will still be able to tell that they are homemade and that I haven't spent loads of money buying them. Thanks.

I think it is a lovely idea.
Surely children of that age will be thrilled to have a cake to take home. And your DD very pleased she has a Mummy who is so clever and kind.
Go for it my love.
xxx

Linnende · 13/10/2026 13:03

Luce1234 · 13/10/2026 12:55

Thanks for all the comments, sorry that it has caused a bit of friction amongst some of you. I think I'll give it a miss, I didn't even think about allergies, just with knowing none of the class have them from past parties, just assumed that it was ok, wasn't aware that there are now actual laws in place, wouldn't want to put the teachers in a difficult position. I hate navigating school, it's a total minefield ☹️

This is so sad to hear 😞 Why do people have to over think things. We managed to survive the 70's, 80's and 90's taking party food into the schools with no problems. life seems so unnecessarily complicated now 💜 x

AshtonGardens · 13/10/2026 13:12

Birthday cake is what birthday parties are for - why school as well?

Asking a TA to mess around with cupcakes, bookbags etc at the end of the school day is not appropriate. But if you want to hand them out personally in the playground, then go for it.

Pumpkinmagic · 13/10/2026 13:28

What kind of buns are you thinking? Cinnamon buns, currant buns etc? Sounds a lovely idea, although I’m surprised the school allow it. Most schools and nurseries in my area no longer allow Birthday cakes/sweets to be brought in due to legislation around healthy eating so they celebrate Birthdays in other ways.

I’d be more concerned you brought products from Temu to be honest.

Luce1234 · 13/10/2026 13:29

AshtonGardens · 13/10/2026 13:12

Birthday cake is what birthday parties are for - why school as well?

Asking a TA to mess around with cupcakes, bookbags etc at the end of the school day is not appropriate. But if you want to hand them out personally in the playground, then go for it.

She isn't having a party this year, whole class ones are just too expensive nowadays 😬 Giving out treats when their birthday falls on a school day is just something they have always done in her class. They normally hand them out themselves in the last 5 mins as they go out the door, they just enjoy doing it.

OP posts:
AshtonGardens · 13/10/2026 13:38

Luce1234 · 13/10/2026 13:29

She isn't having a party this year, whole class ones are just too expensive nowadays 😬 Giving out treats when their birthday falls on a school day is just something they have always done in her class. They normally hand them out themselves in the last 5 mins as they go out the door, they just enjoy doing it.

We did only one whole class party per DC during the primary years, all the others were smaller parties, which seemed standard. If giving out cakes is the done thing at your school, then as I said, go for it. Don't second guess yourself.

PenelopePinkerton · 13/10/2026 13:44

Your husband is a dick. Making cupcakes is pretty basic and not showing off in any way. Home made much nicer than bought too so well worth doing.

ACynicalDad · 13/10/2026 13:45

The first time a child brought in a slice of cake when I was a new teacher my TA whisked it away and said "Sir will have it at breaktime with his tea in the staff room", she stuck it in my cupboard, told me not to touch it and binned it when she got the chance. But is doing this showing off, not particularly, we'd have asked you to hand it out on the playground at the end of the day so the parent agrees they can eat it in case of alergic reaction etc.

nam3c4ang3 · 13/10/2026 13:45

Your husband is a twat. I make them all the time for my kids - its a nice thig to do and works out cheaper. I also make for the school's bake sale, so do so many other parents. Make sure there are no nuts and label everything. Also might be an idea to check with your school its ok to bring in as well.

MaggieBsBoat · 13/10/2026 13:52

It’ll be obvious they’re homemade (unless you’re a pro baker) and no parent should or would give a shit. I’ve literally never given this a thought. Except that I personally wouldn’t eat them. But they’re for the kids. Go for it!

TotHappy · 13/10/2026 14:20

We always called them buns growing up, usually 'little buns'. They were made of cake, but not especially fancy and icing-ey. The fairy cakes/butterfly cakes like someone said were on the icing heavy side. Normal ones (which mum made every week and we just had for snacks) had raisins/Sultanas in and sometimes an almond or Glace cherry on top; or a teaspoon of jam in the middle; or just plain sponge with water icing on top (Glace icing? No egg white, just water and icing sugar, poured over, set to a crackle).
Buttercream was for the middle of big cakes (water icing on top again) and occasionally the butterfly cakes. There were no cupcakes like there are now, lagged in Buttercream and giving you a sugar headache. I don't honestly think most people like them, do they, they're too much.

We do also have 'sticky buns' which means a pastry usually - I will offer to buy the kids a sticky bun at the bakery sometimes which could be a Belgian bun or cinnamon bun or apple turnover or doughnut.