Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think if an MP said this about any other group of people he would be sacked?

82 replies

Cafog · 12/10/2026 20:30

Jim Allister of the TUV - during his interview on BBC’s Sunday Politics programme, he stated that Chief Constable Jon Boutcher should have "sanitised the Garvaghy Road and escorted" the Orangemen down it.

AIBU to think this is absolutely disgusting language, and if he'd said it about Muslims or Jews for example there would be complete uproar, but when it's Catholic Nationalists the backlash is lukewarm to say the least? Im aware there has been some condemnation, and hes tried to defend his comments but he needs to go. There's no place for hate speech like this from anyone never mind an elected MP.

OP posts:
YouHaveAnArse · 13/10/2026 21:57

Octavia64 · 13/10/2026 06:05

I’m English.

never Been to the island of Ireland.

i know about the troubles because at school we read a book in English about it which was Romeo and Juliet reset to Northern Ireland.

i wasn’t religious as a child and didn’t know anyone who went to church. About a quarter of my school were Muslim Pakistanis.

i have family in Canada and New Zealand and Australia.

I’ve read a fair bit about Ireland as an adult and honestly these days it seems to be very much its own country with its own issues. Historically English people have done some horrendous things in many countries and on a personal level I do feel bad about that.

when I went to Ghana we saw one of the slaving castles and honestly I found it really quite upsetting but the group of Ghanaian teens and early twenties I was with didn’t seem bothered.

i find it hard to empathise with people of a religion who hate people of a slightly different flavour of religion. I’m learning Arabic and doing a lot of reading about the Muslim world at the moment abd there’s a lot of that there - one type of Muslim declaring the rest Heretics.

the catholic/protestant thing honestly looks pretty similar from the outside. I have friends who live in Switzerland which is also a mix of catholic and Protestant and is pretty peaceful.

the uk education system (that I have worked in for many years) skates over many things. It doesn’t cover the raj or partition and yet there are many English people of Indian or Pakistani descent, abd we’ve got a link with India due to history.

it doesn’t cover windrush and the arrival of many commonwealth people in the 1950s and 1960s and the contribution they made to building postwar Britain.

so I’m not surprised it doesn’t cover Ireland because there’s so much it doesn’t cover.

It was a big part of the GCSE History syllabus when I was at school. Maybe some on this thread would benefit from BBC Bitesize.

gullgal · 13/10/2026 23:07

sashh · 13/10/2026 08:18

I think it is lack of interest. Many years I got chatting to a guy from NI, he mentioned Derry and added, or as you would say Londonderry I said, "I thought the council had changed the name to Derry. He actually said he was shocked that I knew anything about NI.

I was once on holiday in the Isle of Mann, Bangor Boys Brigade were camping on the same campsite, not a problem until we hit July 12 when there were loud songs, there appeared to be more alcohol than you would expect.

As it got later a few campers were fed up and wanted sleep, so they were told to "Shut the F up you Fing Irish bastards" by more than one camper.

But also the OP wasn't very clear.

I know what the Orange order is, I know about the marches but I didn't know the street that was mentioned.

I didn't know there was a 28 year history of the route of this particular march.

I went to school in England, I did English history at school with a little bit of European, the only time we studied anything about Irish history was a bit about Daniel O'Connell.

Edited

The thing is, what created the situation in northern Ireland actually is English history.

Goatsarebest · 13/10/2026 23:30

blubberyboo · 12/10/2026 21:17

It is too complex to be fully discussed and articulated on AIBU and will only result in a bunch of mumsnet users slagging off both communities in NI. Pointless thread too as MPs cant be sacked by mumsnet users in GB.

Both communities have been through a lot and overcome a lot but an election is coming so the politicians are getting their ducks in a row.

Undoubtedly it was also a little tongue in cheek given that any time the protestant community protest anything the police bring out water cannons and literally do "sanitise" the people off the streets. So he was digging at the double standards.

Water Cannons have been used twice since 2012 in Nothern Ireland.

JoannCourcyIveGotThePowerNSoul · 13/10/2026 23:31

SpecialShark · 12/10/2026 20:34

What are 'orange men?' Who is is meant to be referring to?

Similar to oompa loompas.

Goatsarebest · 13/10/2026 23:42

I'm English Protestant married to an Ulster Catholic with children born in both England and Ireland. We have lived as a family in both Ireland and England. Whilst I complete accept the general lack of knowledge and awareness by English people of the shared history and current issues in Norhern Ireland, it works both ways. There's plenty of Irish people who have no knowledge of any British history outside that in Ireland and have no idea of what is going on in UK at any time.
It's not a uniquely English thing to not know what is going on in their neighbouring Country.

Goatsarebest · 14/10/2026 00:16

quartile · 13/10/2026 06:59

Not really, the "plantation of Ireland" saw tens of thousands of Protestant Scots move to Ulster in the 17th century. it's their descendants that are in Northern Ireland today.

Yes, something that really has got sanitised in history is the changing of the narrative to it was all English and the hate can be directed only at English. These are some facts

Welsh PM of UK during the Irish war of independence
PM leading up to Irish Famine was Duke of Wellington, born in Dublin,
Plantation of Ulster that is the foundation of the modern troubles organised and implemented by James 1st of England and Ireland who was Scottish.
Black and Tans who terrorised rural communities during the war of Independence were almost equally Wesh, Scottish and English unemployed soldiers returned from 1st WW.
Where I live on the West coast the burning of villages and summary execution were carried by Scottish regiments.
So whatever you think of imperial rule in Ireland, it was a combined effort of Britain and Anglo Irish ruling elite. Never just English.

soundsys · 14/10/2026 02:54

Moreuniformstodry · 13/10/2026 14:21

I’m sure pp isn’t an ‘oppressor’ @DebbieSavage. There is no need for you to apologise either. Understanding is what is needed between people, not guilt for a past over which you had no influence. Thank you for your concern though.

No I’m sorry but.. PP isn’t theirselves an “oppressor” but… know your own fucking history people! I spend a lot of my life explaining that how we feel about “The Brits” isn’t how we feel about normal (especially working class) English people but jeezo this thread 🤦🏻‍♀️

New posts on this thread. Refresh page