Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think if an MP said this about any other group of people he would be sacked?

82 replies

Cafog · 12/10/2026 20:30

Jim Allister of the TUV - during his interview on BBC’s Sunday Politics programme, he stated that Chief Constable Jon Boutcher should have "sanitised the Garvaghy Road and escorted" the Orangemen down it.

AIBU to think this is absolutely disgusting language, and if he'd said it about Muslims or Jews for example there would be complete uproar, but when it's Catholic Nationalists the backlash is lukewarm to say the least? Im aware there has been some condemnation, and hes tried to defend his comments but he needs to go. There's no place for hate speech like this from anyone never mind an elected MP.

OP posts:
sashh · 13/10/2026 08:18

SnipSnipMrBurgess · 12/10/2026 21:36

Im never shocked, the lack of education in the UK about Ireland and the Troubles is shameful.

Even if someone doesnt know the history, they may see it on the news the last few weeks, but no, its not even in your news.

A massive event which had the potential to destabilise peace in NI and people are asking whats an orangeman 🤷‍♀️

I think it is lack of interest. Many years I got chatting to a guy from NI, he mentioned Derry and added, or as you would say Londonderry I said, "I thought the council had changed the name to Derry. He actually said he was shocked that I knew anything about NI.

I was once on holiday in the Isle of Mann, Bangor Boys Brigade were camping on the same campsite, not a problem until we hit July 12 when there were loud songs, there appeared to be more alcohol than you would expect.

As it got later a few campers were fed up and wanted sleep, so they were told to "Shut the F up you Fing Irish bastards" by more than one camper.

But also the OP wasn't very clear.

I know what the Orange order is, I know about the marches but I didn't know the street that was mentioned.

I didn't know there was a 28 year history of the route of this particular march.

I went to school in England, I did English history at school with a little bit of European, the only time we studied anything about Irish history was a bit about Daniel O'Connell.

AspiringChatBot · 13/10/2026 09:12

On a practical level: as he's the TUV Party Leader he'd have to sack himself. Even then, all he could do is remove himself from the front benches (ineffective when he's their only MP) or suspend/expel himself from his own party to sit as an independent MP.

It's technically possible for the HOC to suspend an MP and if the suspension is 10+ business days a by-election can be called if 10% of Constituents sign a recall petition. BUT the suspension can only be for crimes, for inappropriate behaviour IN Parliament, or for violating the Code of Conduct (which is mostly corruption / financial conflict of interest stuff). Nothing formally prohibits making irresponsible, bigoted, or disgusting comments outside of Parliament or to/about people besides other MPs.

Moreuniformstodry · 13/10/2026 09:45

blubberyboo · 12/10/2026 20:58

Also he is a barrister so frequently uses over eloquent language that the average man on the street wouldn't use. The term sanitise is something that the courts and police would use about public order but of course when the working class people hear it they think of genocide.

Did he say it deliberately to piss them off knowing that the MPs on the other side are more working class? Probably

Could you explain a bit more about what ‘sanitise’ means in the context of the courts or policing please?

It really, really does not sound good in layman's terms, but I’m open to the possibility of misunderstanding. I did try a quick google, but without success.

Cafog · 13/10/2026 10:33

sashh · 13/10/2026 08:18

I think it is lack of interest. Many years I got chatting to a guy from NI, he mentioned Derry and added, or as you would say Londonderry I said, "I thought the council had changed the name to Derry. He actually said he was shocked that I knew anything about NI.

I was once on holiday in the Isle of Mann, Bangor Boys Brigade were camping on the same campsite, not a problem until we hit July 12 when there were loud songs, there appeared to be more alcohol than you would expect.

As it got later a few campers were fed up and wanted sleep, so they were told to "Shut the F up you Fing Irish bastards" by more than one camper.

But also the OP wasn't very clear.

I know what the Orange order is, I know about the marches but I didn't know the street that was mentioned.

I didn't know there was a 28 year history of the route of this particular march.

I went to school in England, I did English history at school with a little bit of European, the only time we studied anything about Irish history was a bit about Daniel O'Connell.

Edited

My point was the language that was used, I dont think the background or the context matters as much as the language. It's not acceptable language. It implies Catholic Nationlists are dirty and need to be cleaned off the streets. To me anyway. I appreciate the posters who referenced in legal speak it may have a different meaning. With this man though I'm pretty certain he was implying the former.

OP posts:
Moreuniformstodry · 13/10/2026 10:41

sashh · 13/10/2026 08:18

I think it is lack of interest. Many years I got chatting to a guy from NI, he mentioned Derry and added, or as you would say Londonderry I said, "I thought the council had changed the name to Derry. He actually said he was shocked that I knew anything about NI.

I was once on holiday in the Isle of Mann, Bangor Boys Brigade were camping on the same campsite, not a problem until we hit July 12 when there were loud songs, there appeared to be more alcohol than you would expect.

As it got later a few campers were fed up and wanted sleep, so they were told to "Shut the F up you Fing Irish bastards" by more than one camper.

But also the OP wasn't very clear.

I know what the Orange order is, I know about the marches but I didn't know the street that was mentioned.

I didn't know there was a 28 year history of the route of this particular march.

I went to school in England, I did English history at school with a little bit of European, the only time we studied anything about Irish history was a bit about Daniel O'Connell.

Edited

Speaking of the Bangor Boys Brigade, I doubt they consider themselves Irish.

DebbieSavage · 13/10/2026 10:45

Octavia64 · 12/10/2026 21:31

I did meet someone from NI once.

we were both volunteering on a maths camp for gifted and talented students in Ghana.

he told me (I think I remember this right) that I was a fascist imperial pig and he hated British people. I apologised a couple of times for being British and he spent the whole camp refusing to speak to me or work with me.

personally I’m of the opinion that if the march was going to cause public disorder banning it seems reasonable

You could have at least given him some money rather than just apologise profusely, as if that's going to do anything to alleviate the discomfort he most likely felt at having to share space with someone who is from the same country that oppressed his people.

Octavia64 · 13/10/2026 12:16

DebbieSavage · 13/10/2026 10:45

You could have at least given him some money rather than just apologise profusely, as if that's going to do anything to alleviate the discomfort he most likely felt at having to share space with someone who is from the same country that oppressed his people.

It was a bit odd.

we were in Ghana and went to visit one of the slaving castles where the Portuguese/british took slaves off to the ships to go to Africa.

the Ghanaian teens we were with seemed to bear no ill will towards Britain and in fact were very unaffected by it (it upset me a lot).

they were mostly very curious about life in Britain.

it was an odd contrast with this bloke.

once it was clear he really didn’t like me I did try to stay out of his way.

Erin1975 · 13/10/2026 12:23

It's Northern Ireland. There are many things said and done in Northern Irish politics which would be completely unacceptable in any other part of the UK. But it is NI, the bigotry and hatred will continue for generations to come.

Moreuniformstodry · 13/10/2026 12:29

DebbieSavage · 13/10/2026 10:45

You could have at least given him some money rather than just apologise profusely, as if that's going to do anything to alleviate the discomfort he most likely felt at having to share space with someone who is from the same country that oppressed his people.

What??
Money? Why would she give him money?

And he was being a dick if he behaved like that towards pp in the absence of anything she did personally.

There was no need to apologise @Octavia64.
I’m Irish, for context.

TheLastSilverSaint · 13/10/2026 12:33

MPs can't be 'sacked' from their job as an MP for saying things you find offensive. To be removed from parliament they'd have to breach their Code of Conduct very severely. Using unpalatable language about a group of people like this wouldn't be covered by that. If it was, certain parties would have no MPs at all.

They can be sacked from being a minister, and they can be expelled from their party, but they'd still remain an MP even if that were to happen, unless they'd been convicted of a criminal offence and sentenced to prison.

DebbieSavage · 13/10/2026 13:34

Moreuniformstodry · 13/10/2026 12:29

What??
Money? Why would she give him money?

And he was being a dick if he behaved like that towards pp in the absence of anything she did personally.

There was no need to apologise @Octavia64.
I’m Irish, for context.

Edited

Well first of all, I am English, so I apologise to you and your people for what my people did to you. For what its worth, the pain that they wrought bears a heavy pain upon my soul and I wish I could go back in time and stop it all from happening.

Secondly, I understand that it might not matter so much to you but the gentleman that this lady was acquainted with clearly felt differently. The scars must have been much more prevalent and she might have been the first oppressor he ever came across in his life. Please have some consideration for the folks who haven't quite gotten to the stage of letting bygones be bygones.

RocketPanda · 13/10/2026 13:50

sashh · 13/10/2026 08:18

I think it is lack of interest. Many years I got chatting to a guy from NI, he mentioned Derry and added, or as you would say Londonderry I said, "I thought the council had changed the name to Derry. He actually said he was shocked that I knew anything about NI.

I was once on holiday in the Isle of Mann, Bangor Boys Brigade were camping on the same campsite, not a problem until we hit July 12 when there were loud songs, there appeared to be more alcohol than you would expect.

As it got later a few campers were fed up and wanted sleep, so they were told to "Shut the F up you Fing Irish bastards" by more than one camper.

But also the OP wasn't very clear.

I know what the Orange order is, I know about the marches but I didn't know the street that was mentioned.

I didn't know there was a 28 year history of the route of this particular march.

I went to school in England, I did English history at school with a little bit of European, the only time we studied anything about Irish history was a bit about Daniel O'Connell.

Edited

I shouldn't laugh but to have called the BB Irish was such a massive insult. Their ancestors would be spinning like rotisserie chickens in their graves.

MrsShawnHatosy · 13/10/2026 13:54

gullgal · 12/10/2026 21:14

Especially given a few people in this thread don't seem to know anything about Northern Ireland!! They don't know what an Orangeman is or what the context is, which is pretty poor if they are British.

This.

RocketPanda · 13/10/2026 13:55

Oh and to clarify Ireland is just Ireland, not Eire or Southern Ireland. Northern Ireland or The North of Ireland is separate.
As always comes up on these threads

Douglasmummy · 13/10/2026 14:09

Moreuniformstodry · 13/10/2026 12:29

What??
Money? Why would she give him money?

And he was being a dick if he behaved like that towards pp in the absence of anything she did personally.

There was no need to apologise @Octavia64.
I’m Irish, for context.

Edited

LOL Can you imagine how insulting that would be? 'Sorry about the Potato famine. Here's a tenner'

Abitofalark · 13/10/2026 14:10

blubberyboo · 12/10/2026 20:50

YABU for suggesting that he can be sacked.

MPs can only be recalled under a recall petition.

With regards to his comments you need to understand that neither side ever covers themselves in glory in how they behave amd they deliberately go out of their way to be as controversial as possible to garner support from their communities. The Sinn Fein MPs among others were breaking the law by blocking the road. Perhaps they should be sacked too. They won't so I wouldn't get too excited about anything that is said.

But they can be sacked, i.e. expelled, from their party.

Moreuniformstodry · 13/10/2026 14:21

DebbieSavage · 13/10/2026 13:34

Well first of all, I am English, so I apologise to you and your people for what my people did to you. For what its worth, the pain that they wrought bears a heavy pain upon my soul and I wish I could go back in time and stop it all from happening.

Secondly, I understand that it might not matter so much to you but the gentleman that this lady was acquainted with clearly felt differently. The scars must have been much more prevalent and she might have been the first oppressor he ever came across in his life. Please have some consideration for the folks who haven't quite gotten to the stage of letting bygones be bygones.

I’m sure pp isn’t an ‘oppressor’ @DebbieSavage. There is no need for you to apologise either. Understanding is what is needed between people, not guilt for a past over which you had no influence. Thank you for your concern though.

Lifewasapillow · 13/10/2026 14:53

doug The Troubles were on TV news every single day of my childhood in the UK. We got used to no bins in London and having to leave tube stations or school due to hoax bomb threat calls. It was the main story for the 80's and 90's. I just don't remember all the details.

sashh · 13/10/2026 15:13

Cafog · 13/10/2026 10:33

My point was the language that was used, I dont think the background or the context matters as much as the language. It's not acceptable language. It implies Catholic Nationlists are dirty and need to be cleaned off the streets. To me anyway. I appreciate the posters who referenced in legal speak it may have a different meaning. With this man though I'm pretty certain he was implying the former.

Now you have given the context, but your first post did not give that.

If I said a street in Birmingham needed to be sanitised would you know that the refuse collection have been on strike? Or would you assume it was aimed at a particular ethnic group?

If I started talking about something happening in Londonderry would you know it is a place in Staffordshire?

sashh · 13/10/2026 15:17

RocketPanda · 13/10/2026 13:50

I shouldn't laugh but to have called the BB Irish was such a massive insult. Their ancestors would be spinning like rotisserie chickens in their graves.

Oh yes, I know that, it amused me at the time, a group of males celebrating being British and being sworn at by other people who don't know or don't consider them British.

Morebouncetotheounce · 13/10/2026 19:31

MixedBananas · 13/10/2026 02:21

It would be the same of any Muslim made prayers for the safety of Hammas. It is basically ilegal to wear a diplomatic flag for Palestine......so we need to keep the same energy. What is good for the goose is good for the gander.

If we can have matted haired bObJoB call Niqabis post boxes then we can let it all rip for others too? What is good for the goose os good for the gander.

🇪🇭

Read it three times....still doesn't make sense 🤷‍♀️

Savvysix1984 · 13/10/2026 19:48

blubberyboo · 12/10/2026 20:50

YABU for suggesting that he can be sacked.

MPs can only be recalled under a recall petition.

With regards to his comments you need to understand that neither side ever covers themselves in glory in how they behave amd they deliberately go out of their way to be as controversial as possible to garner support from their communities. The Sinn Fein MPs among others were breaking the law by blocking the road. Perhaps they should be sacked too. They won't so I wouldn't get too excited about anything that is said.

It hasn’t been decided yet if they were breaking the law. Civil disobedience isn’t always unlawful. The PSNI and PPS will decide that.

Savvysix1984 · 13/10/2026 19:56

sashh · 13/10/2026 08:18

I think it is lack of interest. Many years I got chatting to a guy from NI, he mentioned Derry and added, or as you would say Londonderry I said, "I thought the council had changed the name to Derry. He actually said he was shocked that I knew anything about NI.

I was once on holiday in the Isle of Mann, Bangor Boys Brigade were camping on the same campsite, not a problem until we hit July 12 when there were loud songs, there appeared to be more alcohol than you would expect.

As it got later a few campers were fed up and wanted sleep, so they were told to "Shut the F up you Fing Irish bastards" by more than one camper.

But also the OP wasn't very clear.

I know what the Orange order is, I know about the marches but I didn't know the street that was mentioned.

I didn't know there was a 28 year history of the route of this particular march.

I went to school in England, I did English history at school with a little bit of European, the only time we studied anything about Irish history was a bit about Daniel O'Connell.

Edited

I’m sure calling them Irish bastards went down well…. They’re more loyal to the crown than the English, Welsh and Scottish.

LakieLady · 13/10/2026 20:13

legallyblond · 12/10/2026 21:29

I wonder if those who don’t seem to know about all this are quite a bit younger. I was shocked at not understanding the references too! The Troubles and the related issues and politics were very much the defining story of my teenage years. It was front page news every week in the UK (I’m English) and so for those born in the 70s or early 80s, I’d guess everyone knows what Orangemen are. I’d say that if a person was still a child or very young teen in 1998 when the Good Friday agreement was signed, they might not know so much…

Edited

I was thinking that, too. I'm 71, so can remember when "the Troubles" were at their height. I doubt if anyone who can remember how bad things were wants to risk seeing a return to those days.

I still feel a bit choked when I think of Bloody Sunday and other horrors, and this Drumcree business brought back a lot of memories. I'm sure it's only a few knuckleheads who want to see a return to provocative marches, regardless of who's marching.

Moreuniformstodry · 13/10/2026 20:27

LakieLady · 13/10/2026 20:13

I was thinking that, too. I'm 71, so can remember when "the Troubles" were at their height. I doubt if anyone who can remember how bad things were wants to risk seeing a return to those days.

I still feel a bit choked when I think of Bloody Sunday and other horrors, and this Drumcree business brought back a lot of memories. I'm sure it's only a few knuckleheads who want to see a return to provocative marches, regardless of who's marching.

The vast majority of sectarian marches in NI are orange @LakieLady. When it comes to marches, the knuckleheads are orangemen.