Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Teacher in private school using AI for everything.

336 replies

ShakespeareSallo · 12/10/2026 18:52

As the title says really.

My now teenage child has attended a private school since 11, they are now in Year 10. It has been a great experience for them and worth the money. We aren’t rich by any means but afford it by making cut backs, we haven’t been on holiday for 5 years. VAT has hugely impacted us.

My child now has a teacher for a core subject which they haven’t had before. They bring their book home every week, and it is very obvious that the whole scheme of work and all of the worksheets and homework are AI generated. I am not a dinosaur, and I do use AI myself. However, this level of usage coming from my child’s teacher seems excessive, and I am not sure how much actual teaching is going on? My child has also said all of the PowerPoints used in lessons are obviously AI generated, and even that it has appeared as though the things on the PowerPoints the teacher is seeing for the first time alongside the students?!

Less of an issue, but I’ve also had some suspiciously AI looking and sounding emails from other members of staff in the school.

WIBU to arrange a meeting with the Head of Year to raise these concerns, or is this just the modern era of teaching?

OP posts:
Goldenbear · 14/10/2026 10:43

Om83 · 14/10/2026 10:08

worksheets and other activities, whether AI generated or not, provide active learning and engagement in the topic. Yes books are great for content and have their place in a lesson (assuming pupils can access the content and reading ability is there) but children sitting reading text books for every lesson would not result in the same level of cognitive engagement and retrieval as worksheets, activities, and discussions with peers and teachers about their misunderstandings or confirmation they are correct, as well as PowerPoints and images to help explain often wordy concepts to contextualise things from those text books. You have to be able to see that learning is happening- how on earth can you do that when they are bored senseless from reading text books!

Textbooks are perceived as 'boring' as they don't provide the dopamine hit that digital resources do, this is the point- human reasoning relies upon cognitive effort, the 'process' and struggle is where the learning takes place.

Natsku · 14/10/2026 11:14

Om83 · 14/10/2026 10:08

worksheets and other activities, whether AI generated or not, provide active learning and engagement in the topic. Yes books are great for content and have their place in a lesson (assuming pupils can access the content and reading ability is there) but children sitting reading text books for every lesson would not result in the same level of cognitive engagement and retrieval as worksheets, activities, and discussions with peers and teachers about their misunderstandings or confirmation they are correct, as well as PowerPoints and images to help explain often wordy concepts to contextualise things from those text books. You have to be able to see that learning is happening- how on earth can you do that when they are bored senseless from reading text books!

The schools where I am use textbooks and workbooks that go with them, as well as other methods of teaching of course but the textbooks and workbooks are the core, which is very helpful when a child is off sick as they can ask (a classmate, though some teachers will send a message on the school app when a child is off or put it on the class webpage) what pages are being covered that day and do them so they don't fall too far behind. No one is just reading textbooks (unless studying for a test)

Porridgeontheroad · 14/10/2026 11:35

ShakespeareSallo · 12/10/2026 22:34

No - the teacher said they couldn’t provide my friends sixth former (at the same school), with information about the topics being covered this term because they decide what to do ‘5 minutes before the lesson’. They were not saying they adapt the lesson or add things in for those who are struggling.

I can’t believe you fell for this @ShakespeareSallo .

No, the teacher did not say that

pollymere · 14/10/2026 11:40

Actually this is considered inappropriate by a number of Educators. I would want to be talking to the Head of Department for the core subject about the use of AI.

It's not just the high level of inaccuracy, it's also the environmental impact of AI and Data Centres. And according to this year's GCSE English, nearly all students don't trust AI and don't believe it should be used in Education.

noblegiraffe · 14/10/2026 12:47

Natsku · 14/10/2026 08:10

I think its fair enough to complain about the use of AI whether its crap or not simply because its AI so is harming our planet, increasing unemployment and limiting our children's futures. And if other teens are anything like my DD and her friend group, its use will turn them right off the lesson as they passionately hate AI (and have refused to use it in class when instructed to do so. Thankfully the teacher was fine with them doing their work without it)

I mean, OP is private so can complain about whatever they like but complaining to a state school would be a non-starter as the DfE are pushing AI hard as a solution to teacher workload. You’d have to complain to the govt.

Spirallingdownwards · 14/10/2026 12:49

thehighseas · 12/10/2026 20:04

Would you be happy if students took this exact approach to their homework?

They would probably get a better result than when their mum does it for them.

CurlyKoalie · 14/10/2026 13:09

ShakespeareSallo · 12/10/2026 21:18

And my child has said that the teacher will often say things like, ‘oh I’m not sure what that’s about’… not in relation to her not understanding the content, but as in not realising it was on there and it’s not relevant… in relation to things on the PowerPoint.

This shows how some teachers rely on resources they have not prepared and don't even read them through before delivering to the children.
Good teachers always proof read, check and adapt what they put In front of the children whether it's AI produced or not.
The extra issue with AI is that it " scrapes" the internet looking for information and it's not always very discriminating about what it includes or how it interprets it.
The role of the teacher in lesson preparation is to check the these resources for accuracy and relevance. If a teacher isn't doing that, they are not doing that part of their job
They should also be able to explain the material in a different way if required. That's the difference between a teacher and a narrator!
This teacher you mention obviously did not review the ppt in question and possibly didn't write it.

stripesandspotsanddots · 14/10/2026 13:32

I am surprised that so many people think this is ok. Good teaching is relational and based on the teacher's understanding of a large body of material, with communication tailored to the learner. AI can't provide any of that.

If I was privately educating and this happened I would absolutely be raising my concerns. Surely the whole point of paying for private school is the quality of education.

I wonder where posters draw the line? Would they think it was ok if their DC went to university and the lectures and tutorials were clearly AI generated?

justasking111 · 14/10/2026 13:44

stripesandspotsanddots · 14/10/2026 13:32

I am surprised that so many people think this is ok. Good teaching is relational and based on the teacher's understanding of a large body of material, with communication tailored to the learner. AI can't provide any of that.

If I was privately educating and this happened I would absolutely be raising my concerns. Surely the whole point of paying for private school is the quality of education.

I wonder where posters draw the line? Would they think it was ok if their DC went to university and the lectures and tutorials were clearly AI generated?

Private schools still have to adhere to what Ofsted, Estyn, decide as to how they are performing.

fuckeditupbadly · 14/10/2026 13:48

justasking111 · 14/10/2026 13:44

Private schools still have to adhere to what Ofsted, Estyn, decide as to how they are performing.

Actually no, its a different body but we are still inspected.

MaeshoweDragon · 14/10/2026 14:05

Do people on here live in a rose tinted world full of bunnies and rainbows... a world where every school day, all children are taught by subject specialists in every lesson.

Last I noticed at the school I helped out in (last year, not in "olden times"), a PE teacher was teaching middle set Y8 maths (because he had a B at GCSE... and was good at "herding cats" or behaviour management as it is termed nowadays).

AI worksheets are not just to save time, sometimes there is no teacher with full knowledge available to actually teach.

Natsku · 14/10/2026 14:17

noblegiraffe · 14/10/2026 12:47

I mean, OP is private so can complain about whatever they like but complaining to a state school would be a non-starter as the DfE are pushing AI hard as a solution to teacher workload. You’d have to complain to the govt.

Would be good if parents (and students) complained en masse to the government about pushing AI

Porridgeontheroad · 14/10/2026 14:21

Natsku · 14/10/2026 14:17

Would be good if parents (and students) complained en masse to the government about pushing AI

You obviously didn’t read @noblegiraffe initial (and very valid) point

Teachers can make shit resources, textbooks can be crap (I've used enough of them), The problem isn't with AI making the resources, it's if it's making shit resources (and it can certainly do that too).
Complain if the resources are shit. Don't complain just because they're AI.

So complaining “en masse” to the government about supposedly pushing AI is daft

justasking111 · 14/10/2026 14:39

fuckeditupbadly · 14/10/2026 13:48

Actually no, its a different body but we are still inspected.

In Wales Estyn inspect private schools.

WhereAreTheTrueGreens · 14/10/2026 15:00

onedayillmoveon · 13/10/2026 19:28

Where have you got that from? Private schools are almost always more interested in subject knowledge than state schools; almost if not all of the teachers will have good degrees and many postgraduate qualifications.

https://targetjobs.co.uk/careers-advice/teaching-and-education/teaching-independent-schools

Skills and qualifications required:

"It isn’t a legal requirement to have a recognised teaching qualification to work in an independent school" . also "Many independent schools do not offer an induction year for NQTs"

You CANNOT WORK AS A TEACHER IN A STATE school if you don't have post graduate certificate in education - you can in a private school.

Teaching in an independent school

Teaching in independent schools

Advice on teaching in an independent school: getting a job, career progression, skills and qualifications required.

https://targetjobs.co.uk/careers-advice/teaching-and-education/teaching-independent-schools

Kimmielee · 14/10/2026 15:04

Private Schools can do what they want, they employ ‘teachers’ who don’t even have to have teaching qualifications so not surprised this one is using AI in a away that even parents unfamiliar with the subjects can spot AI slop when they see it.

Another76543 · 14/10/2026 15:07

WhereAreTheTrueGreens · 14/10/2026 15:00

https://targetjobs.co.uk/careers-advice/teaching-and-education/teaching-independent-schools

Skills and qualifications required:

"It isn’t a legal requirement to have a recognised teaching qualification to work in an independent school" . also "Many independent schools do not offer an induction year for NQTs"

You CANNOT WORK AS A TEACHER IN A STATE school if you don't have post graduate certificate in education - you can in a private school.

“You CANNOT WORK AS A TEACHER IN A STATE school if you don't have post graduate certificate in education“

This is incorrect. Teachers who aren’t qualified are able to work in some state schools. The situation is changing from next year but, as it currently stands, your statement is factually incorrect.

Kimmielee · 14/10/2026 15:09

‘Where have you got that from? Private schools are almost always more interested in subject knowledge than state schools; almost if not all of the teachers will have good degrees and many postgraduate qualifications.’

I know this to be untrue from working in Secondary Education AND from being encouraged to apply for a teaching subject head post in a private school despite NOT having a teaching qualification or any teaching experience. I had my own qualifications in the subjects - degree level- but zero teaching experience and there’s no way I would have gone into that role ( a shoo in apparently) and been a great or even good teacher straight away.

Natsku · 14/10/2026 15:10

Porridgeontheroad · 14/10/2026 14:21

You obviously didn’t read @noblegiraffe initial (and very valid) point

Teachers can make shit resources, textbooks can be crap (I've used enough of them), The problem isn't with AI making the resources, it's if it's making shit resources (and it can certainly do that too).
Complain if the resources are shit. Don't complain just because they're AI.

So complaining “en masse” to the government about supposedly pushing AI is daft

You obviously didn't read my response to that, that its fair to complain about the use of AI simply because its AI and AI is bad for the planet and our futures. What's wrong with people complaining to the government about them pushing the further destruction of the planet?

Kimmielee · 14/10/2026 15:11

Anyway - that’s besides the point. Private schools ARE businesses and can hire who they want for what ever reasons they want and let them run smoke with AI slop too if it comes down to it.

fuckeditupbadly · 14/10/2026 15:12

WhereAreTheTrueGreens · 14/10/2026 15:00

https://targetjobs.co.uk/careers-advice/teaching-and-education/teaching-independent-schools

Skills and qualifications required:

"It isn’t a legal requirement to have a recognised teaching qualification to work in an independent school" . also "Many independent schools do not offer an induction year for NQTs"

You CANNOT WORK AS A TEACHER IN A STATE school if you don't have post graduate certificate in education - you can in a private school.

You dont have to.have QTS but most private schools don't hire people without them these days and as I said upthread, having QTS is not some magic guarantee that the person holding it is a really good classroom practioner, or has the potential to be with more experience. There are good and bad teachers across all sectors, with and without QTS, relevant degrees, up to date training and fundamental classroom skills. Private vs State is a red herring here.

Goldenbear · 14/10/2026 15:22

Porridgeontheroad · 14/10/2026 14:21

You obviously didn’t read @noblegiraffe initial (and very valid) point

Teachers can make shit resources, textbooks can be crap (I've used enough of them), The problem isn't with AI making the resources, it's if it's making shit resources (and it can certainly do that too).
Complain if the resources are shit. Don't complain just because they're AI.

So complaining “en masse” to the government about supposedly pushing AI is daft

The concern being highlighted is not that though it's the unintended consequences for the young generation who receive an education with a culture of AI. Just because you are a good teacher and have good intentions it doesn't mean the unintended consequences of AI use won't occur.

WhereAreTheTrueGreens · 14/10/2026 15:47

Another76543 · 14/10/2026 15:07

“You CANNOT WORK AS A TEACHER IN A STATE school if you don't have post graduate certificate in education“

This is incorrect. Teachers who aren’t qualified are able to work in some state schools. The situation is changing from next year but, as it currently stands, your statement is factually incorrect.

My point still stands. You don't need QTS in a private school - that many want them but not all is the point. Yes there are good and bad teachers but at least in state school they have had to do a post graduate qualification in teaching. That was my point to which you replied "where have you got that from" - knowing full well it is a correct comment - you don't have to have the addtional qualification in teaching to teach at a private school.

onedayillmoveon · Yesterday 19:28
Where have you got that from? Private schools are almost always more interested in subject knowledge than state schools; almost if not all of the teachers will have good degrees and many postgraduate qualifications.
WhereAreTheTrueGreens · 12/10/2026 23:21
Yes, they don't even need the same level of qualifications as that required in state schools.

WonderfulSmith · 14/10/2026 16:54

Another76543 · 14/10/2026 15:07

“You CANNOT WORK AS A TEACHER IN A STATE school if you don't have post graduate certificate in education“

This is incorrect. Teachers who aren’t qualified are able to work in some state schools. The situation is changing from next year but, as it currently stands, your statement is factually incorrect.

I don’t have a PGCE, only QTS. I work in a state school.

fuckeditupbadly · 14/10/2026 17:53

WhereAreTheTrueGreens · 14/10/2026 15:47

My point still stands. You don't need QTS in a private school - that many want them but not all is the point. Yes there are good and bad teachers but at least in state school they have had to do a post graduate qualification in teaching. That was my point to which you replied "where have you got that from" - knowing full well it is a correct comment - you don't have to have the addtional qualification in teaching to teach at a private school.

onedayillmoveon · Yesterday 19:28
Where have you got that from? Private schools are almost always more interested in subject knowledge than state schools; almost if not all of the teachers will have good degrees and many postgraduate qualifications.
WhereAreTheTrueGreens · 12/10/2026 23:21
Yes, they don't even need the same level of qualifications as that required in state schools.

Amd my point still stands that much like the driving test, passing it doesn't make you automatically a good driver. I've seen really weak PGCE students passed in shortage subjects while earning a nice bursary in the process. The market forces of supply and demand mean that weaker student teachers (and I dont just mean inexperienced) often pass. Having a PGCE or QTS does not guarantee competence, just as not having one is not an indicator by itself of incompetence.