Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Teacher in private school using AI for everything.

336 replies

ShakespeareSallo · 12/10/2026 18:52

As the title says really.

My now teenage child has attended a private school since 11, they are now in Year 10. It has been a great experience for them and worth the money. We aren’t rich by any means but afford it by making cut backs, we haven’t been on holiday for 5 years. VAT has hugely impacted us.

My child now has a teacher for a core subject which they haven’t had before. They bring their book home every week, and it is very obvious that the whole scheme of work and all of the worksheets and homework are AI generated. I am not a dinosaur, and I do use AI myself. However, this level of usage coming from my child’s teacher seems excessive, and I am not sure how much actual teaching is going on? My child has also said all of the PowerPoints used in lessons are obviously AI generated, and even that it has appeared as though the things on the PowerPoints the teacher is seeing for the first time alongside the students?!

Less of an issue, but I’ve also had some suspiciously AI looking and sounding emails from other members of staff in the school.

WIBU to arrange a meeting with the Head of Year to raise these concerns, or is this just the modern era of teaching?

OP posts:
Casperroonie · 13/10/2026 21:41

ShakespeareSallo · 12/10/2026 21:16

I’m not inherently against the use of AI in a general sense, and can see some of the benefits of using it in teaching. But when every worksheet, every homework, every PowerPoint is AI, that’s another thing altogether.

You say you use AI but it doesn't sound like it. I'm a teacher and I type to copilot "make me 3 slides containg x y z. Must have: ..." and it does it. Why on earth should I sit there for 4x longer to do it by hand????! What difference does it actually make? Same content, looks more polished and maybe samey but so what, it's not going to remove any learning front heir brains. If you think most teachers (mainstream) are no already doing that you will have a huge shock.

Now, I don't know if private staff are so time starved and overworked that they have no choice, but teachers in mainstream definitely are. Why should I sit there and type questions word by word when I can say "give me 10 number bonds to 10 revision questions". There is absolutely zero difference to the quality of the questions, it just gives teachers more capacity to do more planning for your kids. What is wrong with that? Why do people think a teacher should type word by word when you can instruct AI to do it? Are we not worth it?

SeasideWalkaroundStore · 13/10/2026 21:42

With everybody using AI, we're inevitably going to get loads of complaints of plagiarism - albeit unwittingly. After all, if AI has 'learnt' from 'reading' lots of existing texts and available material, it's only a matter of time until somebody submits an academic piece that they used AI to 'fine tune' for them (basically told it "ChatGPT, write an essay about X" and then go off to put their feet up in front of the TV) and it will be instantly recognisable to the teacher who is marking it that it's their own work.

Unless, I suppose, the teacher is just as lazy and uses AI to mark all the essays that AI has written - in which case, they'll get top marks for their (non) efforts...

Casperroonie · 13/10/2026 21:43

ShakespeareSallo · 12/10/2026 22:34

No - the teacher said they couldn’t provide my friends sixth former (at the same school), with information about the topics being covered this term because they decide what to do ‘5 minutes before the lesson’. They were not saying they adapt the lesson or add things in for those who are struggling.

You sound like you believe anything anyone tells you.

Goldenbear · 13/10/2026 21:44

noblegiraffe · 13/10/2026 21:27

The DfE have already released guidance and training modules.

It's no exactly a debate that's complete is it, the DFE guidance is ok but telling people facts on how tomuse AI doesn't really work if they have lost human agency from over reliance on AI.

fuckeditupbadly · 13/10/2026 21:44

SeasideWalkaroundStore · 13/10/2026 21:38

Yes, you use a washing machine to wash your clothes; but what lots of people are doing with AI is the equivalent of asking your washing machine to choose what you should wear, put your outfits together and tell you to put your arms up in the air and count to 5 so that it can dress you every morning like you're a toddler.

I dont know any teachers who are using it like that. If anything, its the academy chains who are pushing for that kind of uniformity, centralised approach with individual teacher input minimised.

Goldenbear · 13/10/2026 21:54

Om83 · 13/10/2026 21:37

These practices are being scrutinised in schools and education as AI develops and subject to continuing research. You clearly have no idea about teaching practice. The teacher still has to have depth of knowledge and critical thinking skills to know if what AI produces meets their objectives and is accurate. And if it doesn’t then that in itself is a useful tool to teach learners about the pitfalls of trusting AI and AI literacy to ensure critical thinking skills are passed on. It should be an open conversation not shut down and ignored.

the D of E has produced guidance about responsible AI practice, what this looks like and clearly states:
’We see more immediate benefits and fewer risks from teacher-facing use of generative AI.’

https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/generative-artificial-intelligence-in-education/generative-artificial-intelligence-ai-in-education

https://www.gov.uk/government/collections/using-ai-in-education-settings-support-materials

And how would you know that, it's wishful thinking that schools are applying the level of scrutiny needed, there simply isn't the money to employ people who know what they are doing to look at this. Schools already have burgeoning data analytics of students that are ethically questionable but are used out of convenience.

fuckeditupbadly · 13/10/2026 22:05

Goldenbear · 13/10/2026 21:54

And how would you know that, it's wishful thinking that schools are applying the level of scrutiny needed, there simply isn't the money to employ people who know what they are doing to look at this. Schools already have burgeoning data analytics of students that are ethically questionable but are used out of convenience.

What do you mean exactly? What data is being used questionably?

Wotsupmog · 13/10/2026 22:37

supportAct · 13/10/2026 00:39

AI should be used to speed up the laborious work involved in prepping lessons and setting homework. It’s a tool available to them, so yes, they should be using it. It frees up their time to teach!

I also love the AI polish tool when writing emails. I write the email quickly and rather than spending the time re-reading and editing it myself, I let AI do it and press send, then swiftly move on to the next job.

Teachers should be using AI. We’ve long heard that they are overworked and much of their free time is used up by the demands of their job, so if AI helps solve this, then using it is a no brainer!

Edited

The AI polishing tool very likely removes your personal style and produces yet another bit of generic text so boring that it's hard to read. Editing an email to make it clearer and remove typos is part of the process of writing the email, it deserves a bit of time spending on it.

onedayillmoveon · 13/10/2026 22:52

Goldenbear · 13/10/2026 21:20

The reality is relying on AI for speeding up the task of thinking does lead to weakened reasoning. For a human to apply reason in the face of feelings, to gain and maintain knowledge, requires time and energy- in other words, use it or lose it!

Teachers aren’t using AI to replace reasoning though; they just use it to create resources, which are just a means to an end (the end being learning). The reasoning is thought behind the lesson plan itself and the actual interaction with pupils in the classroom.

EnidSpyton · 13/10/2026 22:54

I'm a teacher (in a private school) and I'm horrified by how quickly and thoughtlessly so many schools have drunk the AI kool-aid.

It's a nonsense that teaching students to use AI effectively will help them in the workplace. AI is evolving so rapidly that by the time today's 11 year olds are in the workforce, the technology we have now will look like the equivalent of a penny farthing. It is utterly pointless trying to keep up with the pace of technology in our classrooms.

What our children need to be taught is critical thinking, creativity, compassion and collaboration. They're growing up in a world faced with huge problems, and AI is one of them. Yes they're going to need to know how to navigate that world, but the skills they're going to need to do that will be internal - emotional, and intellectual. Being taught that every time they're faced with a problem, they can just put a prompt into AI to help solve that problem, will only continue to contribute to the problems we're facing. We need to be building a generation of thinkers and creators, and instead, by encouraging and enabling the use of AI, we're building a generation of children who can't think for themselves at all, and can't cope with being intellectually challenged. They can't be bothered to sit and go through the process of editing their work, deciding what word might be better, or really grappling with working out how to punctuate or spell something, because AI can just do it for them. They aren't thinking - they're just mindlessly copying. It's soul destroying to see. I've been teaching for 15 years, and the change in children today as opposed to when I first started teaching is astonishing. I have children in Year 12 and 13 studying English Literature and planning on doing so at university who aren't using capital letters or full stops accurately in their work. They've spent their whole lives using spellcheck and have mindlessly clicked on the wavy line to fix their mistake rather than learning from them. Technology hasn't aided them at all. It's disabled them.

When teachers model that using AI to do their work is acceptable, it really is the nail in the educational coffin. It takes 5 minutes to make some passably decent powerpoint slides, and quite frankly, in 2026, no one should be teaching via worksheets. Writing emails to parents using AI is also, in my book, totally unacceptable. Learning how to communicate effectively with parents is part of our job, and crafting a careful email to express your thoughts is part of the process of that communication. Quite frankly, if you can't string a coherent sentence together without a computer doing it for you, then you're not educated enough to teach others.

I don't use AI for any aspect of my work because no one can plan better for my students than me, and that's what I'm trained to do. We've had staff training on using AI for lesson planning and I've got plenty of lazy, mediocre colleagues who have lapped it up, but when I've tried it for my subject, all I've got back is hackneyed ideas that won't work for various practical reasons, as well as made up quotations and and formulaic interpretations of texts that lack any nuance. I'd never use any of that material for lessons, as I can do so much better. I look down on my colleagues who do, because they're using it to teach really shit lessons - not because they're not able to teach good lessons, but because they can't be bothered to.

What makes me laugh about my colleagues who have embraced AI for their work life balance is that they don't seem to realise they are actively doing themselves out of a job. Every time they cut a corner through using AI, they're proving to a beancounter in the DfE that their work can be done using a machine and not a person. It won't be long before they replace us all with machines at this rate.

They're also contributing to the needless destruction of the environment in the colossal amounts of water that data centres supporting AI use, and in the habitats being destroyed through the clearing of land for the building of said data centres. What a great example to be setting our kids. We can't be teaching them about the climate crisis in one lesson, while encouraging them to contribute to it in another, for goodness' sake.

OP, I'd be complaining to the school, asking for a copy of their AI policy for teachers, and questioning the teacher's competence. How can you trust that he actually knows the students and has engaged meaningfully with their work when he is using AI to plan everything? I wish more parents would complain at my school, as I think it would force our SLT to think much more carefully about how we as teachers are being allowed to use AI in classrooms. In the long term, it's not going to benefit anyone.

onedayillmoveon · 13/10/2026 22:59

Goldenbear · 13/10/2026 21:24

Those working in regulatory areas of data governance or data ethics for example. Introducing these practices in schools need to be scrutinised not just embraced without any regard for the above.

Do you work in such a field? Ethics are a different matter.

Schools do scrutinise teachers’ practice in general, and are accountable for pupils’ grades. If any resources produced with the help of AI affected the quality of the lessons, and therefore grades attained, then teachers would be held accountable for that. I don’t think there are many teachers blindly using AI and not checking its output.

KnickerlessParsons · 13/10/2026 23:03

ShakespeareSallo · 12/10/2026 18:55

All the worksheets in the book and homework’s that have come home are obviously AI generated, you can tell by the art style.

Does it matter? We’re being actively encouraged to use AI at work all the time.

onedayillmoveon · 13/10/2026 23:05

Goldenbear · 13/10/2026 21:54

And how would you know that, it's wishful thinking that schools are applying the level of scrutiny needed, there simply isn't the money to employ people who know what they are doing to look at this. Schools already have burgeoning data analytics of students that are ethically questionable but are used out of convenience.

What data do schools hold that is ethically questionable? All the data I can see about pupils (reading age, SATs, SEN, medical conditions) is practically necessary to me as a teacher.

Minasama · 13/10/2026 23:06

Goldenbear · 13/10/2026 19:56

People go to school to receive an education, students aren't workers

My point is, it doesn’t matter if the teacher uses AI to generate materials, assuming they are qualified in the subject and review & edit the materials. In fact it’s good as they will free up more time to prepare the rest of the lesson properly.

EnidSpyton · 13/10/2026 23:06

onedayillmoveon · 13/10/2026 22:59

Do you work in such a field? Ethics are a different matter.

Schools do scrutinise teachers’ practice in general, and are accountable for pupils’ grades. If any resources produced with the help of AI affected the quality of the lessons, and therefore grades attained, then teachers would be held accountable for that. I don’t think there are many teachers blindly using AI and not checking its output.

I think you're being very naive.

I know many colleagues who copy and paste all sorts into AI, including students' names, email addresses, etc. I have received emails from colleagues that have been copy and pasted from AI without even removing the prompts.

Most schools aren't checking what resources teachers are generating from AI, and many are actively encouraging teachers to use AI to create resources in the first place.

Schools aren't scrutinising any of this. Most school staff have got no idea about this kind of technology, its capabilities, or how to manage it effectively. It's the blind leading the blind.

tillybug · 13/10/2026 23:07

I’m sorry but this is categorically not true and either a case of misunderstanding or miscommunication.
in sixth year pupils are studying A Levels with specific units of learning for a 2 year course.
The idea that a student would not be aware of what the course covers is ridiculous - It is available on the exam board website for a start and first port of call for any interested parents / pupils.
For those who can’t be bothered to do that - schools legally have to have schemes of work outlining what’s being taught.
it’s not a free for all - see what the teacher feels like!!

onedayillmoveon · 13/10/2026 23:11

SeasideWalkaroundStore · 13/10/2026 21:38

Yes, you use a washing machine to wash your clothes; but what lots of people are doing with AI is the equivalent of asking your washing machine to choose what you should wear, put your outfits together and tell you to put your arms up in the air and count to 5 so that it can dress you every morning like you're a toddler.

Your extended analogy there doesn’t work; teachers aren’t using AI to tell them what to actually teach, or in what order, or how to question pupils, or anything that really matters.

EnidSpyton · 13/10/2026 23:14

onedayillmoveon · 13/10/2026 23:11

Your extended analogy there doesn’t work; teachers aren’t using AI to tell them what to actually teach, or in what order, or how to question pupils, or anything that really matters.

In some cases, of course they are.

Stinkybooks · 13/10/2026 23:16

MyEasterBonnet · 12/10/2026 20:48

Surely the teaching is good then, if your child is doing well in it?

No.
Various subjects I was good at at school but had poor teachers in those subjects.
Lots of marvellous eg maths teachers with classes full of kids who struggle with maths however hard their teachers try.
One does not necessarily require the other. It can help but it’s not a given.

onedayillmoveon · 13/10/2026 23:17

EnidSpyton · 13/10/2026 23:06

I think you're being very naive.

I know many colleagues who copy and paste all sorts into AI, including students' names, email addresses, etc. I have received emails from colleagues that have been copy and pasted from AI without even removing the prompts.

Most schools aren't checking what resources teachers are generating from AI, and many are actively encouraging teachers to use AI to create resources in the first place.

Schools aren't scrutinising any of this. Most school staff have got no idea about this kind of technology, its capabilities, or how to manage it effectively. It's the blind leading the blind.

I’ve only worked in state schools which have centralised resources, which I don’t think are AI (which I can tweak and deliver as I like, change activities etc). Many of my colleagues have been teaching for 20/30 years and have resources they made themselves, and which they adapt each year to suit individual classes etc.

Schools should obviously monitor what teachers are delivering, but if AI is used wisely, the lesson quality is high, and pupils achieve or exceed their GCSE and A-level target grades, is it a problem?

onedayillmoveon · 13/10/2026 23:18

EnidSpyton · 13/10/2026 23:14

In some cases, of course they are.

Well if that’s true for some teachers, they maybe need to do some more training.

justasking111 · 13/10/2026 23:22

ShakespeareSallo · 12/10/2026 20:42

My child is doing well, actually. It’s that it is jarring to see them coming home every day with (obviously) AI generated worksheets, homework… it makes me concerned about the quality of teaching. I am constantly telling my children not to use AI for school work, yet they are being given AI work. School has also sent emails home and had assemblies about the use of AI and cheating, AI being inaccurate and all the usual.

DS doing his masters for the past two years, the students were reminded with each assignment not to use AI, they would be caught and would fail that assignment.

I don't know if GCSEs face the same checks though.

EnidSpyton · 13/10/2026 23:25

onedayillmoveon · 13/10/2026 23:17

I’ve only worked in state schools which have centralised resources, which I don’t think are AI (which I can tweak and deliver as I like, change activities etc). Many of my colleagues have been teaching for 20/30 years and have resources they made themselves, and which they adapt each year to suit individual classes etc.

Schools should obviously monitor what teachers are delivering, but if AI is used wisely, the lesson quality is high, and pupils achieve or exceed their GCSE and A-level target grades, is it a problem?

Edited

I think the problem is that we don't know what wise AI use is. There isn't enough research and evidence out there yet for us to be able to evaluate the impact of using AI in classrooms and how it may enhance or diminish teacher expertise or student's learning.

In my view, a computer isn't able to teach my class better than me. So I don't see any need for AI usage in a classroom, whether that usage is considered 'wise' or not.

gardenflowergirl · 13/10/2026 23:28

Surely you must have heard about many teachers leaving the profession due to excessive workload and difficulties in recruitment due to this. AI is likely used in every school now, state and private. Doctors are using it too. You meeting with the headteacher is not going to make any difference. It's the future.

justasking111 · 13/10/2026 23:31

It seems it is acceptable now, the teacher can check it over before handing out to correct erroneous information.

Teacher in private school using AI for everything.