Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Teacher in private school using AI for everything.

336 replies

ShakespeareSallo · 12/10/2026 18:52

As the title says really.

My now teenage child has attended a private school since 11, they are now in Year 10. It has been a great experience for them and worth the money. We aren’t rich by any means but afford it by making cut backs, we haven’t been on holiday for 5 years. VAT has hugely impacted us.

My child now has a teacher for a core subject which they haven’t had before. They bring their book home every week, and it is very obvious that the whole scheme of work and all of the worksheets and homework are AI generated. I am not a dinosaur, and I do use AI myself. However, this level of usage coming from my child’s teacher seems excessive, and I am not sure how much actual teaching is going on? My child has also said all of the PowerPoints used in lessons are obviously AI generated, and even that it has appeared as though the things on the PowerPoints the teacher is seeing for the first time alongside the students?!

Less of an issue, but I’ve also had some suspiciously AI looking and sounding emails from other members of staff in the school.

WIBU to arrange a meeting with the Head of Year to raise these concerns, or is this just the modern era of teaching?

OP posts:
EnidSpyton · 13/10/2026 23:31

onedayillmoveon · 13/10/2026 23:18

Well if that’s true for some teachers, they maybe need to do some more training.

Naturally. But they're not going to, are they? They're just going to go through their careers merrily using AI to produce resources and plan their lessons and write their reports and so on. Cos it's all about 'work-life balance' and 'embracing the future' and so on. Embracing the decline and eventual destruction of our profession, more like!

I have many colleagues who think it's absolutely wonderful that they can now outsource so much of our work to AI. One of them is our AI champion. He sends us tips every week about how we can use AI to reduce our workload. This week's one was about creating exam papers for students. Just a few clicks and you can produce a whole exam without having to think at all. Because not having to think about what I'm doing is precisely the state of being I'm aiming for...

Goldenbear · 13/10/2026 23:37

onedayillmoveon · 13/10/2026 22:59

Do you work in such a field? Ethics are a different matter.

Schools do scrutinise teachers’ practice in general, and are accountable for pupils’ grades. If any resources produced with the help of AI affected the quality of the lessons, and therefore grades attained, then teachers would be held accountable for that. I don’t think there are many teachers blindly using AI and not checking its output.

How are data ethics not relevant when discussing AI? it doesn't matter what field or sector you work in, it's totally relevant when considering the use of AI.

noblegiraffe · 13/10/2026 23:43

It takes 5 minutes to make some passably decent powerpoint slides, and quite frankly, in 2026, no one should be teaching via worksheets.

Well, this is a load of rubbish, @EnidSpyton . Literally nothing wrong with teachers using worksheets.

EnidSpyton · 13/10/2026 23:49

noblegiraffe · 13/10/2026 23:43

It takes 5 minutes to make some passably decent powerpoint slides, and quite frankly, in 2026, no one should be teaching via worksheets.

Well, this is a load of rubbish, @EnidSpyton . Literally nothing wrong with teachers using worksheets.

I respectfully disagree.

Goldenbear · 13/10/2026 23:51

EnidSpyton · 13/10/2026 23:31

Naturally. But they're not going to, are they? They're just going to go through their careers merrily using AI to produce resources and plan their lessons and write their reports and so on. Cos it's all about 'work-life balance' and 'embracing the future' and so on. Embracing the decline and eventual destruction of our profession, more like!

I have many colleagues who think it's absolutely wonderful that they can now outsource so much of our work to AI. One of them is our AI champion. He sends us tips every week about how we can use AI to reduce our workload. This week's one was about creating exam papers for students. Just a few clicks and you can produce a whole exam without having to think at all. Because not having to think about what I'm doing is precisely the state of being I'm aiming for...

I absolutely agree.

noblegiraffe · 13/10/2026 23:54

EnidSpyton · 13/10/2026 23:49

I respectfully disagree.

You are possibly speaking only for your own subject then.

But in maths, kids need to do questions. Those questions can be on a PowerPoint slide, in a textbook or on a worksheet. And worksheets as a format are far more versatile than the first two.

ilovepuppies2019 · 14/10/2026 03:59

SeasideWalkaroundStore · 12/10/2026 21:25

I don't think anybody is suggesting that everything AI-generated is useless. It's just that, if you're paying a teacher for their knowledge, experience, skills and ability to specifically tailor their material to their students, and they're outsourcing most of it to a bot - one that pretty much anybody could use - they're clearly telling you that you don't really need them at all, and that the value that they can add personally is clearly very limited. You can effectively recreate most of what they can offer in minutes with, effectively, a 'magic spell'.

It's amazing how many people are utterly determined to make themselves and their livelihoods obsolete and throw themselves on to the scrapheap as soon as they possibly can.

You're still gaining the expertise and skills of the teacher. The teacher understands the various activities that will scaffold the learning and they use AI to target those skills. Teaching a child to read is an enormous and complex task. Teacher don't just ask AI to 'make a worksheet that will help kids learn to read.' They know the specific skills that they're building in every activity and they're using AI to create a very specific resource. That's why schools buy into workbook schemes, because the skills needed for a larger ability are built sequentially. It's disappointing to realise that parents have no idea what the skills and expertise of teachers actually are.

I think a lot of people are forgetting what things were like in the 'olden' days of the 90s. Yes, we had hand made worksheets....sometimes. A lot of what we had was the workbook that was bought for every Year 2 in the country. You did a page from the workbook with no differentiation of ability and no tailoring to interests. If you were struggling because you were a year or two behind, the teacher had to come over and try and explain, because there were no easier resources to draw on. Most kids just sat there and got it wrong until they eventually became too bored and got disruptive. Current events or celebrations and kids interests were never capitalised upon because the entire country had the same worksheet. When we did have a handmade worksheet, they weren't recreated each year by scratch - that would be an insane and unachievable level of work. They were the same worksheets the teachers had been using for 15 years. Again, because there was no differentiation, the kids who were bright and finished early sat and coloured the worksheet while the teachers tried to wrangle or support the kids who had no idea what to do. So much learning time was lost.

The resources we have available nowadays are brilliant. Kids can do math apps that instantly mark work and are customised to their ability. We don't want kids sitting in a Year 2 classroom because they happen to be the right age but staring out the window because they have the Math skills of a 4 year old and no idea what's going on. That was the inevitable reality in the 90s. Now kids can improve whatever skill level they're on. AI allows teachers to make customised resources which are tailored to different ability levels and kids. Who cares what the illustrations look like! It's fabulous that 5 different ability groups can get a customised worksheet. The kid with dyslexia can get pictures to support their phonics, the kid with ADHD can get a sheet with shorter instructions and breaks built in etc.... It also frees up teachers to spend more of their time in the classroom talking and engaging with kids. A fair chunk of our school day was spent exchanging worksheets so that another kid could mark our work while the teacher read out the answer. Now so much time is freed up for teachers to actually teach.

Kids shouldn't use AI because learning the skill is the point of the task. It's very different.

I suspect OP that the teachers doesn't have a clue what's on the resources because (a) she's not a very good teacher, or (b) the resources was made by another teacher in the year and she hasn't taken the time to read it.

EvieBB · 14/10/2026 04:01

ShakespeareSallo · 12/10/2026 18:52

As the title says really.

My now teenage child has attended a private school since 11, they are now in Year 10. It has been a great experience for them and worth the money. We aren’t rich by any means but afford it by making cut backs, we haven’t been on holiday for 5 years. VAT has hugely impacted us.

My child now has a teacher for a core subject which they haven’t had before. They bring their book home every week, and it is very obvious that the whole scheme of work and all of the worksheets and homework are AI generated. I am not a dinosaur, and I do use AI myself. However, this level of usage coming from my child’s teacher seems excessive, and I am not sure how much actual teaching is going on? My child has also said all of the PowerPoints used in lessons are obviously AI generated, and even that it has appeared as though the things on the PowerPoints the teacher is seeing for the first time alongside the students?!

Less of an issue, but I’ve also had some suspiciously AI looking and sounding emails from other members of staff in the school.

WIBU to arrange a meeting with the Head of Year to raise these concerns, or is this just the modern era of teaching?

How can you tell.if things are AI generated? (Sorry I rarely use it - I'm deffo a dinosaur even though I used to teach MS Word, Excel and PowerPoint back in the day lol!)

ilovepuppies2019 · 14/10/2026 04:07

EnidSpyton · 13/10/2026 22:54

I'm a teacher (in a private school) and I'm horrified by how quickly and thoughtlessly so many schools have drunk the AI kool-aid.

It's a nonsense that teaching students to use AI effectively will help them in the workplace. AI is evolving so rapidly that by the time today's 11 year olds are in the workforce, the technology we have now will look like the equivalent of a penny farthing. It is utterly pointless trying to keep up with the pace of technology in our classrooms.

What our children need to be taught is critical thinking, creativity, compassion and collaboration. They're growing up in a world faced with huge problems, and AI is one of them. Yes they're going to need to know how to navigate that world, but the skills they're going to need to do that will be internal - emotional, and intellectual. Being taught that every time they're faced with a problem, they can just put a prompt into AI to help solve that problem, will only continue to contribute to the problems we're facing. We need to be building a generation of thinkers and creators, and instead, by encouraging and enabling the use of AI, we're building a generation of children who can't think for themselves at all, and can't cope with being intellectually challenged. They can't be bothered to sit and go through the process of editing their work, deciding what word might be better, or really grappling with working out how to punctuate or spell something, because AI can just do it for them. They aren't thinking - they're just mindlessly copying. It's soul destroying to see. I've been teaching for 15 years, and the change in children today as opposed to when I first started teaching is astonishing. I have children in Year 12 and 13 studying English Literature and planning on doing so at university who aren't using capital letters or full stops accurately in their work. They've spent their whole lives using spellcheck and have mindlessly clicked on the wavy line to fix their mistake rather than learning from them. Technology hasn't aided them at all. It's disabled them.

When teachers model that using AI to do their work is acceptable, it really is the nail in the educational coffin. It takes 5 minutes to make some passably decent powerpoint slides, and quite frankly, in 2026, no one should be teaching via worksheets. Writing emails to parents using AI is also, in my book, totally unacceptable. Learning how to communicate effectively with parents is part of our job, and crafting a careful email to express your thoughts is part of the process of that communication. Quite frankly, if you can't string a coherent sentence together without a computer doing it for you, then you're not educated enough to teach others.

I don't use AI for any aspect of my work because no one can plan better for my students than me, and that's what I'm trained to do. We've had staff training on using AI for lesson planning and I've got plenty of lazy, mediocre colleagues who have lapped it up, but when I've tried it for my subject, all I've got back is hackneyed ideas that won't work for various practical reasons, as well as made up quotations and and formulaic interpretations of texts that lack any nuance. I'd never use any of that material for lessons, as I can do so much better. I look down on my colleagues who do, because they're using it to teach really shit lessons - not because they're not able to teach good lessons, but because they can't be bothered to.

What makes me laugh about my colleagues who have embraced AI for their work life balance is that they don't seem to realise they are actively doing themselves out of a job. Every time they cut a corner through using AI, they're proving to a beancounter in the DfE that their work can be done using a machine and not a person. It won't be long before they replace us all with machines at this rate.

They're also contributing to the needless destruction of the environment in the colossal amounts of water that data centres supporting AI use, and in the habitats being destroyed through the clearing of land for the building of said data centres. What a great example to be setting our kids. We can't be teaching them about the climate crisis in one lesson, while encouraging them to contribute to it in another, for goodness' sake.

OP, I'd be complaining to the school, asking for a copy of their AI policy for teachers, and questioning the teacher's competence. How can you trust that he actually knows the students and has engaged meaningfully with their work when he is using AI to plan everything? I wish more parents would complain at my school, as I think it would force our SLT to think much more carefully about how we as teachers are being allowed to use AI in classrooms. In the long term, it's not going to benefit anyone.

Edited

I'm a 90s kid and we were using spell check then. If kids are substantially worse than they were 15 years ago then it's not due to spell check. I agree that it is horrifying that Year 12 kids don't know where a capital letter goes. AI is may too recent to be responsible for that though.

Worksheets have a valuable place, especially in Maths and spelling / grammar. Plenty of kids do learn well by drilling a skill. It's ironic though that we shouldn't be using worksheets when this thread is largely about how much teachers were doing before AI and technology. That's back when the only thing we had was worksheets.

GarlicEverything · 14/10/2026 04:45

onedayillmoveon · 13/10/2026 22:52

Teachers aren’t using AI to replace reasoning though; they just use it to create resources, which are just a means to an end (the end being learning). The reasoning is thought behind the lesson plan itself and the actual interaction with pupils in the classroom.

A friend shared this from her child's workbook.

If the teacher checked it before setting it for the class, the teacher should be fired.

I don't know if it was AI created but the point still stands. I can believe that some teachers would express surprise at the content of the teaching materials they use, having not seen them for themselves.

Teacher in private school using AI for everything.
Autumnalhibernationisthedream · 14/10/2026 04:59

TwinklyAmberSloth

YABU
I'm a teacher and I often use AI.
If you don't put the effort IN to AI, then the output is rubbish. So it is highly unlikely all the PowerPoints are AI, but may have been run through AI to improve them.

That’s really not true given the amount of ‘help’ ai has probably had in the education sector- I’d guess so many have used it and there’s so much content to pull from they can generate something suitable quickly. Ai is only recent and I wasn’t thrilled before ai that so much was just grabbed off the internet- of course both can be used but personally I’d like to students to learn by example that research, time and a built up knowledge is important as opposed to everything being from ai.

And all the people laughing at op’s aibu wouldn’t be saying this if their own child came home with all ai generated worksheets, it’s the typical thing of if it doesn’t happen to me it’s fine!

fuckeditupbadly · 14/10/2026 06:32

So do you honestly think that every teacher should be sat reinventing the wheel for every lesson? Creating bespoke resources with every word, image, question, extract, example, individually crafted for that exact class on that particular day? 30 years ago teachers could buy photocopiable masters for £200 that were high quality layout and design and worked well for subjects where basic content doesn't really change. This isn't much different if we are simply talking about creating resources.

JetFlight · 14/10/2026 06:54

There’s a difference between telling ai “plan a pie chart printable for year 9” and then just getting some generic output and “plan a pie chart lesson - I want it to include this, use a pie chart for sports which includes cricket, netball, basketball, I want it to have this problem to investigate and the proportions should be like this.”
One is just giving up all your thinking and one is using ai as a tool and still using your own methods, style and engagement.
The second wouldn’t bother me and it would be reflected in the teaching.

Cookiecrumblr7 · 14/10/2026 07:17

ShakespeareSallo · 12/10/2026 22:34

No - the teacher said they couldn’t provide my friends sixth former (at the same school), with information about the topics being covered this term because they decide what to do ‘5 minutes before the lesson’. They were not saying they adapt the lesson or add things in for those who are struggling.

Have you ever considered that the teacher may have been joking or flippant? Of course it would be unprofessional otherwise, but this approach to teaching is highly unlikely.

Cookiecrumblr7 · 14/10/2026 07:19

Cookiecrumblr7 · 14/10/2026 07:17

Have you ever considered that the teacher may have been joking or flippant? Of course it would be unprofessional otherwise, but this approach to teaching is highly unlikely.

And besides, most schools' planning is rigorously and thoroughly checked at the start of each term by senior management. This really is very unlikely in a school nowadays.

Natsku · 14/10/2026 07:24

fuckeditupbadly · 14/10/2026 06:32

So do you honestly think that every teacher should be sat reinventing the wheel for every lesson? Creating bespoke resources with every word, image, question, extract, example, individually crafted for that exact class on that particular day? 30 years ago teachers could buy photocopiable masters for £200 that were high quality layout and design and worked well for subjects where basic content doesn't really change. This isn't much different if we are simply talking about creating resources.

What's wrong with using textbooks instead? That have been well thought out, written, and edited by expert humans rather than a machine that hallucinates. That's what they use in schools where I am so teachers don't have to make their own resources (whether by themselves or with AI) and instead have more time and energy to focus on teaching.

noblegiraffe · 14/10/2026 07:35

Teachers can make shit resources, textbooks can be crap (I've used enough of them), The problem isn't with AI making the resources, it's if it's making shit resources (and it can certainly do that too).

Complain if the resources are shit. Don't complain just because they're AI.

Goldenbear · 14/10/2026 07:52

ilovepuppies2019 · 14/10/2026 03:59

You're still gaining the expertise and skills of the teacher. The teacher understands the various activities that will scaffold the learning and they use AI to target those skills. Teaching a child to read is an enormous and complex task. Teacher don't just ask AI to 'make a worksheet that will help kids learn to read.' They know the specific skills that they're building in every activity and they're using AI to create a very specific resource. That's why schools buy into workbook schemes, because the skills needed for a larger ability are built sequentially. It's disappointing to realise that parents have no idea what the skills and expertise of teachers actually are.

I think a lot of people are forgetting what things were like in the 'olden' days of the 90s. Yes, we had hand made worksheets....sometimes. A lot of what we had was the workbook that was bought for every Year 2 in the country. You did a page from the workbook with no differentiation of ability and no tailoring to interests. If you were struggling because you were a year or two behind, the teacher had to come over and try and explain, because there were no easier resources to draw on. Most kids just sat there and got it wrong until they eventually became too bored and got disruptive. Current events or celebrations and kids interests were never capitalised upon because the entire country had the same worksheet. When we did have a handmade worksheet, they weren't recreated each year by scratch - that would be an insane and unachievable level of work. They were the same worksheets the teachers had been using for 15 years. Again, because there was no differentiation, the kids who were bright and finished early sat and coloured the worksheet while the teachers tried to wrangle or support the kids who had no idea what to do. So much learning time was lost.

The resources we have available nowadays are brilliant. Kids can do math apps that instantly mark work and are customised to their ability. We don't want kids sitting in a Year 2 classroom because they happen to be the right age but staring out the window because they have the Math skills of a 4 year old and no idea what's going on. That was the inevitable reality in the 90s. Now kids can improve whatever skill level they're on. AI allows teachers to make customised resources which are tailored to different ability levels and kids. Who cares what the illustrations look like! It's fabulous that 5 different ability groups can get a customised worksheet. The kid with dyslexia can get pictures to support their phonics, the kid with ADHD can get a sheet with shorter instructions and breaks built in etc.... It also frees up teachers to spend more of their time in the classroom talking and engaging with kids. A fair chunk of our school day was spent exchanging worksheets so that another kid could mark our work while the teacher read out the answer. Now so much time is freed up for teachers to actually teach.

Kids shouldn't use AI because learning the skill is the point of the task. It's very different.

I suspect OP that the teachers doesn't have a clue what's on the resources because (a) she's not a very good teacher, or (b) the resources was made by another teacher in the year and she hasn't taken the time to read it.

How depressing, surely the best way to learn to read, is to read lots of those things called, 'books'.

It's like a Black Mirror episode, what's next, AI built from the Student's digital footprint!

Goldenbear · 14/10/2026 07:54

noblegiraffe · 14/10/2026 07:35

Teachers can make shit resources, textbooks can be crap (I've used enough of them), The problem isn't with AI making the resources, it's if it's making shit resources (and it can certainly do that too).

Complain if the resources are shit. Don't complain just because they're AI.

AI 'isn't' just a tool though, there is a fundamental misunderstanding on this thread about what AI is.

Natsku · 14/10/2026 08:10

noblegiraffe · 14/10/2026 07:35

Teachers can make shit resources, textbooks can be crap (I've used enough of them), The problem isn't with AI making the resources, it's if it's making shit resources (and it can certainly do that too).

Complain if the resources are shit. Don't complain just because they're AI.

I think its fair enough to complain about the use of AI whether its crap or not simply because its AI so is harming our planet, increasing unemployment and limiting our children's futures. And if other teens are anything like my DD and her friend group, its use will turn them right off the lesson as they passionately hate AI (and have refused to use it in class when instructed to do so. Thankfully the teacher was fine with them doing their work without it)

ilovepuppies2019 · 14/10/2026 08:15

Goldenbear · 14/10/2026 07:52

How depressing, surely the best way to learn to read, is to read lots of those things called, 'books'.

It's like a Black Mirror episode, what's next, AI built from the Student's digital footprint!

Not for young children who can't read yet, no. They need to learn pre-reading skills. Things like one-to-one correspondence, phonemic awareness, visual discrimination, directionality etc... are all essential pre-reading skills. Teachers know how to build these skills. You don't just put a book in front on them (or an AI sheet) and hope they learn. AI can help teachers plan activities and make sheets that will build these skills with the specific prompts that they know are helpful.

Goldenbear · 14/10/2026 08:53

Natsku · 14/10/2026 08:10

I think its fair enough to complain about the use of AI whether its crap or not simply because its AI so is harming our planet, increasing unemployment and limiting our children's futures. And if other teens are anything like my DD and her friend group, its use will turn them right off the lesson as they passionately hate AI (and have refused to use it in class when instructed to do so. Thankfully the teacher was fine with them doing their work without it)

Yes, the harm to the planet appears depressingly irrelevant despite us knowing that the younger generations will be exposed to the worst of the extreme weather and climate change risks.

There are many teenagers that feel the same as yours.

justasking111 · 14/10/2026 09:21

noblegiraffe · 13/10/2026 23:43

It takes 5 minutes to make some passably decent powerpoint slides, and quite frankly, in 2026, no one should be teaching via worksheets.

Well, this is a load of rubbish, @EnidSpyton . Literally nothing wrong with teachers using worksheets.

It's been proven that the human brain absorbs information better when it's written down rather than on a screen. Unfortunately books are too expensive so work sheets it is.

Om83 · 14/10/2026 10:08

worksheets and other activities, whether AI generated or not, provide active learning and engagement in the topic. Yes books are great for content and have their place in a lesson (assuming pupils can access the content and reading ability is there) but children sitting reading text books for every lesson would not result in the same level of cognitive engagement and retrieval as worksheets, activities, and discussions with peers and teachers about their misunderstandings or confirmation they are correct, as well as PowerPoints and images to help explain often wordy concepts to contextualise things from those text books. You have to be able to see that learning is happening- how on earth can you do that when they are bored senseless from reading text books!

justasking111 · 14/10/2026 10:26

Om83 · 14/10/2026 10:08

worksheets and other activities, whether AI generated or not, provide active learning and engagement in the topic. Yes books are great for content and have their place in a lesson (assuming pupils can access the content and reading ability is there) but children sitting reading text books for every lesson would not result in the same level of cognitive engagement and retrieval as worksheets, activities, and discussions with peers and teachers about their misunderstandings or confirmation they are correct, as well as PowerPoints and images to help explain often wordy concepts to contextualise things from those text books. You have to be able to see that learning is happening- how on earth can you do that when they are bored senseless from reading text books!

You can scribble in the margins, take them home. Revisit when revising. DS papers are still in a cupboard here and he's just finished his masters.