Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To stop MIL interfering with our nanny?

424 replies

marinym · 12/10/2026 14:45

My MIL comes over once a week to see the children and apparently help out. She lives about an hour and a half away and makes the journey herself. We have never asked her to do this. She actually said to DH that she doesn’t feel she’s getting the full grandma experience because she doesn’t help with the children enough so that’s now it started.

The thing is we really don’t need the help. I earn the same as DH, both quite high earners and we can comfortably afford childcare / afterschool clubs. We have a brilliant nanny who has become like a second grandma to the children. She genuinely goes above and beyond her job and we absolutely love her.

When MIL comes over the nanny is still there doing her job. MIL gets to take the baby out or bake banana bread with our eldest while the nanny does everything else and cleans up afterwards. So MIL gets the fun bits and the nanny deals with the aftermath. If the baking turns into a complete disaster the nanny is the one cleaning banana off the kitchen cupboards. If there’s a poonami the nanny changes it whilst MIL has a cup of tea. I don’t mind this arrangement at all. I think we all understand that we could manage perfectly well without her being there but there’s no need to point that out if it makes her feel better.

Recently MIL has started telling our nanny how to do her job. Not anything particularly serious but lots of little comments about how she should be doing things differently when the nanny is simply following our instructions. For example we expect our children to tidy up one activity (to the extent that they can at their ages) before getting another out. MIL will say things like “Oh don’t make her do that. Grandma’s only here for a little while so let her enjoy herself.” The nanny just says she’s following our instructions and carries on. I’ve told her not to get into a discussion about it. Just smile, say she’s following her employers’ instructions and carry on as normal. Same thing with the baby. We give him vitamins and MIL has told the nanny that she shouldn’t be doing that because babies should get everything they need from food. The nanny is following our instructions. If MIL has a problem with what we decide for our children she can speak to us about it rather than telling the nanny what she should or shouldn’t be doing.

She also makes odd comments about that I feed her “little boy” (aka my over-40yo DH). If we’re having leftovers from the night before MIL will say things like “You’re not all eating leftovers, are you? I can come and cook for you if you’re struggling”. We’re not struggling, we’re using time effectively and cooking for 2 days.
Or “It’s salmon for dinner? He never used to like it as a fillet, I think he’d prefer it in fishcakes, do you need a recipe?” Well he’s not living at home now is he? He’s living with me and our children and I’m not running a restaurant where everyone gets a separate meal. I cook what works for the family. If we’re having curry twice because there’s enough left over then that’s what we’re having. If I know kids will eat salmon as a fillet better than in a fish cake, then we’ll have that. If I tell her this it’s “aw I understand, I just know how much he used to like his food” as if I’m malnourishing him. And for the record, we eat home cooked meals every day, it’s either myself or the nanny cooking (DH often finishes later than I do) and DH actually seems to enjoy it, will often have seconds after everyone has eaten or request a repeat of what we’ve previously made.

DH is much more diplomatic than I am. He’ll say something like “Maybe I like it now Mum” or “It’s just easier to cook something we’ll all eat” but also she rarely makes the comments in front of him, usually just to me and nanny. He does stand up for us and I don’t want to give the impression that he doesn’t but he’s very gentle with her and always tries to keep things pleasant. I’m not like that. I’m quite direct and perfectly happy to say “Look this is our house and this is how we do things. If you don’t like it you don’t have to come over.” I think some of it is probably cultural. I’ve lived here since I was 16 but I’m much more comfortable being blunt about things whereas DH would rather smooth everything over. It’s the same if we disagree with each other - he’ll be diplomatic and smooth things over, I’ll say exactly what I mean and likely in a spicy tone.

I’ve also told DH that I’m not comfortable leaving MIL alone with the children. He agrees that’s fair so the nanny is always there. I don’t particularly trust MIL’s judgement and I’m not going to pretend otherwise just to avoid an awkward conversation.

Whilst I think it’s lovely that she wants a relationship with the children and I appreciate the effort of travelling 3hrs total once a week, we don’t actually need her help. I do think she needs to understand that being Grandma doesn’t make her the boss of our household. DH thinks we should keep things diplomatic and let the nanny carry on ignoring the comments. I think that’s fine up to a point, that point has been reached for me, and I’d like to say something. Our nanny already has the patience of a saint and I don’t see why she should put up with someone getting in the way of her doing her job.

AIBU to say that she either needs to stick to her role of being a guest or the visits will become a lot more rare?

OP posts:
bert3400 · 13/10/2026 05:55

I've been a nanny, when I was younger, I'm now a GM & MIL. I do not interfere but am genuinely there to help when asked and needed by my lovely DIL.

If I was your nanny I would dread the day MIL turned up...it's like she's being put under surveillance.

It's a tricky situation but MIL definitely needs to be spoken to by your DH, just a quiet word about criticism of Nannies procedures which you as the parents have requested and she has implemented...'please do not question them as it puts the nanny in an awkward situation'

You sound like a great employer OP, and to retain a nanny for 7 years definitely shows you must be a great person and family to work for.

morbiddest · 13/10/2026 05:55

She hasn't really done anything wrong except share her opinion and say a few things that you don't like. It's not awful for people to say things that you don't agree with. It might annoy you but it doesn't seem like a good reason to stop the children building a strong bond with their grandparent. It seems quite selfish of you to have paid help when a grandparent is desperate to spend time with the children. You havent really given any evidence that she couldn't care for the children - presumably she raised your husband. Of course if a paid nanny is there then she will worry less about cleaning up and stuff? And I also totally get what she means about her time with the kids being so limited that she wants to make the most of it. Poor woman. Giving the nanny unasked for advice is annoying but she's probably just feeling bad and desperately wanting to find a way to be in her grandkids lives.

BinfortheWin · 13/10/2026 05:55

Calliopespa · 12/10/2026 18:24

Ultimately your nanny is a paid employee, she doesn’t love your kids, isn’t their family and won’t be in your lives for very long

This is what the OP isn't seeing.

She is the "Grandmother" the OP loves because a) she doesn't care enough to have a contradictory opinion and b) she is paid to do what the OP wants, so she does.

The OP will be the next thread where the mother is absolutely shattered that their "part of the family" nanny is leaving for her own reasons, when they no longer coincide with being paid to mind these dc, and will be lamenting that she cannot understand how the nanny can do this to her dc because she always "loved them so much."

Paid help is exactly that OP: paid help. Yes, it's more convenient, yes, it's more obedient, and yes it masquerades well, but confuse it with genuine love at your peril.

This one million times.

We had some lovely nannies when my children were younger. They were ‘like family’ in that they knew us, knew the routines, were genuinely fond of the children. One, we are still in touch with now.

But they are not family and they don’t love you. They all leave eventually when it suits them - as they should! And it is usually unexpected.

Of course you prefer the nanny (please don’t say ‘second grandma’ again) - you pay her to do exactly what you want, which she does.

But you are being unfair to MIL.

morbiddest · 13/10/2026 05:57

My children also have a nanny who is 'like a grandmother' as she has been with them since birth and we live abroad so they barely know their actual grandparents. It is NOT ideal. A nanny doesn't love your children. She is at work. She will quit one day or retire or get a better paid job and never see them again. You cannot replace family with paid help.

thepariscrimefiles · 13/10/2026 06:13

Biddybobsleigh · 12/10/2026 22:43

I doubt she is,
If thats OP perspective then I wouldn't trust her word, shes all but banned her MIL from contact with her grandchildren, because she quite obviously got a problem with her.
Maybe with good reason, but she shouldnt be blocking her MIL from having a relationship with her sons children.

You're just making stuff up now. It's the nanny that has complained to OP about OP's MIL's constant snarky criticisms. It isn't as though OP can give her nanny the day off on MIL's days because she refuses to do any practical child care such as changing nappies and making their lunch.

OP is worried that her nanny will leave as she has spoken to OP and asked her to do something about it.

thepariscrimefiles · 13/10/2026 06:16

Tourmalines · 12/10/2026 23:41

Yep

OP and her husband provide financial support to OP's MIL, not the other way round so the threat of MIL leaving her non-existent money to other people is an empty one.

thepariscrimefiles · 13/10/2026 06:20

Sensiblesal · 12/10/2026 23:52

You aren’t actually allowing her to be grandma. You clearly don’t like her.

poor woman is just trying to be involved with her family & gets to visit whilst supervised by the nanny. You are putting the Nanny in a terrible position at the same time.

no mention of actual family visits or doing activities all together. Not allowing her to look after the children without the Nanny. I hope your DH has siblings so your MIL can experience proper grandparenting

As MIL refuses to change nappies or do any of the practical stuff required such as making their lunch, OP can't leave her children with her without the nanny being there.

Biddybobsleigh · 13/10/2026 06:22

thepariscrimefiles · 13/10/2026 06:13

You're just making stuff up now. It's the nanny that has complained to OP about OP's MIL's constant snarky criticisms. It isn't as though OP can give her nanny the day off on MIL's days because she refuses to do any practical child care such as changing nappies and making their lunch.

OP is worried that her nanny will leave as she has spoken to OP and asked her to do something about it.

Im making stuff up? Where does it say anything about the nanny complaining of 'snarky comments?' It doesnt lol.

HylianShroom · 13/10/2026 06:48

doodleygirl · 12/10/2026 15:02

I think you sound quite nasty. Your MIL wants a relationship with her grandchildren and is pro active in doing so.

OP, I found your MIL

Ihatelittlefriendsusan · 13/10/2026 06:49

Your set up (minus mil) sounds lovely and your nanny sounds amazing. But she is telling you very clesrly that your MIL is becoming too much.

This is something your DH needs to tackle and promptly before you loose the nanny.

I have zero relationship with my in-laws. They have made more underhanded comments than I can be bothered to go into, but both mil and fil are very like your mil. DH is like yours and keeps the peace whereas I am fiery and will defend myself.

With DH's agreement i have stopped being nice about it and started to point out when they were being rude. It went down like a lead balloon but I would do the same (and have) when it is my own parents making such comments.

You need a conversation with dh and he needs to lay it out clearly that her behaviour will no longer be tolerated.

Supporting2026 · 13/10/2026 06:50

marinym · 12/10/2026 16:28

Topseyt123 I can assure you the nanny isn’t looking for a way out. We’ve known her for nearly seven years, so I know her pretty well by now, she’s been on holiday with us, I’ve spent every one of my mat leaves seeing her daily. We’ve helped her and her family out over the years and she’s gone above and beyond for us too. There’s a lot of mutual affection and trust there. Obviously she’s employed by us and nothing is guaranteed, but I know the person she is and I genuinely don’t think she’s secretly planning her escape! We’d both have enough respect for each other to inform each other before seeking a new job or new nanny.

No, we don’t call her a replacement grandma to MIL or the children. The sentiment is there even if we don’t name it or discuss it though. The children get excited when they know she’s coming on holiday with us, make her birthday presents without being prompted, have their own little in-jokes with her and look forward to days that she stays overnight (if my husband is on a business trip and I need the help). I can see that she genuinely loves the kids too, and it’s understandable given she’s helped to raise them from babies and has seen them every day. That’s not to say they love her more than their parents or their actual grandparents, it’s simply a lovely relationship that’s developed over years of spending so much time together.

Just to say well done - its great your kids have such a fantastic relationship with their nanny. Super important. Also, ignore the people saying the nanny doesn't love them, I've had a nanny just a year and she absolutely does love the kids because she's not a monster and you can't care for small children that intensely and not love them. It doesn't mean that the relationship would last forever if she left but that would be much more about the kids moving on and our relationship (i.e. we get on but she's not my family). However, after 7 years its a lot more than just a job. One of my friends had the same nanny for 14 years and she still takes her kids to visit her now more than 3 decades later even though she lives 2 hours away.

Smokeywater · 13/10/2026 06:55

Recently MIL has started telling our nanny how to do her job.

Is Nanny complaining or are you over hearing this - If Nanny is telling what mil is saying or you are asking what dmil is saying then you tell her she has your full trust and to ignore DMIL and you don't want to hear what annyoing things DMIL has said as it annoys you

SixAndJuliet · 13/10/2026 06:56

thepariscrimefiles · 13/10/2026 06:20

As MIL refuses to change nappies or do any of the practical stuff required such as making their lunch, OP can't leave her children with her without the nanny being there.

That’s not at all what has been said though. Nanny and Grandma are both there in an awkward situation where one is being paid to make the lunch and change the nappies. It’s not fair to criticise the grandma for not doing that stuff, especially as if she did Nanny would likely report back about having her toes stepped on.

If grandma was in sole charge of the children for a couple of hours and asked to do this stuff then she most probably would. I’m still not clear why OP is uncomfortable allowing gran to spend time alone with them.

What is clear is that OP likes her kids having a paid grandma that she can control and has to obey her more than their own grandma.

Busybeemumm · 13/10/2026 07:15

There will be a day not so long from now when your MIL is too frail to make the 3 hour round journey, your kids are older and no longer want to make banana bread and your baby won't be in nappies. Just let the comments she makes breeze over.

I would just let the nanny have the afternoon off and let your MIL have the kids on her own. If she can manage a 3 hours of travelling then she will be just ok. It might not be as perfect as your nanny but your MIL loves your kids more than your nanny ever will.

JayJayj · 13/10/2026 07:29

Mapletree1985 · 12/10/2026 16:08

I hope your MIL finds some other worthy children to adopt as grandchildren and leave her money to, since you've made it abundantly clear you neither need nor want her. You oh-so-graciously allow her to come over, I guess because you don't want to be a complete Amanda, but you've pretty much spelled it out to her that she is surplus to requirements.

You sound like you are probably one of these interfering grandma’s yourself 😂

JayJayj · 13/10/2026 07:30

Busybeemumm · 13/10/2026 07:15

There will be a day not so long from now when your MIL is too frail to make the 3 hour round journey, your kids are older and no longer want to make banana bread and your baby won't be in nappies. Just let the comments she makes breeze over.

I would just let the nanny have the afternoon off and let your MIL have the kids on her own. If she can manage a 3 hours of travelling then she will be just ok. It might not be as perfect as your nanny but your MIL loves your kids more than your nanny ever will.

Oooor, the mil can be told, like an adult, to keep her comments to herself because she is done raising children. These are her grandchildren not her children. She doesn’t get to decide whether or not they need vitamins.

2chocolateoranges · 13/10/2026 07:34

Why doesn’t grandma visit on a day you are home?

I’ll tell you why because when you are home you are in control, but when nanny is there grandma thinks she is control as she is family.

grandma likes the fact that it’s not you that’s home as she probably gets to do as she wants .

Biddybobsleigh · 13/10/2026 07:50

Biddybobsleigh · 13/10/2026 06:22

Im making stuff up? Where does it say anything about the nanny complaining of 'snarky comments?' It doesnt lol.

And where does it state rhat the grandmother doesnt do the other stuff like changing nappies? Again, it doesnt, she doesnt get a look in by the tone of OPs post.

Busybeemumm · 13/10/2026 07:55

JayJayj · 13/10/2026 07:30

Oooor, the mil can be told, like an adult, to keep her comments to herself because she is done raising children. These are her grandchildren not her children. She doesn’t get to decide whether or not they need vitamins.

We give him vitamins and MIL has told the nanny that she shouldn’t be doing that because babies should get everything they need from food.

Isn't it ok for mil to have her own opinions on what she thinks is right or wrong. It doesn't mean that the OP and her DH have to change their parenting styles. The nanny just needs to crack on with her instructions.

The OP needs to tell MIl that she can talk to her and DH about the vitamins rather than the nanny as the nanny is paid child care and will do as she is instructed.

It's great that the MIL feels able to share her opinions and hasn't been shut down...yet!

chirrupybird · 13/10/2026 08:14

Simple solution let grandma come when nanny has a day off then they won't be under each others feet and vying for the attention of the children. Part of one day a week not putting toys away instantly won't hurt.

My MIL didn't do everything (or hardly anything) the way I did, but so what the DC were happy with her, which is all that matters, and seeing how different people do things might even be beneficial.

saraclara · 13/10/2026 09:18

As a grandmother, the whole 'not having/voicing opinions' thing is quite interesting. I'm well aware that I'm not supposed to express my opinions, so I very rarely do (and I'm not apologising for the times that I did, in fact on one of the occasions it was vital and led to my DGC being an emergency admission to hospital for two weeks as my DC hadn't recognised how serious a symptom was).

However, I would say that almost every time my adult children visit (and we love each other very much) they have an opinion on something to do with my life, or my home, or some something in the house that I need to 'do something about'.

And going by Mumsnet threads, it seems extremely common for adult kids to have opinions and to tell their parents what they should be doing and how they should be doing it. It's quite the one way street.

LivingTheDreamish · 13/10/2026 09:26

Sounds like you and the nanny handle MIL perfectly. So long as the nanny is fine with it (and hopefully she feels free to be slightly undiplomatic when discussing MIL with you) then surely everyone just cracks on. MIL sounds very annoying but essentially harmless. You're stuck with her but don't lose a lovely nanny over her.

Blondeshavemorefun · 13/10/2026 09:57

I do think you should try granny alone with kids. She isn’t going to leave baby in a dirty nappy if only her to change

yes toys /an activity should be tidied up before the next one and again if granny is alone she may reliese this rather than everything be on the floor

it is nice she wants to be involved but the comments have to stop to the nanny

if nanny isn’t there then mil can only complain to you or dh - who then may say something to his mum

one day she won’t be able to drive herself there and children do grow quickly so let her come over once a week and play /look after them but let nanny go

assume kids happy to see granny

when daddy blondes comes aka grandad blondes , mini blondes adores him and they play and cuddle and he makes maths fun by saying I go to shop and get 2 apples at 10p each and one banana at 20p. How much change is left from £1/2/5 etc

or they play eye ball bounce /catch or read a story together or he will watch her do gym stuff

he doesn’t tidy up as such but in fine with that as he’s spending time with her and one day he sadly won’t be here as heading up to 90

sorry a lot of woffle. But basically let nanny finish early and granny be in charge by herself and see how things go - it’s a few hours once a week

godmum56 · 13/10/2026 10:01

Busybeemumm · 13/10/2026 07:55

We give him vitamins and MIL has told the nanny that she shouldn’t be doing that because babies should get everything they need from food.

Isn't it ok for mil to have her own opinions on what she thinks is right or wrong. It doesn't mean that the OP and her DH have to change their parenting styles. The nanny just needs to crack on with her instructions.

The OP needs to tell MIl that she can talk to her and DH about the vitamins rather than the nanny as the nanny is paid child care and will do as she is instructed.

It's great that the MIL feels able to share her opinions and hasn't been shut down...yet!

having opinions fine, voicing them unless asked not fine.

009395elj · 13/10/2026 10:03

SixAndJuliet · 13/10/2026 06:56

That’s not at all what has been said though. Nanny and Grandma are both there in an awkward situation where one is being paid to make the lunch and change the nappies. It’s not fair to criticise the grandma for not doing that stuff, especially as if she did Nanny would likely report back about having her toes stepped on.

If grandma was in sole charge of the children for a couple of hours and asked to do this stuff then she most probably would. I’m still not clear why OP is uncomfortable allowing gran to spend time alone with them.

What is clear is that OP likes her kids having a paid grandma that she can control and has to obey her more than their own grandma.

This . W