Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To find gift giving and receiving really stressful and wish we could just stop

95 replies

ProfessorofDarkArts · 12/10/2026 09:56

I have 2 close family members with birthdays coming up and I have no idea what to buy for either of them. I try to choose thoughtful gifts that are within my budget but they dont really need anything and I feel like I've exhausted all my ideas over the years. And then before long I'll need to buy Xmas presents as well!

It's the same with receiving gifts - I'm appreciative of anything I'm given but my house is very small and I haven't got room for any more 'stuff'. The only things I really want cost way more than anyone would be able to spend on me and I'd feel uncomfortable if they did. And if I see something small I'd like I tend to buy it as you can guarantee it wont be in stock if I wait and ask for it for Xmas/birthday.

Some things I've tried before anyone suggests them:

  • Secret Santa for close family. Helps a bit but various people wont take part so I still need to buy separately for them
  • Buying experiences for my partner and he does the same for me. This is great but he still likes to buy other things and then I feel I should reciprocate
  • Asking for money or vouchers and giving the same. This is ideal in some ways but youre basically just swapping money and it feels wrong giving eg my elderly mum £20 in a card!

AIBU to think most adults* dont need any more stuff and gift giving and receiving is a massive pain in the arse?

*Obviously referring to your average person who is working and reasonably OK financially.

OP posts:
Sartre · 13/10/2026 10:46

I appreciate it when someone asks what I want and I can tell them. I hate it when people guess and are hugely off the mark, it’s just so wasteful and I don’t want to pretend to like it incase they buy more of whatever it is.

MIL’s presents are always so hit and miss. One year she got me lots of lovely candles and I appreciated that. Another year she got me some random vampire books because I’m an English lit lecturer and also apparently in her view a goth because I wear black often…

It’s the worst with DC when people don’t ask and just buy shite they’ll never use. It then becomes your issue to find a new home for these things.

Blueskies3 · 13/10/2026 11:20

Yes, I feel completely the same about gifts. If I’m given anything I prefer second hand, a plant or consumable, or experience. But I’ve really stopped giving and receiving most gifts. I don’t miss it. Except I do give for for the children of course. And they’re teachers. That’s so hard to plan and buy for

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 13/10/2026 11:23

@ProfessorofDarkArts - I tend to buy nice foodie gifts for people - posh biscuits or jam from Fortnum and Mason - they are a nice treat, and, once eaten, they don’t add to the stuff in someone’s house.

SillyPiccalilli · 13/10/2026 14:29

How about homemade gifts? If you can be bothered with the faff, I think it's quite nice to give/receive something homemade as there's clearly been thought and effort put into it.

In our family we've had hand knitted scarves, mittens, socks, a cardigan, homemade pickles, chutneys and jams, felted Christmas ornaments, cross stitch/embroidered artwork, homemade wines and flavoured vodka/gin/brandy, Christmas cake/biscuits, sweets, etc.

We also do IOUs for theatre/gig tickets of the recipients choice, and attend together. It means they get something they enjoy, and you get to spend time together doing that thing, but it removes the pressure of having to decide yourself and pre-book etc. For smaller gifts we've done the same with homecooked meals for closer family (e.g. for mums birthday we may say choose a cuisine of their choice and we'll throw them a themed dinner party at our house, with three courses of homecooked food and no washing up for them!).

Coffeeeecups · 13/10/2026 14:33

We do small things we wouldn't normally spend on.
Socks are popular from my mum! She knows where to find some premium cotton ones and they are lush. And premium food items. Basically things we normally think "ah, not going to pay that!". We also do things like local theatre annual ticket etc.
It has to be either useful, lush or enjoyable. Or all 3.

museumum · 13/10/2026 14:35

most of what i give people is high end flowers, food or drink. the sort most people don't treat themselves to.
add in a few book vouchers for readers and the occasional book i actually think somebody will like and sometimes a restaurant voucher or cinema or sauna and that's most of my gift giving and receiving. no unwanted landfill for anybody.

Vidalbuffay · 13/10/2026 15:02

just rip the plaster off and tell people you won’t be doing gifts anymore.
resist any pressure to change your mind, you won’t regret it.
I did it several years ago with friends/ some family and now I only get a couple of close family members.

Uppitymuppity · 13/10/2026 19:51

Op I couldn't agree with you more, I also find it stressful and mostly pointless to buy presents for other adults who have their own income. I've suggested in the past to my sister who's into her 50s and my elderly mother, that we don't need to swap presents other than for the kids. I was shot down by both and told I'm just tight, however I think I'ts just practical thinking! I actually dread Christmas because I have my own children to think about and buy for (all awkward ages now) and then on top of that my grown family members who need nothing and can buy things for themselves if they do. We don't spend much but that's not the point, it's the hassle of thinking about what to buy, wrap it and then get it to them that's that extra hassle on the top of what you is already a stressful time of the year. I couldn't care less if I ever receive another pointless present again which is what I usually receive, and I wish I didn't have to buy them again either!

Pumpkinmagic · 13/10/2026 20:33

I could not agree with you more. It’s a massive pain in the arse. Thankfully my family started secret Santa a few years ago, I’ve opted out altogether since I had children. I’ve stopped with Birthday presents for family and friends too except my elderly Nan. I will buy token flowers (think a few bunches of carnations) and chocolates for a friend’s Birthday if they bought for me as feel obligated to. But that is all. I know my Mum is quietly seething I don’t buy her a Birthday present but she receives a ridiculous amount of presents from her friends I mean 20 odd presents, so I’d just be buying something for the sake of it. I don’t want to be spending money on something I have no idea if they want/need and frankly I don’t have the time to be choosing something special. It’s just another thing that I don’t want on my to do list. Husband and I are on the same wavelength, we may buy ourselves a joint Christmas present but not always.

OriginalPeanut · 13/10/2026 20:44

We've never done adult gifts in our family. If we're together at Christmas (rare as spread across the globe) we might do a £20 Secret Santa so everyone has something to open as the children of the family like that but it's no hassle. I've never exchanged presents with friends at Christmas.

ProfessorofDarkArts · 14/10/2026 07:25

@Uppitymuppity yes getting it to them as well! My mum sent my partner a £50 gift card last year and it never arrived so now we have to make sure we meet up near various peoples birthdays to deliver gifts as the post just can’t be trusted 🤦🏻 Obviously sometimes we’d be meeting anyway but often it’s just one more thing to arrange.

OP posts:
MrsWallers · 14/10/2026 15:46

Google Martin Lewis on this issue its really helpful and to summarise its not really necessary to give adults presents for all the reasons you highlight
I haven’t bought an adult a present for years beyond a token food item like M&S treats or choclates
I have 2 adult children who I give money too or pay for things they need like car insurance etc

sausageth · 14/10/2026 15:55

Nah, I'm with you OP. It's hard enough buying a present for my own DH, never mind my two brothers who I barely see.
I honestly think I'd be better off just buying nice hampers, cheese, wine, beer, that sort of thing. Especially for couples as they can share it, job done. I might try that this year. If they have an issue with it, then that says more about them.

Nannyfannybanny · 15/10/2026 09:47

oh yes,MrsWallers, the very adult kids..DD moved house bought her washing machine cooker said ", happy birthday, happy Christmas. They get parts for their vehicles at cost price, usually installed by DH.

Nannyfannybanny · 15/10/2026 09:54

Not on their Birthday or Christmas

Useraxiomak1 · 15/10/2026 09:57

I stopped this years ago. I give my 2adult kids £100 as a gesture every Christmas and that’s it.
If you don’t want to do it just tell everyone “ I’m not doing gifts anymore as it’s not good for my mental health’
Then stop taking part.
Christmas is about enjoying the day doing what you like, eating what you enjoy and good company. We don’t need cheap crap cluttering up the house.

Julynian · 15/10/2026 10:12

I think people generally could change their approach to gifts. Gift-giving used to be a gesture of showing someone that you thought of them and wanted to give them something to represent that. These days it’s become so commercialised, so overthought, and people get so caught up in trying to find something unique, extra special, or a big gift to go alongside a collection of little gifts, etc, it’s all distorted.

For my mother, for birthday and Christmas, I buy her the toiletries set that I know she likes. She buys me a jigsaw and a book. For my sister, I buy her the perfume I know she likes. She books me a massage. Yes, we could just buy all of these things for ourselves, but we make the effort with the gesture, knowing it’s things we all definitely will love, and we exchange them in person so we have that personal connection.

Just keep it all simple. And if you don’t want to do any gifting, just don’t do it!

girljulian · 15/10/2026 10:15

You are so correct, but one year I said to my sister that as all we do is give each other the same £20 in vouchers back and forth so should we just not bother, and she was really upset for some reason!

Katemax82 · 15/10/2026 10:20

I hate it with a passion. My husband has 7 grandkids we live 100s of miles from who are all young so we send stuff via Amazon because they obviously like physical presents. So that's hard. Then there's my 2 oldest son's...I have no idea what to get them ever. My 8 year old only likes creating games and characters on scratch so isn't interested in toys and my 20 year old autistic son can't be left out because he's like a child mentally but I'm always at a loss of what to get him my daughter is easy she makes a gowish list

FinallyHere · 15/10/2026 12:11

the older I get, the more strongly I feel that I really do not want more stuff. I have wrangled all but one relative to buy consumables. But it’s so pointless swapping bottles of wine.

Over the years, I have now cleared the effects of DF, DM and DH and feel really very strongly indeed that I don’t want any more stuff myself.

It was DH who really loved presents, happy for a stream of duds for the sake of the odd real success. Sigh. I’ve always been much more minimalist

This year, I’m adamant, anyone who refuses to agree to just exchange cards, I shall ask them to buy themselves something instead of giving my anything. And to let me know what they ‘got’ or not, just as they like.

The junior members of the family get money paid into their saving accounts, they have all the things they want and will be glad when it comes to financing uni and/of house purchase

Such a weight off my shoulders and makes Christmas much more enjoyable, too.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page