Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Unvaccinated children shouldn't be allowed in mainstream childcare or school

430 replies

ApronSprings · 11/10/2026 21:42

To think children shouldn't be allowed in nurseries or schools if their parents refuse to vaccinate them..

I'm excluding children who medically can't have them for some reason, and this will be too rare to cause a problem, and they deserve the benefit of herd immunity.

But I'm growing tired of the nutcase conspiracy theorists who failed GCSE science but think they've somehow found something missed by experts.

The only argument against this is that it keeps them home with their quack parents and reduces the opportunity for them to be exposed to normal people. But I don't think we should risk other people's lives for it if their parents aren't willing to do the same.

OP posts:
Gengha · 12/10/2026 07:20

bigvig · 12/10/2026 07:18

This! If vaccines work this isn’t an issue. Many measles etc outbreaks have been linked to vaccine strains of the virus - so came from the vaccine. Both my children are vaccinated btw - with the exception of the flu vaccine which is just pointless.

Not correct, there are some kids who can’t have vaccines for medical reasons. Vaccination needs to be at a high level for herd immunity

IronEverything · 12/10/2026 07:22

TealHacks · 12/10/2026 06:45

They wouldn't be if I had my way. Vaccinating should be seen as a social contract, you break it and you lose certain privileges.

I vaccinated my children to not only protect them, but to protect those who cannot be vaccinated. I did NOT vaccinate them so your kids can piggy back off their immunity.

I loathe anti-vaxers and see them as a real scourge on society.

That's nice.

Firefly24 · 12/10/2026 07:25

ApronSprings · 11/10/2026 21:53

The alternative is that we punish children (with their lives) for other people's parent's choices.

If they are vaccinated surely they are protected ...

CinnamonJellyBeans · 12/10/2026 07:26

Children who pose a physical risk to others should not be in a mainstream setting.

Maybe child benefit/school attendance should be dependent on vaccinations (and other stuff that parents are too lazy to do, like toilet training, ability to speak in sentences, read, sit up straight for longer than one minute)

OP is quite right: vulnerable children (and older people) in schools with medical conditions need the herd immunity that mass vaccination confers upon them.

Thesillysocks · 12/10/2026 07:30

Vaccines are mandatory to access school in France, parents just do it, you don’t see many children being home schooled to avoid it.
And even if they were, home schooling is strictly controlled (yearly checks on what is being taught, physical health of the child, etc).

I don’t understand why it’s not the case here.

Firefly24 · 12/10/2026 07:30

Gengha · 12/10/2026 07:06

It’s not punishment, it’s consequences and something the parents can easily resolve

Of course it's a punishment. People can choose whether to vaccinate or not vaccinate it's freedom of choice. Some may choose not to for good reason. All my children are vaccinated but would I give them the covid vaccine... no.

Awkwardisfunny · 12/10/2026 07:32

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 11/10/2026 21:59

Or make it a finable offence?

This really isn’t something to fuck about with tbh.

And I don’t really think parents have the right to deny their children vaccination.

No chance. No one is forcing me to inject anything in to anyone.

Goosebynature · 12/10/2026 07:33

curious79 · 11/10/2026 22:38

Amazing how parents of vaccinated children are still so worried about their children catching diseases (that they’ve been vaccinated against) from unvaccinated children. Do you see the irony?

Amazing how spectacularly some people miss/don’t understand the point!

Have a read about herd immunity and how it works.

Somethinggg · 12/10/2026 07:35

Mine have not only had all usual NHS vaccines but some I paid privately for besides, but this would concern me. The pandemic experience taught me that the state isn't entitled to this level of trust when it comes to my children's welfare.

MrsBennetsPoorNervesAreBack · 12/10/2026 07:38

Firefly24 · 12/10/2026 07:30

Of course it's a punishment. People can choose whether to vaccinate or not vaccinate it's freedom of choice. Some may choose not to for good reason. All my children are vaccinated but would I give them the covid vaccine... no.

It isn't just about freedom of choice, though, is it? Because unvaccinated children will potentially put others at risk. Not the other children who are vaccinated, but the people who can't be vaccinated for whatever reason.

Should people have a free choice to make irresponsible decisions which put other people at risk?

I'm not in favour of denying children an education because their parents have made poor decisions. The children are absolutely not at fault. But the parents are responsible for their decisions and should face consequences imo.

Thesillysocks · 12/10/2026 07:42

Firefly24 · 12/10/2026 07:25

If they are vaccinated surely they are protected ...

Why are you ignoring all the PP who pointed out that younger children or the ones who couldn’t have the vaccine for health reasons wouldn’t be protected?
Why do you think that children of antivax parents should not be « punished » but other children should?

JohnofWessex · 12/10/2026 07:47

May I suggest that vaccine refusal, except where medically contra indicated be treated as a child protection issue?

One other suggestion was that while you could refuse vaccination parents who did so would still be required to attend an appointment with the child to discuss the issue so they dont get a 'free ride' if they cant be bothered

IronEverything · 12/10/2026 07:57

JohnofWessex · 12/10/2026 07:47

May I suggest that vaccine refusal, except where medically contra indicated be treated as a child protection issue?

One other suggestion was that while you could refuse vaccination parents who did so would still be required to attend an appointment with the child to discuss the issue so they dont get a 'free ride' if they cant be bothered

They already do that. I still get regular calls and monthly letters from the GP wanting to discuss vaccinations for my 3 year old. I attended the first time, listened and declined.

They definitely don't just leave people to it.

MinnieMountain · 12/10/2026 07:59

@bigvig there is a point to 'flu vaccination. Do you really think the NHS would pay for the many people who are entitled to it for free if it were pointless? It's just different because it depends on what is the most common strain that season, so it isn't 100% effective.

fashionqueen0123 · 12/10/2026 08:02

Sooooewanttobut · 12/10/2026 02:58

Exactly!! I really don't understand the thinking of some posters in here who seem to think that an individual child being vaccinated means "that" child is no longer at risk.

Vaccinations are not about individual removal of risk for a single person but a whole eradication of infections and harmful diseases through enough of us being able to protect those that can't have that protection through whatever
reason (autoimmune compromised as an example)

Those that are able to, should have the vaccinations to creat a herd immunity: this means that there are enough of us in the community who are no longer spreading the infection that it stops in people who can fight it! I think 95% has been mentioned before for measles as an example.

If a lot of people who could take them choose not to, then that 95% of people vaccinated will be lower and this infection passes on and will increase and put your own unvaccinated child at a higher risk.

It makes very little sense to me why you would roll those dice on the basis of a very small risk of a healthy child having the vaccination.

Vaccinations have removed / reduced a huge amount of serious threats to our children (and serious symptoms in adults) measles, polio, rubella, etc etc. We seem to be forgetting that.

Mind boggles.

Well yes it does make me laugh (but scared for their kids) when they say things like their kids rarely get colds and eat lots of vegetables and have great immune systems… like that is remotely related.

AllIwantForChrismasIsAKitchenAidStandMixer · 12/10/2026 08:05

IronEverything · 12/10/2026 07:57

They already do that. I still get regular calls and monthly letters from the GP wanting to discuss vaccinations for my 3 year old. I attended the first time, listened and declined.

They definitely don't just leave people to it.

jolly good job too! You should be vaccinating your child and they are thing to stop you being reckless

user1492757084 · 12/10/2026 08:06

We have had this for more than 40 years
Possibly more than 60 years.
Showing BC and a vaccination certificate upon enrolling for school. And from then on, vaccinations occur at school.

JustCraicOn · 12/10/2026 08:07

Measles vaccinations are mandatory in educational settings where I live (a region of Germany). That applies to children and adults alike. Adults who aren’t vaccinated can’t work in education - that’s their decision.
Important to note that 1. it’s a misdemeanor, not a crime 2 the offence is failing to provide evidence of a vaccination or an exemption for medical reasons, not failing to vaccinate as such.
Children cannot attend nursery without this certificate (vaccination or exemption) because nursery is voluntary.
School is mandatory in Germany so a child cannot be excluded (or discriminated against) if the parents don’t provide a certificate. Parents are usually fined, starting at a few hundred and going up to 2,500€. I couldn’t find any statistics on how many parents are fined. The goal is obviously to ensure herd immunity in educational settings for the sake of those who medically can’t be vaccinated, and that strategy seems to have worked.
The law only applies to measles, but since only MMR is offered by doctors it effectively means all three are covered in schools.

fashionqueen0123 · 12/10/2026 08:07

Clonakilla · 11/10/2026 23:13

These kids parents have already prioritised their own stupidity over their children’s safety. I don’t think removing their children from schools where they will have an opportunity to encounter more rational people helps the kids at all. Certainly wouldn’t want those people home-schooling (some do).

As for the poster above who thinks I don’t say this to anti-vaxxers faces, you’re right. I certainly do soften the message when negligent parents who thought they’d ’done their research’ and risked their child’s life as a consequence ask if they child might not have needed to be intubated if they’d vaccinated.

Have you watched The Pitt? There’s an episode where a kid has bad effects of measles and the parents can’t decide if to allow them intubate him (because the mum is a conspiracy nut) so the dr takes the Dad to the dead bodies in another room to ask him what he’d prefer.

AllIwantForChrismasIsAKitchenAidStandMixer · 12/10/2026 08:08

Celtic1hair · 12/10/2026 07:04

But we did stop smoking in public places to reduce the rates of second hand smoke related injury to those who didn't, thus protecting people from the choices of others.
You are absolutely not being unreasonable OP. decisions have concequences and those who do not have immunology degrees should not be allowed to jeapordise the health and wellbeing of those who follow the evidence of vaccinations.

Yes and there are certain things you can’t access unless you stop smoking. You cannot adopt a child for example unless you have been smoke free for at least 6 months.

attichoarder · 12/10/2026 08:10

There appears to be such aggression to those who hold a view that parents have a choice whether to vaccinate. Choosing not to vaccinate is not case of child cruelty or neglect and suggestions that the parents are unhinged, uneducated or loons shows a lack of tolerance.

CactusCuttings · 12/10/2026 08:11

No I don't really think that unnecessary medical treatment of healthy babies and children should be mandatory. 😂 Bloody Hell.

EppingIsFun · 12/10/2026 08:13

attichoarder · 12/10/2026 08:10

There appears to be such aggression to those who hold a view that parents have a choice whether to vaccinate. Choosing not to vaccinate is not case of child cruelty or neglect and suggestions that the parents are unhinged, uneducated or loons shows a lack of tolerance.

It's not aggression to state the truth. Wilfully denying your child protection from some of the most awful diseases known to humankind (unless medical exemption of course) makes one a shit parent. It is medical neglect and should warrant an investigation by child protection services.

Hoodle · 12/10/2026 08:15

There is legal authority that going about in public with a serious infectious disease is a public nuisance and attracts sanction. All we need to do is widen the criteria so that anti-vax parents could be sued or prosecuted, or both, for contributing to the spread of dangerous notifiable diseases if there are outbreaks.

Since anti-vaxers are so keen on their ‘choices’, they could choose to not vaccinate and risk some massive legal consequences. Some reports of anti-vaxers losing their homes and jobs or attracting convictions for exposing other children to risk of life-changing disability or death would do wonders for vaccine uptake.

None of this would stop anti-vaxers from ‘researching’ vaccines (and they could add legal research to their hobby) or from going on bracing walks in the woods.

CactusCuttings · 12/10/2026 08:15

attichoarder · 12/10/2026 08:10

There appears to be such aggression to those who hold a view that parents have a choice whether to vaccinate. Choosing not to vaccinate is not case of child cruelty or neglect and suggestions that the parents are unhinged, uneducated or loons shows a lack of tolerance.

I agree. One could just as easily argue that handing your healthy newborn baby over to a stranger to inject them is neglect. I can't imagine willingly causing my baby pain.

Swipe left for the next trending thread