Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To dislike Birmingham?

560 replies

redeoof · 10/10/2026 20:55

I’ve worked in the city maybe 4 years now .. there really isn’t much appealing about it. I once overheard a woman on the train say she does guided tours for Manc, London and Birmingham - and Bham is a hard sell.

I’ve been coming into New Street station for years and there’s always been construction and it’s never seemed to progressed to anything.

I walk down New Street and actually feel unsafe. It’s depressing and dreary .. and it should be so much more

OP posts:
Thread gallery
14
browneyes77 · 13/10/2026 08:23

Rrei · 13/10/2026 07:47

I've actually been and had multiple days where I've been in the city and seen the area. I've been for work and other things. Always happy when I can leave

We’re happy when you leave too…..

browneyes77 · 13/10/2026 08:29

Rrei · 13/10/2026 08:15

Again when people from the EU come to see the UK where do they usually? London or Edinburgh mainly.

Does a Parisian ever think "oh let me take the Eurostar and then from that I'll go take a connecting train to see Birmingham"

You should probably research tourism in UK cities before you spout nonsense.

To dislike Birmingham?
walrushurricane · 13/10/2026 08:29

envbeckyc · 13/10/2026 00:00

That can only be Trinity Hill when a pregnant woman was attacked by her ex partner, amazingly both she and her daughter survived thanks to help from passers by who saved their lives, and amazing doctors!

It happened a decade ago….

She became an advocate for women experiencing domestic violence and he was sent to prison!

It was such a shocking incident that everyone knows about it and the location is etched into the memory of residents.

I don’t think it’s a tourist attraction… but perhaps because it was so shocking and gained national publicity they pointed it out to you!

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-birmingham-56230392

Yes, what i remember about that was firstly that it was a horrendous attack on a pregnant woman by her partner and secondly he didn't get away with it because strangers risked their lives to stop him and some of them were also stabbed.

MissSookieStackhouse · 13/10/2026 09:09

I really like Birmingham! My DD went to uni there and my DP is from the Midlands so we go there a few times a year when visiting his parents. I always think it’s a vibrant city with lots going on. I’m going there in a couple of weeks to a new restaurant that’s just opening up. Looking forward to it!

Shinyhappyapple · 13/10/2026 09:44

Rrei · 13/10/2026 08:15

Again when people from the EU come to see the UK where do they usually? London or Edinburgh mainly.

Does a Parisian ever think "oh let me take the Eurostar and then from that I'll go take a connecting train to see Birmingham"

I don’t think anyone is advocating it as a must-see tourist destination, just that the downsides in terms of crime are issues in most towns and cities, and that there are things to see in terms of museums, theatres, green space, if you are there and want to do that. There are good and bad points about all cities.

But I don’t think anything anybody says to you will help you to become more rational.

Muffsies · 13/10/2026 10:44

browneyes77 · 13/10/2026 08:29

You should probably research tourism in UK cities before you spout nonsense.

My family live in Oxford and we have have taken many family trips to Birmingham. We've done the christmas market, jewellery quarter, sealife centre, zoo, the canals (which have been redeveloped), black country museum, cadbury world, etc. Can't tell you how many times we've been around the Wrekin. I've never felt unsafe and brummie people are lovely.

My partner and i have often spoken about retiring to worcestershire. I have no qualms about leaving oxford and making brum my nearest city destination.

1dayatatime · 13/10/2026 10:53

Muffsies · 13/10/2026 10:44

My family live in Oxford and we have have taken many family trips to Birmingham. We've done the christmas market, jewellery quarter, sealife centre, zoo, the canals (which have been redeveloped), black country museum, cadbury world, etc. Can't tell you how many times we've been around the Wrekin. I've never felt unsafe and brummie people are lovely.

My partner and i have often spoken about retiring to worcestershire. I have no qualms about leaving oxford and making brum my nearest city destination.

That's wonderful from your own personal experience that you feel safe in Birmingham. However the statistical evidence is that Birmingham has the third highest violent crime rate of UK cities.

That of course doesn't mean that everyone will be a victim of crime, just as not everyone is a victim of violent crime in Johannesburg, but just that it is statistically more likely.

Muffsies · 13/10/2026 11:31

1dayatatime · 13/10/2026 10:53

That's wonderful from your own personal experience that you feel safe in Birmingham. However the statistical evidence is that Birmingham has the third highest violent crime rate of UK cities.

That of course doesn't mean that everyone will be a victim of crime, just as not everyone is a victim of violent crime in Johannesburg, but just that it is statistically more likely.

Third highest, but a fraction of London's (which i assume you're perfectly happy visiting), and in absolutely no way comparable to Johannesburg.

We have stabbings and thefts and rapes here in oxford, too. There are areas i would not go, same goes for any city.

Brum has loads of culture, things to do and nice people. I just can't see bad crime areas (which every city has) as a sole reason to dislike it so much, especially as most of the posters saying that clearly don't know the city as a whole or any brummies at all.

walrushurricane · 13/10/2026 11:51

Rrei · 13/10/2026 11:23

Birmingham is a very unsafe city.

https://www.birminghammail.co.uk/news/midlands-news/terrifying-moment-man-attacked-knifepoint-28956963

If this is normal and happens elsewhere in the UK then maybe most of the UK is kinda crap isn't it.

Armed robberies do happen in other parts of the UK ffs. Have you any idea how big Birmingham is?

LeedsLoiner · 13/10/2026 11:56

Ineedanewsofa · 10/10/2026 21:57

Dude, if you were looking for an absolute “Brum is a shithole” pile on, you should have said. Plenty of folks will actually think it’s ok.
Perhaps worth considering a new job if you hate it that much tho…HS2 will get you to that fancy London 15 minutes quicker in 15 years time, so not long to wait 😂

Regarding HS2 I'm convinced it would have cost less to demolish Birmingham and rebuild it half an hour closer to London - and it would have been done quicker!

walrushurricane · 13/10/2026 11:58

1dayatatime · 13/10/2026 10:53

That's wonderful from your own personal experience that you feel safe in Birmingham. However the statistical evidence is that Birmingham has the third highest violent crime rate of UK cities.

That of course doesn't mean that everyone will be a victim of crime, just as not everyone is a victim of violent crime in Johannesburg, but just that it is statistically more likely.

Nobody feels safe in every area of Birmingham. There are some very unsafe areas just as there are in every city. Most areas are absolutely fine though. 1.2 million people live in Birmingham itself but if you count the whole urban area and include Walsall, Wolverhampton, Solihull, Black Country etc it's about 4.3 million. Do you seriously think everyone is shaking in their boots because they feel unsafe.

Americasfavouritefightingfrenchman · 13/10/2026 12:45

OMGyoucantbeserious · 11/10/2026 18:42

I'm from Brum and agree, the city isn't quite what it was, but it's no different really to other major cities. I visited Newcastle for the first time recently and thought what a dirty and unattractive place.

It just goes to show how subjective these things are given Newcastle has what is frequently described as “the finest street in Britain” (Grey street). We live out by the coast near it and I really like it (also really liked Birmingham, Manchester, York, Edinburgh and London on recent visits) but it’s undeniable city centres are dirtier/more rubbish strewn of late and that there are a lot more homeless people and addicts visible in the main thoroughfares. I dislike it but I accept it’s something that’s happening widely vs individual cities being unpleasant. What I like is the museums, theatres, eating out opportunities, parks, galleries etc and seeing the architecture. We really loved the big open squares & the library in Birmingham. If you ever go to Newcastle again it has a very cool small castle by the railway, the Baltic art gallery on the riverside is interesting, theatre royal is gorgeous and on the aforementioned Grey street and Jesmond Deane park is pleasant for a walk just outside the city centre.

Americasfavouritefightingfrenchman · 13/10/2026 12:52

TrixieFatell · 11/10/2026 20:00

I've lived in Manchester. Regularly go to London. Have had weekends away in different cities. Still think they are all pretty much the same in terms of nice and horrible areas

Agree. I wonder if people who hate it have just had a really bad first impression or went expecting the bad and looked for it? I’m definitely a glass half full person and will look to find the good bits about places we visit.
I hadn’t realised so many people had strong opinions on Birmingham until mentioning we planned to go on holiday there this past summer. It was a place we’d never visited and yet so many people said it was awful who it turned out had also never visited. We had a great time and kids are asking if we can go back. Of all the places we’ve visited I can only really think of Sheffield that we didn’t enjoy at all but even then I accept we might have just chosen what to look at poorly vs assuming the whole place is awful.

1dayatatime · 13/10/2026 13:58

Muffsies · 13/10/2026 11:31

Third highest, but a fraction of London's (which i assume you're perfectly happy visiting), and in absolutely no way comparable to Johannesburg.

We have stabbings and thefts and rapes here in oxford, too. There are areas i would not go, same goes for any city.

Brum has loads of culture, things to do and nice people. I just can't see bad crime areas (which every city has) as a sole reason to dislike it so much, especially as most of the posters saying that clearly don't know the city as a whole or any brummies at all.

Sorry I should have been clearer- I was referring to the per capita rate.

On that basis London is 14th compared to Birmingham as 3rd.

https://securityjournaluk.com/most-dangerous-cities-in-the-uk/

most dangerous cities in the uk

15 Most Dangerous Cities in the UK

The most dangerous cities in the UK are known for high crime rates. Discover the 15 most dangerous cities in the UK and what makes them unsafe.

https://securityjournaluk.com/most-dangerous-cities-in-the-uk/

lilkitten · 13/10/2026 14:17

I go into the Jewellery Quarter once or twice a week for work, I like it there and it's quite peaceful. Not so keen on the centre, but I'm not a big shopper. I walk down Newhall Street from the JQ and there's a couple of nice bars and restaurants on the way in, but I don't do so much in the centre. I much prefer Nottingham (I live midway between the two).

walrushurricane · 13/10/2026 14:32

1dayatatime · 13/10/2026 13:58

Sorry I should have been clearer- I was referring to the per capita rate.

On that basis London is 14th compared to Birmingham as 3rd.

https://securityjournaluk.com/most-dangerous-cities-in-the-uk/

What do they define as a crime though and surely it depends on whether it 8s reported. e.g car theft will be reported whereas pick pocket might not.

PrettyLittleRose · 13/10/2026 15:40

browneyes77 · 13/10/2026 08:23

We’re happy when you leave too…..

😂

PrettyLittleRose · 13/10/2026 15:42

walrushurricane · 13/10/2026 11:51

Armed robberies do happen in other parts of the UK ffs. Have you any idea how big Birmingham is?

I am getting genuinely baffled as to why @Rrei has such deep hatred for Birmingham. Same as the OP. Irrational hatred. (Where is the OP by the way?)

Muffsies · 13/10/2026 15:59

walrushurricane · 13/10/2026 14:32

What do they define as a crime though and surely it depends on whether it 8s reported. e.g car theft will be reported whereas pick pocket might not.

Where i come from, oxford, has a high sex crime rate per capita. Possibly to do with a high student population (but then other cities have big universities too, so not sure why). Do i feel like i'm about to be raped at any moment? Obviously not. Even places with higher crime rates than others, you'd still have to be very unlucky to witness or be the victim of a crime.

Muffsies · 13/10/2026 16:03

lilkitten · 13/10/2026 14:17

I go into the Jewellery Quarter once or twice a week for work, I like it there and it's quite peaceful. Not so keen on the centre, but I'm not a big shopper. I walk down Newhall Street from the JQ and there's a couple of nice bars and restaurants on the way in, but I don't do so much in the centre. I much prefer Nottingham (I live midway between the two).

Nottingham? Isn't that where they have a terrible youth knife crime problem? Aren't you terrified of being stabbed to death by a teenager?? /s

I love the JQ too

lilkitten · 13/10/2026 16:05

Muffsies · 13/10/2026 16:03

Nottingham? Isn't that where they have a terrible youth knife crime problem? Aren't you terrified of being stabbed to death by a teenager?? /s

I love the JQ too

TBF that's everywhere really unfortunately. I live in a small town, there was a stabbing round the corner at 4.30 last Wednesday, kids were still on their way back from school up there. And I work in Derby, same story. It's scary everywhere right now.
Not sure if it is worse now, maybe it is, but the two times I've been attacked have been near to home - in Oxford in 2001, and in Derby in 2008.

Muffsies · 13/10/2026 16:39

lilkitten · 13/10/2026 16:05

TBF that's everywhere really unfortunately. I live in a small town, there was a stabbing round the corner at 4.30 last Wednesday, kids were still on their way back from school up there. And I work in Derby, same story. It's scary everywhere right now.
Not sure if it is worse now, maybe it is, but the two times I've been attacked have been near to home - in Oxford in 2001, and in Derby in 2008.

Edited

Absolutely. My lovely little market home town of abindon has had many nasty crimes in recent years, there was a fatal stabbing in the pound shop and one in the woods, a woman was shot in the head outside her flats only a few streets away from my old home, and a son recently killed his mum in her own home. Hasn't affected the house prices tho!

browneyes77 · 13/10/2026 19:11

Rrei · 13/10/2026 11:23

Birmingham is a very unsafe city.

https://www.birminghammail.co.uk/news/midlands-news/terrifying-moment-man-attacked-knifepoint-28956963

If this is normal and happens elsewhere in the UK then maybe most of the UK is kinda crap isn't it.

How many times do you have to be told that major crime happens in EVERY city in the UK?

Are you really this naive? Or just blind to the truth?

Either that or you’re just on a wind up.

Because nobody can continue to be this obstinate, after being continually proven wrong.

Rrei · 13/10/2026 20:03

browneyes77 · 13/10/2026 19:11

How many times do you have to be told that major crime happens in EVERY city in the UK?

Are you really this naive? Or just blind to the truth?

Either that or you’re just on a wind up.

Because nobody can continue to be this obstinate, after being continually proven wrong.

I'd happily admit most of the UK is a dump then