Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To find all these "why aren't people having children any more" arrives absurd

326 replies

CurdinHenry · 10/10/2026 17:59

It's not really a mystery is it

The real intrigue is why people still do

It's not a logical choice, it's something else that's very hard to describe

OP posts:
Mapletree1985 · 13/10/2026 05:21

CatesandAle · 10/10/2026 18:07

I think it’s bullshit? Most people I know have children. And some have gone through a lot and a lot of expense to get there - repeated IVF, donors, adoption. As a childless person I find these articles particularly irritating because if what they were saying was true my life would feel like the norm, and I can tell you that it definitely doesn’t. I feel like all the people writing these articles have children and don’t actually know what they’re talking about.

Of the 13 people I work with, all adults in or past their 30s, 4 have children.

Delphiniumandlupins · 13/10/2026 05:26

I'm in my 60s. Most of my friends from school and university have children, not all but the majority. My own DC are mid to late 30s, lots of their school and university friends are still child-free. Particularly my child-free DC who has only a few friendswithchildren (perhaps they were selecting friends with similar attitudes in their teens although I wouldn't have predicted then that so many of them wouldn't have children).

Lengokengo · 13/10/2026 05:57

i find this a really interesting thread: it’s an area I have observed over the years. I am mid 50s, and have a cohort of 30 friends from over the years that I invited to my wedding, from different stages of my life ( school, uni, work, hobbies etc)

of these 30 women, 23 had kids and 7 didn’t. Already a large amount. Total number of kids in all is 45, so 1.5 kids per woman.

if I look at how many kids those women’s mothers had ( so women now in their 70/80/90s), it was 68. So a massive change in a generation, from 68 to 45.

most of my friends were one of 3 kids, most of these 30 women, if they had kids at all, had 2. So there is both a child gap ( having less kids than your mother) and a significant amount of child free.

of those 7 who didn’t have kids, 3 didn’t want them, and 4 did want kids but didn’t have them, largely due to not meeting a willing and/ or suitable man. The 3 who didn’t want them, either had a genetic condition they didn’t want passing on, or had observed awful relationship/ divorce dynamics from their parents, which put them off.

of the 23 who had kids, probably ( and of this I am less certain) there were at least 7 who had some sort of fertility treatment/ intervention, which seems incredibly high, though in part reflects age of having kids ( mid to late 30s, mostly).

this is of course skewed data to just my friend and a narrow basis on which to view birth rate, but I find it fascinating how much things have changed in so little a time and for so many different reasons.

PersephoneParlormaid · 13/10/2026 06:13

I work in schools and I see multiple siblings, so I don’t think we are going to run out of humans.

Piglet89 · 13/10/2026 06:30

MrsBennetsPoorNervesAreBack · 10/10/2026 18:55

Honestly, perhaps I am missing something, but it isn't really obvious to me why people aren't having children now at all? In many ways, things are so much better than they used to be - easier for women to maintain their careers, more expectation on men to step up and share the load, more flexible working, more subsidised childcare etc.

Is it about cost of living?
Is it because of climate change?
Is it because more people have mental health problems?
Is it fear of war?
Is it because of family breakdown?
Or some other reason?

I honestly don't understand it. I mean, I totally get that not everyone is cut out to be a parent and I respect the choices of those who don't want kids, but, in a life that has been full of fantastic opportunities and experiences, being a mum is by far and away the single most rewarding thing that I've ever done. Why wouldn't most people want that?

@MrsBennetsPoorNervesAreBackbecause (bluntly) not everyone finds it the single most rewarding thing they’ve done - and some people anticipate that.

Smokeywater · 13/10/2026 06:44

Is it about cost of living?
Is it because of climate change?
Is it because more people have mental health problems?
Is it fear of war?
Is it because of family breakdown?
Or some other reason?

I think it's sad (as a DGM of 5 lovely (but demanding) DGCs)

Camilla Cavendish has just written a book about this issue which is why it is in the news so much,
She was on Politics Now briefly on BBC 2 the other day.
Other reasons
Dating apps make money from people dating, not from them marrying, so the algorithms want people to keep looking.
Going by first impressions (dating apps) only isn't great for a large cohort of people
Social contagion - if everyone around you is doing something (or not ) you are more likely to fall into this lifestyle
Wfh, not going to pubs, on phone instead - harder to meet eligible mate.
Schools teach how not to get pregnant - they don't teach infertility

IMV denying adulthood by keeping DCs in school to 18 doesn't help.
Availability of porn doesn't help. When I was young there was lots of snogging and hand holding before you needed to do the deed. Doing the deed could mean you jump to a very close relationship (risk pregnancy) too quickly. Which might scare people from going there at all.

It's a worldwide problem

CraftySeal · 13/10/2026 06:52

I am the only woman I know in a LTR who has actively chosen not to have children.

Of women I know, probably 25+ have children, and only 4 don't. One due to never finding the right man and not wanting to go it alone, another due to infertility, and 2 due to choice and being long term single.

Of gay male couples I know, probably 1 in 5 chose to have children. I can think of a few long term single men I know who never had children. I can't think of any in a LTR where they didn't have children, but I know of one who left his infertile long term partner and went on to have children with someone else.

Smokeywater · 13/10/2026 07:13

But regardless of the above post - figures in even India demonstrate that numbers of children being born is less than the replacement rate, South Korea's is the lowest at 0.7 per woman

Bobbieiris · 13/10/2026 07:21

I know it drives me mad too. Parenting these days is exhausting because you have to juggle work around raising kids and running a house. Then there's the logistics of work and school drop off/ pick up. And with the cost of living it's increasingly hard to manage financially. Parents are just not supported and people aren't given any incentive or encouragement to start a family. I have twins and I'm planning a third...I must be mad! It's definitely tougher than it needs to be. Also less pressure for women to have kids these days.

SomeoneIsWrongOnTheInternet · 13/10/2026 07:25

oldestmumaintheworld · 10/10/2026 18:09

What annoys me about these articles is that they are never addressed at men just at women. Why are women not having babies is always the question. Well why not ask men what they will do to support women with having children? Step up, support, care instead of pissing off when it gets hard and boring. And then not paying child support. That's why women are reluctant to have children

This. And be warned. For my generation (late Gen X, xennial) we were told it was going to be different, women were more empowered, men were going to help, everyone would be working part time and parenting part time, like the Scands. What we got was globalism, the internet, inequality on steroids, male contempt and hatred of women creeping up with entitlement. The deterioration of women’s health services, the destruction of the value of women’s work, the elevation of male celebrities and politicians everywhere, the elevation of male celebrities. Why are male footballers now paid more than nurses? Why are taxi drivers paid more than everyone? Why do male binmen and warehouse workers find it so much easier to strike and get given what they want rather than healthcare and education staff?

Men lie. And it was beyond stupid of us then to believe that the most vicious and cruel species on the planet would change.

OhamIreally · 13/10/2026 07:26

Douglasmummy · 11/10/2026 16:58

But we do need people who work pay taxes to work in and fund services. Almost all societies are going to be an inverted pyramid for a very long time. The global population rise is being caused entirely by people living longer. The global birthrate has been stable since the 1970's and is now dropping off a cliff which means that once current 50 year olds die the global population will plummet. What is annoying is that it is not only predictable but inevitable. Even if everyone started having tons of babies they will not be adults for 20 years. The 50 year olds will have ( hopefully!) long retired. Yet instead of trying to work on solutions we harangue women into having more babies and causing another boomer generation. We need to sort out elderly care in this country and globally, that isn't going to mean a massive shit show for the people that do exist. I don't know what that is but there surely must be some people working on it.

Presumably this is what assisted dying is intended to address.

MrsBennetsPoorNervesAreBack · 13/10/2026 07:29

Piglet89 · 13/10/2026 06:30

@MrsBennetsPoorNervesAreBackbecause (bluntly) not everyone finds it the single most rewarding thing they’ve done - and some people anticipate that.

You're missing the point that I was trying to make. Obviously, I know that not everyone thinks they will find it rewarding. And that's totally fair enough - I have some very dear friends who have chosen to remain child free, it works very well for them and I'm genuinely happy for them. We don't all have to want the same thing. But that was kind of my point.

The OP claimed that it's not really a mystery as to why people choose not to have children, that the real intrigue is why people still do, and that it isn't a logical choice to have them etc.

My point was that (bluntly) not everyone finds it to be an illogical choice, that some find it the most rewarding thing that they've ever done, and that some people anticipate that. So where's the intrigue and the mystery exactly?

The OP's post implied that articles about why people are choosing to be child free are not necessary because she thinks the reasons are obvious. However, the reasons are not particularly obvious to me, and I am not convinced that all childfree people choose to be childfree for exactly the same reasons anyway. It is hardly as if there is just one self-evident reason that parents have somehow failed to see.

I am perfectly happy to respect other people's choice not to have children, but there is really no need for childfree people to sneer at parents for having made different choices. I get that this probably comes from a place of feeling judged for the decision not to have kids, and that's obviously wrong - nobody should have to justify their choices. But presenting a childfree life as the obvious, logical choice is just as judgemental in the other direction.

Can't we just accept the fact that different people can make different choices for different reasons, and that there is no one "logical" way in which we should live our lives?

Millerner · 13/10/2026 07:30

My young professional friends, mid 30s just have things they’d rather do with their lives than have children. They’re into gravel biking, hiking, having adventures, craft, art. They can’t be bothered to save to be able to afford to buy a nice period property in a middle class area with good schools.

CraftySeal · 13/10/2026 07:33

I seem to think that studies found that childless people and people with children report the same day to day levels of well being and happiness. But parents tend to report a greater sense of big picture fulfilment, which I guess makes sense.

When I look at the people I know who have no children, I think the main reason for it is being long term single during child bearing years. Number two reason is just never having wanted children or felt the urge.

I don't know anyone who wanted children and was in a position to have them (ie someone to have them with, and no known infertility issues), but chose not to have any for financial/practical/environmental reasons. I DO know plenty of people who stopped at one or two children for those reasons when ideally they'd have liked more.

MeetMeOnTheCorner · 13/10/2026 07:44

@CraftySeal I know several men who refused to consider dc. One said he didn’t wanted to be as unhappy as he was! A sort of joke but it wasn’t. Wife earned more and he hated his job. However he wouldn’t give it up and look after a dc. So no dc. Other men we know just didn’t like dc and absolutely refused to entertain a change of lifestyle. That’s been the key regarding most of our childless friends. Somewhat self absorbed and not prepared to change to accommodate anyone else (a baby). As we get older, they are definitely more self centred than people with dc!

Piglet89 · 13/10/2026 07:55

Smokeywater · 13/10/2026 07:13

But regardless of the above post - figures in even India demonstrate that numbers of children being born is less than the replacement rate, South Korea's is the lowest at 0.7 per woman

@Smokeywaterthis article explores the South Korea situation in a bit more detail.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-asia-68402139

South Korean women increasingly don;t want to have babies

Why South Korean women aren't having babies

South Korea has spent billions to reverse its low birth rate, but some say it isn't listening to young women’s needs.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-asia-68402139

Goldenbear · 13/10/2026 08:01

Meadowfinch · 11/10/2026 10:03

Birth rates are declining in every country where women have a choice so it's not hard to work out.

Women don't want 10 babies they will struggle to feed, clothe and house. Women don't want the danger of repeated childbirth and the associated birth injuries.
Women who have an education and the chance of a better standard of living and a better life, will take it.

My gran had 12 dcs.
my mum had 6 dcs (the pill became available while she was pregnant with her
youngest).
I have one dc. I also have a degree, a career, a house I own outright and a pension.

What, this is massively overstating and fact averse. Every woman I know who has children has two or more, all highly educated, Masters level, 90% in professions that earn well, the other percentage doesn't need to earn well due to inheritance or husband's work.

Goldenbear · 13/10/2026 08:03

Equally, my Mum had a career and only had two children, my MIL is the same. I can't think of any friend's that have more than two siblings.

Goldenbear · 13/10/2026 08:11

MeetMeOnTheCorner · 13/10/2026 07:44

@CraftySeal I know several men who refused to consider dc. One said he didn’t wanted to be as unhappy as he was! A sort of joke but it wasn’t. Wife earned more and he hated his job. However he wouldn’t give it up and look after a dc. So no dc. Other men we know just didn’t like dc and absolutely refused to entertain a change of lifestyle. That’s been the key regarding most of our childless friends. Somewhat self absorbed and not prepared to change to accommodate anyone else (a baby). As we get older, they are definitely more self centred than people with dc!

I think that is a huge difference today there is this idea that they are putting their lives in jeopardy, particularly with men.

Goldenbear · 13/10/2026 08:12

Piglet89 · 13/10/2026 06:30

@MrsBennetsPoorNervesAreBackbecause (bluntly) not everyone finds it the single most rewarding thing they’ve done - and some people anticipate that.

I don't see how you can possibly know that pre-children. I think it's more about those that are risk averse choose not to.

Summerlovingtheraspberries · 13/10/2026 08:19

I think it’s more about not finding a partner, or a good enough partner.
The young women I know who are mothers have tended to want a child above and beyond a stable relationship.
It’s not necessarily a conscious decision. But if they waited and really thought about it, then they might hesitate to commit so much to the men they are with.
I also see women where I live having children to multiple partners. These women often either don’t work, or work part time in low skilled jobs.

ExtraHotDoubleShot · 13/10/2026 08:25

I’m 35 and the child free women in my circles are predominantly child free due to infertility. I know a scary number of women going through IVF at the moment. My best friend also just disclosed she and her DH have been contraception free for 2 years and nothing (she’s not overly worried though because she wants to adopt).

All the women I know pursuing IVF are fit, slim and healthy. Makes no sense.

Piglet89 · 13/10/2026 08:31

Goldenbear · 13/10/2026 08:12

I don't see how you can possibly know that pre-children. I think it's more about those that are risk averse choose not to.

@GoldenbearI agree that some people do have much more fun as parents than they anticipated. It is hard to predict how it’ll go as so much depends on factors beyond one’s control. But it’s safe to say if you like order and quiet and being in control, you’re probably not going to enjoy being a parent (certainly of younger children).

ExtraHotDoubleShot · 13/10/2026 08:32

Summerlovingtheraspberries · 13/10/2026 08:19

I think it’s more about not finding a partner, or a good enough partner.
The young women I know who are mothers have tended to want a child above and beyond a stable relationship.
It’s not necessarily a conscious decision. But if they waited and really thought about it, then they might hesitate to commit so much to the men they are with.
I also see women where I live having children to multiple partners. These women often either don’t work, or work part time in low skilled jobs.

The quality of men (millennials and younger) is very low. I know this sounds a bit sexist but it’s true. They see themselves as too young to settle down until at least 35 and more like 40, expect their girlfriends to watch 10 years for engagement and mess them around no end. A generalisation of course but it is noticeable.

Goldenbear · 13/10/2026 08:34

Piglet89 · 13/10/2026 08:31

@GoldenbearI agree that some people do have much more fun as parents than they anticipated. It is hard to predict how it’ll go as so much depends on factors beyond one’s control. But it’s safe to say if you like order and quiet and being in control, you’re probably not going to enjoy being a parent (certainly of younger children).

😂, yes, very true!