Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To find all these "why aren't people having children any more" arrives absurd

326 replies

CurdinHenry · 10/10/2026 17:59

It's not really a mystery is it

The real intrigue is why people still do

It's not a logical choice, it's something else that's very hard to describe

OP posts:
CordeliaNaismithVorkosigan · 13/10/2026 08:46

Of my close female friends, four are child free (three by choice, one because she didn't meet a suitable partner during her fertile years and didn't want to go it alone). The rest of us, including me, have one child. I do also have some friends with two, but I don't know anyone well who has more.

Interestingly almost all my team at work have two children. But I think that's partly self-selecting: we're a good, flexible employer so we attract people who have or want children.

I didn't want children in the abstract at all, but DH did. I had to choose between having a child and being married to someone who was fundamentally disappointed - what I wanted, a contentedly child free marriage, wasn't available. Happily for all of us, particularly DD, it worked out well: she's 16 now and we're very close. I don't think I would necessarily advise other women to choose the road I took: it depended so much on DH stepping up and being able and willing to be the primary parent.

Goldenbear · 13/10/2026 08:46

ExtraHotDoubleShot · 13/10/2026 08:32

The quality of men (millennials and younger) is very low. I know this sounds a bit sexist but it’s true. They see themselves as too young to settle down until at least 35 and more like 40, expect their girlfriends to watch 10 years for engagement and mess them around no end. A generalisation of course but it is noticeable.

I think that change in attitudes from men, women as well though is really noticeable. The whole approach to commitment is noticeable with 'dating stage' talk, in the 00s I don't recall any man I knew talking like that and asking you to be their girlfriend, after a certain time it was a given really. Things have improved in some ways because that jealousy aspect of men seems to have lessened with this change in outlook on commitment but in terms of having children I can see how prohibitive it is.

ExtraHotDoubleShot · 13/10/2026 09:19

Goldenbear · 13/10/2026 08:46

I think that change in attitudes from men, women as well though is really noticeable. The whole approach to commitment is noticeable with 'dating stage' talk, in the 00s I don't recall any man I knew talking like that and asking you to be their girlfriend, after a certain time it was a given really. Things have improved in some ways because that jealousy aspect of men seems to have lessened with this change in outlook on commitment but in terms of having children I can see how prohibitive it is.

Yes it feels like men used to really want marriage and children (if only because it was expected), now if you bring up the topic they make you feel stalkerish and desperate even if you’ve been dating for a few years.

ExtraHotDoubleShot · 13/10/2026 09:26

Millerner · 13/10/2026 07:30

My young professional friends, mid 30s just have things they’d rather do with their lives than have children. They’re into gravel biking, hiking, having adventures, craft, art. They can’t be bothered to save to be able to afford to buy a nice period property in a middle class area with good schools.

This is bizarre. Why would you need a period property to have kids? It would be nightmare, they’re very unsuited to kids on the whole.

Agapornis · 13/10/2026 09:35

AlonsoMosley · 11/10/2026 17:34

I completely agree with you here @DiNozzoComingBack and have thought that for a while.

I actually think there is some subtle, sinister politics behind this focus. It always dwells on women, how we have choice now etc. It always seems to thinly disguise a "too much choice perhaps...?"

We never see analysis of men, their share of the "blame" in the drop off, how they behave when it goes wrong etc.

Yes agree it's sinister. I'm surprised no one has brought up rightwing pro-natalism, and their weird tradwife held in captivity as their ideal. It's all about men having as many children as possible (with multiple women), and producing good little workers for their shit factories. It's not far off eugenicism.

The women with children I know (all age 35-45) are nearly all divorced, and none of the dads are good, present, financially fully contributing dads. If you can't rely on their fathers or wider society to raise the children, what is the incentive to have them? Breeding 'for the economy' is very sinister. We've all seen The Matrix or read Brave New World, right?

ExtraHotDoubleShot · 13/10/2026 09:42

Agapornis · 13/10/2026 09:35

Yes agree it's sinister. I'm surprised no one has brought up rightwing pro-natalism, and their weird tradwife held in captivity as their ideal. It's all about men having as many children as possible (with multiple women), and producing good little workers for their shit factories. It's not far off eugenicism.

The women with children I know (all age 35-45) are nearly all divorced, and none of the dads are good, present, financially fully contributing dads. If you can't rely on their fathers or wider society to raise the children, what is the incentive to have them? Breeding 'for the economy' is very sinister. We've all seen The Matrix or read Brave New World, right?

I agree. These are men who want to go back to the early 1900s, where all they have to do is ‘provide’ aka work 8 hours in a very comfortable job, only to be treated like a returning hero every day by a stressed out wife who has magically managed to homeschool 8 kids while keeping an immaculate home, cooking from scratch and looking amazing.

Tbh I think the fact women given the choice choose fewer kids shows in times gone by they didn’t really want 9 kids, their husband was a bit of a rapist who didn’t care about their health.

IzzyLeng · 13/10/2026 09:42

I have one dc (now an adult), I'd have liked more but couldn't afford it. And between us I think me and dh had quite good incomes. We could have stretched ourselves and had a 2nd but we'd have needed a bigger house or an extension and it seemed to much to do.

I was talking to someone the other day who said her nursery bill was £900 a month for 3 days a week!!!!!!

Is that normal? I was paying about £25 a day over 20 years ago and thought that was expensive.

I'm not surprised people don't have more kids, the cost of food, heating, etc has gone up so much.

CraftySeal · 13/10/2026 09:58

MeetMeOnTheCorner · 13/10/2026 07:44

@CraftySeal I know several men who refused to consider dc. One said he didn’t wanted to be as unhappy as he was! A sort of joke but it wasn’t. Wife earned more and he hated his job. However he wouldn’t give it up and look after a dc. So no dc. Other men we know just didn’t like dc and absolutely refused to entertain a change of lifestyle. That’s been the key regarding most of our childless friends. Somewhat self absorbed and not prepared to change to accommodate anyone else (a baby). As we get older, they are definitely more self centred than people with dc!

Well as a childless by choice person myself I have to ask: do you think these more self centred / self absorbed people would have been improved by having children ie become more selfless and found happiness in their children? Or do you think it's a good job they didn't have children because they weren't cut out for it and might have been not-great parents?

MrsShawnHatosy · 13/10/2026 10:04

Schools teach how not to get pregnant - they don't teach infertility.

Just wondering how do you think they should teach infertility? That having children is essential for a happy and fulfilled life? That you should always insist on a prospective long term partner having a fertility test before committing? That having children with a shit partner is preferable to risking ending up childless?

ExtraHotDoubleShot · 13/10/2026 10:05

MrsShawnHatosy · 13/10/2026 10:04

Schools teach how not to get pregnant - they don't teach infertility.

Just wondering how do you think they should teach infertility? That having children is essential for a happy and fulfilled life? That you should always insist on a prospective long term partner having a fertility test before committing? That having children with a shit partner is preferable to risking ending up childless?

No, probably more like ‘extremely painful periods aren’t normal and could be adanomyosis or similar, which can then affect fertility later on’

MrsShawnHatosy · 13/10/2026 10:08

CraftySeal · 13/10/2026 09:58

Well as a childless by choice person myself I have to ask: do you think these more self centred / self absorbed people would have been improved by having children ie become more selfless and found happiness in their children? Or do you think it's a good job they didn't have children because they weren't cut out for it and might have been not-great parents?

i have friends - well more like acquaintances now - whose interest in the wider world does not extend beyond their children and grandchildren. They are incredibly boring to be around.

DorsetKnobBiscuit · 13/10/2026 10:19

Goldenbear · 13/10/2026 08:12

I don't see how you can possibly know that pre-children. I think it's more about those that are risk averse choose not to.

Or those who really have a good think about what it means for their life choose not to.

In my experience people who choose to remain child free spend more time thinking about the decision than people who do have children. There's an awful lot of 'oops I fell pregnant' or 'I want a little baby' going on.

DorsetKnobBiscuit · 13/10/2026 10:22

Goldenbear · 13/10/2026 08:01

What, this is massively overstating and fact averse. Every woman I know who has children has two or more, all highly educated, Masters level, 90% in professions that earn well, the other percentage doesn't need to earn well due to inheritance or husband's work.

But the truth is that the more highly educated a woman is the less likely she is to have children, and if she does she will have fewer children.

Notagayne · 13/10/2026 10:22

MrsShawnHatosy · 13/10/2026 10:08

i have friends - well more like acquaintances now - whose interest in the wider world does not extend beyond their children and grandchildren. They are incredibly boring to be around.

Quite! I find a few friends with kids extremely self-absorbed. And the worse thing is these same ones expect me to attend every kids party and baby shower bearing presents, but can’t even remember to text me on my birthday for example or come visit me or send a card when I’m unwell.

Many of the people I know who are more involved with keeping up with friends, caring for elder relatives and volunteering and political activism are childfree people who obviously typically have more time and energy to pour into that . But then there are parents who do a lot to for others outside their family.

I think really you get all sorts who are selfish, some don’t have kids some do. Simple.

IME what happens when selfish women have kids is they just extend their circle of interest to include their “little family” which they see as an extension of themselves and indeed use motherhood to justify being more selfish towards everyone outside their immediate family.

As for the selfish men who become fathers nothing changes at all not even towards their family lol

But then I have some friends with kids who are so caring and generous and don’t always expect me to travel to them, who do check up on me, who don’t feel entitled for me to spend loads on presents for their kids or assume I have loads of disposable income just because I don’t have kids! And interestingly in either case it’s reflected in how their children are. The selfish friends who became parents - their kids ended up a lot more brattier to the extent I took a step back from all of them. The more considerate parent friends kids are typical a delight.

iamnotalemon · 13/10/2026 10:24

DorsetKnobBiscuit · 13/10/2026 10:19

Or those who really have a good think about what it means for their life choose not to.

In my experience people who choose to remain child free spend more time thinking about the decision than people who do have children. There's an awful lot of 'oops I fell pregnant' or 'I want a little baby' going on.

Agree with you. Having worked in children’s services, more people should give it a proper thought before having them to be honest.

Instead of being concerned with people choosing not to have children, focus should be directed elsewhere.

DorsetKnobBiscuit · 13/10/2026 10:33

"I look at my child free friends and their lives appear to be either a joyless self obsession, ongoing existential crisis, sadness that it didnt work out, or a mix. "

I'm child free by choice and in my sixties. About half of my friends are mothers and now grandmothers and half are not.

My childfree friends are generally speaking punching the air with joy. They have given a lot of years to caring for elderly parents and are now finding themselves free of that responsibility. They have made firm, female friendships and some are in long, happy relationships. They all know exactly who they are and are comfortable in their own skin. We have lifelong hobbies, causes we fight/work for, full lives, have had the time to keep fit, careers pretty much behind us now we are all retiring early with savings and pensions sorted.

My friends who are mothers are generally still supporting adult children and now providing considerable amounts of care for grandchildren. The need to provide financial support/inheritance is keeping them at work. The rest are facing the empty nest, looking at a husband/partner and wondering if they'll make it now it's just the two of them. They're wondering what will fill their days as they've not had time to develop their own hobbies, interests and passions.

None of my childfree friends tell me they regret their decision. About half of those who are mothers tell me that if they knew what they know now (especially about the responsibilities of grandchildren) they would have thought twice.

Are we all equally happy? Yes, I reckon. In our own way.

Millerner · 13/10/2026 10:41

ExtraHotDoubleShot · 13/10/2026 09:26

This is bizarre. Why would you need a period property to have kids? It would be nightmare, they’re very unsuited to kids on the whole.

It’s just what they were brought up in and think is normal. If you want kids these days it’s hard to afford the lifestyle that you were brought up in. Some are prepared to downgrade their lifestyle others aren’t.

DorsetKnobBiscuit · 13/10/2026 10:45

ExtraHotDoubleShot · 13/10/2026 09:26

This is bizarre. Why would you need a period property to have kids? It would be nightmare, they’re very unsuited to kids on the whole.

And yet people have been raising children in those properties for generations and still do quite safely and happily.

MrsShawnHatosy · 13/10/2026 10:49

My childfree friends are generally speaking punching the air with joy. They have given a lot of years to caring for elderly parents and are now finding themselves free of that responsibility. They have made firm, female friendships and some are in long, happy relationships. They all know exactly who they are and are comfortable in their own skin. We have lifelong hobbies, causes we fight/work for, full lives, have had the time to keep fit, careers pretty much behind us now we are all retiring early with savings and pensions sorted.

This is pretty much me. I’m childless through infertility but at 65 am very content and have no regrets about how things turned out.

Goldenbear · 13/10/2026 11:33

MrsShawnHatosy · 13/10/2026 10:08

i have friends - well more like acquaintances now - whose interest in the wider world does not extend beyond their children and grandchildren. They are incredibly boring to be around.

How unfortunate for you.

JHound · 13/10/2026 11:40

MeetMeOnTheCorner · 13/10/2026 07:44

@CraftySeal I know several men who refused to consider dc. One said he didn’t wanted to be as unhappy as he was! A sort of joke but it wasn’t. Wife earned more and he hated his job. However he wouldn’t give it up and look after a dc. So no dc. Other men we know just didn’t like dc and absolutely refused to entertain a change of lifestyle. That’s been the key regarding most of our childless friends. Somewhat self absorbed and not prepared to change to accommodate anyone else (a baby). As we get older, they are definitely more self centred than people with dc!

I have never noticed any big difference in the levels of being self-absorbed / selfish between those with and without children. Except those with children think that because they may prioritise their children they automatically cannot ever be behaving in a selfish manner to the wider public.

Goldenbear · 13/10/2026 11:43

DorsetKnobBiscuit · 13/10/2026 10:33

"I look at my child free friends and their lives appear to be either a joyless self obsession, ongoing existential crisis, sadness that it didnt work out, or a mix. "

I'm child free by choice and in my sixties. About half of my friends are mothers and now grandmothers and half are not.

My childfree friends are generally speaking punching the air with joy. They have given a lot of years to caring for elderly parents and are now finding themselves free of that responsibility. They have made firm, female friendships and some are in long, happy relationships. They all know exactly who they are and are comfortable in their own skin. We have lifelong hobbies, causes we fight/work for, full lives, have had the time to keep fit, careers pretty much behind us now we are all retiring early with savings and pensions sorted.

My friends who are mothers are generally still supporting adult children and now providing considerable amounts of care for grandchildren. The need to provide financial support/inheritance is keeping them at work. The rest are facing the empty nest, looking at a husband/partner and wondering if they'll make it now it's just the two of them. They're wondering what will fill their days as they've not had time to develop their own hobbies, interests and passions.

None of my childfree friends tell me they regret their decision. About half of those who are mothers tell me that if they knew what they know now (especially about the responsibilities of grandchildren) they would have thought twice.

Are we all equally happy? Yes, I reckon. In our own way.

You and your friends with children don't sound, 'equally happy', your friends with children seem to really be overcome with lassitude as a result of one poor decision when they decided to reproduce!

Goldenbear · 13/10/2026 11:44

JHound · 13/10/2026 11:40

I have never noticed any big difference in the levels of being self-absorbed / selfish between those with and without children. Except those with children think that because they may prioritise their children they automatically cannot ever be behaving in a selfish manner to the wider public.

Again, how insulting.

MeetMeOnTheCorner · 13/10/2026 12:02

@JHound The big difference is that childless couples, in our orbit anyway, definitely want everything their own way. They are poor at compromise. Those who have had dc definitely see the bigger picture and and are willing to compromise far more. When you have dc, life becomes a compromise - it’s inevitable. You do prioritise dc over yourself.

Many with dc look after parents too and work. It’s certainly a tougher decision to have dc and they cost money. Parental money has to go further. I’m sure people in their 60s feel free if parents have died or they are in a care home. They don’t have grandchildren either and I do see the joy lots of grandparents get from their grandchildren. However those without anyone might find they are very alone in the future and might be glad the rest of us had dc when they need looking after.

CraftySeal · 13/10/2026 12:31

MeetMeOnTheCorner · 13/10/2026 12:02

@JHound The big difference is that childless couples, in our orbit anyway, definitely want everything their own way. They are poor at compromise. Those who have had dc definitely see the bigger picture and and are willing to compromise far more. When you have dc, life becomes a compromise - it’s inevitable. You do prioritise dc over yourself.

Many with dc look after parents too and work. It’s certainly a tougher decision to have dc and they cost money. Parental money has to go further. I’m sure people in their 60s feel free if parents have died or they are in a care home. They don’t have grandchildren either and I do see the joy lots of grandparents get from their grandchildren. However those without anyone might find they are very alone in the future and might be glad the rest of us had dc when they need looking after.

I think it's a bit sad to make such generalisations and statements, though I know you say it's your particular experience. It's not a competition of who has a better life or is a better person or, surely some people are better off child-free and others are better off as parents, in terms of happiness and being their best selves?