Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To find all these "why aren't people having children any more" arrives absurd

326 replies

CurdinHenry · 10/10/2026 17:59

It's not really a mystery is it

The real intrigue is why people still do

It's not a logical choice, it's something else that's very hard to describe

OP posts:
CraftySeal · 13/10/2026 15:02

ExtraHotDoubleShot · 13/10/2026 14:13

I didn’t say there was? You’re confusing all sorts here.

I think because you said “people who choose to devote their lives to caring for others are more likely to be selfless”, like the key is in the choosing. Whereas I don’t think the choice to have children or not is really based on any inherent selflessness, but largely on what you think will ensure your own happiness. I don’t think people choose to have children because they seek an outlet for selflessness, more that they want to experience the overwhelming love, they want a family life, they feel a biological urge, they want the fulfilment of holding their baby in their arms. Surely the part where you give up your sleep, your money, your me-time, and you accept the worry, the stress, the responsibility, is more the price you pay, rather than a motivation for having children?

I also don’t think that most childless people choose not to have children because they aren’t selfless enough to bear the idea of paying that price (the sleepless nights, the worry, the financial outlay etc). I think it’s more because they don’t feel the want strongly enough in the first place - the biological urge, the overwhelming desire to hold their baby in their arms, the desire for a family life. Certainly myself I never felt those things. Being worried about the stress and the responsibility of parenting was certainly a factor, but I honestly think if I’d felt the urge or a strong desire to have the experience of having children, I’d have just put those things aside and gone with it. That's not even getting into all the childless people who would have chosen to have children if they could.

Openmouthinsertfood · 13/10/2026 15:13

ExtraHotDoubleShot · 13/10/2026 14:20

So we all stop having kids. Who looks after you in your old age?

So this 'unselfish' value in bringing up children is in fact just so you can be looked after in old age?

DorsetKnobBiscuit · 13/10/2026 15:14

MeetMeOnTheCorner · 13/10/2026 12:02

@JHound The big difference is that childless couples, in our orbit anyway, definitely want everything their own way. They are poor at compromise. Those who have had dc definitely see the bigger picture and and are willing to compromise far more. When you have dc, life becomes a compromise - it’s inevitable. You do prioritise dc over yourself.

Many with dc look after parents too and work. It’s certainly a tougher decision to have dc and they cost money. Parental money has to go further. I’m sure people in their 60s feel free if parents have died or they are in a care home. They don’t have grandchildren either and I do see the joy lots of grandparents get from their grandchildren. However those without anyone might find they are very alone in the future and might be glad the rest of us had dc when they need looking after.

Many child free people, myself included spend/spent years caring for ailing, elderly parents.

My friends without children are generally as willing to compromise as those with children.

"those without anyone might find they are very alone in the future and might be glad the rest of us had dc when they need looking after."
Counting on your children to look after you when you are older is a risky business. You children move away, be too busy or just not willing to give up the time it takes to care for elderly relations.

The child free people I know are far from lonely as they have spent a lifetime building strong friendships, are in various friendship groups through work, hobbies, volunteering.

DorsetKnobBiscuit · 13/10/2026 15:19

ExtraHotDoubleShot · 13/10/2026 12:34

Of course there are individual exceptions but broadly speaking of course having children makes you more selfless. Because living your entire life based around somebody else’s needs, rather than your own, will have that effect. In the same way I assume caring for a disabled person has the same effect. Living your life with yourself as number 1 priority of course will not have that result. I don’t know why this is controversial.

This isn't controversial it's a hackneyed, unproved assumption.

Not having children doesn't mean you have nobody else to care for. Few people live in isolation without a partner, dear friends, aging parents.

I'm child free by choice and my DH, parents, disabled brother and lifelong friends are right up there in my list of priorities. I'd say the same or similar is true for all my child free friends, many of whom work in social care/the caring professions.

Goldenbear · 13/10/2026 15:28

Openmouthinsertfood · 13/10/2026 15:13

So this 'unselfish' value in bringing up children is in fact just so you can be looked after in old age?

I thought they were discussing the next generation rather than specifically their own children

DorsetKnobBiscuit · 13/10/2026 15:29

Goldenbear · 13/10/2026 14:01

No it's not, evident from this thread you certainly have a widened empathy and don't see them as irritants. Equally, you have an additional moral drive to do the right thing for a world that they are going to be in a lot longer than you.

I disagree with this strongly.
I run a local environmental charity based around litter prevention, litter picking, encouraging recycling and wildllife protection.

We have huge amounts of interest from child free people who care deeply about the world for its own sake and for the people who will come after them.

In my experience MANY people with children are very likely to litter, not recycle and not give a shiny shit about the environment. You would think it was VERY important to them - but that's not universal.

Openmouthinsertfood · 13/10/2026 15:49

Goldenbear · 13/10/2026 15:28

I thought they were discussing the next generation rather than specifically their own children

and where would the next generation be coming from?!

Goldenbear · 13/10/2026 15:57

DorsetKnobBiscuit · 13/10/2026 15:29

I disagree with this strongly.
I run a local environmental charity based around litter prevention, litter picking, encouraging recycling and wildllife protection.

We have huge amounts of interest from child free people who care deeply about the world for its own sake and for the people who will come after them.

In my experience MANY people with children are very likely to litter, not recycle and not give a shiny shit about the environment. You would think it was VERY important to them - but that's not universal.

Course you do and of course your anecdata is true. Do you mean you run a litter picking group that oddly in the day most retired people are members of. Many parents simply don't have time as they are doing the business of parenting, working and recycle anyway or go to the rubbish dump at he weekend to recycle stuff. I don't know anyone with children that litters or anyone that is not interested in Environmental issues, it must be area specific or simply fiction, I'm rather inclined to believe the latter.

Goldenbear · 13/10/2026 15:58

Openmouthinsertfood · 13/10/2026 15:49

and where would the next generation be coming from?!

What?

bababamama · 13/10/2026 16:02

Plenty of people are having children, what the article should be saying is why are educated affluent young people having children, and it’s not as simple as cost of living, it’s about people of that age group putting their wants above the sacrifices it takes, and has always taken to raise children, often substituting the children for pets. Outside of metropolitan elite circles plenty of children are being conceived, and plenty of people are going to extraordinary levels to have them (eg surrogacy, ivf). I actually think selfishness is at the route

SillyBoyChuckie · 13/10/2026 16:05

In my experience the same people who criticise women for not having children, criticise women after they have children, the same old double bind. It is just so much easier for them to judge and criticise at every opportunity than connect and show some understanding of others.

If they spent half the time on growing and developing as people that they did criticising and judging, humanity would be booming.

florasl · 13/10/2026 16:05

I’m in my early 30s with 3 children but lots of my colleagues around the same age aren’t interested in having children. They cite not wanting their lives to change or aren’t 100% and don’t want to have a child unless they are 100%.

Personally, the cost of having 3 children is huge and I can see puts people off having more than one child. We have a six figure household income but nursery fees are absolutely massive, our mortgage is big despite having a three bed semi and is only going to increase when we need to move to a four bed in the next year or two. All our choice, but you need to be reasonable earners to fund multiple children!

The governments response to the maternity pay petition makes it clear that nothing is going to change to support people in making children more affordable too so more people are just going to chose one child, if at all.

DorsetKnobBiscuit · 13/10/2026 16:09

Goldenbear · 13/10/2026 15:57

Course you do and of course your anecdata is true. Do you mean you run a litter picking group that oddly in the day most retired people are members of. Many parents simply don't have time as they are doing the business of parenting, working and recycle anyway or go to the rubbish dump at he weekend to recycle stuff. I don't know anyone with children that litters or anyone that is not interested in Environmental issues, it must be area specific or simply fiction, I'm rather inclined to believe the latter.

Not a daytime pensioners group. It's a town wide, well supported group called Turn the Tide that operates on many levels - going into schools to do talks, working with the local DofE groups including scouts, youth centre, schools. Monthly litter picks at weekends, an annual week of environmental projects including town wide litter pick, campaigning our local MP and national organisations like the Environment Agency and planning organisations.

We don't have a rubbish dump here. We have a recycling centre.

DorsetKnobBiscuit · 13/10/2026 16:15

Goldenbear · 13/10/2026 15:57

Course you do and of course your anecdata is true. Do you mean you run a litter picking group that oddly in the day most retired people are members of. Many parents simply don't have time as they are doing the business of parenting, working and recycle anyway or go to the rubbish dump at he weekend to recycle stuff. I don't know anyone with children that litters or anyone that is not interested in Environmental issues, it must be area specific or simply fiction, I'm rather inclined to believe the latter.

I don't know anyone with children that litters or anyone that is not interested in Environmental issues,

That's anecdata and not borne out by any of the research our group has done here or research generally. Loads of data show that convenience trumps environmental concerns when it comes to those with children.

Goldenbear · 13/10/2026 16:16

DorsetKnobBiscuit · 13/10/2026 16:09

Not a daytime pensioners group. It's a town wide, well supported group called Turn the Tide that operates on many levels - going into schools to do talks, working with the local DofE groups including scouts, youth centre, schools. Monthly litter picks at weekends, an annual week of environmental projects including town wide litter pick, campaigning our local MP and national organisations like the Environment Agency and planning organisations.

We don't have a rubbish dump here. We have a recycling centre.

So you feel this disdain and make huge uncomplentary assumptions about children yet your charity appears to work with them frequently.

Obviously, the 'dump' is the same thing as the recycling centres. I'm curious as to how recycling even at home or going to the council dump is something worthy of a pat on the back- we all do it!

DorsetKnobBiscuit · 13/10/2026 16:19

Goldenbear · 13/10/2026 16:16

So you feel this disdain and make huge uncomplentary assumptions about children yet your charity appears to work with them frequently.

Obviously, the 'dump' is the same thing as the recycling centres. I'm curious as to how recycling even at home or going to the council dump is something worthy of a pat on the back- we all do it!

Where have I expressed disdain about children?

Openmouthinsertfood · 13/10/2026 16:19

Goldenbear · 13/10/2026 15:58

What?

Ok, so a PP infered we should have children to look after us in old age. I thought this sounded selfish but apparently it's the childless who are selfish and the one's with children selfless because they care so much, when in fact it's not that, it's that they want someone to look after them in old age.

SodaPopBop · 13/10/2026 16:24

DebbieSavage · 13/10/2026 14:19

There is no need for anybody in this country to have children, immigration is keeping the population stable. In this day and age it purely comes down to selfishness.

Thanks, but no thanks. You do you though. Ridiculous take.

Goldenbear · 13/10/2026 16:25

DorsetKnobBiscuit · 13/10/2026 16:19

Where have I expressed disdain about children?

Well your last post was pretty scathig about parents of said children, so let me get this straight you think it is mostly parents in this world that litter, not their children, parents and that is categorically true across the country and the world, parents are more selfish, parents litter more than any other group, parents aren't interested in the environment etc. Etc. it's such an absurd and far-fetched goady statement. Parents are just human beings like you.

Goldenbear · 13/10/2026 16:27

Openmouthinsertfood · 13/10/2026 16:19

Ok, so a PP infered we should have children to look after us in old age. I thought this sounded selfish but apparently it's the childless who are selfish and the one's with children selfless because they care so much, when in fact it's not that, it's that they want someone to look after them in old age.

It was my understanding that this is meant at a societal level, where are the tax payers coming from, who is going to run the infrastructure, who is going to treat you, looks after you, ensure your house is heated. Ensure your pension is paid!

SodaPopBop · 13/10/2026 16:28

bababamama · 13/10/2026 16:02

Plenty of people are having children, what the article should be saying is why are educated affluent young people having children, and it’s not as simple as cost of living, it’s about people of that age group putting their wants above the sacrifices it takes, and has always taken to raise children, often substituting the children for pets. Outside of metropolitan elite circles plenty of children are being conceived, and plenty of people are going to extraordinary levels to have them (eg surrogacy, ivf). I actually think selfishness is at the route

I think lots of people are delaying and having fewer rather than committing to being Childfree forever (imo).

AlonsoMosley · 13/10/2026 16:28

JHound · 13/10/2026 11:40

I have never noticed any big difference in the levels of being self-absorbed / selfish between those with and without children. Except those with children think that because they may prioritise their children they automatically cannot ever be behaving in a selfish manner to the wider public.

I think @JHound that different things happen.

All of us operate in a state of constant compromise. We have to, to live. Clearly other people, but also nature - weather for example will define a lot.

The majority of adults (not all, clearly) live a life of compromise and cooperation. As grown, rational beings, we have literally or philosophically accepted the art of and the need for compromise.

Children have to learn that skill. The adults "working" with children (parents by and large) are preparing them to enter into that world. For them that means a life that is in a constant state of negotiation, but with non rational entities. The parents have massive levels of compromise to make in order to prepare the young to participate in society.

Both can be selfish - but the parents have to pay it forward. The non parents get a quicker return!

DorsetKnobBiscuit · 13/10/2026 16:33

Goldenbear · 13/10/2026 16:25

Well your last post was pretty scathig about parents of said children, so let me get this straight you think it is mostly parents in this world that litter, not their children, parents and that is categorically true across the country and the world, parents are more selfish, parents litter more than any other group, parents aren't interested in the environment etc. Etc. it's such an absurd and far-fetched goady statement. Parents are just human beings like you.

So when you said "You feel this disdain and make huge uncomplentary assumptions about children" You didn't mean that at all.

Also no distain about parents from me either.

I said "many people with children are very likely to litter.

I didn't say 'it is mostly parents in this world that litter'.

Neither have I said -
"it is mostly parents in this world that litter"
"not their children"
"and that is categorically true across the country and the world"
"parents are more selfish"
"parents litter more than any other group"
"parents aren't interested in the environment "

All that is your imagination.

dreamiesformolly · 13/10/2026 16:37

MeetMeOnTheCorner · 13/10/2026 12:02

@JHound The big difference is that childless couples, in our orbit anyway, definitely want everything their own way. They are poor at compromise. Those who have had dc definitely see the bigger picture and and are willing to compromise far more. When you have dc, life becomes a compromise - it’s inevitable. You do prioritise dc over yourself.

Many with dc look after parents too and work. It’s certainly a tougher decision to have dc and they cost money. Parental money has to go further. I’m sure people in their 60s feel free if parents have died or they are in a care home. They don’t have grandchildren either and I do see the joy lots of grandparents get from their grandchildren. However those without anyone might find they are very alone in the future and might be glad the rest of us had dc when they need looking after.

What a superior and self-congratulatory post. Containing far too many inaccurate sweeping generalisations.