Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To find all these "why aren't people having children any more" arrives absurd

326 replies

CurdinHenry · 10/10/2026 17:59

It's not really a mystery is it

The real intrigue is why people still do

It's not a logical choice, it's something else that's very hard to describe

OP posts:
ExtraHotDoubleShot · 13/10/2026 14:13

CraftySeal · 13/10/2026 14:11

What really is the moral value in creating a new being in order to then devote your life to caring for it and putting it above yourself? Ethically, I don't really get it, if you want to devote yourself to caring for someone it would be morally better to care for a being that already exists and is in need of care.

It just takes me back to the conviction that people have children mostly because they think they'll be happier for having them. And other people don't have children mostly because they think they'll be happier for not having them. And both of those things are fine but there isn't any kind of inherent moral superiority in one or the other.

Edited

I didn’t say there was? You’re confusing all sorts here.

Goldenbear · 13/10/2026 14:13

Homealonelez · 13/10/2026 14:06

My daughter doesn’t want children and never has which I’m fine with I just don’t get why women are expected to have children it’s the individual’s choice she works with children and is good with them just doesn’t want her own.

Who said they do. The problem comes in with posts on a site named, Mumsnet, non the less that deride and patronise those that have.

Notagayne · 13/10/2026 14:15

Homealonelez · 13/10/2026 14:06

My daughter doesn’t want children and never has which I’m fine with I just don’t get why women are expected to have children it’s the individual’s choice she works with children and is good with them just doesn’t want her own.

Now people Like your daughter who work with children (and enjoy it and are good to the kids) now they are more what I consider altruistic.

It’s natural to feel intense love and a sense of protection for your own bio kids and as a result you get why parents run around after kids. It’s their lineage on show. Kids also give soooo much love to their parents so it’s very rewarding in that sense. Yes I know they can be challenging but as parents you likely also get a lot of hugs and kisses and I love yous!

Teachers OTOH often go the extra mile and care so much for these kids that are unrelated to them. They don’t get paid that much and often spend their own salary decorating classrooms or getting supplies.

I remember my teacher friend stepping out to sacrifice herself when there was a report of a gunned masked man on the premises.

It’s one thing to put yourself in the firing line for your own flesh and blood and another thing to do it for other peoples kids.

Goldenbear · 13/10/2026 14:15

MrsShawnHatosy · 13/10/2026 14:12

And you ignore every view on Mumsnet that doesn’t tally with yours?

I think you are being naive, the fact is Mumsnet was not so polarised and was in fact a place parents frequented more than those dissing them.

ExtraHotDoubleShot · 13/10/2026 14:16

Notagayne · 13/10/2026 14:15

Now people Like your daughter who work with children (and enjoy it and are good to the kids) now they are more what I consider altruistic.

It’s natural to feel intense love and a sense of protection for your own bio kids and as a result you get why parents run around after kids. It’s their lineage on show. Kids also give soooo much love to their parents so it’s very rewarding in that sense. Yes I know they can be challenging but as parents you likely also get a lot of hugs and kisses and I love yous!

Teachers OTOH often go the extra mile and care so much for these kids that are unrelated to them. They don’t get paid that much and often spend their own salary decorating classrooms or getting supplies.

I remember my teacher friend stepping out to sacrifice herself when there was a report of a gunned masked man on the premises.

It’s one thing to put yourself in the firing line for your own flesh and blood and another thing to do it for other peoples kids.

They’re being paid to do it

Goldenbear · 13/10/2026 14:18

Notagayne · 13/10/2026 14:15

Now people Like your daughter who work with children (and enjoy it and are good to the kids) now they are more what I consider altruistic.

It’s natural to feel intense love and a sense of protection for your own bio kids and as a result you get why parents run around after kids. It’s their lineage on show. Kids also give soooo much love to their parents so it’s very rewarding in that sense. Yes I know they can be challenging but as parents you likely also get a lot of hugs and kisses and I love yous!

Teachers OTOH often go the extra mile and care so much for these kids that are unrelated to them. They don’t get paid that much and often spend their own salary decorating classrooms or getting supplies.

I remember my teacher friend stepping out to sacrifice herself when there was a report of a gunned masked man on the premises.

It’s one thing to put yourself in the firing line for your own flesh and blood and another thing to do it for other peoples kids.

The average pay for a classroom teacher is nearly £46000-not bad really. Respectfully how would you possibly know whether it widens your empathy if you don't have children?

Notagayne · 13/10/2026 14:18

Goldenbear · 13/10/2026 14:09

With the perception of childfree of them being a burden, or a symbol of something they don't value, arguably that sentiment is much more damaging to how they are treated in society.

No. The real danger to kids is usually parents or other adults who in most cases will have their own kids. That is statically fact, someone didn’t go abuse their daughter or stepson because someone else on Instagram is posting about being childfree 🙄 a father didn’t walk out on their child because society told them a kid was a burden. They either love and care for their kids or they don’t. This is on them.

And before being “ childfree” (as opposed to being childless) was a thing abuse and abandonment was endemic in society and still is sadly.

DebbieSavage · 13/10/2026 14:19

There is no need for anybody in this country to have children, immigration is keeping the population stable. In this day and age it purely comes down to selfishness.

MrsShawnHatosy · 13/10/2026 14:19

Goldenbear · 13/10/2026 14:15

I think you are being naive, the fact is Mumsnet was not so polarised and was in fact a place parents frequented more than those dissing them.

It is MNHQ policy to welcome those without children here. If you have an issue with that, why not start a thread in AIBU with a poll, and depending on the response,take it up with them?

ExtraHotDoubleShot · 13/10/2026 14:20

DebbieSavage · 13/10/2026 14:19

There is no need for anybody in this country to have children, immigration is keeping the population stable. In this day and age it purely comes down to selfishness.

So we all stop having kids. Who looks after you in your old age?

Goldenbear · 13/10/2026 14:20

Notagayne · 13/10/2026 14:15

Now people Like your daughter who work with children (and enjoy it and are good to the kids) now they are more what I consider altruistic.

It’s natural to feel intense love and a sense of protection for your own bio kids and as a result you get why parents run around after kids. It’s their lineage on show. Kids also give soooo much love to their parents so it’s very rewarding in that sense. Yes I know they can be challenging but as parents you likely also get a lot of hugs and kisses and I love yous!

Teachers OTOH often go the extra mile and care so much for these kids that are unrelated to them. They don’t get paid that much and often spend their own salary decorating classrooms or getting supplies.

I remember my teacher friend stepping out to sacrifice herself when there was a report of a gunned masked man on the premises.

It’s one thing to put yourself in the firing line for your own flesh and blood and another thing to do it for other peoples kids.

Equally, so many parents 'are' teachers, what is it with these basic binary arguments- can't be a parent and have a caring job, can't care for an elderly relative and be a parent! Such rubbish

Goldenbear · 13/10/2026 14:22

MrsShawnHatosy · 13/10/2026 14:19

It is MNHQ policy to welcome those without children here. If you have an issue with that, why not start a thread in AIBU with a poll, and depending on the response,take it up with them?

Why would I do that, you've wholly missed the point I was making. If you had picked up on the point you wouldn't have suggested setting up a vote on a forum where many of the posts are questionable these days!

Notagayne · 13/10/2026 14:23

Goldenbear · 13/10/2026 14:18

The average pay for a classroom teacher is nearly £46000-not bad really. Respectfully how would you possibly know whether it widens your empathy if you don't have children?

Teachers are absolutely underpaid and many pay for their own resources due to lack of budgets and work extra hours.

It’s not just teachers in schools too, it’s TAs and many of them put children first too and they are extremely underpaid and often are the first to have parents or children lash out at them.

And I have witnessed enough parents on actions to see it clearly doesn’t for many! Or if it has widened their empathy I’d be shocked to see what they were like before kids 🤣

The self absorbed ones tend to remain self absorbed but just extend their orbit to include their kids. And the considerate generous ones still stay considerate.

I have witnessed and heard of so many cases of neglect, abandonment and abuse from parents. These aren’t exceptional cases, these are common and it’s rife in society.

DebbieSavage · 13/10/2026 14:24

ExtraHotDoubleShot · 13/10/2026 14:20

So we all stop having kids. Who looks after you in your old age?

It will all be automated one day but until then I did say that immigration will be keeping the population stable. We do bring in a lot of incredibly skilled healthcare workers from countries that value hard work like Nigeria and they bolster the care sector so we don't really need to be producing any lazy consumerist sprogs of our own.

ExtraHotDoubleShot · 13/10/2026 14:27

DebbieSavage · 13/10/2026 14:24

It will all be automated one day but until then I did say that immigration will be keeping the population stable. We do bring in a lot of incredibly skilled healthcare workers from countries that value hard work like Nigeria and they bolster the care sector so we don't really need to be producing any lazy consumerist sprogs of our own.

So the immigrants should have kids to work NMW jobs but it’s below us? I don’t like the sound of that.

Notagayne · 13/10/2026 14:27

Goldenbear · 13/10/2026 14:20

Equally, so many parents 'are' teachers, what is it with these basic binary arguments- can't be a parent and have a caring job, can't care for an elderly relative and be a parent! Such rubbish

I didn’t say they weren’t?! Nobody is saying they can’t be both.

The point is some posters foolishly suggested that childfree people are intrinsically selfish and my point was no, that’s false and their presence in these caring professions is one of the many examples of that.

I clearly acknowledged that SOME parents are generous and considerate and will help others outwith their “little family” too.

But I completely reject the idea that parents tend to be more selfless and child free people tend to be more selfish. Nonsense!

ExtraHotDoubleShot · 13/10/2026 14:29

Notagayne · 13/10/2026 14:27

I didn’t say they weren’t?! Nobody is saying they can’t be both.

The point is some posters foolishly suggested that childfree people are intrinsically selfish and my point was no, that’s false and their presence in these caring professions is one of the many examples of that.

I clearly acknowledged that SOME parents are generous and considerate and will help others outwith their “little family” too.

But I completely reject the idea that parents tend to be more selfless and child free people tend to be more selfish. Nonsense!

Who said they are intrinsically selfish? Intrinsically means inherently. If it’s dependent on a choice then it isn’t inherent.

Notagayne · 13/10/2026 14:31

ExtraHotDoubleShot · 13/10/2026 14:29

Who said they are intrinsically selfish? Intrinsically means inherently. If it’s dependent on a choice then it isn’t inherent.

As I’ve said I completely reject the idea that parents tend to be more selfless and child free people tend to be more selfish.

You get many selfish and selfless and plain awful kind of people in both groups. This is my main point.

Goldenbear · 13/10/2026 14:33

Notagayne · 13/10/2026 14:18

No. The real danger to kids is usually parents or other adults who in most cases will have their own kids. That is statically fact, someone didn’t go abuse their daughter or stepson because someone else on Instagram is posting about being childfree 🙄 a father didn’t walk out on their child because society told them a kid was a burden. They either love and care for their kids or they don’t. This is on them.

And before being “ childfree” (as opposed to being childless) was a thing abuse and abandonment was endemic in society and still is sadly.

I think you have misunderstood my point. The manifestations of an individualistic society are very damaging to those who are vulnerable in society, the capacity to act compassionately is not going to be helped by the promotion of a culture that suggests they are a burden, that they should be unwelcome in public spaces, they are a nuance in a waste of money. Tbh to speak about any other group like that would be discriminatory and considered unhinged and rightly so!

Goldenbear · 13/10/2026 14:36

DebbieSavage · 13/10/2026 14:24

It will all be automated one day but until then I did say that immigration will be keeping the population stable. We do bring in a lot of incredibly skilled healthcare workers from countries that value hard work like Nigeria and they bolster the care sector so we don't really need to be producing any lazy consumerist sprogs of our own.

That's actually hilarious and outrageously optimistic.

Why would you post on a parenting forum seems an odd choice with that outlook

Dontlletmedownbruce · 13/10/2026 14:41

I think AIBU because it is not an obvious answer and often very complex. It's not just because it's hard work. Look at all the people training for marathons or similar, many people thrive on hard work. I think its because it shouldn't be this hard, financially or otherwise. Most of this could be remedied with social policy changes or economic changes. Those on the fence often choose not to but could go the other way, those who want parenthood often choose one or two only but might want more, if some changes were made. For instance:
-free school transport for all, a bus collects your kids from the end of your street every day. The school run as a concept no longer exists. Traffic is lighter for everyone, its a win win whether a parent or not.

  • Affordable housing for families, perhaps zoning of certain properties or capping sale amounts in conjunction with more provision. I don't know specifics, but let's say buying a house that fits a family of 5 is the same price as a family of 3. Some areas around schools are zoned to prioritise families.
- financial supplements. Where i live we get a universal children's benefit per child, rising proportionally with bonus amounts for multiples. I have a single and twins so I get paid for 4 children. This covers most school and activity related costs and massively cushions the jump from 1 to 2 or beyond.
  • Heavily funded childcare to the parents cost is manageable, then perhaps increasing proportionally so the 3rd child is less than the cost of the first etc, like a discount for multiples.
  • a supplements so certain healthy foods are free to families with children.
  • some sort of tax deduction for single salaries with multiple dependants so that having a partner at home minding kids isn't a straightforward loss of salary. A scheme lasting 3 years per child or similar so parents can choose if they want to use childcare or stay home.

All of these would sway those on the fence. If we actually wanted to increase the population...

Goldenbear · 13/10/2026 14:42

Notagayne · 13/10/2026 14:23

Teachers are absolutely underpaid and many pay for their own resources due to lack of budgets and work extra hours.

It’s not just teachers in schools too, it’s TAs and many of them put children first too and they are extremely underpaid and often are the first to have parents or children lash out at them.

And I have witnessed enough parents on actions to see it clearly doesn’t for many! Or if it has widened their empathy I’d be shocked to see what they were like before kids 🤣

The self absorbed ones tend to remain self absorbed but just extend their orbit to include their kids. And the considerate generous ones still stay considerate.

I have witnessed and heard of so many cases of neglect, abandonment and abuse from parents. These aren’t exceptional cases, these are common and it’s rife in society.

TAs again are likely to be parents due to the flexibility of the job.

Teachers aren't underpaid in comparison to jobs with similar educational requirements and experience. Many teachers have add on payments for being curriculum leads or they one of the burgeoning SLT in schools so more likely on £70000.

TAs are underpaid. Indeed inequalities of pay scales is probably the worst in any sector in under 16s education. Parents being abusive is certainly not the norm this is sensationalist nonsense!

Goldenbear · 13/10/2026 14:45

Notagayne · 13/10/2026 14:31

As I’ve said I completely reject the idea that parents tend to be more selfless and child free people tend to be more selfish.

You get many selfish and selfless and plain awful kind of people in both groups. This is my main point.

You state, "both groups" which I agree with but your posts very much suggest you believe it's only parents who are selfish.

MrsShawnHatosy · 13/10/2026 14:47

Goldenbear · 13/10/2026 14:45

You state, "both groups" which I agree with but your posts very much suggest you believe it's only parents who are selfish.

No they really don’t. Try reading the post she made at 14.27 and 14.23.

Goldenbear · 13/10/2026 14:49

MrsShawnHatosy · 13/10/2026 14:47

No they really don’t. Try reading the post she made at 14.27 and 14.23.

Edited

I have read all the posts, how do you think I arrived at that very clear conclusion