Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Colin is not a birthday cake

480 replies

BeMintFatball · 10/10/2026 11:52

Tomorrow our younger daughter is 24. I would love to have the energy to make her a cake but I’m running on fumes and have been for months.

I gave my husband one job. Go buy her a birthday cake. He sent me a photograph Colin. I said no, there is only one time a year she can have a cake with happy birthday written on it. Would you believe such a thing does not exist at our nearest M&S!

Her older sister has come to the rescue, she’s gone to Sainsbury’s.

YABU Colin is the gold standard shop bought cake

YANBU Colin is an any time of year cake

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Overnightoats1 · 11/10/2026 22:17

We had a tradition in our office that we had a Colin for every birthday and the birthday person HAD to eat the entire white chocolate face - was very funny and very sweet 😂.. Colin with candle is a brilliant birthday option !

Overnightoats1 · 11/10/2026 22:25

Forton26 · 11/10/2026 06:57

You would hate me i love celebrating everyone’s birthdays and i often drink out of a straw😂. Life is short celebrate the fun.

Not everyone gets to live to an old age and i’ve worked with many that don’t reach even adulthood so to me all birthdays are worth a celebration child or adult that we’ve reached another year.

I'm with you!! Life is for celebrating! I love making a fuss of all the young, old and not so old people in my life for their birthdays!! (And always celebrate mine)

booksoverscreens · 11/10/2026 22:27

They now do a gf Colin and I'd love this as a b'day cake!!!!!1

patq1967 · 12/10/2026 00:29

we had a surprise lunch for my daughter turning 20 have a large family Confused male here ,my daughter is turning 20 tomorrow and only 20 of us turned up , we had a Connie the cateterpilla cake with a 20 candle on it which she blew out with a big grin and then sliced the cake like she was 12

Neverstopwondering · 12/10/2026 00:37

If a party is big with lots of people we put two or three Colin's together. Just take the faces off all but one, then butt then up against each other on a board

PyongyangKipperbang · 12/10/2026 00:48

Neverstopwondering · 12/10/2026 00:37

If a party is big with lots of people we put two or three Colin's together. Just take the faces off all but one, then butt then up against each other on a board

I cannot be the only person who's thoughts went a certain way.......

Sensiblesal · 12/10/2026 01:39

too lazy to make a cake
too lazy to go buy a cake
husband’s choice is wrong.
still too lazy to make or buy a cake
sends other daughter to get a cake to your standards

the problem here is not Colin

DeftGoldHedgehog · 12/10/2026 05:38

Salmonoftheseas · 11/10/2026 20:38

You sound so extremely ignorant.
yes. They’re tough and they’re bleak. The job market is bleak, we can barely afford rent, and buying a house feels absolutely impossible. Not to mention life after university for many is jarring - moving back in with parents and struggling in an oversaturated market. many of us are dealing with the crushing realisation that we’ll never be able to afford to have families if the economy doesn’t improve drastically.

I’m currently doing a full time post grad degree while juggling a part time job. I’m two hours away from my uni, an hour away from my job, and I’m working more hours than I should be with a FT degree. I’m sacrificing sleep to make it all work. I got two hours of sleep last night. Four the night before. I haven’t got a full eight hours in probably 6 weeks.

I’m living at home because there’s no way I could afford rent - which is why there is little employment / degree opportunities near me.

I was also previously living with my long term boyfriend - but now he’s also living at home to save for a house deposit, so we can get out of the rut of barely making rent every month and never having enough left over to save for a deposit. he lives on the other side of the country — even if he were nearer I’d never see him anyway, because I’m always at work or locked in my room studying. I couldn’t afford to do anything fun even if I wanted to.

so yeah. I’m pretty fucking unhappy actually. All of my spare time is eaten up by work, studying, commuting, and I can only see my partner once a fortnight, after cohabiting for 4 years.

so maybe a fucking novelty chocolate cake is a bit of laugh in comparison.

I'm sorry to hear that but I still find it a strange blanket assumption to say that your early 20s are universally a tough time. And many are still at university or didn't go in the first place. I made no criticism of the cake either.

PurpleNebula84 · 12/10/2026 06:20

Newsenmum · 11/10/2026 22:06

Omg which part of the country is this? If not tll outing?

It's in Oldham

Colin is not a birthday cake
Tahlbias · 12/10/2026 07:05

Maybe for a child, yes!

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 12/10/2026 07:30

BeMintFatball · 11/10/2026 12:12

@sherbetlemonade my sympathies. Your idea of a birthday cake is exactly what I want for DD . Victoria sponge, white icing says Happy Birthday. Fortunately older DD bought exactly that from Sainsbury’s.

The daughter whose birthday it is has had a very tough year. Getting to 24 is an achievement and that is why an unmistakable birthday cake is important to me.

As long as that’s what your daughter wants too!

A lot of people don’t like a shop Victoria sponge or that kind of white icing so it’s possible your DH is one of those people who prefers something different.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 12/10/2026 07:30

But Colin is definitely a birthday cake

Namechangefordaughterevasion · 12/10/2026 07:50

Colins are a universal celebration cake. I went to the afternoon tea part of a hen do a couple of years ago where the main cake was a Connie Caterpillar wearing a veil created by the MOH, surrounded by mini Colins with tiny top hats.

T1Dmama · 12/10/2026 08:17

WWE get the Cuthbert one from Aldi, but it’s practically the same… I’m happy with it as my cake. My daughter had one as hers the other year but it was a second one as it was celebrated twice. Once on her b,day and then a bigger cake at the weekend with extended family

reallyagainplease · 12/10/2026 08:36

Am I the only one who finds Colin or other caterpillar cakes not nice at all? I’ve never got the hype over them. Every time I’ve had to eat a slice eagerly shoved into my hand, I have to force some of it down before feigning fullness. They are grim.

lovemybooks · 12/10/2026 09:02

It’s a standard yearly cake in our house . My 7 year old nephew asks for Colin for his birthday every year 😊

Salmonoftheseas · 12/10/2026 09:31

DeftGoldHedgehog · 12/10/2026 05:38

I'm sorry to hear that but I still find it a strange blanket assumption to say that your early 20s are universally a tough time. And many are still at university or didn't go in the first place. I made no criticism of the cake either.

Edited

you clearly don’t know what’s going on in the world right now. All of my friends in their early 20s are going through similar difficulties to me, so it’s a pretty fair statement. Especially because most is to do with the economy. I friends from affluent families who cant find work, middle class who are having to work way too many PT hours to make ends meet, can’t afford rent, won’t be able to so afford the lives that their parents had at that age. Myself (and my other working class friends) are feeling all of this more without wealthy families to buffer the struggles.

BananaPeels · 12/10/2026 09:43

reallyagainplease · 12/10/2026 08:36

Am I the only one who finds Colin or other caterpillar cakes not nice at all? I’ve never got the hype over them. Every time I’ve had to eat a slice eagerly shoved into my hand, I have to force some of it down before feigning fullness. They are grim.

Depends if you like a chocolate roll cake I guess. That is all it is. It isn’t my favourite type of cake but it’s easy to cut and the slices aren’t too much so works well as an easy to cut and serve cake and it’s quite whimsical. A lot of people like it as it was around when we were young so there is the continuity of serving a cake a lot of us got when we were younger

Paganpentacle · 12/10/2026 09:46

BigBurrata · 10/10/2026 11:54

Colin puts in an appearance at every birthday in our house!

Same.
Tradition.

DeftGoldHedgehog · 12/10/2026 09:59

Salmonoftheseas · 12/10/2026 09:31

you clearly don’t know what’s going on in the world right now. All of my friends in their early 20s are going through similar difficulties to me, so it’s a pretty fair statement. Especially because most is to do with the economy. I friends from affluent families who cant find work, middle class who are having to work way too many PT hours to make ends meet, can’t afford rent, won’t be able to so afford the lives that their parents had at that age. Myself (and my other working class friends) are feeling all of this more without wealthy families to buffer the struggles.

I would never say there are not plenty of challenges for young people these days and anyone can find life tough at any age, and clearly my offhand comment touched a raw nerve. I suggest you get some historical and global perspective as moaning about hard work and long hours in a life where you have so many choices available to you and the hard work results from your own choices will not gain you much sympathy as most people have been there at some point or are in the thick of it now. If life is making you miserable now then it could be a good deal worse in 20 or 30 years time when you may have poor health or far more responsibilities, so FGS get off this path and do something else. You only have your 20s once.

Harmonypuss · 12/10/2026 10:10

Colin is made in the same factory as the Sainsbury's cakes

Neuronimo · 12/10/2026 10:13

I think that based on the poll, even Colin himself would say

'I'm picked therefore I am.'

Neverstopwondering · 12/10/2026 10:22

Harmonypuss · 12/10/2026 10:10

Colin is made in the same factory as the Sainsbury's cakes

Something about that spoils the magic of Colin a little

I see him getting made somewhere more interesting with chocolate flowers and leaves all around a decorating table

EmmaM84 · 12/10/2026 10:44

Colin is a birthday tradition in our house. Also has to be real Colin not a fake Colin. I got Asda one for my daughter over weekend as M&S is a bit further and I was pushed for time and will never make that mistake again! Ew

MissyGirlie · 12/10/2026 10:49

TLDR: Colin is an epic birthday cake.

It was traditional that at the nursery school my DC attended that the birthday child brought in a cake. One of my DC was turning 3 on her last day at nursery (the Friday) and we were moving house, right out of the area, on the Monday.

Without even being asked, the woman who owned and ran the nursery brought in a Colin the Caterpillar, well aware that with 4 DC, a half-packed house and general chaos, there was no way I'd be making or buying a cake.

DC was delighted, as was I. This was 25 years ago and I remain grateful. Thank you, Rita!

Swipe left for the next trending thread