Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would Labour voters be upset if joining the EU meant they could no longer tax children’s education?

1000 replies

Blarneyspoco · 04/10/2026 12:03

Taxing children’s education is banned as part of EU membership. If the U.K. rejoined the EU, would Labour supporters be upset that they can no longer levy the tax or would it be seen as a necessary compromise.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
EasternStandard · 12/10/2026 14:10

Boohoo76 · 12/10/2026 13:45

Fairer?! That’s hilarious. Trying to destroy a sector that adds billions to the economy resulting in people losing jobs and children being displaced from their schools is fairer than what?

The fairest thing would have been to increase general taxation and actually put more money into state schools. I have always supported that as a state and private school parent. Instead, a policy was introduced that is very likely to cost the taxpayer money whilst damaging jobs and children in the process. And it’s the more vulnerable children that are being damaged, such as the 20+ pupils that were funded by the local education authority in one private school that closed. It’s not the pupils at the elite schools like Eton that are being impacted.

The gap will widen between state and private with VAT anyway.

AStonedRose · 12/10/2026 14:10

Hedgerowmanager · 12/10/2026 14:06

If it’s only for a few, then how can have been anything but ideological?

If you consider making education fairer to be ideological, then i don't dispute it's ideological.

Most studies actually show that, once you normalise for other things, public school confers little actual educational advantage (the data's quite interesting, it varies from subject to subject). The advantage there for is social - it's the connections you make, it's a world view based on them and us. That's an effect that I've no difficulty with taxing. It's also unearned privilege upon unearned privilege. We can't - shouldn't - look to eliminate that altogether. But i'll be fucked if it should be subject to a tax break on what's blatantly a luxury for most.

DuncinToffee · 12/10/2026 14:14

I don't think PS users want a fairer system, otherwise what is the point of paying?

AStonedRose · 12/10/2026 14:14

Boohoo76 · 12/10/2026 12:18

I have not seen one person in my local area argue against state schools being built. In fact, quite the opposite. Yet again, I read another article this morning about the huge population growth in my area with numerous people criticising the lack of facilities. People have been calling out for new schools, doctors and other facilties for years. Begging for them! It’s a massive failure of the district council. Also worth pointing out that it is not controlled by any of the major political
parties. However, the current Government are insisting that more and more houses are built in this area. They see it as a way of resolving housing shortages in London. They don’t care about the local
community as it’s not a typical Labour area.

And it is a nonsense argument. The capacity in state schools doesn’t exactly match where private schools are closing.

Edited

I'm in an area that's seen quite a lot of house building over last two decades.

They're now trying to build a special school, and a Lidl/Aldi (can't remember which) on a field on the edge of the town that's only currently used by a few dog walkers. It's not even the whole of the space, only about a third of it. There are local protests against both. You can guess the demographic of most of the objectors.

Are you seriously suggesting NIMBYism isn't a thing?

AStonedRose · 12/10/2026 14:17

DuncinToffee · 12/10/2026 14:14

I don't think PS users want a fairer system, otherwise what is the point of paying?

Well yes, and the fact that posters are arguing the policy is 'unfair' is effing ridiculous.

But we are where we are.

EasternStandard · 12/10/2026 14:18

AStonedRose · 12/10/2026 14:10

If you consider making education fairer to be ideological, then i don't dispute it's ideological.

Most studies actually show that, once you normalise for other things, public school confers little actual educational advantage (the data's quite interesting, it varies from subject to subject). The advantage there for is social - it's the connections you make, it's a world view based on them and us. That's an effect that I've no difficulty with taxing. It's also unearned privilege upon unearned privilege. We can't - shouldn't - look to eliminate that altogether. But i'll be fucked if it should be subject to a tax break on what's blatantly a luxury for most.

This view is why such a bad policy got through, and hardly any other countries do it. People paying tax but not taking a state place are paying twice. If there’s hardly any educational advantage then fine let people pay.

Quite a few countries offer a rebate because they don’t get caught up in this type of emotion.

BIossomtoes · 12/10/2026 14:22

People paying tax but not taking a state place are paying twice

By choice. People with no kids are paying tax and getting nothing.

EasternStandard · 12/10/2026 14:23

placemats · 12/10/2026 13:32

Private schools in the EU do not operate under charitable status.

This current Labour government has removed the charitable status.

This isn’t correct.

AStonedRose · 12/10/2026 14:42

EasternStandard · 12/10/2026 14:18

This view is why such a bad policy got through, and hardly any other countries do it. People paying tax but not taking a state place are paying twice. If there’s hardly any educational advantage then fine let people pay.

Quite a few countries offer a rebate because they don’t get caught up in this type of emotion.

Edited

Again, this isn't how taxation works. It's not all about you as an individual getting your money's worth. It's about a collective pot that helps everyone, and just about every civilised society expects those with broader shoulders to bear more of the burdern.

Just wait until you need healthcare that costs more than you've got in the bank, or you and your kids lose your job and you need support. Or are you alright, Jack?

Hedgerowmanager · 12/10/2026 14:44

DuncinToffee · 12/10/2026 14:14

I don't think PS users want a fairer system, otherwise what is the point of paying?

Wasn’t a Labour MP who famously said they wanted the best for their child before enrolling the child in a public school?

EasternStandard · 12/10/2026 14:45

AStonedRose · 12/10/2026 14:42

Again, this isn't how taxation works. It's not all about you as an individual getting your money's worth. It's about a collective pot that helps everyone, and just about every civilised society expects those with broader shoulders to bear more of the burdern.

Just wait until you need healthcare that costs more than you've got in the bank, or you and your kids lose your job and you need support. Or are you alright, Jack?

We use state and Labour’s pledge was nonsense. It was meant to be for extra state teachers not just to give a kicking to a few dc you don’t know on this thread.

I’m not going to rejoice a few posters had to move their dc, ridiculous politics of envy. As some have now admitted it wasn’t about raising revenue. No bloody point then. But that was known already by many.

BIossomtoes · 12/10/2026 14:48

Hedgerowmanager · 12/10/2026 14:44

Wasn’t a Labour MP who famously said they wanted the best for their child before enrolling the child in a public school?

And they made their choice as does every other parent. Was that supposed to be some kind of gotcha?

DuncinToffee · 12/10/2026 14:48

Hedgerowmanager · 12/10/2026 14:44

Wasn’t a Labour MP who famously said they wanted the best for their child before enrolling the child in a public school?

There is probably more than one. It's their choice, they pay the fees incl the VAT.

Labour is not abolishing private schools or are against people using them.

Hedgerowmanager · 12/10/2026 14:49

BIossomtoes · 12/10/2026 14:48

And they made their choice as does every other parent. Was that supposed to be some kind of gotcha?

A reminder.

DuncinToffee · 12/10/2026 14:50

Reminder of what?

Labour voters are amongs PS parents? Not exactly news, is it?

BIossomtoes · 12/10/2026 14:50

Hedgerowmanager · 12/10/2026 14:49

A reminder.

Of what? That individual parents make their own choices for their own children? I think we all already knew that.

Hedgerowmanager · 12/10/2026 14:51

DuncinToffee · 12/10/2026 14:48

There is probably more than one. It's their choice, they pay the fees incl the VAT.

Labour is not abolishing private schools or are against people using them.

Don’t they want a fairer system?

The Labour MP who are paying for private education?

Boohoo76 · 12/10/2026 14:51

AStonedRose · 12/10/2026 14:14

I'm in an area that's seen quite a lot of house building over last two decades.

They're now trying to build a special school, and a Lidl/Aldi (can't remember which) on a field on the edge of the town that's only currently used by a few dog walkers. It's not even the whole of the space, only about a third of it. There are local protests against both. You can guess the demographic of most of the objectors.

Are you seriously suggesting NIMBYism isn't a thing?

Well that’s your area. It doesn’t mean that everywhere is the same. In fact, a new supermarket has just opened recently in my area and it has very much been celebrated. Everyone was fed up of Tesco having a monopoly in the town.

Araminta1004 · 12/10/2026 14:52

“Labour is not abolishing private schools or are against people using them.”

I would say at this point, Labour are probably desperate for people to keep using private schools and pay the VAT. So their shoddy uneconomic policy is not exposed further.

DuncinToffee · 12/10/2026 14:55

Hedgerowmanager · 12/10/2026 14:51

Don’t they want a fairer system?

The Labour MP who are paying for private education?

They do, that is what Labour stands for.

I guess your gotcha is that I didn't say 'not all' PS users want a fairer system. You are correct, I should have added that.

BIossomtoes · 12/10/2026 14:56

Hedgerowmanager · 12/10/2026 14:51

Don’t they want a fairer system?

The Labour MP who are paying for private education?

Guess what? Every Labour MP isn’t issued with a box of beliefs they have to adopt. Any more than politicians in every other party.

DuncinToffee · 12/10/2026 14:57

Araminta1004 · 12/10/2026 14:52

“Labour is not abolishing private schools or are against people using them.”

I would say at this point, Labour are probably desperate for people to keep using private schools and pay the VAT. So their shoddy uneconomic policy is not exposed further.

But I thought the VAT was triggering an exodus

How would that work if they are deperate for people to keep using PS🤔

SerendipityJane · 12/10/2026 15:01

BIossomtoes · 12/10/2026 14:56

Guess what? Every Labour MP isn’t issued with a box of beliefs they have to adopt. Any more than politicians in every other party.

Conservative MPs have to believe in scrapping Net Zero and removing Britain from the ECHR.

BIossomtoes · 12/10/2026 15:01

DuncinToffee · 12/10/2026 14:57

But I thought the VAT was triggering an exodus

How would that work if they are deperate for people to keep using PS🤔

It’s a mystery.

TemperanceWest · 12/10/2026 15:02

SerendipityJane · 12/10/2026 15:01

Conservative MPs have to believe in scrapping Net Zero and removing Britain from the ECHR.

Very true. Badenoch will boot out dissenters.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.