Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would Labour voters be upset if joining the EU meant they could no longer tax children’s education?

904 replies

Blarneyspoco · 04/10/2026 12:03

Taxing children’s education is banned as part of EU membership. If the U.K. rejoined the EU, would Labour supporters be upset that they can no longer levy the tax or would it be seen as a necessary compromise.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
KatiesHat · Today 20:42

Hellohelga · Today 20:38

It’ll take time to rejoin the EU - lengthy negotiations re terms. The there will probably be an implementation phase. By the time vat on private schools is removed OPs DC will have left school, shame.

It would make a lot of sense to deny as many children as possible a vat free private education before the policy is reversed, hopefully we can squeeze the closure of a few more schools in.

Hellohelga · Today 20:46

KatiesHat · Today 20:25

Crazy isn’t it that Labour did it anyway. Madness.

It’s supported by 55% and another 20% don’t really care. So it’s easy money with barely any political capital spent. Not madness at all.

DuncinToffee · Today 20:47

Nobody is denied education. Private school is choice and only for the few.

Brexit cost the UK hundreds of billions.

EasternStandard · Today 20:51

Hellohelga · Today 20:46

It’s supported by 55% and another 20% don’t really care. So it’s easy money with barely any political capital spent. Not madness at all.

It can be dropped easily and there doesn’t seem any extra for state education anyway.

Duncantoldme2 · Today 20:52

strawberrybubblegum · Today 20:42

Makes me laugh too. Although it's not really very funny.

The education tax was one of the very first policies Labour implemented. Somehow more important than all the other problems our country faces.

And they had it start that very January - half-way through a school year - even though they were warned by their own advisors it would cause more disruption to the children affected.

I find it fairly bitter that with the tax they added to vapes in the same budget, they gave a grace period of 2 years. That tax hasn't actually taken effect yet!

Vape sellers got 2 years to adjust. Children in their critical exam years got nothing.

They could even have started with a 5% VAT rate, to give time for existing kids to get through to a less disruptive stage... like they did for restaurants and leisure centres during covid. But no, nothing to soften the blow for schools.

How on earth can you pretend that it wasn't a top priority for Labour? And it was a top priority for Labour because they knew it was red meat to their supporters.

Edited

Totally agree.

Duncantoldme2 · Today 20:54

DuncinToffee · Today 20:47

Nobody is denied education. Private school is choice and only for the few.

Brexit cost the UK hundreds of billions.

Like the bulging benefits - except that hundreds of billions is never ending.

KatiesHat · Today 20:56

DuncinToffee · Today 20:47

Nobody is denied education. Private school is choice and only for the few.

Brexit cost the UK hundreds of billions.

Diamonds are forever.

The bubonic plague killed 40 million people in Europe.

PippiLongshanks · Today 20:57

Duncantoldme2 · Today 20:28

'How is it so difficult for some to see what is so obvious? Most people don’t care about VAT on school fees'

That makes me laugh. Many - many - people seemed to care about VAT on school fees a couple of years ago, led idiotically by this toxic Labour government we're still lumbered with. Most of these people were not in any way affected by VAT on school fees. Yet they seemed to 'care'. Fascinating

Who are all these people who cared? A handful of randoms on here it would seem.It’s a bit delusional to think that great swathes of people were delighted at it. That notion is distorted. Disappointing though it may be, a high proportion of the electoral vote with predominantly their own interests at heart. If it doesn’t affect them directly, they are not invested enough to have strong feelings either way.

Duncantoldme2 · Today 20:58

EasternStandard · Today 20:51

It can be dropped easily and there doesn’t seem any extra for state education anyway.

The state of a bog standard state education is worse now than it was in 2024. No new teachers, fewer teachers, more pupils, less sport, less music, less art. And soon they'll be stopping any overall school assessment system at all. Ain't it grand. Poor kids. And teachers.

DuncinToffee · Today 20:58

Duncantoldme2 · Today 20:54

Like the bulging benefits - except that hundreds of billions is never ending.

An ageing population will increase the largest part of the welfare bill.

The economy would be a lot healthier if it wasn't for Brexit.

Duncantoldme2 · Today 21:00

PippiLongshanks · Today 20:57

Who are all these people who cared? A handful of randoms on here it would seem.It’s a bit delusional to think that great swathes of people were delighted at it. That notion is distorted. Disappointing though it may be, a high proportion of the electoral vote with predominantly their own interests at heart. If it doesn’t affect them directly, they are not invested enough to have strong feelings either way.

Oh they were 'invested' in 2024 bless them, So invested it was Labours main policy... How easily you forget.. Funny that.

AStonedRose · Today 21:00

As much as certain PPs will protest, the policy of VAT on unearned privilege via school fees is very popular with voters. Source: https://yougov.com/en-gb/articles/49655-general-election-2024-which-new-policies-do-people-support

I think this is great to see. The British sense of fairness is a cornerstone of our culture, and is alive and well. Among most of us, at least.

How popular are the parties’ 2024 manifesto policies?

Prominent Conservative pledges get a mixed reception

https://yougov.com/en-gb/articles/49655-general-election-2024-which-new-policies-do-people-support

BIossomtoes · Today 21:01

Duncantoldme2 · Today 21:00

Oh they were 'invested' in 2024 bless them, So invested it was Labours main policy... How easily you forget.. Funny that.

No it wasn’t. It was a minor part of the manifesto.

EasternStandard · Today 21:03

AStonedRose · Today 21:00

As much as certain PPs will protest, the policy of VAT on unearned privilege via school fees is very popular with voters. Source: https://yougov.com/en-gb/articles/49655-general-election-2024-which-new-policies-do-people-support

I think this is great to see. The British sense of fairness is a cornerstone of our culture, and is alive and well. Among most of us, at least.

Ah Starmer’s flagship policy along side his face. He didn’t go down well even with VAT.

Duncantoldme2 · Today 21:04

BIossomtoes · Today 21:01

No it wasn’t. It was a minor part of the manifesto.

Sure Blossom. Rewrite history all you like. We have the receipts.

Interesting link @AStonedRose

DuncinToffee · Today 21:05

Duncantoldme2 · Today 21:04

Sure Blossom. Rewrite history all you like. We have the receipts.

Interesting link @AStonedRose

The receipts from 14 years of underfunding education? The receipts of the damage Brexit has caused?

Duncantoldme2 · Today 21:06

DuncinToffee · Today 21:05

The receipts from 14 years of underfunding education? The receipts of the damage Brexit has caused?

Still? 2 years in? 8 years in? Never ending.

Hedgerowmanager · Today 21:07

It was one of Labour’s flagship policies
for the last elections.

strawberrybubblegum · Today 21:08

DuncinToffee · Today 20:58

An ageing population will increase the largest part of the welfare bill.

The economy would be a lot healthier if it wasn't for Brexit.

The economy would also be a lot healthier if half of all UK billionaires hadn't left the UK since Labour came into power. Chris Rokos paid £330m last year, before he left. That's more than private school VAT brings in.

The economy would also be a lot healthier if Labour's increases in NI and minimum wage, and extra regulations hadn't caused a joblessness crisis in the young.

Won't be long before they run out of other people's money to spend. Unfortunately, it's our money which will have run out.

BIossomtoes · Today 21:08

Duncantoldme2 · Today 21:06

Still? 2 years in? 8 years in? Never ending.

It takes more than two years to undo the damage wreaked in 14. Sadly most of it’s permanent.

Duncantoldme2 · Today 21:09

BIossomtoes · Today 21:08

It takes more than two years to undo the damage wreaked in 14. Sadly most of it’s permanent.

Blossom we were talking about how VAT on school fees was one of Labour's flag ship policies.

KatiesHat · Today 21:10

AStonedRose · Today 21:00

As much as certain PPs will protest, the policy of VAT on unearned privilege via school fees is very popular with voters. Source: https://yougov.com/en-gb/articles/49655-general-election-2024-which-new-policies-do-people-support

I think this is great to see. The British sense of fairness is a cornerstone of our culture, and is alive and well. Among most of us, at least.

A fair tax on unearned privilege? Brilliant. I don’t know why they didn’t lead with that assortment of meaningless words, rather than the 6500 new teachers claim. At least nobody would know what they’re talking about to hold them to account.

Hedgerowmanager · Today 21:10

Hedgerowmanager · Today 21:07

It was one of Labour’s flagship policies
for the last elections.

The Five National Missions.

BIossomtoes · Today 21:11

Youth unemployment has remained steady since 2023. It’s yet another inherited problem.

BIossomtoes · Today 21:12

Duncantoldme2 · Today 21:09

Blossom we were talking about how VAT on school fees was one of Labour's flag ship policies.

You weren’t. I quoted your post. 😂

Swipe left for the next trending thread