Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Hoarder MIL living with us?!

77 replies

xxshirleyx · 15/05/2026 23:08

Hi all,
been a silent lurker but now need advice or to be told ‘ you are being unreasonable’

We (partner and 3 children) own a lovely home and both wok hard and have a presentable home because of this.
In my partners culture they often bring their parents in with them, to give a multigenerational upbringing to their children. My MIL is lovely, can’t do any more for us and is the best you could wish for, however, we have built her a garden house (like a static caravan) and she is slowly wrecking it. She is a hoarder (always has been but we never visited her, she always done the visiting) and is making our home embarrassing. She leaves rubbish/food/dirt everywhere, parks her car whenever she likes rather than considerately often blocking us in or out and is just very very lazy so buys lots of food and items, never packs them away, then goes and buys more. Doesn’t sweep, lets food rot, you name it!

She doesn’t pay anything to contribute and has the family home she is renting out, although she is in her 70’s so managed by her children she receives the finances. Everytime we go in the garden, i’m met with rubbish and smells which wasn’t a problem before she moved in, making me now not want to go outside which inadvertently means she takes up ‘more’ space as it’s unused. I’m talking filled bin bags that haven’t found the big bin yet, but then get ripped and go everywhere.

if I had my way, she would move out. i’ve tried being nice and telling her to clean, DH has also although he is a people pleaser. She is a hoarder and genuinely see’s no wrong with how she lives.

YABU- it’s his mum and his culture, don’t argue try and live with it
YANBU- ifs your home she has moved into. She needs to live how you do….

Thanks

OP posts:
Craftysue · 29/08/2026 18:30

Your not unreasonable at all. You have let her move in with you rent free and she's being very disrespectful treating you and your home like this. She either keeps it clean and accepts the help of a cleaner or she goes home.

nomas · 29/08/2026 18:42

xxshirleyx · 16/05/2026 07:53

Thankyou for all your kind replies!!
just to go back on a few bits, I have said about a cleaner, she says she doesn’t like them as they are intrusive…….. also with regards to moving the car. We have moved it for her at times as we will call her and say come and move and she says come and get the keys. We move it, however I feel its also enabling her, so I personally say no u need to move it but then im still sat waiting for 10 mins for her to do so. Partner will just get her keys and move. If I complain about her way of living she says its my house too and I say yes so we need to find a way to live together but she doesn’t budge

i agree, she is probably just lazy and dirty rather than hoarder. I’ve not been surrounded by this lifestyle before and I just saw dirty clutter as hoarder (making trying to give it a mental health disorder rather than she just can’t be bothered to clean) but you are right - she is just lazy.

i don’t want to live here with her, I have been with partner for over 30 years and he isn’t happy but won’t say anything to her, but i feel it’s either me put up with this and be embarrassed to invite people over etc or say goodbye to him which will also make me upset

As she’s not a hoarder the cleaner should be non-negotiable.

Your DH should go in ahead of the cleaner every week and bin bag the rubbish.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page